Juan Roa Sierra

Victims
1 killing in Bogotá, Colombia, April 9, 1948; named by the judicial investigation; never tried (he was killed by a crowd the same day)
Years active
April 9, 1948
Location
Bogotá, Colombia (killing); Bogotá, Colombia (birth and death)
Method
Shot (finding of the 1948 judicial investigation and the Scotland Yard review; never tested at trial)
Status
Never tried. A special judicial investigation (1948) and a Scotland Yard review concluded he acted alone. Died untried: killed by a crowd in Bogotá, Colombia, April 9, 1948.

On April 9, 1948, Jorge Eliécer Gaitán, the leader of Colombia's Liberal Party and the man widely expected to win the next presidential election, was killed in central Bogotá. The man named as his killer was Juan Roa Sierra, an unemployed Bogotá native of about 26 who had spent the previous months trying, and failing, to get an audience with him. Roa was dead the same day, before anyone in authority could put a single question to him.

That is the heart of the case and the reason it has never closed. Roa was never charged, never tried and never heard. A special judicial investigation opened within days, and a team of officers from Scotland Yard reviewed it at the government's invitation; both concluded that Roa had committed the killing and had acted alone. No court ever ruled on that evidence, and none ever found who, if anyone, stood behind him.

Roa was born in Bogotá in November 1921. The British investigators recorded that he had three years of primary schooling and then drifted through casual work as an unskilled laborer; later accounts describe him as a driving apprentice, a bricklayer or a worker in the tire repair trade. In the months before April 1948 he had no job at all, and he was living in the Ricaurte district of the city. Letters between Roa and the Rosicrucian order in San José, California, turned up in the investigation, and he had told people he believed he was the reincarnation of Francisco de Paula Santander, the general and statesman of Colombian independence. For about eighteen months he had also been consulting a palm reader, the last time on April 7, 1948, two days before the killing.

The man Roa had been trying to see was the most popular politician in the country. He had trained as a lawyer at the National University and studied criminal law in Rome, and he built his public life on a direct appeal to the poor of the cities and the countryside. He had been mayor of Bogotá for about eight months in 1936, minister of education in 1940 and minister of labor in the mid-1940s, and he sat in Congress. In the 1946 presidential election the Liberal vote split between him and the party's official candidate, and the Conservative Mariano Ospina Pérez won the presidency. By 1948 he had taken control of the Liberal Party and was the strong favorite for the election due in 1950.

He was still practicing law, and on April 9 itself he had won an acquittal for an army lieutenant charged in a 1938 killing in Manizales. As violence against Liberal supporters spread through the provinces, he led a silent march of about 100,000 people into the Plaza de Bolívar on February 7, 1948, to demand that it stop. On March 30, 1948, the Ninth International Conference of American States opened in Bogotá.

The evidence that tied Roa most closely to the Liberal leader came from the leader's own office. His secretary told the investigation that Roa had come several times in the months before the killing, asking to see him, and had been left to wait with the other callers; she did not remember him ever being received. Twice, she believed, he came with another man who did the talking, a companion who was never identified. Roa was in the office on April 8 and came back on the morning of April 9, when she wrote his name on an appointment card. Some days after the killing she checked the card and found the name was the same.

What he wanted is not entirely clear. Evidence gathered by the inquiry indicated that he had asked the Liberal leader for a job, had been told that a leader whose party was out of power could not help him, and had been advised to write to the president instead. He did, and the letter is in the file.

On April 9, as the Liberal leader came out of his office building with friends, he was killed. Two police officers detained Roa at once, a crowd took him from them, and he was dead within minutes. The Liberal leader died later that day. The killing set off riots that burned much of central Bogotá and left several thousand people dead before the army restored order.

Roa's identity was established from his national identity card and other evidence that the British investigators later said left them in no doubt. A first criminal judge gathered the earliest evidence, and from April 21, 1948, a magistrate of the Supreme Court of Justice, appointed special investigator, took the inquiry over and widened it. One line of inquiry concerned the companion seen in the waiting room. In September 1948 the secretary picked a man out of a lineup as someone who had come to the office shortly before the killing and given his name as Roa Sierra; he was questioned and never charged.

At the government's request, three officers from Scotland Yard arrived in Bogotá in June 1948. Under Colombian law the inquiry had to stay secret until it reached a court, so the British officers worked as advisers on the magistrate's own file rather than running an investigation of their own. Their report, sent through the British embassy in July 1948, stayed confidential until it was declassified in 2002.

Its conclusions were plain. The evidence of the friends who were with the Liberal leader, of the two police officers and of other eyewitnesses, together with the evidence of Roa's identity, his clothing and his visits to the office, left the officers in little or no doubt that Roa was the killer. They found no reliable evidence that any political party as such had taken part. They examined a detective's report that two young Cuban visitors, in Bogotá for a student congress held alongside the conference, might have spoken with a man resembling Roa on the morning of the killing. The detective's account shifted when the magistrate questioned him again, and the officers judged any link so remote that it should be mentioned only with great caution. They rejected the idea that Roa had been part of a premeditated plot.

On motive they reached no firm finding. They thought it possible, perhaps probable, that frustration at being refused not only a job but even a hearing had driven him, and both they and the magistrate said they were not wholly satisfied that they had uncovered the whole truth.

The file did not close with the British report. In May 1959 it passed to a new criminal judge, who ordered further evidence, and in June 1960 a new examination in Bogotá supported the account of a single assailant. Inquiries pressed by the civil party in the 1970s led nowhere. A superior criminal judge in Bogotá then declared the penal action extinguished by reason of Roa's death, and in April 1978 a chamber of the Bogotá Tribunal confirmed that ruling. Those last steps are known from a single published account, a 1998 investigation by the newspaper El Espectador. The ruling ended the case in law without any verdict on what Roa had done.

From the first hours, the finding that Roa acted alone has had to compete with theories that someone else planned the killing, and no court ever resolved the question. The government at first blamed communists and foreign agents bent on sabotaging the inter-American conference, but within days it was describing the killing as a non-political act, and in 1982 a secret inquiry by the United States State Department found no solid evidence tying it to Colombian or foreign communists. Later theories have pointed at domestic political rivals, at the political police, at foreign governments and at business interests. Accusations examined in the file fell away, some because they were false and others because they grew out of political feuds. The presence of the two Cuban students in Bogotá has fed claims, decades later, that they took part, a link the Scotland Yard officers had judged remote.

Some witnesses described the killer in terms they said did not fit Roa, and other writers have proposed different people as the true killer. No court has tested any of these accounts, and Roa's motive died with him.

Timeline

November 1921: Juan Roa Sierra is born in Bogotá.

1946: The Liberal vote splits and a Conservative wins the presidency.

Early 1948: Roa makes repeated visits to the Liberal leader's office asking to see him.

February 7, 1948: The Liberal leader leads a silent march of about 100,000 people in Bogotá's Plaza de Bolívar.

March 30, 1948: The Ninth International Conference of American States opens in Bogotá.

April 8, 1948: Roa visits the Liberal leader's office again.

April 9, 1948: The Liberal leader is killed in central Bogotá; Roa is detained and killed by a crowd minutes later; rioting spreads through the capital.

April 21, 1948: A Supreme Court magistrate, appointed special investigator, widens the inquiry.

June 1948: Three Scotland Yard officers arrive in Bogotá.

July 1948: The Scotland Yard officers report that Roa was the killer and that no political party took part.

September 1948: The secretary identifies a man as the companion seen at the office; he is never charged.

May 1959: A new criminal judge takes over the file and orders further evidence.

June 1960: A new examination in Bogotá supports the account of a single assailant.

April 1978: The Bogotá Tribunal confirms that the penal action is extinguished by reason of Roa's death.

1982: A secret United States State Department inquiry finds no solid evidence of communist involvement.

2002: The Scotland Yard report is declassified.