On the night of June 10, 2016, Kevin James Loibl, a 27-year-old from St. Petersburg, Florida, killed the singer Christina Grimmie in Orlando as she met fans after a performance. Her brother intervened at once, and Loibl died by suicide the same night. Orlando police found no sign that the two had ever known each other.
Because Loibl died that night, he was never arrested, charged or tried, and no court ever heard the evidence. What the police investigation did establish was a portrait of a solitary man whose private fixation on a stranger had grown, over six months to a year, into something no one around him fully understood.
She was born in Marlton, in Evesham Township, New Jersey, and grew up in the Medford area of South Jersey. She began performing as a small child and taught herself piano. As a teenager she began posting videos of herself singing online, covering songs by Miley Cyrus, Sia and Adele, and the clips drew millions of views. A video she posted in 2009 first brought her wide attention, and by 2011 she had close to a million subscribers; by 2016 the figure had passed three million.
In 2012 she moved with her family to southern California and went on tour as an opening act for Selena Gomez, whose managers had noticed her videos and signed her. She appeared at Disney events and on several television programs. In 2014 she finished third in the sixth season of the NBC competition The Voice, on Adam Levine's team, and the run led to a recording contract with Island Records. That same year she returned to Evesham Township to sing at its Fourth of July celebration. She had released an EP and singles of her own, and in June 2016 she was on the road with the band Before You Exit.
Loibl lived in St. Petersburg, on Florida's Gulf Coast, more than 100 miles west of Orlando. He had no criminal record. He worked part time, mostly on weekends, with the technical team at a Best Buy in the St. Petersburg area, on computers in the back of the store, with little contact with customers. He kept no social media accounts of his own.
He had one close friend, a co-worker who had known him for about 15 years. That man became the most important witness in the investigation, because he was the one person to whom Loibl had spoken about the singer.
The friend told detectives that Loibl's interest in her had grown over the six months to a year before June 2016 into an infatuation he did not consider normal or healthy. Loibl spent most of his waking hours watching her videos and checking her social media accounts, and he told the friend he had changed his appearance to impress her. When the friend told him a relationship with her was not realistic, Loibl became angry and defensive and threatened to end their friendship. The friend took his worry to their supervisor, who recalled the conversation as taking place in January or February 2016 and never spoke to Loibl about it. At least five co-workers knew of the obsession, the report said, but none realized how far it went.
The friend last saw him on June 5, 2016. Loibl never said outright that he intended harm, and the friend did not know he planned to go to Orlando. He traveled there alone and was in the audience on the evening of Friday, June 10.
The next day Orlando police identified Loibl as the man responsible and released his photograph. They said he did not appear to know her personally and that they knew of no history of him following or stalking her.
Over the following days detectives interviewed his relatives, his supervisor and co-workers, his friend, and the singer's family and management. An examination of his devices produced nothing that explained his motive, and her phone held no threatening messages and no sign of contact between them. The final report, released on Wednesday, June 22, 2016, set out the friend's account at length but offered little on why he had done it. Because he had died, police closed the investigation as cleared.
Detectives wrote that had he lived, they would have had enough evidence to charge him with first-degree murder. The autopsy report, made public in late July 2016, ruled the manner of her death a homicide.
Why Loibl killed her was never established. The report recorded a fixation and the friend's account of it, but his devices yielded nothing that explained the act, and investigators made public no explanation from him.
He told his friend that he played online games with her, a claim detectives were unable to verify. Police found no sign that she had ever been in contact with him.
2009: A video the singer posts online first brings her wide attention.
2012: She tours as an opening act for Selena Gomez.
2014: She finishes third in the sixth season of The Voice.
January or February 2016: Loibl's friend tells their supervisor about Loibl's fixation on the singer.
June 5, 2016: The friend sees Loibl for the last time.
June 10, 2016: Loibl kills the singer in Orlando and dies by suicide the same night.
June 11, 2016: Orlando police identify Loibl.
June 22, 2016: Orlando police release the final report and close the case as cleared.
July 2016: The autopsy report rules the singer's death a homicide.