On the evening of June 4, 2014, Justin Christien Bourque, a 24-year-old from Moncton, New Brunswick, killed three officers of the Royal Canadian Mounted Police and wounded two more in the northwest of the city. The two wounded officers recovered and were released from hospital. Bourque was arrested on June 6.
On August 8, 2014, he pleaded guilty in the Court of Queen's Bench of New Brunswick to three counts of first-degree murder and two counts of attempted murder. On October 31, 2014, the court sentenced him to life imprisonment on each count and ordered the three 25-year periods of parole ineligibility attached to the murders to run one after another. The total came to 75 years.
That term did not survive. In May 2022 the Supreme Court of Canada struck down the provision under which it had been imposed, retroactive to the day it was enacted. On March 2, 2023, the New Brunswick Court of Appeal, with the Crown's agreement, varied his sentence to concurrent 25-year periods of parole ineligibility. Everything else about the sentence stands. He remains a man serving life, entitled after a quarter century to ask for parole, and nothing more than that.
The dead were three constables of the force's Codiac detachment in Moncton.
Constable Douglas James Larche was born in Saint John, New Brunswick, and joined the force in Moncton on February 4, 2002. In 2008 he received a commander's commendation for saving the life of an unconscious baby in the city. He was a keen runner, and he was known for his sense of humor.
Constable David Ross came from Victoriaville, Quebec. He enlisted on July 9, 2007, and after training at the force's academy in Regina he was posted to Codiac. He loved the outdoors and he loved dogs.
Constable Fabrice Georges Gevaudan was born in Boulogne-Billancourt, France. He joined the force on February 11, 2008, and was posted to Codiac. He was athletic and a scuba diver.
Their deaths became the three counts of first-degree murder on which the case turned. The two wounded officers, a man and a woman, were the subjects of the two counts of attempted murder. In the agreed statement of facts he later signed, Bourque admitted that he had targeted police officers that evening, and the document described what he did as "planned and deliberate."
He was charged on the day of his arrest with three counts of first-degree murder and two counts of attempted murder. Before he entered any plea, the court ordered a psychiatric assessment. Most of the report was kept sealed at the defense's request, but the finding that mattered was made public: Bourque was competent and mentally fit to stand trial.
There was no trial. The guilty plea and the agreed statement of facts went in together, and from that day the only open question was when, if ever, he could ask the Parole Board to let him out.
The answer came at the end of October. Every count carried a mandatory sentence of life imprisonment, so parole eligibility was the only question left for the court to decide. The chief justice of the Court of Queen's Bench turned to section 745.51 of the Criminal Code, added in 2011, which allowed a judge sentencing a person for more than one murder to weigh certain factors and decide whether the periods of parole ineligibility should run consecutively. He determined that the three periods would run one after another. Bourque would not be able to apply for parole for 75 years. He did not appeal, and until 2022 the sentence stood as the longest period of parole ineligibility ordered in Canada.
In December 2014 the same court refused a joint application by the Crown and the defense to ban publication of evidence presented at the sentencing hearing. It found the supporting affidavits insufficient to meet the legal test for a ban, and ordered that the evidence be copied and released to the public and the media.
On September 29, 2017, the New Brunswick Provincial Court found the force guilty of one count under the Canada Labour Code for failing to give its members appropriate equipment and training for active-threat events, with a total penalty of $550,000.
The provision behind Bourque's sentence fell in R. v. Bissonnette, a Quebec case. In May 2022 the Supreme Court of Canada held that section 745.51 breached section 12 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, which protects everyone against cruel and unusual punishment, that section 1 did not save it as a reasonable limit, and that it was invalid from the date of its enactment. It added that any first-degree murderer whose periods had been ordered to run consecutively must be able to seek a remedy, even if no longer in the court system. For Bourque, that turned a sentence the law had allowed in 2014 into one it no longer permitted.
He applied to the New Brunswick Court of Appeal late in 2022, years past the usual deadline. The court said that in the ordinary course his request for more time would likely have failed the established test, but the Supreme Court had directed that offenders in his position must be able to seek a remedy, and his appeal went ahead on the parole-ineligibility parts of the sentence alone. He asked for one thing only: a 25-year period, consistent with the law as Bissonnette had left it. The Crown accepted that Bissonnette was binding and that the appeal had to be allowed. On March 2, 2023, the court agreed. Bissonnette governed the outcome, it held, and had left the sentence neither permitted by law nor constitutional. It varied the sentences to concurrent 25-year periods of parole ineligibility and left them unchanged in every other respect. Repeating the Supreme Court's caution, it noted that eligibility for parole is not a right to it.
Bourque is serving five concurrent life sentences in Canada. Since March 2, 2023, the period of parole ineligibility on his murder convictions has been 25 years. Any release would be for the Parole Board of Canada to decide.
Bourque's guilt is not in dispute. He admitted the facts in an agreed statement and pleaded guilty to every count.
His mental state is only partly public. He was assessed before his plea and found fit to stand trial, and the rest of the psychiatric report was kept sealed at the defense's request.
June 4, 2014: Three RCMP constables are killed and two other officers wounded in northwest Moncton, New Brunswick.
June 6, 2014: Bourque is arrested and charged with three counts of first-degree murder and two counts of attempted murder.
July 2014: He is found fit to stand trial after a court-ordered psychiatric assessment; most of the report is sealed.
August 8, 2014: He pleads guilty in the Court of Queen's Bench in Moncton; an agreed statement of facts is filed.
October 31, 2014: Life on each count, with 75 years' parole ineligibility under section 745.51.
December 4, 2014: The Court of Queen's Bench refuses a joint application to ban publication of the sentencing evidence.
September 29, 2017: The RCMP is found guilty of one Canada Labour Code count in New Brunswick Provincial Court.
May 2022: The Supreme Court of Canada strikes down section 745.51 retroactively in R. v. Bissonnette.
March 2, 2023: The New Brunswick Court of Appeal varies the sentence to concurrent 25-year periods of parole ineligibility.