Kevin Garry Crump was sentenced to life imprisonment in New South Wales in 1974, together with Allan Baker, for crimes committed in November 1973 across the north-west of the state and in southern Queensland. The two men were convicted of the murder of Ian Lamb, a 43-year-old itinerant worker shot dead at Narrabri, and of conspiracy to murder Virginia Morse, a mother of three abducted from her home near Collarenebri and shot dead in southern Queensland on November 7, 1973. The death of Virginia Morse is covered by the conspiracy conviction; neither man was convicted of her murder.
The sentencing judge, Justice Taylor, told them they should spend the rest of their lives in jail and die there, and their files were marked "never to be released." Crump's later attempts to win a release date shaped New South Wales sentencing law for more than a decade. In 1997 a Supreme Court judge set a minimum term of 30 years. Parliament responded twice, first in 1997 and again in 2001, and in 2012 the High Court of Australia upheld the 2001 law that kept him from parole unless he was dying or too incapacitated to harm anyone.
Little is on record about Crump's early life. In 2011 the Newcastle Herald described him as a Cessnock man, from the coalfields town in the Hunter Valley, and gave his age as 64. His co-offender, Allan Baker, was sentenced with him in 1974 and followed a separate path through the courts afterwards.
Ian Lamb was 43. He was a stranger to Crump and Baker. He was shot dead near Narrabri, in north-western New South Wales, in early November 1973. The Northern Daily Leader, reporting in 2012, put his death five days before Virginia Morse's. His death led to the one murder conviction against the two men.
Virginia Morse was a mother of three from near Collarenebri, a small center west of Moree. She was taken from Collarenebri and shot dead in southern Queensland on November 7, 1973. Many details of the crime were suppressed by the court.
The New South Wales conviction for her death was for conspiracy to murder, not murder. The 1974 sentences were imposed on "one count of murder and one count of conspiracy to murder."
The two men were caught days later, back in the Hunter Valley. According to the Newcastle Herald, police at first believed the pair were breaking into a property and stealing a car. Their movements were traced from Kearsley to Stanford Merthyr, and a police pursuit began at Black Hill. Crump, who was driving, rammed a police car near East Maitland, and shots were fired at the police vehicles following them. One shot came through the windscreen of a patrol car and struck Senior Constable Bill Millward, a highway patrolman from Cessnock and the father of two young children.
Millward survived. He spent four days in hospital and was back at work about 12 days later. Colleagues later told him that the bullet that hit him came from the 13th round fired during the chase. He received the Queen's and police medals for bravery, left the force in 1981 and went back to coalmining. Speaking in 2011, he said there had been no stress leave or counseling in those days and that he had been "a bit touchy" for a while.
Police blocked the bridge at Woodville. The stolen car crashed into a paddock and became bogged, and the two men ran toward the Paterson River and fired at police. More than 80 officers joined the search, supported by a plane and by guns borrowed from local farms, while marksmen covered the riverbanks. Baker was found first. Crump was found in the river beside a log. "He was so cold he could hardly say his name," one officer recalled. The Northern Daily Leader put the time between the men's flight on foot and their capture at about three hours; the Newcastle Herald described a two-hour search. Crump and Baker were charged with maliciously wounding a police officer with intent to prevent lawful apprehension.
At first the police in Maitland did not know what lay behind the chase. Evidence found in the stolen car pointed to Collarenebri. Senior Sergeant Bob Bradbury of the New South Wales Special Crime Squad, who was investigating the killing linked to Collarenebri, asked about a fleece-lined coat found in the same car. It belonged to Ian Lamb, who had been found shot dead at Narrabri almost two weeks earlier.
In 1974 Crump and Baker were sentenced to life imprisonment on one count of murder and one count of conspiracy to murder. Life imprisonment was then the mandatory penalty for murder in New South Wales, and the law provided no minimum or non-parole term.
Justice Taylor's remarks became part of every later stage of the case. "The description 'men' ill becomes you," he told them. "You would be more aptly described as animals and obscene animals at that." He said he believed they should spend the rest of their lives in jail and die there, and, as later reports quoted him, "If ever there was a case where life imprisonment should mean what it says," this was it. Both men's files were marked "never to be released."
At the time the remark had no binding legal force. In the 1970s a life sentence in New South Wales meant imprisonment for the rest of a prisoner's natural life, subject to release on license by the executive. Those "tickets of leave" were abolished in 1989 and replaced with minimum terms and parole orders set by the courts. Prisoners already serving life could apply to the Supreme Court, under section 13A of the Sentencing Act 1989, to have a minimum term and an additional term fixed.
Crump applied under section 13A. On April 24, 1997, in the Application of Kevin Garry Crump, Justice Peter McInerney of the Supreme Court of New South Wales set a minimum term of 30 years, with life as the maximum. Under the parole system then in force, that made Crump eligible for parole on November 13, 2003.
On May 9, 1997, the Sentencing Legislation Further Amendment Act 1997 took effect. It provided that a prisoner who was the subject of a "non-release recommendation" could not apply for a determination unless he first showed that "special reasons" existed to justify one. Taylor's 1974 remarks were accepted as such a recommendation. Crump's own determination had been made before the new rule began, so it stood. The New South Wales Minister for Police spoke of acting "so as not to give Crump and these nine other animals any hope for the future," words later quoted by Justice Michael Kirby of the High Court.
Baker applied for a determination of his own on August 1, 1997, after the new rule had begun. Justice G. R. James of the Supreme Court found in 2001 that he had not shown special reasons, and the Court of Criminal Appeal agreed in 2002, despite evidence that Baker had been an exemplary prisoner. He took the case to the High Court, arguing that the 1997 amendment was invalid. On October 1, 2004, in Baker v The Queen, the High Court rejected his challenge by six votes to one.
Justice Kirby, dissenting, described the law as being in substance aimed at "a tiny and specific class of approximately ten New South Wales prisoners." The legal scholar Oscar Roos, writing in the Deakin Law Review in 2005, criticized the use of a sentencing remark made when life was mandatory as the foundation for restricting a prisoner's liberty decades later, and cited the Minister's language as an example of "tough on crime" politics.
In 2001 New South Wales went further. On May 30, 2001, Premier Bob Carr introduced the Crimes Legislation Amendment (Existing Life Sentences) Bill in the Legislative Assembly. It passed both houses on June 21 and received assent on June 27, 2001, as Act No 29 of 2001.
The Act raised from 20 to 30 years the time a non-release prisoner had to serve before applying for redetermination, and it stopped the Supreme Court from fixing a set term for such prisoners. Its central provision, section 154A of the Crimes (Administration of Sentences) Act 1999, applied to non-release prisoners whose sentences had already been redetermined, a group that included Crump. They were removed from automatic parole consideration. Parole could be granted only if the chief executive of the Corrections Health Service reported that the prisoner was in imminent danger of dying, or was so incapacitated that he no longer had the physical ability to harm anyone, and the prisoner also showed that he did not pose a risk to the community. If a prisoner released on those grounds recovered, the parole authority could revoke his parole. Section 154A came into force on July 20, 2001.
Crump's 30-year minimum term had expired in 2003, and he challenged section 154A in the High Court. Bill Millward, the officer wounded in 1973, spoke out against any release. "How can they let this man out of prison?" he told the Newcastle Herald in September 2011, adding that the authorities "really should put a finish to it once and for all."
At the hearing, reported in March 2012, Crump's barrister, Bret Walker, argued that the 2001 law left him almost no real chance of release and in effect overrode Justice McInerney's order. Walker accepted that a state could change parole conditions, but argued it could not change them so far as to deny eligibility in practice. The New South Wales Solicitor-General, Michael Sexton, argued that "eligible" meant only that Crump could apply, not that he would be released, and that the 1997 ruling had simply replaced an indeterminate life sentence with a minimum term. The Commonwealth and other states supported New South Wales. Queensland's Solicitor-General, Walter Sofronoff, argued that the life sentence itself had not changed, only how it was expressed, and Victoria's Solicitor-General, Stephen McLeish, argued that the judicial task ended once a sentence was passed. The court reserved its decision.
On May 4, 2012, in Crump v New South Wales, the High Court unanimously upheld section 154A. Crump had argued that the 1997 determination was a judgment the state Parliament could not override. The court held that section 154A did not impeach, set aside, alter or vary his life sentence. Neither the substance nor the form of the 1997 determination "created any right or entitlement for the plaintiff to be released on parole," so the law was valid.
The New South Wales Attorney-General, Greg Smith, welcomed the ruling. "Crump is no better than a vicious animal and when he committed those crimes he forfeited his right to be part of society," he said, adding that he hoped Crump would spend the rest of his days "reflecting on the misery he has inflicted on the Morse family." Howard Brown of the Victims of Crime Assistance League said the original truth-in-sentencing legislation had been "flawed because it was rushed," and urged lawmakers to write sentencing laws that could not be challenged.
In November 2015, more than 42 years after his arrest, Crump appeared by video link before the New South Wales Court of Criminal Appeal, with Justices Anthony Meagher, Geoffrey Bellew and Stephen Rothman sitting, to seek another chance to appeal his sentence. He told the court: "I believe the sentence I received is over the limit of what I should have received." The court reserved its decision and told him to expect a judgment within weeks.
Accounts differ on several points. One 2015 newspaper report said the two men were convicted of conspiring to murder and of murdering Virginia Morse; the 1974 sentences, as the High Court later summarized them, were for one murder and one conspiracy to murder, and the death of Virginia Morse is covered only by the conspiracy conviction. Reports also differ on the length of the search at the Paterson River, given as two hours in one account and about three in another.
November 1973: Ian Lamb, 43, is shot dead at Narrabri, New South Wales.
November 7, 1973: Virginia Morse, of Collarenebri, is shot dead in southern Queensland.
November 1973: Police chase Crump and Baker through the Hunter Valley; Senior Constable Bill Millward is wounded; both men are arrested near Woodville.
1974: Crump and Baker are sentenced to life imprisonment for the murder of Ian Lamb and conspiracy to murder Virginia Morse; Justice Taylor says they should die in jail.
1989: Tickets of leave are abolished in New South Wales; life prisoners may apply under section 13A of the Sentencing Act 1989 for a minimum term.
April 24, 1997: Justice Peter McInerney sets Crump's minimum term at 30 years.
May 9, 1997: The Sentencing Legislation Further Amendment Act 1997 takes effect, requiring "special reasons" from non-release prisoners.
August 1, 1997: Allan Baker applies for a determination.
June 27, 2001: The Crimes Legislation Amendment (Existing Life Sentences) Act 2001 receives assent.
July 20, 2001: Section 154A comes into force.
November 13, 2003: The date of Crump's parole eligibility under the 1997 determination.
October 1, 2004: The High Court dismisses Baker's challenge, six votes to one.
September 2011: Bill Millward speaks out against Crump's release.
March 2012: The High Court hears Crump's challenge.
May 4, 2012: The High Court unanimously upholds section 154A in Crump v New South Wales.
November 2015: Crump seeks leave from the Court of Criminal Appeal to appeal his sentence.