Josef Schwammberger

Victims
7 murder counts, 32 of accessory to murder, Poland, 1942-1944. Found guilty by the Landgericht Stuttgart, May 18, 1992, and sentenced to life imprisonment.
Years active
1942 to 1944
Location
Rozwadów, Poland (killings); Przemyśl, Poland (killings); Mielec, Poland (camp; not tried); Huerta Grande, Córdoba, Argentina (arrest); Stuttgart, Germany (trial)
Method
Shooting (his own 1945 confession to about 35 deaths at Przemyśl, never tried); the method in the convicted counts is not made public
Status
Life imprisonment, May 18, 1992; release on grounds of age and frailty refused, 2002. Died in custody in a prison hospital near Stuttgart, Germany, December 2004.

Josef Schwammberger commanded SS forced-labor camps in German-occupied southern Poland from 1942 to 1944, at Rozwadów (Rozwadow) and Przemyśl (Przemysl), and later at Mielec. Most of the prisoners held under him were Jews. On May 18, 1992, the Landgericht Stuttgart, the regional court in the capital of Baden-Württemberg, found him guilty on seven counts of murder and 32 counts of accessory to murder and sentenced him to life imprisonment.

The road to that judgment ran for almost half a century. Arrested in Austria in the summer of 1945, he escaped in 1948 and spent the next four decades in Argentina. Argentine police arrested him in Córdoba province in November 1987, and his fight against extradition went all the way to the country's Supreme Court before he was handed over to West Germany in May 1990. He denied the charges from first to last. He died in custody in December 2004, at the age of 92, still serving the sentence.

Schwammberger was born on February 14, 1912, in South Tyrol, and grew up Austrian. He joined the Nazi Party early and rose through the SS. From 1941 he served with the SS in Kraków, in occupied Poland, and it was from there that he was sent to command camps in the district. The prosecution later dated the start of his command at Rozwadów to September 1942. At Przemyśl he was commandant of the labor camp and of a section of the ghetto, and in 1943 and 1944 he also held command at Mielec.

On July 19, 1945, French forces arrested him in Innsbruck, in the French zone of occupied Austria. While in custody he signed a statement admitting about 35 deaths at Przemyśl, and Austrian police kept it on file. The statement followed him through every later stage of his case, but it never came before a court as a charge of its own. In January 1948, while he was being transferred under guard, he got away. No court had yet tried him for anything.

Within months he was in Argentina. He lived there under his own name, and in 1965 he became an Argentine citizen. For years he worked at a petrochemical plant in La Plata, the capital of Buenos Aires province, and by the late 1980s he was living in Córdoba province, far to the northwest. In West Germany his file stayed open. A West German warrant for his arrest was issued in 1972, and in 1973 a court in Stuttgart asked Argentina to arrest and extradite him. Nothing came of the request until 1987.

On November 13, 1987, Argentine police arrested him in Huerta Grande, a town in Córdoba province where he had been living. Argentina had no extradition treaty with West Germany, and he fought the request through every level of the Argentine courts while he was held in custody in La Plata. Argentine prosecutors argued that he had obtained his citizenship unlawfully, by hiding his arrest record when he applied for it, and he was stripped of it. West Germany framed its request as a prosecution for crimes against humanity. In late August 1989 the federal court of appeals at La Plata upheld the order to extradite him, and in March 1990 the Supreme Court of Argentina upheld it in a ruling that was final. On May 2, 1990, Argentine officials handed him over to West German officers in Buenos Aires. He landed at Frankfurt the next day and was taken to a prison near Stuttgart.

Stuttgart prosecutors indicted him on August 20, 1990, on charges of murdering at least 50 Jews and of being an accessory to the murder of at least 3,377 more. By then the court had found him fit to stand trial. The trial opened on June 26, 1991, before the Landgericht Stuttgart, and from the start he said very little. He had denied any personal part in the killings at earlier hearings, and in court he said he could not remember the Rozwadów camp, the witnesses or the incidents they described.

The case rested on the people who had survived his camps. Survivors came to Stuttgart to testify against him, testimony taken in Paris and in Israel was read aloud, and court officials traveled to New York to question survivors who could not make the journey. The court also heard depositions from witnesses who had died before the extradition. As the trial went on, the prosecution narrowed its case to 34 prisoners it said he had killed himself and at least 275 whose deaths it said he had ordered. By April 1992 the last witnesses had been heard.

The judgment came on May 18, 1992. The court convicted him on seven counts of murder and 32 counts of accessory to murder and sentenced him to life imprisonment. It placed the crimes between 1942 and 1944 at the camps he had commanded at Rozwadów and Przemyśl; Mielec was not part of the case. The court found that he had acted out of hatred of Jews as well as for reasons of his own.

The prosecutors were not finished with him. Evidence that had surfaced during the trial could not be added to it, because it lay outside the request on which Argentina had surrendered him, and new allegations needed charges of their own. In July 1992 the prosecutors said they might bring charges over his command at Mielec, which the trial had not covered. In March 1993 they sought new proceedings over 35 further deaths, and in December 1994 they filed a new indictment of 144 counts of murder. No conviction on any of these allegations is on record. When he died, the 1992 judgment was still the only verdict against him.

He served his sentence in Baden-Württemberg. In 2002 he asked to be released on the grounds of his age and frailty, and he said again that he had only followed orders. The court refused, holding that the particularly cruel nature of his crimes outweighed the concerns about his health. He died in custody in December 2004, in a prison hospital near Stuttgart, at the age of 92. The Stuttgart prosecutor's office announced the death, and no cause was made public.

The verdict is reported as seven counts of murder and 32 counts of accessory to murder. One wire report of the judgment, filed the same day, described him instead as guilty of killing at least 25 inmates and of taking part in the killing of at least 640, and the two sets of figures have never been reconciled.

Every larger figure attached to his name was an allegation that never resulted in a conviction: the at least 5,000 deaths cited in the German extradition request, the 1990 indictment's murder of at least 50 and accessory to the murder of at least 3,377, the Mielec allegations raised in 1992, the 35 further deaths of 1993 and the 144 counts of the 1994 indictment. The about 35 deaths admitted in his 1945 confession were never tried as a charge of their own.

His own account never changed. He denied the charges, said he could not remember what the witnesses described, and in 2002 maintained that he had followed orders; the court rejected that account in 1992, and the court that heard his plea for release in 2002 did not accept it either.

Reports differ on the date of his death: one obituary gives December 2, 2004, while the agency report of the announcement on December 3 says he died overnight.

Timeline

February 14, 1912: Josef Schwammberger is born in South Tyrol.

1941: He begins SS service in Kraków, in occupied Poland.

September 1942: His command at the Rozwadów forced-labor camp begins, as the prosecution later dated it.

1942 to 1944: He commands SS forced-labor camps at Rozwadów, Przemyśl and Mielec.

July 19, 1945: French forces arrest him in Innsbruck, Austria.

January 1948: He escapes from custody and soon reaches Argentina.

1965: He becomes an Argentine citizen.

1972: West Germany issues a warrant for his arrest.

1973: A court in Stuttgart asks Argentina to extradite him.

November 13, 1987: Argentine police arrest him in Huerta Grande, Córdoba province.

Late August 1989: The federal court of appeals at La Plata upholds the extradition order.

March 1990: The Supreme Court of Argentina upholds the extradition order.

May 2, 1990: He is handed over to West German officers in Buenos Aires and flown to Germany.

August 20, 1990: He is indicted in Stuttgart for murder and accessory to murder.

June 26, 1991: His trial opens before the Landgericht Stuttgart.

May 18, 1992: He is convicted on seven counts of murder and 32 counts of accessory to murder and sentenced to life imprisonment.

March 1993: Stuttgart prosecutors seek new proceedings over 35 further deaths (no conviction followed).

December 1994: A new indictment charges him with 144 counts of murder (no conviction followed).

2002: A German court refuses his request for release on grounds of age and frailty.

December 2004: He dies in custody in a prison hospital near Stuttgart, aged 92.