Jozef Puska

Victims
1 woman murdered at Tullamore, Ireland, January 2022; convicted by a unanimous Central Criminal Court jury, November 9, 2023
Years active
January 12, 2022
Location
Cappincur, Tullamore, County Offaly, Ireland (killing); Mucklagh, County Offaly, Ireland (residence); Dublin, Ireland (trial)
Method
Stabbed (jury verdict; trial evidence)
Status
Mandatory life imprisonment, November 17, 2023. Conviction appeal abandoned July 10, 2026; sentence appeal dismissed July 16, 2026. Serving life in Ireland as of July 16, 2026.

On the afternoon of Wednesday, January 12, 2022, Ashling Murphy was killed at Cappincur, on the edge of Tullamore in County Offaly. She was a young woman from the Offaly countryside with a fiddle and a camogie team. The man convicted of her murder was Jozef Puska, a Slovak-born resident of the nearby village of Mucklagh who had never met her. Both sides at his trial accepted that there was no connection between them, and no motive was ever offered.

Puska was charged a week after the killing. Twenty-one months later a Central Criminal Court jury in Dublin heard a case built on his own admissions to gardaí, on video from the streets of Tullamore that afternoon, on an eyewitness and on scientific evidence. He gave evidence and denied the murder. The jury returned a unanimous guilty verdict on November 9, 2023, and he received the only sentence Irish law allows for murder: life imprisonment. In July 2026, days before the Court of Appeal was due to hear his challenge to the conviction, he abandoned it. The appeal court then rejected his one remaining complaint, about the date from which his life sentence runs.

Music shaped her life from the start. She played the fiddle and sang, belonged to the Ballyboy branch of Comhaltas Ceoltóirí Éireann in Offaly, toured with Comhaltas in Ireland and abroad, and taught the branch's younger players. She played camogie for the Kilcormac-Killoughey club. She was involved in her parish and her county, in sport, in music and in events for older people.

Much less is on record about the man convicted of killing her. He was born in Slovakia and came to court with a Slovakian interpreter at every stage, from his first appearance in January 2022 to his trial. He was 31 when he was charged and 33 when he was tried. He lived in Mucklagh, a village just outside Tullamore, and he later told detectives that he had not worked since 2017.

Gardaí opened a murder investigation on the day of the killing, run from Tullamore Garda Station with the National Bureau of Criminal Investigation. The case that eventually reached the jury placed Puska in Tullamore in the hours before her death, on video from the town center, and the prosecution said that physical and scientific evidence tied him to the scene itself.

He was in Dublin two days after the killing. On January 14, 2022, gardaí spoke to him there through an interpreter, and they later testified that he told them, "I did it, I murdered, I am the murderer." That admission, made before he had been arrested or cautioned in a garda station, became the most contested piece of evidence in the case. At the trial the defense attacked the circumstances in which it was taken, the way gardaí approached him, the absence of any recording and his condition at the time.

Puska was arrested on suspicion of murder on January 18, 2022, and he remained in custody from that date until his trial. During questioning, first in Dublin and later at Tullamore Garda Station, he made admissions and then denied knowing her. The prosecution later asked the jury to draw an inference, under the Criminal Justice Act 1984, from his failure in questioning to explain the evidence that linked him to the scene. He also told gardaí things in January 2022 that he admitted under cross-examination were lies.

On the evening of January 19, 2022, a week after the killing, he was charged with her murder at a special sitting of Tullamore District Court, where he replied "no" when cautioned, and he was remanded in custody. The case then went forward to the Central Criminal Court, which tries every murder charge in Ireland.

The trial opened at the Central Criminal Court, at the Criminal Courts of Justice in Dublin, on Monday, October 16, 2023. Puska was arraigned on a single count of murder at Cappincur on January 12, 2022, and through his interpreter answered "not guilty." The prosecution opened its case the next morning, relying on his admissions, on video from Tullamore, on scientific evidence and on witnesses.

Over the following weeks the jury heard from gardaí, from witnesses in Tullamore, from scientists and from medical experts. An eyewitness described what she saw at the scene, and the defense challenged her account as a mistaken impression. It challenged the admission in Dublin from every angle: the setting, the questioning, the use of an interpreter and the effect of his medical treatment.

Puska then went into the witness box. He denied the murder and told the jury that another man, a stranger, was responsible. He accepted under cross-examination that he had lied to gardaí in January 2022, and he put his conduct after the killing down to fear for his family's safety.

Closing speeches were made on November 7, and both sides fought once more over the reliability of the admission. The trial judge charged the jury the next day. If the jurors had a reasonable doubt about the reliability of the admission in Dublin, he directed, they should put it aside, and lies alone did not prove guilt. On Thursday, November 9, 2023, the jury returned a unanimous verdict of guilty on the single count of murder.

Murder carries a mandatory life sentence in Ireland, and Puska was sentenced at the Central Criminal Court on Friday, November 17, 2023. The trial judge imposed life imprisonment. Irish law gave him no power to set a minimum term before parole could be considered. He backdated the sentence only to the day of the verdict, November 9, 2023, rather than to January 2022, when Puska first went into custody. That decision left his time on remand outside the life sentence, and it became the only ground he pursued to a hearing in the Court of Appeal.

Puska lodged an appeal against his conviction, and on April 19, 2024, the Court of Appeal granted him legal aid to pursue it. The grounds were expected to center on two rulings by the trial judge: the decision to let the jury hear his admission to gardaí two days after the killing, which the defense said had been involuntary because of the effects of his medical treatment, and the decision to admit the video from Tullamore town center.

The appeal moved slowly. In April 2026, less than a week before a scheduled hearing, his barristers told the court that his instructions required them to seek leave to withdraw, and the hearing was put back to July. On Friday, July 10, 2026, his new senior counsel told the Court of Appeal that Puska had signed a notice abandoning the appeal against conviction. Only the challenge to the sentence remained.

That appeal was heard on Thursday, July 16, 2026. The defense argued that the trial judge had given no proper basis for refusing to backdate the sentence to the arrest and that the date matters because parole review is measured from the time a prisoner enters custody. The court dismissed the appeal. It held that the sentencing judge had a discretion over backdating and had stated his reasons for exercising it as he did, and that a court passing or reviewing a sentence must leave remission and parole out of account.

With both appeals ended, the conviction and the life sentence stand. As of July 16, 2026, the latest report, Puska was serving that sentence in Ireland.

No motive was ever established. Neither side offered one at trial. Puska and the woman he was convicted of killing had never met.

The reliability of Puska's admission in Dublin on January 14, 2022, was the central dispute at trial. The defense argued that his medical condition, an unfamiliar setting, the questioning and a language barrier made it unreliable, and that it should not have been admitted at all. The trial judge let the jury hear it and told them to set it aside if they had a reasonable doubt about its reliability. The jury convicted, and because Puska abandoned his appeal against conviction in July 2026, the Court of Appeal never ruled on the admission or on the video evidence from Tullamore.

Puska's own account, that a stranger was responsible, was rejected by the jury. No other person was ever charged with the killing; a man arrested on January 19, 2022, was released without charge the same day. Why Puska abandoned the conviction appeal so close to the hearing was not explained in court.

Timeline

January 12, 2022: A young woman is killed at Cappincur, outside Tullamore, County Offaly; a murder investigation begins.

January 14, 2022: In Dublin, Puska tells gardaí through an interpreter that he did it, as they later testified at trial.

January 18, 2022: Puska is arrested on suspicion of murder; he remains in custody from this date.

January 19, 2022: Puska is charged with murder at a special sitting of Tullamore District Court and remanded in custody.

October 16, 2023: Puska pleads not guilty at the Central Criminal Court in Dublin.

November 9, 2023: A unanimous jury finds him guilty of murder.

November 17, 2023: Puska is sentenced to mandatory life imprisonment, backdated to November 9, 2023.

April 19, 2024: The Court of Appeal grants legal aid for his appeal against conviction.

July 10, 2026: Puska abandons his appeal against conviction.

July 16, 2026: The Court of Appeal dismisses his appeal against the start date of his sentence; he is serving life in Ireland.