Karl Frenzel arrived at Sobibor in April 1942, in the weeks when the camp in eastern Poland was being made ready for its first transports, and he was still there eighteen months later when its prisoners rose against their guards. He ran Lager I, the section where the small number of prisoners kept alive to work were housed, and he commanded the camp's railway detail. With the camp's senior sergeant, he decided which of the new arrivals would be held back for labor.
Twenty years after the war, a West German court tried him for it. On December 20, 1966, the Hagen Regional Court convicted him of joint murder of at least 150,000 people at Sobibor, and of further murders in six individual cases, and sentenced him to life imprisonment. Of the twelve former camp staff indicted in that case, no other defendant received a life term. The Federal Court of Justice dismissed his appeal in 1971. Later in the decade the Hagen court reopened most of the case, and at the end of the retrial, on October 4, 1985, it set aside the rest of the 1966 judgment, acquitted him on six individual counts, convicted him again of joint murder of at least 150,000 people and once more imposed life imprisonment. One conviction from 1966, for a single murder, had never been reopened, and in 1987 the Federal Court of Justice made the new judgment final with one combined life term. The sentence was remitted because of his poor health. He died on September 2, 1996, at Garbsen, near Hanover.
Karl August Wilhelm Frenzel was born on August 20, 1911, in Zehdenick, on the Havel River. He belonged to the Nazi Party and to its street militia, the SA, from the movement's early days.
In late 1939, after the invasion of Poland, the party issued a call for reliable members willing to take on special service. Frenzel answered it. The service turned out to be Aktion T4, the regime's program for murdering people with mental and physical disabilities. He worked first as a guard at Grafeneck, one of the program's killing centers, and then at Hadamar, where he took part in the killing of patients.
When the SS began building camps in occupied Poland for Operation Reinhard, the plan to murder the Jews of the territory the Germans called the General Government, it staffed them largely with veterans of the T4 program. Frenzel was one of them.
The camp stood near the village of Sobibor, south of Włodawa (Wlodawa) in the Lublin District. German SS and police authorities built it in the spring of 1942 as the second of the three Operation Reinhard killing centers, after Bełżec (Belzec) and before Treblinka.
Frenzel was posted to the camp on April 20, 1942. He belonged to the small group of SS men who served there from its establishment until the revolt of October 1943, and he held the rank of Oberscharführer, a staff sergeant. He was placed in charge of Lager I, which held the barracks and workshops of the Jewish forced laborers, and of the Bahnhofkommando, the railway detail.
The prisoners kept alive to work sorted belongings, labored in the forest and the gardens and served the SS as tailors, cobblers and cleaners. Their number began at about 120 and later rose to about 600, and they lived under Frenzel's authority. With the camp's senior sergeant, he decided which newly arriving Jews would be held back to work at Sobibor or sent to labor camps nearby. A woman who escaped in the revolt later gave evidence against him in court.
On October 14, 1943, the prisoners of Sobibor revolted, and about 300 broke out. Frenzel survived the revolt. The Germans then closed the camp, and Frenzel took part in its dismantling. He was afterward sent to Italy with Sondertruppe R, a unit that seized the homes and property of Jews who had been deported from there. In Italy he wore police uniform, and by the end of his service there he held the police rank of Hauptwachtmeister at Trieste and Fiume.
In April 1945, in Carinthia, he was released from his T4 service. American forces took him into custody and interned him, then let him go in May 1945, though he had to keep working for them until that August. From November 1945 he lived in Göttingen. In 1947 he found work at the film studio there, and he stayed with it for fifteen years, rising to deputy stage manager.
His wartime role did not catch up with him for nearly two decades. A survivor of the camp helped trace him. He was arrested on March 22, 1962, and taken into pretrial custody in an investigation run by the central office of the Dortmund prosecutors for Nazi mass crimes. He would stay behind bars for almost fifteen years.
The case came to trial before the Hagen Regional Court on September 6, 1965. Twelve former members of the camp's staff were indicted together on charges of complicity in the murder of about 250,000 Jews at Sobibor. Frenzel was charged with 42 murders and with complicity in the deaths of 250,000 people. Beyond the general count of taking part in the camp's machinery of murder, the indictment charged him with a long series of individual killings, and the court dropped 23 of those as immaterial to the sentence. A co-defendant described as the chief defendant died by suicide in custody in October 1966, before the verdicts, and was never convicted.
The trial ran for sixteen months, and survivors traveled to Hagen to give evidence about forced labor in the camp. On December 20, 1966, the court convicted Frenzel of joint murder of an indeterminate number of people, at least 150,000, and of the murder of nine more people in six individual cases, and sentenced him to life in the penitentiary. It acquitted him on the remaining charges.
None of the others came close. Four of his co-defendants were convicted of joint aiding and abetting of murder and given penitentiary terms of eight years, four years, three years and three years; a fifth, whose case had been separated from the rest shortly before the verdict, received four years. Five were acquitted. The court found that it could not disprove their claim that they had believed a refusal to take part would put their own lives in immediate danger, and it held them excused on that ground.
Frenzel appealed. On March 25, 1971, the Federal Court of Justice dismissed the appeal, correcting the sentence only in form, to life imprisonment under the reformed penal code.
Frenzel did not accept the verdict. He asked for his case to be reopened, and on December 20, 1976, exactly ten years after the judgment, the Hagen Regional Court ruled the application admissible for all the counts on which he had been convicted and suspended enforcement of his sentence. He walked out of custody the next day, December 21, 1976.
Two years later, on December 29, 1978, the court ordered the reopening itself and a fresh trial on the general count and on five of the individual cases. On one count it refused. The court rejected as unfounded his application to reopen his conviction for the murder of a single prisoner, and on April 3, 1980, the Higher Regional Court at Hamm threw out his challenge to that refusal. The 1966 conviction on that count, with its own life sentence, was now final.
The consequence was a return to prison. From May 5, 1980, to September 1, 1981, the life sentence was enforced again. It was then interrupted by way of clemency, and on October 28, 1982, the sentence enforcement chamber of the Hagen court suspended the remainder on probation. From then on Frenzel was a free man under supervision.
The new trial before the Hagen court, at his own request, began on November 5, 1982, and ran for almost three years. On October 4, 1985, the court gave its judgment. It upheld the general count: Frenzel was convicted once more of joint murder of an indeterminate number of people, at least 150,000, and sentenced to life imprisonment. In every other respect the 1966 judgment was set aside, and he was acquitted on six individual counts. Several further individual allegations were dropped as immaterial to the sentence.
Frenzel appealed again. On May 26, 1987, the Federal Court of Justice let the judgment stand, with one change to the sentence: the life term of 1985 and the surviving life sentence from 1966 for the single murder were merged into one combined life sentence. Because of his age and poor health, the sentence was remitted, and he was not sent back to prison.
The court stated its finding as a minimum: joint murder of at least 150,000 people. He went to trial facing 42 individual murder charges as well as the complicity counts. The 1966 court convicted him in six individual cases; the retrial acquitted him on six individual counts, and the combined life sentence of 1987 rests on the general count and the one individual murder conviction that was never reopened.
August 20, 1911: Karl August Wilhelm Frenzel is born in Zehdenick.
Late 1939: He joins the T4 killing program, serving at Grafeneck and then Hadamar.
April 20, 1942: He is posted to Sobibor, where he takes charge of Lager I and the railway detail.
October 14, 1943: Prisoners revolt at Sobibor; about 300 break out.
Late 1943: Frenzel helps dismantle the camp and is then sent to Italy with Sondertruppe R.
May 1945: He is released from American internment.
1947: He begins work at the film studio in Göttingen.
March 22, 1962: He is arrested and taken into pretrial custody.
September 6, 1965: Trial of twelve former Sobibor staff opens at the Hagen Regional Court.
December 20, 1966: Frenzel is sentenced to life imprisonment.
March 25, 1971: The Federal Court of Justice dismisses his appeal.
December 20, 1976: The Hagen court rules his reopening application admissible and suspends his sentence.
December 21, 1976: He is released from custody.
December 29, 1978: The Hagen court orders a retrial on the general count and five individual cases.
April 3, 1980: The Higher Regional Court at Hamm confirms the refusal to reopen one murder conviction.
May 5, 1980, to September 1, 1981: He serves the life sentence again until it is interrupted by clemency.
October 28, 1982: The rest of the sentence is suspended on probation.
November 5, 1982: The retrial begins in Hagen at his request.
October 4, 1985: He is convicted again of joint murder of at least 150,000 people, sentenced to life and acquitted on six individual counts.
May 26, 1987: The Federal Court of Justice makes the judgment final with one combined life sentence, later remitted on health grounds.
September 2, 1996: Frenzel dies at Garbsen, near Hanover.