Karl Ludwig Sand

Victims
1 murder: the writer August von Kotzebue, Mannheim, March 23, 1819; sentenced to death for it by the Hofgericht at Mannheim, May 5, 1820
Years active
March 23, 1819
Location
Mannheim, Grand Duchy of Baden, Germany (killing, trial and execution); Wunsiedel, Bavaria, Germany (birth); Jena, Saxe-Weimar-Eisenach, Germany (residence)
Method
Stabbed
Status
Sentenced to death by the Hofgericht at Mannheim, May 5, 1820. Executed in Mannheim, Grand Duchy of Baden, May 20, 1820.

On March 23, 1819, in the Baden city of Mannheim, a theology student from the University of Jena named Karl Ludwig Sand murdered August von Kotzebue, a dramatist whose comedies and dramas filled theaters from Vienna to St. Petersburg and who also held the rank of state councillor in the service of the Russian tsar. Sand had arrived in the city that same day. Afterward he tried to take his own life, survived, and was taken into custody.

On May 5, 1820, the Hofgericht at Mannheim condemned him to death, and he was executed in Mannheim on May 20, 1820. The killing is regarded as the first politically motivated assassination in modern German history, and within six months the governments of the German Confederation had made it their reason for the Carlsbad Decrees against the universities, the student fraternities Sand had served and the press.

Sand was born on October 5, 1795, in Wunsiedel, a small town in Upper Franconia that was then Prussian territory. He went to the lyceum in Wunsiedel and then to the Gymnasium in Hof and in Regensburg. In 1809, while he was a schoolboy in Hof, Napoleon was expected in the town, and the boy left rather than risk being in the same place as the emperor.

In 1814 he enrolled at the University of Tübingen to study Protestant theology. He joined the Landsmannschaft Teutonia there in 1815. That spring, after a journey to Switzerland, he volunteered for the field army and served in the last campaign of the Wars of Liberation against Napoleon.

After the war he resumed his studies at the University of Erlangen in 1816. There he set out to win the Landsmannschaft Franconia at Erlangen over to the Burschenschaft idea. The attempt failed and he was expelled from it. He then helped found a Teutsche Burschenschaft at Erlangen, later called Teutonia, and led it until the middle of 1817. In 1817 he also joined the Burschenschaft Arminia.

Early in 1817 he moved to the University of Jena, in the Grand Duchy of Saxe-Weimar-Eisenach, where the first German Burschenschaft had been founded in 1815. He joined it and sat on its committees. In October 1817 he went to the Wartburg festival near Eisenach, the great gathering of the student movement. He served on the organizing committee and carried a flag. He handed out a leaflet calling for a general free Burschenschaft. He also took part in the book burning on the Wartenberg hill, where students destroyed writings they regarded as hostile to their cause. Among them was a history of the German Reich by the dramatist he would later kill.

At Jena, Sand fell in with the small circle that called itself the "Unbedingten," the Unconditionals, an offshoot of the radical "Schwarzen" or Blacks of the University of Giessen. The group held radical democratic and nationalist views, agitated against the governments of the day and wrote with an uncompromising readiness for violence. Its guiding figure was a young lecturer who had come to Jena from Giessen as a Privatdozent. Under that influence Sand became an adherent of the wing of the Burschenschaft that did not rule out political murder.

The man Sand came to regard as his enemy had been born in Weimar on May 3, 1761. He studied at Jena and at Duisburg, where he took up the theater and his first writing again, and practiced briefly as a lawyer in Weimar. In 1781 he went to St. Petersburg as secretary to the governor-general who oversaw the imperial theaters. Two years later he became an assessor at an appeal court, and in 1785 he was appointed president of the provincial magistracy in Estonia, a post that brought him a patent of Russian service nobility.

His literary breakthrough came in 1789 with Menschenhaß und Reue, his first international success. Well over 200 plays came from his pen; about 230 survive, together with 45 volumes of prose. In the nineteenth century he was the most performed playwright in Europe. By one count made at the Vienna Burgtheater in 1867, that theater alone had staged 104 of his plays in 77 years, for more than 3,650 performances. His comedies included Die deutschen Kleinstädter of 1803. The critics were less kind than the public. Goethe, Schiller and the early Romantics attacked his work, and he answered the Schlegel brothers in 1799 with a satire of his own, Der hyperboreische Esel.

In 1795 he withdrew from public life for a time. In 1798 he was briefly a house poet at the theater in Vienna, and in 1799 he was back in Weimar, quarreling with its literary circles. His life took its strangest turn in 1800. Crossing into Russia, he was arrested at the border as a suspected Jacobin and sent to Siberia without trial. After about four months he was released and made director of the German court theater in St. Petersburg. He told the story in 1801 in Das merkwürdigste Jahr meines Lebens, the most remarkable year of my life. After the death of Tsar Paul I he lived in Weimar, Jena and then Berlin, where from 1804 to 1806 he co-edited the journal Der Freimüthige. He published accounts of his travels to Paris and Italy, and in the journals he edited during the Napoleonic years, Die Biene and Die Grille, he campaigned against the French emperor.

The Russian crown made him a state councillor, and from 1813 he served as Russian consul general in Königsberg. He wrote a history of the German Reich in 1814 and 1815. In late 1816 he began sending monthly political reports to the Russian government as a correspondent, which fed the suspicion among his enemies that he was a Russian spy. He returned to Weimar in 1817 and launched the Literarisches Wochenblatt, which ran until 1819. It was conservative and openly hostile to the liberal program: he wrote against democracy, against freedom of the press and against the student associations, and he mocked the gymnastics leader Friedrich Ludwig Jahn. An extract of his reports reached the Jena historian Heinrich Luden and was printed in Lorenz Oken's journal Isis.

By 1817 the national-liberal circles around the universities had made him so plainly their target that he judged it wise to move away. He chose the southwest. He had once written that if anyone asked him where to live in contentment he would name Heidelberg, but in the end he settled in quiet Mannheim, the neighboring city, which had a celebrated National Theater where his plays were especially popular and, unlike Heidelberg, no university. He expected that there he would be safe from the fraternities.

To Sand the dramatist was everything the Burschenschaft opposed. He saw him as a traitor to the German nation, a corrupter of the people and an enemy of the student movement, and he believed him to be an agent of the Russian tsar, who stood in student eyes for legitimism and despotism. Reading the Literarisches Wochenblatt convinced him that its editor was a dangerous enemy of German freedom. These were Sand's own convictions, and he held to them before his judges.

The idea of killing the writer first appears in Sand's diary in an entry of May 5, 1818. At the end of 1818 he wrote to his mother of his resolve, and a later diary entry, written about five months before he acted, records that the decision had been made. Over the winter of 1818 to 1819 he composed a written declaration against the dramatist. In February 1819 he formally resigned from the Burschenschaft, so that no one could tie the fraternity to what he meant to do.

Sand traveled to Mannheim, arrived on March 23, 1819, and killed the dramatist in the city that same day. He then tried to end his own life. The attempt failed, and he was taken into custody. Within days the killing was being read as a political act far beyond Baden: on March 29 the Elector of Hesse-Kassel ordered secret surveillance of the students and, where circumstances warranted, the professors at the universities of Marburg and Giessen.

Sand remained in custody in Mannheim while the case was investigated. Beyond the deed itself, which was never in doubt, the question that mattered to the governments was whether he had acted alone or for others.

Investigators turned to the circle of the Unconditionals. The lecturer from Giessen who had guided the group was arrested at Weimar and at Jena and brought to Mannheim to be confronted with Sand. Nothing of consequence came of it, and he was released on September 21, 1819. The authorities never proved that he had a direct part in the killing.

The case came before the Hofgericht at Mannheim. During the proceedings Sand acknowledged the written declaration against the dramatist that he had composed before the journey. On May 5, 1820, the Hofgericht sentenced him to death for the murder. Sand was executed in Mannheim on May 20, 1820.

The murder at Mannheim did not set off the rising Sand had hoped for. Many German liberals had expected the killing to frighten the governments of the Restoration; instead it gave them their pretext. The measures drafted at a conference of the leading German states at Carlsbad in August 1819 were adopted unanimously by the Federal Diet of the German Confederation at Frankfurt on September 20, 1819. The universities were placed under state supervision, the Burschenschaften were banned, a general press censorship was imposed and a Central Investigation Commission was set up at Mainz to pursue "demagogic" associations across Germany.

The claim that drove Sand, that his victim was a spy for the tsar, rested on something real and something imagined. The dramatist was a Russian state councillor and a former Russian consul general, and from late 1816 he sent monthly political reports to the Russian government as its correspondent. That service is what fed the suspicion. Sand's description of him as a traitor and corrupter of the people was Sand's own judgment.

Whether Sand had accomplices is the larger open question. His contact with the Unconditionals of Giessen and Jena is established, and the ideas of that circle shaped his act. Whether the lecturer who led the circle had any direct part in it is still a matter on which historians are divided.

Timeline

May 3, 1761: The dramatist Sand would kill is born in Weimar.

1789: Menschenhaß und Reue brings the dramatist his first international success.

October 5, 1795: Karl Ludwig Sand is born in Wunsiedel.

1800: The dramatist is arrested at the Russian border, sent to Siberia without trial and freed about four months later.

1814: Sand begins studying Protestant theology at Tübingen.

Spring 1815: Sand volunteers for the field army in the last campaign against Napoleon.

1816: Sand continues his studies at Erlangen.

Early 1817: Sand moves to the University of Jena and joins its Burschenschaft.

1817: The dramatist returns to Weimar and founds the Literarisches Wochenblatt.

October 1817: Sand serves on the committee of the Wartburg festival; the dramatist's history of the German Reich is among the books burned there.

May 5, 1818: Sand's diary first records the idea of killing the dramatist.

February 1819: Sand formally resigns from the Burschenschaft.

March 23, 1819: Sand arrives in Mannheim and murders the dramatist there; his suicide attempt fails and he is taken into custody.

March 29, 1819: The Elector of Hesse-Kassel orders secret surveillance of students and professors at Marburg and Giessen.

September 20, 1819: The Federal Diet at Frankfurt adopts the Carlsbad Decrees unanimously.

September 21, 1819: The lecturer from Giessen, questioned at Mannheim, is released.

May 5, 1820: The Hofgericht at Mannheim sentences Sand to death.

May 20, 1820: Sand is executed in Mannheim.