On August 23, 1989, a Black teenager from another part of Brooklyn was killed in Bensonhurst, a largely white neighborhood in the south of the borough. He had done nothing to anyone there. Young men from the neighborhood had come to believe, wrongly, that a Black youth was on his way to see a local white girl, and he was taken for that youth. His death brought racial tension in the city to a boil.
Joseph Fama was the man prosecutors named as the killer. A Brooklyn jury acquitted him of intentional murder in May 1990 and convicted him of murder in the second degree on the theory that he had acted with depraved indifference to human life. He received an aggregate term of 32 years and 8 months to life. The eyewitness at the center of the case against him withdrew his account before the jury retired, and the question of who caused the death has shadowed the verdict ever since.
Fama was born in 1970. He was arrested and charged in 1989, one of a group of young men charged in connection with the death, and from the start he was the one accused of causing it. The physical description given by the victim's companions soon became a point of contention. They described the killer as about six feet tall. Fama stood five foot eight.
Prosecutors tried Fama at the same time as the young man they described as the ringleader, before two separate juries that heard the same testimony. The ringleader was charged as the organizer of the group that had gathered that night. Fama was charged as the killer.
The case against him rested heavily on one witness, a young man who first testified that he had seen Fama commit the act and then admitted during the trial that he had not been there at all. He made that recantation on videotape at the defense lawyer's office, and it came to light before the case went to the jury. The defense asked the trial judge to reopen the case and put him back on the stand for further cross-examination. The judge refused, and Fama's jury never heard the recantation. The witness's reliability had already been fought over in front of the jurors.
The prosecution had a second pillar. A prisoner who had often worked as a police informer testified that Fama confessed to him while they were in jail together. The defense attacked him as a man who had misled people before, who expected a reward for his testimony and who had followed the case in the press, and Fama has disputed that testimony ever since. A second young man had told another witness that he saw Fama do it and repeated the claim before the grand jury, but he did not testify at trial.
The jury acquitted Fama of intentional murder, the count that required proof that he meant to cause death. In May 1990 it convicted him instead of murder in the second degree under the New York law that covers a person who, "under circumstances evincing a depraved indifference to human life," recklessly creates a grave risk of death to another and thereby causes a death. The same jury convicted him of riot in the first degree, three counts of menacing, three counts of unlawful imprisonment in the first degree, four counts of discrimination and one further count. The discrimination counts put the racial character of the crime into the verdict against him, not only into the case against the others.
Fama was sentenced in 1990 to an aggregate term of 32 years and 8 months to life, with murder in the second degree as the controlling conviction. He could not be considered for parole until 2022.
The others were dealt with far more lightly. The ringleader was acquitted of murder and manslaughter, convicted of twelve lesser counts including riot, unlawful imprisonment and discrimination, sentenced to 5 1/3 to 16 years, and paroled in 1998. The young man who had told a witness he saw Fama commit the act was acquitted of murder, convicted of riot and sentenced to 2 2/3 to 8 years. Three others were acquitted of every charge. By the summer of 2020 Fama was the only person arrested in the case who was still in custody.
Fama's appeal went first to the Appellate Division, Second Department, which affirmed the judgment unanimously in 1995. He then sought leave to take the case to the Court of Appeals, the state's highest court. A judge of that court denied leave without prejudice to a fresh application once new counsel was substituted, and when the application was renewed, leave was denied again on December 11, 1995. That closed his direct appeal.
He kept trying in the state courts. On July 28, 1997, the Appellate Division denied his application for a writ of error coram nobis. He also moved in the trial court to vacate the judgment on newly discovered evidence about the two witnesses who had done the most damage: a sworn statement from the eyewitness recanting his identification, and a statement from another man saying the jailhouse informant had admitted lying. The trial court denied the motion, and the Appellate Division refused leave to appeal.
On October 3, 1996, Fama petitioned the federal court for the Eastern District of New York for a writ of habeas corpus. He argued that the evidence could not support a conviction for depraved-indifference murder and that publicity and the intimidation of jurors had denied him a fair trial. In July 1999 he asked to add the new evidence about the two witnesses. The district court refused the amendment as too late, refused to hold a hearing, found his claims unexhausted or procedurally barred, and denied the petition.
The United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit took up his appeal and decided it on December 21, 2000. Its three-judge panel held that the district court had been wrong on almost every procedural point: Fama had exhausted his sufficiency claim, his fair-trial claim was not barred, and his amendment should not have been refused as untimely. It then turned to the merits and rejected every claim. On sufficiency, the panel was not convinced that it had been irrational for the jury, unpersuaded that Fama meant to kill, to find that he had acted with depraved indifference to human life. On the fair-trial claim, it found the case for prejudicial publicity insufficient and the case for intimidation of the jury unsubstantiated on the record. On the new affidavits, it held that the jurors had already been given ample reasons to disbelieve both the eyewitness and the informant, and that the other evidence of guilt was substantial. The court affirmed the denial of the writ, and the conviction stood.
Fama served his sentence in New York State correctional facilities. The Board of Parole denied him release at his first appearance, in December 2021. On July 18, 2022, the board affirmed that denial on administrative appeal. As of that decision he remained in New York State custody.
Who caused the death has never been settled to everyone's satisfaction. The jury did not find that Fama intended to kill. The prosecution's central eyewitness recanted before the jury retired, and the jury never heard the recantation; the informant who said Fama confessed was accused, in a later affidavit, of admitting he had lied. The companions' description of the killer's height does not match Fama's, and two witnesses identified another young man, who was never charged with the killing. Fama has denied the killing throughout, saying he was present that night but did not cause the death. Against all of that stands the conviction itself, which the state courts and the federal courts have each refused to set aside; the federal appeals court found the recantation and the informant affidavit immaterial because the jury already had good reason to doubt both men.
1970: Joseph Fama is born.
August 23, 1989: A Black teenager is killed in Bensonhurst, Brooklyn.
1989: Fama is arrested and charged.
1990: Fama and the alleged ringleader are tried together in Brooklyn before two juries; the only eyewitness against Fama recants during the trial.
May 1990: Fama's jury acquits him of intentional murder and convicts him of murder in the second degree (depraved indifference).
1990: Fama is sentenced to an aggregate term of 32 years 8 months to life.
1995: The Appellate Division, Second Department, unanimously affirms the conviction.
December 11, 1995: The Court of Appeals denies leave to appeal on a renewed application.
October 3, 1996: Fama petitions the federal court for the Eastern District of New York for a writ of habeas corpus.
July 28, 1997: The Appellate Division denies his coram nobis application.
1999: The federal district court denies the habeas petition.
December 21, 2000: The Second Circuit affirms the denial of habeas relief.
December 2021: The Board of Parole denies Fama release at his first appearance.
July 18, 2022: The denial is affirmed on administrative appeal; Fama remains in New York State custody.