Karl Linnas

Victims
About 12,000 prisoners killed at the Tartu camp, 1941 to 1943; Soviet death sentence in absentia, 1962; US civil courts found he supervised executions
Years active
1941 to 1943
Location
Tartu, Estonia (killings); Tartu, Estonia (trial, 1962); Greenlawn, New York (residence); Westbury, New York (trial, 1981); Tallinn, Estonia (prison); Leningrad, Soviet Union (death)
Method
Shooting (court findings: he supervised and took part in killing camp prisoners)
Status
Sentenced to death in absentia, Tartu, 1962. US civil cases: citizenship revoked July 30, 1981; deported to the USSR April 20, 1987. Died in Soviet custody in Leningrad, July 1987.

During the German occupation of Estonia, which began in 1941, the occupiers ran a concentration camp in Tartu. About 12,000 people died there, among them about 2,000 Jews: men, women and children from across Eastern Europe. Four decades later, in a courtroom on Long Island, a federal judge found that an Estonian draftsman from Greenlawn, New York, had belonged to an Estonian unit that aided the Germans and had supervised the executions of prisoners at that camp. The deportation courts went further and upheld the charge that he had been the camp's commandant. Every one of those American findings came in a civil case; no American court ever tried him on a criminal charge.

His name was Karl Linnas. A Soviet court in Tartu had already tried him in his absence in 1962 and sentenced him to death. For most of the 1980s he fought, through 13 court appearances and repeated petitions to the Supreme Court of the United States, to avoid being sent back to face that sentence. On April 20, 1987, he lost. He was flown out of New York that evening, the first person accused of Nazi war crimes to be deported to the Soviet Union against his will. That July he died in Soviet custody in Leningrad, without ever being retried.

Linnas was a native of Estonia. When he entered the United States, he told immigration officials he had been a university student in Tartu from 1940 to 1943, the years in which the courts later placed him at the camp.

The courts saw those years differently. In the case the Justice Department's Office of Special Investigations brought against him, prosecutors charged that in 1941, once Germany occupied Estonia, he joined a unit at the Tartu camp whose purpose was to destroy people the occupiers called "undesirables," most of them Jews. They charged that he commanded the squads that carried out the killings of men, women and children, and that he took part in killing inmates himself. According to an investigator in the case, Linnas acknowledged membership in the camp's guard unit and in the Estonian National Army.

The federal district court in Westbury, Long Island, made the first findings in 1981. The judge held that the government had proved, "clearly, unequivocally and convincingly," that Linnas belonged to an Estonian group that aided the German occupying forces and that on "one or more occasions" he supervised executions of prisoners, including Jews and Communists. In 1983 an immigration judge affirmed those findings and the earlier federal rulings that he had served as an officer in an Estonian partisan group that collaborated with the German army and had conducted executions at the camp. When the Second Circuit reviewed the deportation order in 1986, it upheld the government's charges that he had been commandant of the Tartu camp from 1941 to 1943 and had personally taken part in killing inmates.

The dead of Tartu are known by number and by group, not by name. The figures given in the American proceedings and in Soviet charges are about 12,000 killed, including about 2,000 Jews, drawn from across Eastern Europe. The Soviet news agency alleged that Linnas had organized mass killings of Soviet citizens there and had taken part in them personally.

The Soviet authorities did not wait for Linnas to return. In 1962 a court in Tartu tried him in absentia for war crimes committed at the camp and sentenced him to death. He was convicted, in the words of the Soviet case, of running the Tartu concentration camp and of participating in the mass murder of Jews and others held there.

He was not present. That trial became the center of the argument over his deportation a quarter of a century later. In 1986 Amnesty International wrote to the Attorney General of the United States expressing "grave doubts" about its fairness. Its main concern was timing: an account of the court's judgment had appeared in Socialist Legality, the official journal of the Soviet procuracy, in an article dated December 7, 1961, weeks before the trial was held in January 1962. Amnesty obtained the article through the Library of Congress and said that, to its knowledge, it was authentic.

Amnesty did not argue that Linnas should go free. In a letter dated June 27, 1986, it asked that he not be sent to the Soviet Union unless he could be guaranteed a fair, public trial with a right of appeal and no death sentence.

Linnas reached the United States from Germany in 1951, admitted as a displaced person under the Displaced Persons Act of 1948. He settled in Greenlawn, on Long Island, and worked as a draftsman and land surveyor. He became a naturalized American citizen in 1960. Neither when he entered in 1951 nor at his naturalization in 1960 did he disclose any service at the Tartu camp.

He lived in Greenlawn for about 30 years, and the Soviet judgment of 1962 was passed while he was already an American citizen.

The Office of Special Investigations opened the case in June 1981, charging that Linnas had lied to immigration authorities in 1951 and again at his naturalization in 1960. The case was heard in the district court at Westbury, and documents supplied by the Soviet Union were used in evidence.

On July 30, 1981, the court revoked his citizenship. It found that he had concealed his wartime role, that he had belonged to the Estonian unit that assisted the occupiers and that he had supervised the executions of prisoners. Linnas appealed. In 1982 the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit unanimously affirmed the judgment, and on October 5, 1982, the Supreme Court declined to review it.

The government filed deportation charges in June 1982, while the citizenship case was still on appeal. On May 29, 1983, an immigration judge ordered Linnas deported, affirming the federal findings about his service at the camp.

The country he would be sent to was the hardest question in the case. Linnas had designated Estonia, which in 1983 was part of the Soviet Union. The United States had never recognized the Soviet annexation of the Baltic states, and an Estonian consulate dating from before the war still operated in New York with American backing.

In 1984 the Board of Immigration Appeals found him deportable but sent the case back to an immigration judge on whether American non-recognition of Estonia's incorporation affected where he could be sent. The answer, from the Board and the State Department, was that it did not bar deportation, and the Board affirmed the order in 1985.

From April 1986 Linnas was held at the federal jail in Manhattan. In May 1986 a three-judge panel of the Second Circuit unanimously upheld the deportation, rejecting his claims that the order violated his constitutional rights to due process and equal protection. It upheld the findings that he had served as commandant of the Tartu camp and had personally taken part in killing inmates.

On December 1, 1986, the Supreme Court declined to hear his appeal against deportation to the Soviet Union. In January 1987 it declined again.

The order still needed the Attorney General's signature, and it did not come quickly. Linnas asked to be sent to "free Estonia," a state that no longer existed, and sought refuge at the Estonian consulate in New York, which said it could not give it.

In early April 1987 a federal district court ruled that he could be deported to Estonia. In the week before the deportation the Attorney General agreed to send him to Panama instead. Panama withdrew its offer the same day, and more than a dozen other countries also refused him.

On April 20, 1987, the Supreme Court denied him a stay. Last appeals failed the same day, and the Chief Justice denied a final stay while Linnas was already aboard the aircraft. A Czechoslovak airliner left Kennedy International Airport that evening with him on board.

Soviet authorities took him into custody in Prague, and a Soviet plane flew him on to Tallinn. He was the 14th person accused of war crimes to be removed from the United States through an investigation by the Office of Special Investigations.

In June 1987 the public prosecutor of Soviet Estonia said that he saw no grounds for holding a new trial. That month Linnas was moved from his cell in Tallinn to Leningrad, where he died in Soviet custody in July 1987. He had not been retried, and the 1962 sentence had not been carried out.

The 1962 trial is the most contested part of the record. Amnesty International doubted its fairness because an account of the judgment appeared on December 7, 1961, before the January 1962 trial, and the sentence is dated to December 1961 in some accounts and to 1962 in most.

The American cases leaned in part on evidence from the Soviet Union, and that is where the defense fought hardest. Its lawyers argued that Soviet witnesses could not be properly cross-examined and that captured German forms, inks and stamps could have been used to forge documents. The government answered that the documents were examined by experts on handwriting, ink and paper, that defense counsel could question Soviet witnesses at videotaped depositions, and that the case did not rest on the Soviet material alone. FBI experts and the courts verified the documents as authentic.

The figure of about 12,000 dead at Tartu, with about 2,000 Jews among them, comes from the Soviet charges and was repeated in the American proceedings. His own account of the war years, that he was a student in Tartu from 1940 to 1943, was rejected by every American court that heard the case, and the findings against him rest on a civil standard of proof, not a criminal verdict. Linnas maintained his innocence.

Timeline

1941: German forces occupy Estonia.

1941 to 1943: Linnas serves at the Tartu camp; the deportation courts found he was its commandant.

1951: Linnas enters the United States from Germany as a displaced person and settles in Greenlawn, New York.

1960: Linnas becomes a naturalized American citizen.

December 7, 1961: An account of the Soviet court's judgment against him is published in Socialist Legality.

January 1962: A Soviet court in Tartu tries him in absentia and sentences him to death.

June 1981: The Office of Special Investigations opens the denaturalization case.

July 30, 1981: The federal district court at Westbury revokes his citizenship.

1982: The Second Circuit affirms the denaturalization.

June 1982: Deportation charges are filed.

October 5, 1982: The Supreme Court declines to review the denaturalization.

May 29, 1983: An immigration judge orders him deported.

1984: The Board of Immigration Appeals finds him deportable and remands the country question.

1985: The Board of Immigration Appeals affirms the deportation order.

April 1986: He is held at the federal jail in Manhattan.

May 1986: The Second Circuit unanimously upholds the deportation order.

June 27, 1986: Amnesty International asks the Attorney General not to deport him without a guarantee of a fair trial.

December 1, 1986: The Supreme Court declines to hear his appeal.

January 1987: The Supreme Court declines again.

April 1987: A federal district court rules he may be deported to Estonia; Panama offers and withdraws asylum.

April 20, 1987: The Supreme Court denies a stay; he is deported to the Soviet Union by way of Prague.

June 1987: The prosecutor of Soviet Estonia says he sees no grounds for a new trial; Linnas is moved from Tallinn to Leningrad.

July 1987: Linnas dies in Soviet custody in Leningrad.