Keith Luke

Victims
2 murders in Brockton, Massachusetts, January 21, 2009; first-degree murder (2 counts), aggravated rape, attempted murder, kidnapping, armed home invasion.
Years active
January 21, 2009
Location
Brockton, Massachusetts (killings; trial); Shirley, Massachusetts (death in custody).
Method
Shot (both victims; jury verdict of first-degree murder).
Status
Jury verdict May 30, 2013; two consecutive life terms without parole. Insanity defense rejected. Died by suicide in Massachusetts state custody, May 12, 2014.

On January 21, 2009, the day after the first inauguration of Barack Obama, Keith Luke killed two people in Brockton, Massachusetts, and left a third gravely wounded. All three were of Cape Verdean descent. Luke was 22 and lived in the city. He was in police custody before the day was out, and investigators later said he told them that he had set out to kill people who were not white. More than four years later, in May 2013, a jury rejected his claim that he was insane and convicted him of two counts of murder in the first degree, along with aggravated rape, attempted murder, kidnapping and armed home invasion. A judge of the Plymouth County Superior Court ordered him to serve two consecutive life sentences without the possibility of parole. He died by suicide in May 2014, a little less than a year into that sentence.

Two of the three were sisters who shared a residence in Brockton. Luke knew them. He had been their neighbor, and they were the first people he sought out that day. The younger sister was Selma Goncalves. The elder survived.

The third was Arlindo Dipina Goncalves, an older man who, like the sisters, was of Cape Verdean descent. He shared their surname but was not related to them, and he had no known connection to Luke.

The prosecution laid out the events of that day at trial in 2013, and the defense did not dispute them. Its case was only that Luke was not criminally responsible for what he had done.

Luke went first to the sisters. He attacked the elder sister, and when the younger sister arrived he killed her. The elder sister survived, gravely wounded. Later that day he killed the older man.

Brockton police took Luke into custody the same day, and Brockton and state police investigators questioned him. He spoke openly to them about his motive.

On January 22, 2009, Luke pleaded not guilty in Brockton District Court. He was ordered held without bail and sent to Bridgewater State Hospital for a psychiatric evaluation. Indicted in the Superior Court that spring, he again pleaded not guilty to every count: two of murder, four of aggravated rape, six of attempted murder, armed home invasion, kidnapping and further offenses under the state's arms laws.

His pretrial motions to dismiss the indictments and to disqualify the Plymouth district attorney's office were denied. On June 23, 2011, the Supreme Judicial Court, the state's highest court, affirmed a single justice's refusal to intervene before trial, without ruling on the merits of either motion. Almost two more years passed before a jury was seated.

Jury selection began in Brockton in May 2013, and opening statements were made on May 16. The defense did not contest the acts. It argued that Luke was not criminally responsible because of mental illness, pointing to hospitalizations in his teens and a diagnosis that included paranoid schizophrenia, and asked for a verdict of not guilty by reason of insanity. The prosecution answered that clinicians who examined Luke at Bridgewater State Hospital about two weeks after his arrest had found no mental illness, and that the killings had been planned.

On May 22, 2013, the surviving sister took the stand and testified about the day her sister died. Closing arguments were heard on May 29, and the case went to the jury that afternoon.

On Thursday, May 30, 2013, the jury returned its verdicts: guilty of murder in the first degree on both murder counts, and guilty of aggravated rape, attempted murder, kidnapping and armed home invasion.

Each first-degree murder conviction carried an automatic sentence of life imprisonment without the possibility of parole. The judge ordered Luke to serve the two life terms consecutively.

Luke was committed to the custody of the Massachusetts Department of Correction. He died by suicide in May 2014, at the age of 28, and state officials confirmed his death on May 12, 2014. He had served less than a year of his sentence, a little over five years after his arrest.

Luke's mental state was the one real contest at trial. The defense relied on his history of hospitalizations and a diagnosis of paranoid schizophrenia; the prosecution relied on the Bridgewater State Hospital evaluation of early 2009, which found no mental illness, and on the evidence of planning. The jury rejected the insanity defense on every count. No appellate court ruled on that finding before his death.

Timeline

January 20, 2009: Barack Obama is inaugurated as president.

January 21, 2009: Luke kills two people in Brockton, Massachusetts, and leaves a third gravely wounded; he is arrested the same day.

January 22, 2009: He pleads not guilty in Brockton District Court, is held without bail and is sent to Bridgewater State Hospital for evaluation.

Spring 2009: Indicted in the Superior Court; pleads not guilty to every count.

June 23, 2011: The Supreme Judicial Court affirms a single justice's refusal to intervene before trial.

May 16, 2013: Opening statements in his trial in Brockton.

May 22, 2013: The surviving sister testifies.

May 30, 2013: Convicted of two counts of murder in the first degree and of aggravated rape, attempted murder, kidnapping and armed home invasion; sentenced to two consecutive life terms without parole.

May 12, 2014: Massachusetts officials confirm his death by suicide in state custody, at 28.