Over the night of November 13 and the morning of November 14, 2017, five people died in Rancho Tehama Reserve, a rural community in Tehama County, California, about 130 miles north of Sacramento. The Tehama County Sheriff's Department attributed every one of those deaths to Kevin Janson Neal, a 44-year-old resident of the reserve. At least eight other people were wounded, three of them children. Neal died by suicide before the morning was over, during a confrontation with a sheriff's deputy and an officer of the Corning Police Department. He was never charged with any of the deaths, and no court ever ruled on them.
At the time he died, Neal was already a defendant. He was free on bail and awaiting trial in Tehama County on felony and misdemeanor charges from an incident earlier that year, and a judge's order required him to stay away from two women who lived near him. The sheriff's department's own records, released a week after the deaths, showed that deputies had answered calls involving him again and again in the year before.
The case against Neal began with an incident on January 31, 2017, in Rancho Tehama Reserve. He was arrested that month and charged in Tehama County with five felonies and two misdemeanors. The Tehama County District Attorney's office was prosecuting the case, and a felony trial was set for the following year. Neal was released on bail of $160,000.
After the January arrest Neal was released from jail on bail, and the district attorney's office then sought a protective order for the two women involved in the January incident. A judge issued it, requiring Neal to stay away from both of them, and placed further restrictions on him. In February he certified to the court that he had met those restrictions. Investigators established after his death that he had not. One of the two women sought a further order in February, and on April 1 a sheriff's deputy served him with a court order to stay away from her and her family.
Records the sheriff's department released on November 21, 2017, in answer to a public records request, showed that deputies had responded 21 times in the preceding year to calls involving Neal. At least six of those calls came from neighbors. Seven of the calls were made by Neal and his wife themselves, complaining about their neighbors.
When deputies went to Neal's door, he would not open it, and they left without speaking to him. The complaints went to the sheriff's department; the January case, meanwhile, stayed on its course toward trial in the hands of the district attorney's office.
The sheriff's department concluded that the deaths began with Neal's wife, Barbara Ann Glisan, on the night of Monday, November 13, 2017.
On the morning of Tuesday, November 14, four more people died at several locations in the reserve: Danny Elliott, Diana Steele, Joseph McHugh and Michelle McFadyen.
At least eight other people were wounded that morning, six adults and three children, and all of them survived.
The morning ended in a confrontation between Neal and two officers, a Tehama County sheriff's deputy and a Corning police officer. Neal died during it.
The sheriff's department led the investigation, which covered seven separate locations in the reserve. The district attorney's office publicly identified Neal the next day, November 15, as the man the department held responsible. On the day itself the sheriff's office announced that Neal had been killed by officers, and early reports repeated that account.
The department's final report, released in December 2017, replaced it. An autopsy by a forensic pathologist found that Neal had died by suicide. Neither officer caused his death. The sheriff concluded that both officers had acted within the law.
The final report also found that Neal had acted alone. It confirmed that the death on November 13 had been the first, and that he was responsible for all five deaths and for the wounds of the eight survivors counted by the department.
No one else was ever charged. With Neal dead, the felony case from January could not go to trial, and no court heard evidence about November 13 and 14. The findings in this case are those of the sheriff's department and the forensic pathologist, not of a judge or a jury.
Every death on November 13 and 14, 2017, rests on the sheriff's department's findings. Neal was never charged with them, never entered a plea and never stood trial, so none was tested in court.
The cause of his own death changed between the first statements and the final report. The announcement of November 14 said officers had killed him; the autopsy found that he had died by suicide, and the department adopted that finding in December 2017.
The protective orders and the pending case were never resolved by a court either. His certification in February that he had complied with the January order was found to be untrue only after his death, by the sheriff's investigation, not by any judicial ruling.
November 2016 to November 2017: Deputies respond 21 times to calls involving him.
January 31, 2017: Incident in Rancho Tehama Reserve leads to Neal's arrest; he is charged in Tehama County with five felonies and two misdemeanors and released on $160,000 bail.
February 2017: After his release on bail, the district attorney's office seeks a protective order; a judge's protective order requires him to stay away from two women in the community; he certifies compliance with its restrictions; one of the women seeks a further order.
April 1, 2017: A sheriff's deputy serves him with an order to stay away from her and her family.
November 13, 2017: His wife dies in Rancho Tehama Reserve; the sheriff's department attributes her death to him.
November 14, 2017: Four more people die in the reserve; at least eight others are wounded, three of them children; Neal dies by suicide during a confrontation with a sheriff's deputy and a Corning police officer.
November 15, 2017: The district attorney's office publicly identifies Neal.
November 21, 2017: The department releases its records of the year's calls.
December 2017: The sheriff's final report finds he died by suicide, acted alone and caused all five deaths; both officers are found to have acted within the law.