Three men died in Rockland County, New York, on Tuesday, October 20, 1981. Peter Paige, a Brink's guard, died in Nanuet. Two Nyack police officers, Sgt. Edward O'Grady and Officer Waverly Brown, known to his friends as Chipper, died in Nyack. About $1.6 million was taken from a Brink's truck that afternoon. Among the people arrested that day was Kathy Boudin, a former member of the Weather Underground who had spent eleven years in hiding.
Boudin carried no arms and killed no one. She was charged with murder all the same, because the three men died in the course of a robbery she had joined. In 1984 she pleaded guilty to felony murder and robbery, and she was sentenced to 20 years to life. She was refused parole twice, granted it in August 2003, and released that year after 22 years in custody. She died in New York City on May 1, 2022, at the age of 78.
Boudin was born in New York on May 19, 1943, and graduated from Bryn Mawr College in 1965. She later joined the Weather Underground, survived the explosion that destroyed a Greenwich Village townhouse on March 6, 1970, and stayed in hiding for the next eleven years.
The robbery at the Nanuet Mall was carried out by a team drawn from former Weather Underground members and members of the Black Liberation Army. A second guard was seriously hurt at the mall, and a detective was wounded in Nyack. Boudin was unarmed. She was arrested the same day, and others were arrested with her. One of them was David Gilbert, also a former Weather Underground member. Gilbert was unarmed too, and he was charged with murder and robbery on the same basis as Boudin: people had died during a crime he had joined.
The two took different paths through the courts. Gilbert went to trial with two other defendants, Judith Clark among them, and Gilbert and Clark were each sentenced to 75 years to life. Boudin pleaded guilty in 1984 to felony murder and robbery. The murder charge rested on the deaths that occurred during the robbery, not on any act of killing by her. She never admitted taking a life, and she maintained that her part had been limited and that she had carried no arms. In court she expressed remorse for the lives that were lost. Her sentence of 20 years to life carried a far shorter minimum than the terms her co-defendants received at trial.
She served it in a New York state prison for women, where her disciplinary record showed three minor infractions, none after 1989. Inside she developed a parenting program for imprisoned mothers, worked with prisoners who had AIDS, and earned a master's degree.
The state parole board refused her release on August 22, 2001, after 20 years in custody. A judge set that decision aside, ruling that the board had not taken into account the sentencing justice's recommendation that she be released after 20 years. The board refused parole again in May 2003, then granted it at her third hearing, on August 20, 2003, and she was paroled later that year. Relatives of the three men opposed her release.
After prison she earned a doctorate from Teachers College, Columbia University, co-founded the university's Center for Justice, and from 2013 taught at its School of Social Work as an adjunct professor.
Clark's sentence was commuted in 2016, and she was paroled in 2019. Gilbert's sentence was commuted in August 2021, and he was paroled later that year after about 40 years in prison. Marilyn Buck, who got away on October 20, was arrested in 1985 and was released from federal prison a month before her death in 2010. Mutulu Shakur was still in federal prison in 2021, when he was denied parole for the ninth time. In all, nine people tied to the Black Liberation Army and the Weather Underground were convicted in the case, a tenth was killed by police, and two more were convicted of conspiracy and racketeering connected to the robbery.
Boudin's own account, from her plea onward, was that her role had been limited and that she had been unarmed. Her conviction does not contradict it: her plea to felony murder rested on her part in a robbery in which three men died, not on any death caused by her own hand.
May 19, 1943: Boudin born in New York.
1965: Graduates from Bryn Mawr College.
March 6, 1970: Survives a townhouse explosion in Greenwich Village and goes into hiding.
October 20, 1981: Brink's robbery in Rockland County; a guard dies in Nanuet and two police officers in Nyack; Boudin arrested the same day.
1984: Boudin pleads guilty to felony murder and robbery and is sentenced to 20 years to life.
August 22, 2001: Parole refused at her first hearing.
May 2003: Parole refused at a court-ordered rehearing.
August 20, 2003: Parole granted; released later in 2003.
2016: Clark's sentence commuted.
2019: Clark paroled.
August 2021: Gilbert's sentence commuted; paroled later in 2021.
May 1, 2022: Boudin dies in New York City, aged 78.