Joseph P. Smith

Victims
1 girl kidnapped and murdered in Sarasota, February 1, 2004. Convicted November 17, 2005, of first-degree murder, kidnapping and a further capital charge; affirmed 2009
Years active
February 1, 2004
Location
Sarasota, Florida
Method
First-degree murder, with other charges (kidnapping among them)
Status
Death (March 15, 2006), two life terms; affirmed 2009; vacated, reinstated 2020, resentencing ordered May 2021; died July 2021 before resentencing

On February 1, 2004, a girl was kidnapped and murdered in Sarasota, Florida. Within days the man accused of taking her was in custody, and within two years a Sarasota County jury had convicted him of first-degree murder, with other charges, kidnapping among them. He was Joseph Peter Smith, an unemployed mechanic who was serving a drug-offender probation at the time.

A circuit judge sentenced Smith to death in March 2006, and the Florida Supreme Court affirmed the convictions and the sentence in December 2009. Then the law under him changed. His jury had recommended death by ten votes to two, a margin Florida accepted in 2005 and stopped accepting after 2016. For the last years of his life his sentence moved back and forth between the circuit court in Sarasota and the state supreme court: vacated, the vacatur affirmed by a single vote, reinstated, then sent back for a new hearing. Smith died in Florida custody in late July 2021, before any new jury heard the case. His convictions were never disturbed.

By early 2004 Smith had been out of work for some time, living in Sarasota and renting a room. Evidence offered at his sentencing later described a long and documented history of mental illness and drug addiction, years of severe back pain that he said fed the addiction, repeated hospital admissions for addiction and depression, and repeated attempts at treatment that came to little.

His earlier convictions, for drug possession and prescription fraud, had brought probation and a term in state prison, and in February 2004 he was again on drug-offender probation.

Investigators from the Sarasota County Sheriff's Office and the Federal Bureau of Investigation took up the case on the night of February 1. On February 3 officers arrested Smith in Sarasota for violating his probation and for possessing drug paraphernalia. After he was read his rights he asked for a lawyer, and the questioning stopped. The probation violation let the state hold him without bail while the larger investigation went on, and within days he was named as under arrest for the girl's abduction and murder.

On February 20, 2004, prosecutors in the Twelfth Judicial Circuit charged him with kidnapping and a further capital felony, and a Sarasota County grand jury indicted him the same day for first-degree murder. Physical evidence linked him to the crime, and in recorded conversations, the Florida Supreme Court later found, he admitted the killing.

Smith pleaded not guilty, and the trial opened in Sarasota in November 2005. He did not testify, and on November 17 the jury found him guilty of first-degree murder, kidnapping and the further capital charge. In the penalty phase the defense called witnesses on his addiction, the treatment he had sought, his hospital admissions and his good conduct and spiritual counseling in the county jail. On December 1, 2005, the jury recommended death by a vote of ten to two.

Under Florida law as it then stood, that recommendation was advisory, and the judge had to give it great weight. At a separate hearing in February 2006, known in Florida practice as a Spencer hearing, Smith spoke for himself. He wept, apologized and said he accepted responsibility for what he had done. He said he had taken large quantities of drugs that day in an attempt to end his own life and remembered little of it. "I do not ask for mercy for myself," he told the court, and asked for a life sentence.

On March 15, 2006, the circuit judge sentenced him to death for the murder, to two terms of life imprisonment on the other counts, and to five years for violating his probation. The written order found several aggravating circumstances, among them that he had been on felony probation and that the murder was committed during the other felonies, and no statutory mitigating circumstance. It weighed his history of mental illness and drug abuse, and his remorse, as nonstatutory mitigation, and concluded that the aggravation far outweighed it.

The Florida Supreme Court decided Smith's direct appeal on December 17, 2009. It found some errors at trial and held each of them harmless. It struck the finding that the murder was cold, calculated and premeditated for lack of competent, substantial evidence, and left undecided whether the finding that it was committed to avoid arrest was supported, because the trial judge had said that any one of the remaining aggravators, apart from felony probation, outweighed the mitigation by itself. His argument under Ring v. Arizona, the 2002 United States Supreme Court decision on the jury's role in capital sentencing, failed because the same jury had unanimously convicted him of the kidnapping and the further capital felony. The court held the evidence sufficient on every count and the sentence proportionate, and it affirmed the convictions and the death sentence. On June 28, 2011, the United States Supreme Court declined to review the case, and with that refusal the convictions and the sentence became final.

His postconviction motion, which attacked Florida's capital sentencing statute, its jury instructions and its execution methods, was denied without an evidentiary hearing. On September 11, 2014, a unanimous Florida Supreme Court affirmed that denial, holding the claims procedurally barred, without merit or waived. Smith then took his case into federal court with a petition for a writ of habeas corpus in the United States District Court for the Middle District of Florida, and by July 2016 that petition had been stayed.

In 2016 the United States Supreme Court, in Hurst v. Florida, held that Florida's capital sentencing system gave judges too much of the jury's role, and the Florida Supreme Court, in Hurst v. State, then required a unanimous jury for death and applied that rule to sentences that had become final after 2002, Smith's among them. On January 5, 2017, Smith filed a successive motion to vacate his death sentence under the new decisions. In July 2017 a Sarasota County circuit judge granted it in part. The judge held that the principles of Hurst applied retroactively to Smith's case, a sentence that had become final after Ring and that Smith had challenged under Ring before his trial ever began. He vacated the death sentence but refused Smith's request to replace it with a sentence of life imprisonment, and he ruled that the state could seek death again at a new penalty phase. The convictions were not touched.

The state appealed, and on April 5, 2018, the Florida Supreme Court affirmed by a vote of four to three in an unsigned opinion. Hurst applied to Smith, the majority held, because his sentence had become final in 2011, after Ring. The only remaining question was whether the error had been harmless, and on that question the burden lay with the state: it had to show beyond a reasonable doubt that a rational jury would have unanimously found each aggravating factor proven, unanimously found the aggravation sufficient for death and unanimously found that it outweighed the mitigation. The court held that the state could not carry that burden. Smith's jury had made none of those findings and had divided ten to two on its recommendation, so there was no way to know whether the jurors had agreed on any of the five aggravating factors still standing after the 2009 appeal, and the court would not guess at the reasons of the two jurors who had voted for life. The error was not harmless beyond a reasonable doubt, and the order granting a new penalty phase stood. The case went back to Sarasota, and in May 2019 the state said it would again seek death.

In January 2020, in State v. Poole, the Florida Supreme Court receded from its unanimity requirement. In April 2020 the circuit judge granted the state's motion and reinstated Smith's death sentence. Later that year, in the Jackson and Okafor cases, the same court held that Poole did not undo an earlier order granting a new penalty phase once that order had become final. In March 2021 the Attorney General's office conceded that Smith's case had to return to the circuit court, and in May 2021 the Florida Supreme Court, by unanimous order, remanded it for resentencing. The order left his convictions untouched.

Smith died in Florida custody in late July 2021 while awaiting that hearing. No jury ever revisited his sentence, and his convictions for first-degree murder and the other offenses, affirmed in 2009 and left standing in every later ruling, remained in place at his death.

Smith never contested at sentencing that he was responsible for the girl's death. His account of having taken drugs that day in an attempt to end his life, and of remembering little of it, was his own statement at the Spencer hearing; the trial court weighed his drug abuse as mitigation but found no statutory mitigating circumstance. The cold, calculated and premeditated finding was struck on appeal, and the avoid-arrest finding was never reviewed on its merits.

Timeline

February 1, 2004: A girl is kidnapped and murdered in Sarasota.

February 3, 2004: Arrested in Sarasota for violation of probation and possession of drug paraphernalia.

February 20, 2004: Charged with kidnapping and a further capital felony; indicted for first-degree murder.

November 17, 2005: Convicted of first-degree murder, kidnapping and the further charge.

December 1, 2005: Jury recommends death by ten votes to two.

February 2006: Apologizes and asks for a life sentence at the Spencer hearing.

March 15, 2006: Sentenced to death, with two life terms and five years for the probation violation.

December 17, 2009: Florida Supreme Court affirms the convictions and the death sentence.

June 28, 2011: The United States Supreme Court declines to review the case.

September 11, 2014: Florida Supreme Court affirms the denial of postconviction relief.

2016: Hurst v. Florida and Hurst v. State change Florida's capital sentencing law.

July 2016: His federal habeas corpus petition is stayed.

January 5, 2017: Files a successive motion to vacate the death sentence under Hurst.

July 2017: A Sarasota County circuit judge vacates the death sentence, refuses to substitute a life sentence and orders a new penalty phase.

April 5, 2018: Florida Supreme Court affirms by four votes to three, holding the Hurst error not harmless.

May 2019: The state says it will seek death again at resentencing.

January 2020: State v. Poole recedes from the unanimity requirement.

April 2020: The circuit judge reinstates the death sentence.

March 2021: The Attorney General's office concedes that a new sentencing hearing is required.

May 2021: Florida Supreme Court remands for resentencing by unanimous order.

July 2021: Dies in Florida custody before resentencing.