Kaoru Kobayashi

Victims
1 young girl murdered in Nara, Japan, November 17, 2004. Convicted of murder with other charges; sentenced to death by the Nara District Court, September 26, 2006
Years active
November 17, 2004
Location
Nara, Nara Prefecture, Japan; Osaka (execution)
Method
Murder, with other charges
Status
Death sentence final in October 2006 after he withdrew his appeal; challenges and a retrial request rejected, the last by the Supreme Court in December 2009; executed February 21, 2013

Kaoru Kobayashi was put to death in Osaka on February 21, 2013, for the murder of a young girl in the city of Nara more than eight years earlier. The Nara District Court sentenced him to death on September 26, 2006, for her murder, with other charges, after a trial in which he admitted the crime and prosecutors asked for the death penalty and received it. The sentence did not reach Japan's higher courts in the usual way. Kobayashi's lawyers lodged an appeal, and within weeks he withdrew it himself, which made the judgment final. Everything that came after, a challenge to that withdrawal through three levels of court and a request for a retrial, turned on that single decision of his own. All of it failed. He was 44 when he was executed.

He had worked for a newspaper sales agency in Nara Prefecture, and by the time of his arrest he was a former employee of that trade.

The victim was a young girl from the city of Nara. She died on November 17, 2004, and her death was confirmed the following day, November 18, when the case became a murder inquiry for the Nara Prefectural Police. For six weeks the inquiry went on without an arrest.

Nara Prefectural Police arrested Kobayashi on December 30, 2004. He was linked to the crime by evidence, and the arrest came at the very end of the year in which the girl had died. Over the weeks that followed, prosecutors prepared the charges on which he would be tried: murder, together with a group of other offenses arising from the same events.

Kobayashi was tried in the Nara District Court, where he admitted the crime. What remained for the court was the sentence.

Prosecutors asked for the death penalty. On September 26, 2006, the court imposed it, exactly as the prosecution had requested, convicting him of the murder of the girl together with the other charges. He was 37.

The presiding judge set out the court's reasoning in plain terms. The court acknowledged that there was one victim and still held that death was the only sentence it could impose. It gave weight to two aims of punishment: that the sentence should answer the gravity of the crime, and that it should deter others from crimes of the same kind. On those grounds the court rejected any lesser penalty.

His defense lawyers appealed the sentence to the Osaka High Court. In October 2006, before the appeal could be heard, Kobayashi withdrew it himself. He told his first-instance counsel of his intention and then lodged the withdrawal. Under Japanese procedure the withdrawal ended the appeal, and the Nara District Court's judgment became final. From that point he was a condemned prisoner awaiting execution.

The finality of the sentence did not go unchallenged. In June 2007 a different lawyer argued that the withdrawal had been invalid and asked the Osaka High Court to set a date for the appeal hearing, as though the appeal were still alive. The High Court accepted the application for consideration, and the question went before the courts in turn.

The Nara District Court, the Osaka High Court and the Supreme Court each rejected the challenge. In every court the answer was the same: the withdrawal had been Kobayashi's own act, it was valid, and the death sentence stood as a final judgment.

Kobayashi next sought a retrial. The Nara District Court refused the request, and the Osaka High Court rejected his appeal against that refusal; the High Court's ruling was in the Nara press by August 11, 2009. Kobayashi then took a special appeal to the Supreme Court. In December 2009 the Supreme Court rejected the special appeal, and the refusal of a retrial became final.

Kobayashi was executed in Osaka on February 21, 2013. He was 44. He was one of three condemned men put to death in Japan that day, in three cities, and the three executions were the first since a new government had taken office in December 2012. The previous executions in Japan had taken place in September 2012. After the three executions, Japan held 134 prisoners under sentence of death.

The justice minister announced the executions at a press briefing in Tokyo the same day.

The validity of Kobayashi's withdrawal of his appeal was the one question about his case that remained in dispute after the verdict. A later lawyer argued that it was invalid; the Nara District Court, the Osaka High Court and the Supreme Court each held that it was valid. The facts of the murder were not reopened by any court, and his retrial request was refused at every level.

Timeline

November 17, 2004: A young girl from the city of Nara is murdered.

November 18, 2004: Her death is confirmed, and Nara Prefectural Police open a murder inquiry.

December 30, 2004: Nara Prefectural Police arrest Kaoru Kobayashi.

September 26, 2006: The Nara District Court sentences Kobayashi to death for murder, with other charges, as prosecutors asked; his lawyers appeal.

October 2006: Kobayashi withdraws the appeal, and the death sentence becomes final.

June 2007: A different lawyer asks the Osaka High Court to treat the withdrawal as invalid.

After June 2007: The Nara District Court, the Osaka High Court and the Supreme Court reject the challenge in turn.

By August 11, 2009: The Nara District Court has refused a retrial and the Osaka High Court has rejected his appeal.

December 2009: The Supreme Court rejects his special appeal, ending the retrial request.

February 21, 2013: Kobayashi is executed in Osaka, one of three prisoners executed in Japan that day.