Juan Luna was convicted in May 2007 of the first degree murder of seven people in Palatine, Illinois, a suburb northwest of Chicago, on the night of January 8, 1993. The seven were killed at a business where Luna had once worked, and his friend James Degorski was convicted with him in a separate trial. The case stayed unsolved for more than nine years. It broke in March 2002, when Degorski's former girlfriend told a friend what the two men had told her weeks after the killings, and the friend went to the police.
A Cook County jury found Luna guilty of seven counts of first degree murder on May 10, 2007, and found him eligible for the death penalty. It did not reach a unanimous verdict on a death sentence, and on August 8, 2007, the trial judge sentenced him to natural life imprisonment. The Appellate Court of Illinois affirmed the conviction in April 2013, and the Illinois Supreme Court declined to hear a further appeal that September. Degorski, tried separately, was convicted in 2009 and also sentenced to life. Since recanting his confession Luna has maintained that he is innocent, and in 2017 the federal government went to court to strip him of the American citizenship he had gained two years after the killings.
Luna and Degorski had been friends since high school. A friend of Degorski's who later testified at the trial knew both of them, and the three spent time together in the early 1990s. Degorski's girlfriend from 1992, the woman whose statement would finally break the case, met Luna through Degorski in 1991, when she was still in high school.
Luna had once worked at the Palatine business where the seven died.
He was not yet a citizen. Federal court records show that he applied to become a naturalized American citizen on April 24, 1994, fifteen months after the killings. The form asked whether he had ever knowingly committed a crime for which he had not been arrested, and the box marked "no" was checked. A government officer interviewed him on October 27, 1994, and he took the oath of citizenship on January 31, 1995. In his later answer to the government's suit he admitted that he had not disclosed any involvement in the crimes during that process, while denying that he had been involved at all.
Seven people died that night: Lynn and Richard Ehlenfeldt of Arlington Heights, Michael Castro, Guadalupe Maldonado, Thomas Mennes, Marcus Nellsen and Rico Solis. Palatine police learned of the deaths in the early hours of January 9, 1993, and the investigation that followed would run for more than nine years.
Every count in the indictment, and every count on which Luna was later convicted, carried one of those seven names.
The investigation began with the people who knew the business. Luna was among the former workers interviewed in February 1993.
Evidence collected in January 1993 was kept for years, but none of it yet pointed to a name that police could charge.
Luna came back into the investigation on November 25, 1995. A Palatine officer asked Degorski's friend, the woman who would later testify at both trials, to come to the police station, and she went there with Degorski and Luna. She told the officer that the three of them had been together on the night of the murders and that they learned about the killings the next morning. At trial she admitted that only part of that account had been true.
The years that followed produced suspects and statements that led nowhere. A task force formed in the late 1990s questioned other men, among them M.B., J.S. and T.W.; none of them was charged, and J.S., who gave a videotaped statement in 1999, was released and never prosecuted.
Degorski's former girlfriend had been away from her friends in early January 1993. Degorski telephoned her a few days after the killings, and after January 25, 1993, she saw him again with Luna. She testified that the two men then described the murders to her and admitted taking part in them, that Degorski threatened her if she ever spoke, and that he told her he would use his other friend as an alibi.
She kept the secret for more than nine years. In March 2002 she told a friend what the two men had told her. The friend went to the police, and that same month a sergeant of the Palatine police department contacted her.
Two months later, on May 16, 2002, police arrested Luna. Degorski was arrested the same day. The next morning an assistant state's attorney spoke with Luna, who waived his Miranda rights and gave a videotaped statement admitting that he and Degorski had taken part. He later recanted the statement, saying it had been coerced.
After the arrest, evidence kept from 1993 was linked to Luna.
Luna and Degorski were charged in the Circuit Court of Cook County with the first degree murder of all seven victims. Both men pleaded not guilty. The court severed the two cases, so each man would face his own jury. Prosecutors sought the death penalty against both.
Degorski's friend, the woman who had given police the 1995 alibi, agreed to testify for the State. In exchange the State's Attorney's office promised not to prosecute her for obstruction of justice, concealment or acting as an accessory after the fact.
Luna went to trial first, in the spring of 2007, before a Cook County jury. The trial lasted several weeks and dozens of witnesses testified for both sides.
The State built its case on two kinds of evidence. The first was Luna's own words: the videotaped statement of May 17, 2002, which the jury watched, and the accounts of the two women. Degorski's friend testified that she met the two men in Carpentersville on the evening of January 8, 1993, and that they told her that night what they had done. Degorski's former girlfriend testified to what the men had told her later that January. Both women were cross-examined about their histories and their delays in coming forward, and the judge instructed the jury to view the friend's testimony with caution because of her agreement with the State.
The second was the physical evidence kept from 1993, which the State's experts linked to Luna and the defense attacked through experts of its own.
The defense also offered another explanation for the crime, and the jury was shown J.S.'s 1999 videotaped statement. The judge refused to admit statements by T.W. and C.S., ruling that neither was against the speaker's own penal interest.
On May 10, 2007, the jury found Luna guilty of all seven counts of first degree murder.
The same jury then heard the State's case for death. It found Luna eligible for the death penalty. Under Illinois law at the time, a death sentence required a unanimous jury, and this jury was not unanimous: one juror would not vote for death. That decision required the judge to impose the lesser sentence.
On August 8, 2007, the judge denied the defense motion for a new trial and sentenced Luna to natural life imprisonment without the possibility of parole.
Degorski's trial in the same court took four weeks in 2009. The jury convicted him of the murders and found him eligible for death, but two jurors refused a death sentence, and on October 20, 2009, the jury declined to impose death. He too was sentenced to natural life. The Appellate Court of Illinois affirmed his conviction on October 17, 2013, rejecting his complaints about the testimony of the former prosecutor who had taken his confession and about a video shown to the jury.
Luna's appeal went to the First District of the Appellate Court of Illinois. Lawyers from the State Appellate Defender's office raised five arguments, and the court rejected every one of them in a published opinion filed on April 25, 2013.
The first argument challenged the identification evidence from 1993 and the method behind it. The court held that the trial judge had properly taken judicial notice of the general acceptance of the method, and that doubts about how the examiner had applied it in this case went to the weight of the evidence, for the jury to judge, and not to whether it was admissible.
The second argument was that Luna's trial lawyers had been ineffective for not seeking a pretrial hearing on the laboratory evidence. The court found that the defense team had been fully aware of the issue and had attacked it at trial with multiple experts, that their choice could have been a reasonable strategy, and that Luna's contrary view was, in the court's words, "wholly speculative."
The third argument asked the court to abandon the general-acceptance test used in Illinois and adopt the federal standard instead. The court answered that this was not an argument it could accept, since the Illinois Supreme Court had repeatedly held that Illinois courts follow the older test.
The fourth argument concerned the prosecutor's rebuttal closing. Most of the complaints had been forfeited because no objection was made at trial or carried into the post-trial motion. Even so, the court examined each remark. It found most of them within the bounds of fair argument, but it held that three were improper: a passing remark that demeaned the defense expert's doctorate, a needlessly disparaging comment about defense counsel's tactics, and a statement that the verdict would reach beyond the courtroom to the community. The trial judge had stopped the prosecutor at once after the last remark and told the jurors to consider only the facts and the law as they applied to Luna. The court held that those instructions cured any prejudice and that the other two remarks were too brief to have denied Luna a fair trial.
The fifth argument was that the judge should have admitted the statements of T.W. and C.S. The court held that neither statement was against the speaker's penal interest. T.W. had not admitted any role in the killings or even that he had seen them, and C.S. had said only that she was present and fled. Being present at a crime, the court said, is not a crime in itself. A new theory that C.S. could have been prosecuted for obstruction because she had first told police she knew nothing had never been raised in the trial court, and the court found nothing in the record to support it.
The court affirmed the conviction. On September 25, 2013, the Illinois Supreme Court denied Luna leave to appeal, and the conviction became final.
On February 27, 2017, the United States filed a civil suit in the federal district court in Chicago to revoke Luna's citizenship. The government relied on all three grounds the immigration law allows: that his naturalization had been illegally procured, that it had been procured by concealing a material fact, and that it had been procured by willful misrepresentation. Each ground came down to the same point: he had not disclosed the 1993 murders when he applied.
Luna answered the suit himself at first, and the court recruited a lawyer for him after finding he could not afford one. In his answer he admitted that he stood convicted of the seven murders and that he had not disclosed them, but he maintained that he was innocent.
The government then asked for judgment on the pleadings, arguing that the state conviction settled the question and that Luna could not relitigate his guilt. On March 8, 2019, the district judge denied the motion. The court noted that the evidence for withdrawing citizenship must be clear, unequivocal and convincing, and that the government's case depended on the doctrine that bars a party from relitigating an issue already decided. Because Luna's possible innocence claim would rest on new evidence never presented to an Illinois court, and because he had no lawyer to present it, the judge held that she could not yet say whether applying that doctrine would be fair. She expressly declined to take any view on the ultimate question.
By March 2019 Luna had still not found counsel for a state innocence petition.
Luna is serving natural life imprisonment in Illinois. Degorski is serving the same sentence. Both were still serving those sentences in January 2023, thirty years after the killings.
Two bodies of law decided Luna's later court battles, and the courts that heard his case set out the tests they used.
The appellate court measured his scientific-evidence complaints against the test Illinois takes from a 1923 federal appeals decision, Frye v. United States. Under it, the court explained, the test matters only when a technique is new or novel, and general acceptance does not mean unanimity, consensus or even a majority of experts. The question is whether a method is accepted, not whether a particular examiner reached the right answer.
The federal court in the citizenship suit began from the Supreme Court's description of withdrawing citizenship as a "drastic measure." To use Luna's conviction against him, the government had to satisfy four conditions: the issue had to be the same as in the criminal case, it had to have been actually litigated, its decision had to have been essential to the judgment, and Luna had to have been fully represented. Even then the court kept discretion to refuse if applying the bar would be unfair. A party can also escape it by showing new evidence, essential to a proper decision, that was not his fault to have missed. Those were the open questions when the judge denied the government's motion.
Luna has maintained his innocence since recanting his videotaped statement, which he says was coerced. The trial jury and the appellate court rejected his challenges, and his conviction is final. The innocence claim he described to the federal court in 2017 and 2018 has not been presented to an Illinois court.
The two men's individual roles inside the business that night rest on Luna's statement and on what the two women testified the men told them. Those accounts placed both men at the center of the killings and were the State's theory at both trials.
The other men questioned over the years, M.B., J.S. and T.W., were never charged. J.S.'s 1999 statement was shown to Luna's jury, which convicted Luna after hearing it.
January 8, 1993: Seven people are killed in Palatine, Illinois.
January 9, 1993: Palatine police learn of the deaths and open the investigation.
Late January 1993: Degorski's girlfriend later testifies that the two men told her of the killings at about this time.
February 1993: Luna is among the former workers interviewed.
April 24, 1994: Luna applies for naturalization.
January 31, 1995: Luna becomes a naturalized US citizen.
November 25, 1995: Luna, Degorski and a friend go to the Palatine police station; the friend gives a partly false account of the night.
August 9, 1999: J.S. gives a videotaped statement; he is released and never prosecuted.
March 2002: Degorski's former girlfriend tells a friend what the men told her; police contact her that month.
May 16, 2002: Luna and Degorski are arrested.
May 17, 2002: Luna gives a videotaped statement after waiving his Miranda rights.
Spring 2007: Luna's separate jury trial in Cook County.
May 10, 2007: Jury finds Luna guilty of seven counts of first degree murder.
August 8, 2007: After the jury fails to agree on death, Luna is sentenced to natural life.
October 20, 2009: Degorski is sentenced to natural life after his own conviction.
April 25, 2013: The Appellate Court of Illinois affirms Luna's conviction.
September 25, 2013: The Illinois Supreme Court denies leave to appeal.
October 17, 2013: The Appellate Court affirms Degorski's conviction.
February 27, 2017: The United States sues to revoke Luna's citizenship.
March 8, 2019: The federal court denies the government's motion for judgment on the pleadings.
January 2023: Both men are serving life sentences, thirty years after the killings.