On the night of Friday, November 14, 1997, a teenage girl from View Royal died in Saanich, on the edge of Victoria, British Columbia, after a gathering of teenagers turned on her. Eight young people took part in the first assault on her that night: seven girls and one boy, none older than 16. Six of the girls were dealt with in youth court and convicted of assault. The other two, Kelly Ellard and Warren Glowatski, were charged with murder, tried as adults and convicted of second-degree murder.
Glowatski was convicted once, in 1999, and the verdict stood. Ellard's case went on for almost twelve years. She was convicted in 2000, won a new trial on appeal, saw a second jury deadlock in 2004, was convicted again in 2005, won a second appeal in 2008 and lost, finally, in the Supreme Court of Canada in June 2009. Both were sentenced to life imprisonment with no eligibility for parole for seven years. Glowatski was granted full parole in 2010. Ellard, who now uses the name Kerry Marie Sim, was released on day parole in 2017 and lost it in 2025.
Kelly Marie Ellard was 15 in November 1997. Warren Paul Glowatski was 16. Both moved in the same wide circle of teenagers from the western suburbs of Victoria, a crowd that met on Friday nights on a field in View Royal, and both were with the group on the night of November 14.
Glowatski's road through the case would be very different from Ellard's. He came to accept his part while serving his sentence; Ellard would spend most of two decades insisting on her innocence before she began, in stages, to accept responsibility.
That Friday the teenagers met on the field in View Royal, as they often did at the end of the week, and the assault that followed took place a short distance away, in Saanich. Ellard and Glowatski were the two the Crown would hold responsible for her death.
On November 21, 1997, Glowatski was arrested and charged with murder. At the same time seven teenage girls, Ellard among them, faced charges that ranged from assault to murder.
The youth court cases moved first. In February 1998 six of the girls were dealt with: on February 13 three were convicted of assault causing bodily harm, and three others pleaded guilty to the same offense. On November 13, 1998, one of them was sentenced to five months for her part in the first assault.
The murder charges against Glowatski and Ellard went to adult court because of the gravity of the crime. In May 1999 a court ruling settled that Ellard, too, would be tried as an adult.
Glowatski's trial opened in Vancouver on April 12, 1999. On May 3 he went into the witness box. He admitted that he had taken part in the assault before her death, but he denied killing her. On June 2, 1999, he was convicted of second-degree murder.
On June 18, 1999, he was sentenced to life imprisonment with no eligibility for parole for seven years. He appealed, and on November 29, 2001, the B.C. Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal. His conviction has stood ever since.
Ellard's first trial began in Vancouver on March 9, 2000, on a charge of second-degree murder. She gave evidence in her own defense. On March 31, 2000, the jury found her guilty of second-degree murder.
The verdict did not last. On February 4, 2003, the B.C. Court of Appeal set the conviction aside and ordered a new trial. It held that Crown counsel's repeated questioning of Ellard in cross-examination, pressing her on why the witnesses against her would lie, had made the trial unfair. Years later Ellard would acknowledge that she had left details out of her own testimony.
Ellard was free on bail after the 2003 ruling. In March 2004 the bail was revoked.
Her second trial opened on June 14, 2004, and the Crown's case rested on witnesses from the circle of teenagers. On June 16 a girl testified that Ellard had admitted to her that she had killed the victim. On June 24 Glowatski, by then serving his life sentence, testified that he had watched Ellard cause the death. The jury could not agree, and on July 18, 2004, the trial judge declared a mistrial.
The Crown tried her a third time. The trial began on February 21, 2005, again on the charge of second-degree murder, and on April 12, 2005, the jury found her guilty.
On July 7, 2005, the trial judge sentenced her to life imprisonment with no eligibility for parole for seven years, the same sentence Glowatski had received. She had been 15 at the time of the killing, and she was sentenced as an adult.
Ellard appealed again, and on September 5, 2008, the B.C. Court of Appeal allowed the appeal, set the conviction aside and ordered a fourth trial. The court was divided.
The majority's ground concerned a single Crown witness. Under cross-examination by the defense, she had given conflicting accounts of what she had seen of Ellard and Glowatski that night. The trial judge then allowed the Crown to re-examine her to show that she had made earlier statements consistent with her evidence at trial. The majority held that the judge should have told the jury how limited a use it could make of those earlier statements, and that the omission required a new trial.
The Crown appealed to the Supreme Court of Canada as of right.
On June 12, 2009, almost twelve years after the death, the court, by a majority, allowed the Crown's appeal and restored the conviction for second-degree murder. The question before it was whether the trial judge's failure to give the jury a special instruction on the limited value of the witness's prior consistent statements amounted to misdirection. The majority found no reasonable possibility that the omission had affected the verdict. The re-examination, it held, had gone to a matter that was not in dispute, and it had not touched the real question of what the witness had seen of the two accused. The dissenting justice took the opposite view: in his reading the only purpose of the re-examination had been to bolster the witness's credibility, and the jury could have treated it as bearing on the disputed question of what Ellard had done.
The ruling ended the prospect of a fourth trial. The 2005 conviction and its life sentence were final.
Glowatski spent his years in custody coming to terms with what he had done. He accepted responsibility for his part in the death and took counseling.
He was granted day parole in June 2007 and moved to a halfway house. He had been eligible for full parole since 2005. At a hearing of the National Parole Board in British Columbia on June 23, 2010, he described his part in the death, the counseling he had done and his plans. He told the board that he carried "a life sentence inside" him and that he had given it to himself by his actions.
The board granted him full parole that day. His conditions required him to keep in constant contact with his parole officer, to abstain from alcohol and to avoid anyone he knew or suspected to be involved in crime or drugs. At the time he held a full-time job, was taking classes and planned to leave the halfway house.
Ellard's early years in custody were spent maintaining her innocence and breaking institutional rules. By her own later account she went through a year of heavy drug use while serving her sentence, and she put her last use at June 2015. By June 2010 she was eligible to apply for parole, and she had not done so.
She first sought day parole in 2016, at a hearing at a federal institution in British Columbia where she was serving her sentence. For the first time she accepted responsibility in public. She told the board that she had omitted details from her trial testimony, that the victim would probably be alive if she had not taken part and, when asked who was responsible for the death, that she believed she was. She said she had acted out of self-interest and panic. But she denied the act the jury had found against her, and the board held that her admission still did not match the facts of the conviction. In May 2016 the board refused day parole and barred her from applying again for a year.
When she came back before the board in November 2017, she went further. She said that the victim should have been with her family that night and apologized. Asked again who was responsible for the death, she answered: "I am." She admitted that she had planned to harm the girl. She still denied the central act the jury had found against her.
The board found her more transparent than before, though it still saw her minimizing the facts. It credited her trauma counseling, the support of her parole officer, no substance use since June 2015 and a decade without violence. On November 30, 2017, the board granted her day parole for six months, to begin once she entered a residential substance-abuse treatment program. Her conditions barred alcohol and drugs, contact with anyone involved in crime and any contact with the victim's family.
She entered the residential program in January 2018 and later moved to a community residential facility in the Lower Mainland. From then on the board renewed her day parole in six-month periods. In July 2018, in a decision made public on October 30, it found a "positive and encouraging commitment to change" and noted that she had kept her conditions, but said a longer period of compliance was needed before any wider leave. By then she had taken the name Kerry Marie Sim. A further extension followed on January 8, 2019, with the board recording her continued progress and her part-time work in sales and marketing.
In August 2020 the board widened her release, allowing her to live away from the facility for up to five days a week. It found that she had completed five periods of day parole without issue, that there had been no concerns about substance misuse or violence for many years and that she had shown increased accountability. In January 2021 it continued that arrangement for another six months, describing her as "positive and compliant" in the community, with a high potential for reintegration.
Her release unraveled in 2025. Her day parole was suspended after a urine test showed a prohibited drug, and she was arrested for breaching her conditions. She rejected the result, arguing that it was a false positive caused by medication she had been prescribed. The board also had before it threatening behavior toward staff at her residential facility, breaches of the facility's rules and her acceptance of medication that had not been prescribed to her. She first postponed and then waived her right to a hearing, objecting to the presence of the media.
In June 2025 the board revoked her day parole. It found that she presented an undue risk to society, that she still held an "anti-social and delinquent value system," that she remained unwilling to accept responsibility for her actions and that she had "significant deficits" in managing her emotions and her substance use. It held that it did not need to consider any less restrictive option.
She appealed in August 2025, arguing that the decision was unfair and rested on "erroneous or incomplete information." In a decision dated February 20, 2026, and released on March 5, the appeal division of the Parole Board of Canada dismissed the appeal. It found that the board had carried out a "fair and adequate risk assessment," had weighed the stresses she described and had grappled with the conflicting versions of the drug test. Her day parole remained revoked.
Both cases began under the former Young Offenders Act, and both were moved to adult court because of the gravity of the crime. The move decided what the two of them could face. Glowatski's sentence of life imprisonment with no eligibility for parole for seven years was the maximum penalty the act then allowed in his case, and Ellard's 2005 sentence was the same. The move also decided who would be named. The six girls dealt with in youth court were never publicly identified; the two tried as adults were.
Ellard has never accepted the central finding of her trials. From 2016 onward she acknowledged responsibility for the death and admitted planning to harm the victim, but she has consistently denied the central act the Crown attributed to her and that Glowatski described in his evidence. Her conviction for second-degree murder stands.
Glowatski, for his part, admitted at his own trial that he had taken part in the assault but denied killing her. His conviction for second-degree murder was upheld on appeal.
November 14, 1997: The victim dies in Saanich, British Columbia.
November 21, 1997: Glowatski is arrested and charged with murder; seven girls face charges ranging from assault to murder.
February 13, 1998: Three girls are convicted in youth court of assault causing bodily harm.
November 13, 1998: One of the girls is sentenced to five months.
April 12, 1999: Glowatski's trial opens in Vancouver.
June 2, 1999: Glowatski is convicted of second-degree murder.
June 18, 1999: Glowatski is sentenced to life with no parole eligibility for seven years.
March 31, 2000: Ellard is convicted of second-degree murder at her first trial.
November 29, 2001: The B.C. Court of Appeal dismisses Glowatski's appeal.
February 4, 2003: The B.C. Court of Appeal orders a new trial for Ellard.
July 18, 2004: Ellard's second trial ends in a mistrial.
April 12, 2005: Ellard is convicted of second-degree murder at her third trial.
July 7, 2005: Ellard is sentenced to life with no parole eligibility for seven years.
June 2007: Glowatski is granted day parole.
September 5, 2008: The B.C. Court of Appeal sets aside Ellard's conviction and orders a fourth trial.
June 12, 2009: The Supreme Court of Canada restores Ellard's conviction.
June 23, 2010: Glowatski is granted full parole.
May 2016: Ellard is denied day parole.
November 30, 2017: Ellard is granted day parole.
August 2020: Ellard's day parole is widened to five days a week away from her facility.
June 2025: Ellard's day parole is revoked.
February 20, 2026: The appeal division of the Parole Board of Canada upholds the revocation.