Jürgen Stroop was the SS and police general who took command of the German operation in the Warsaw ghetto on April 19, 1943, and ended it on May 16. The indictment later laid against him in Warsaw charged that his orders in those weeks led to the deaths of at least 56,065 people. He was sentenced to death twice. The first sentence came from an American military court at Dachau in March 1947, for the murder of American prisoners of war in Germany. The second came from the Provincial Court for the capital city of Warsaw on July 23, 1951, which found him guilty of every charge in the indictment, including membership of the SS, the killings in the ghetto, a reprisal order against 100 Poles and earlier crimes against Polish civilians in the Warthegau. The American sentence was never carried out. The Polish one was. He was executed in Warsaw on March 6, 1952.
His case has an unusual shape. He stood trial in two systems, under two bodies of law, for two separate sets of crimes, and the second trial came only after long negotiations between governments over which country would try him first. In Warsaw his defense was that he was a soldier who had followed orders and had never personally killed anyone. The court found him guilty on every count.
He was born Josef Stroop on September 26, 1895, in Detmold, the capital of the small principality of Lippe in western Germany. He went to elementary school and then worked as a clerk. When he later described his life to the Warsaw court, he began with the military upbringing of his youth, and he presented himself throughout as a man formed by discipline.
In 1914 he volunteered for the 55th Infantry Regiment, and he rose in the course of the war to the rank of Vizefeldwebel, a senior noncommissioned grade. After the war he went back to clerical work in the land registry office of the Lippe government in Detmold.
He joined the SS on July 1, 1932, and the Nazi Party on September 1 of the same year, before the party came to power. In January 1933 he ran the party's campaign in the Lippe state election, and in March 1933 he became leader of the auxiliary police of the state of Lippe, a force made up of SS men. In March 1934 he was promoted from SS-Oberscharführer, a noncommissioned rank, straight to SS-Hauptsturmführer, the equivalent of captain, and he moved on to posts in the SS administration in Münster and Hamburg. In the fall of 1938, promoted to SS-Standartenführer, the equivalent of colonel, he organized the SS in the Sudetenland and headed it in Karlovy Vary.
After the German invasion of Poland in September 1939, his career moved into occupied territory. From October 9, 1939, to March 6, 1940, he commanded the Selbstschutz in Poznań, the ethnic German auxiliary formation that operated in the western Polish lands annexed to the Reich as the Warthegau. From March 6, 1940, until October 22, 1941, he commanded the SS district based in Gniezno. The Warsaw indictment of 1951 charged that in these two posts he took part in mass killings and in the persecution of the Polish civilian population of the Warthegau.
In May 1941 he changed his first name from Josef to Jürgen. The official certificate gave the reason as his world view. At his trial he gave a different, personal reason.
In October 1941, after the German attack on the Soviet Union, he was sent east and attached to an SS special command working against the resistance in Ukraine and the Caucasus and guarding construction of the highway from Lwów to Donetsk. He served for a time as a reserve lieutenant with the 3rd SS Panzer Division "Totenkopf." He was promoted to SS-Brigadeführer, and in February 1943 he was appointed SS and Police Leader in Lwów.
He arrived in Warsaw on April 17, 1943. The German authorities had begun deporting the remaining population of the ghetto, and armed Jewish resistance had met the operation. On April 19 he took over command of the final liquidation of the ghetto from the SS and Police Leader of the Warsaw District, who had been removed. He held the command until May 16, when the operation was declared complete; on that last day he ordered the destruction of the Great Synagogue, which stood outside the ghetto walls. He was awarded the Iron Cross First Class, and on June 29, 1943, he was appointed SS and Police Leader of the Warsaw District in his own right.
The four weeks of that command were the center of the Polish case against him eight years later. The indictment put the figure for the dead at at least 56,065 people, and it charged that he had also ordered the plunder of the victims' property, valued at no less than 10 million Polish zlotys together with foreign currency and jewelry.
He wrote a formal report on the operation for his superiors, titled "The Jewish residential district in Warsaw no longer exists!", which was later used as evidence at Nuremberg and in his own trial in Warsaw. The summary was dated May 16, 1943, and it was bound together with the daily operational reports he had sent by teletype from April 20 to May 24 to his immediate superior, the Higher SS and Police Leader East, and with an album of photographs.
The report reached the International Military Tribunal at Nuremberg as a captured document. The Seventh United States Army had seized it, and it passed through army intelligence to the American prosecution staff, who registered it as document 1061-PS. In his opening statement on November 21, 1945, the chief American prosecutor read the report's own total for the operation, 56,065, to the court.
On the morning of December 14, 1945, an American prosecutor formally offered the bound volume, entered as Exhibit USA-275, and asked the Tribunal to accept the whole document in evidence rather than have it read in full. The Tribunal agreed.
The Tribunal came back to the report in its judgment of 1946. In the part dealing with the persecution of the Jews, it held that the planned and systematic character of that persecution was best illustrated by the original report of the SS general who had been in charge of the destruction of the ghetto in Warsaw, and it recorded that it had received the illustrated report in evidence. In declaring the SS a criminal organization, the judgment named the massacre of Jews in the Warsaw ghetto as carried out under his direction. That declaration was the basis of the membership charge he later faced at Dachau. The report was entered again as evidence in later American trials at Nuremberg.
His time as SS and Police Leader in Warsaw produced the second count of the Warsaw indictment. On July 16, 1943, after an attack by an unknown person on a marching SA column in the city the day before, in which several men were injured, he ordered the killing of 100 Poles in reprisal. At the trial he was questioned about this order only briefly; the court's attention stayed on the ghetto.
In September 1943 he left Warsaw to become Higher SS and Police Leader in Greece, based in Athens, and was promoted to SS-Gruppenführer. He clashed there with senior SS and army commanders, and about a month later he was transferred back to Germany. On November 9, 1943, he was posted to Wiesbaden as Higher SS and Police Leader Rhein-Westmark, with a deputy command in Military District XII, and he held that post until March 1945. One of his tasks in the last months of the war was to organize the Werwolf force, a German formation meant to operate behind the advancing Allied lines. He ended the war as an SS-Gruppenführer and lieutenant general of police.
It was in this last post that the conduct charged by the Americans took place. American airmen who came down over western Germany in the final phase of the war were captured, and several were killed in custody in places including Giessen, Wiesbaden, Bensheim and Offenbach.
American soldiers took him into custody in Bavaria on May 8, 1945. Within a year he was wanted by two governments.
In February 1946 the Polish delegate to the United Nations War Crimes Commission lodged a formal request for his extradition with the military governor of the American zone of Germany. The request rested on the Moscow Declaration, under which war criminals were to be returned for trial to the countries where they had committed their crimes, and it drew on testimony given in January 1946 by Franz Konrad, an SS officer who had been in the ghetto during the operation and would later sit beside Stroop in the dock. The request was refused. Stroop was already under American investigation for the deaths of the captured airmen, and if he were sentenced to death the sentence would, under American rules, have to be carried out by American authorities.
Negotiations went on through 1946. In August the Polish delegate proposed a compromise: if Stroop were sentenced to death by both courts, the execution would take place in Poland. The American side replied that its regulations did not allow it to accept that solution formally, but signaled that the head of the American war crimes office in Wiesbaden was willing to discuss the matter with Polish representatives. The Polish delegate read this as an informal assurance that a Polish execution would not cause a diplomatic dispute.
The case of the United States of America against Jürgen Stroop and others was heard by the General Military Government Court at Dachau, an American military court. The trial ran from January 10 to March 21, 1947. Stroop was one of a group of defendants drawn from the SS and police apparatus in the Rhein-Westmark region.
The charges were war crimes. The accused were charged with taking part in a common plan to subject surrendered American prisoners of war to cruelties and mistreatment, including killings, and with membership of organizations that the International Military Tribunal at Nuremberg had declared criminal. One specification charged that the killing of a captured American flier by one of the accused had been carried out in conformity with an order from Stroop, passed down through another of the accused.
The court gave its verdict on March 21, 1947. Stroop was found guilty of participating in the murder of American prisoners of war and of membership in a criminal organization, and he was sentenced to death. The court passed thirteen death sentences in the case, his among them; one of the others was later reduced to life imprisonment on review.
The case went to review. He appealed, and on November 22, 1947, his appeal against the American sentence was rejected and his American case was closed.
On May 31, 1947, Stroop was handed over to the security authorities in Warsaw and placed in custody. For more than a year he went on invoking his rights as a prisoner of war under the 1929 Geneva Convention, and he was questioned repeatedly by the Central Commission for Investigating German Crimes in Poland.
The case was prepared over the following years as one of the largest war crimes prosecutions in Poland. In 1948 it was joined with that of Franz Konrad, an SS officer who had headed the office that collected the property of Jews deported from the ghetto, and expert reports were prepared on Stroop's role in the ghetto operation, on the Selbstschutz and on the racial ideology of the Nazi state.
On July 5, 1951, almost four years after Stroop's arrival in Warsaw, the prosecutor for the capital city of Warsaw signed the indictment. It charged him with membership in a criminal organization, the SS, and with three further sets of crimes.
The first count covered April 19 to May 16, 1943, in Warsaw. It charged that while directing the deportation of the remaining Jews of the ghetto, about 100,000 people, to extermination camps, and the liquidation of the ghetto itself, he gave orders that led to the killing of at least 56,065 people and the deaths of tens of thousands of others, to the destruction of the buildings of the ghetto and of the synagogue outside its walls, and to the plunder of the victims' property.
The second count charged that as SS and Police Leader in Warsaw he ordered the killing of 100 Poles on July 16, 1943, in reprisal for the incident of the previous day.
The third count charged that as commander of the Selbstschutz in Poznań and of the SS district in Gniezno, from 1939 to 1941, he took part in mass killings and persecution of the Polish civilian population in the Warthegau.
His own report on the ghetto operation was the documentary basis of the first count and was used to calculate the number of the dead.
The trial of Jürgen Stroop and Franz Konrad opened on July 18, 1951, before the Fourth Criminal Division of the Provincial Court for the capital city of Warsaw. A panel led by the court's deputy president heard the case. Two public prosecutors presented it, and Stroop was represented by a Polish defense lawyer. The hearing lasted four days.
The first day was given to Konrad. He testified about his own work in the ghetto and about the part Stroop had played in the operation. Konrad had been at Stroop's side for much of it, taking photographs that later illustrated the report, and his evidence put orders for killings in Stroop's mouth. He was the only eyewitness to Stroop's conduct in the ghetto to testify against him.
Stroop testified on the second day, July 19. He began with his upbringing and army career and then gave the court a long account of the ghetto operation. He pleaded not guilty. He told the court that he had never in his life personally killed anyone, and he described Konrad's evidence as revenge: Stroop's arrival in Warsaw, he said, had curtailed Konrad's own exploitation of the ghetto. He presented himself as a soldier bound by military discipline and said, in the words the court heard, that he had been raised as a soldier and as a soldier had carried out orders. He defended his conduct by reference to the Hague Convention, arguing that people who resisted were not lawful combatants. Shown the bound report, he confirmed that the signature on it was his and that it was the original.
Witnesses were heard on the second and third days, among them a survivor of the ghetto and a veteran of one of the Jewish fighting organizations. Stroop was also questioned, more briefly, about the reprisal order of July 16, 1943.
On July 23, 1951, the fourth day of the hearing, the court found Jürgen Stroop guilty of the crimes charged in the indictment. Under the decree of August 31, 1944, on the punishment of fascist-Hitlerite criminals, it sentenced him to death, to the permanent loss of public rights and civic rights of honor, and to the forfeiture of all his property.
The court found no mitigating circumstances.
Franz Konrad was sentenced to death under the same decree.
Stroop's defense lawyer appealed against the verdict on the ground that there was no direct evidence of his guilt. The appeal was dismissed.
On December 12, 1951, Stroop asked for clemency. On December 29 the Provincial Court for the capital city of Warsaw gave a negative opinion on the request. On February 29, 1952, the President of Poland was recorded as not exercising the right of clemency, and the request was refused.
He was executed in Warsaw on March 6, 1952.
Stroop was convicted under the decree of August 31, 1944, issued by the Polish Committee of National Liberation, on the punishment of fascist-Hitlerite criminals guilty of the murder and mistreatment of civilians and prisoners of war, and of traitors to the Polish nation. A consolidated text was published in 1946.
Article 1 provided the death penalty for anyone who, acting for the German state, took part in the killing of civilians, soldiers or prisoners of war, or harmed people sought or persecuted for political, national, religious or racial reasons by identifying or seizing them.
Article 4 made membership of a criminal organization created or recognized by the German state a crime in itself, punishable by at least three years' imprisonment, life imprisonment or death, and it named the SS among those organizations.
Article 7 required a court that convicted under the decree to order the loss of public rights and civic rights of honor and the forfeiture of the convicted person's entire property. Those were the additional penalties pronounced on July 23, 1951.
Stroop never admitted guilt in either court. In Warsaw he went further than a general denial, contesting particular acts that Konrad attributed to him and calling Konrad's evidence untrue. His appeal argued that there was no direct evidence against him. The court of first instance had convicted him on every count, and the appeal was dismissed.
The figure of at least 56,065 dead is the indictment's, drawn from his own report. Questioned by his defense lawyer, Stroop told the court that 56,065 was the number of people he had been told were living in the ghetto when he arrived; he did not accept it as a count of the dead. The court convicted him on the indictment as charged.
September 26, 1895: Born Josef Stroop in Detmold, principality of Lippe.
1914: Volunteers for the 55th Infantry Regiment; wounded on the Western Front.
July 1, 1932: Joins the SS; joins the Nazi Party on September 1, 1932.
March 1933: Becomes leader of the auxiliary police of Lippe.
March 1934: Promoted to SS-Hauptsturmführer.
October 9, 1939: Takes command of the Selbstschutz in Poznań.
March 6, 1940: Takes command of the SS district in Gniezno, until October 22, 1941.
May 1941: Changes his first name to Jürgen.
February 1943: Appointed SS and Police Leader in Lwów.
April 17, 1943: Arrives in Warsaw.
April 19, 1943: Takes command of the final liquidation of the Warsaw ghetto.
May 16, 1943: The operation is declared complete.
June 29, 1943: Appointed SS and Police Leader of the Warsaw District.
July 16, 1943: Orders the reprisal killing of 100 Poles in Warsaw.
September 1943: Higher SS and Police Leader in Greece; promoted to SS-Gruppenführer.
November 9, 1943: Posted to Wiesbaden as Higher SS and Police Leader Rhein-Westmark, until March 1945.
May 8, 1945: Taken into custody by American forces in Bavaria.
November 21, 1945: The chief American prosecutor cites the report in his opening statement at Nuremberg.
December 14, 1945: The report is entered in evidence before the International Military Tribunal as Exhibit USA-275.
February 1946: Poland requests his extradition; the request is refused.
January 10, 1947: Trial opens before the General Military Government Court at Dachau.
March 21, 1947: Sentenced to death at Dachau.
May 31, 1947: Handed over to the Polish authorities in Warsaw.
November 22, 1947: His appeal against the Dachau sentence is rejected.
July 5, 1951: The Warsaw indictment is signed.
July 18, 1951: Trial of Stroop and Franz Konrad opens in Warsaw.
July 23, 1951: Found guilty and sentenced to death.
December 12, 1951: Asks for clemency.
February 29, 1952: Clemency is refused.
March 6, 1952: Executed in Warsaw.