For a little more than three years in the middle of the Second World War, Josef Schuetz stood guard over the prisoners of Sachsenhausen, the concentration camp the SS ran at Oranienburg, just north of Berlin. For almost eight decades afterward he lived quietly in the state of Brandenburg and kept that past to himself. Then, in February 2021, prosecutors charged him with 3,518 counts of accessory to murder. On June 28, 2022, the Neuruppin Regional Court found him guilty of aiding and abetting murder in combination with aiding and abetting attempted murder and sentenced him to five years' imprisonment. He was 101 years old, the oldest person ever convicted of complicity in the crimes of the Holocaust.
He never accepted any of it. Throughout the trial he denied that he had ever served at the camp, and the court rejected his account on the strength of SS records bearing his name, his date of birth and his place of birth. He appealed, remained free while the appeal was pending, and died on April 11, 2023, before the Federal Court of Justice could rule. Because of his death the judgment never became final. On May 3, 2023, the federal court discontinued the case, and in its order it held that his appeal would have failed.
Schuetz was born in Lithuania, and his SS records give his date of birth as November 16, 1920. His own account of the war years was simple: he had left Lithuania when the war began, had spent it as a farm laborer near Pasewalk, in the far northeast of Germany, and had never worn a German uniform. After the war he was held in Soviet captivity and then returned to Germany. He settled in Brandenburg, in what became the German Democratic Republic, worked as a farmer and as a locksmith, and lived there for decades without drawing attention to himself. The court later found that the East German state security service had known about his service in the SS.
The SS opened Sachsenhausen in the summer of 1936. More than 200,000 people passed through the camp before Soviet troops liberated it on April 22, 1945, and tens of thousands of them died there.
The records the prosecution laid before the court described a young man who joined the SS and spent the war in its service at the camp. Investigators dated his SS service at Sachsenhausen from October 23, 1941, to February 18, 1945, beginning with a period of training. The court fixed the period of his guard service from January 20, 1942, to February 18, 1945. He served in the SS Death's Head guard battalion, and his promotion to the rank of SS-Rottenführer was entered in his records.
The indictment charged him with aiding and abetting cruel and insidious murder in 3,518 cases, covering the deaths of Soviet prisoners of war in 1942 and of other prisoners at the camp during his years of service. He was not accused of killing anyone with his own hands. The charge was that his guard duty helped make the murders possible.
For most of his life no one came for him. The case began at the special federal prosecutors' office in Ludwigsburg that investigates Nazi-era crimes, which in 2019 passed the file to the public prosecutor's office in Neuruppin. In October 2019 investigators confronted him with his SS past. The case against him was built on paper: troop rolls from 1941 and 1943, personnel records and other SS files that carried his name, his birthplace and his date of birth. His name appeared once, and only once, on the lists of the SS Death's Head guard battalion. The charges rested on the reasoning of earlier German camp-guard cases, under which serving as part of a camp's machinery of killing was enough for a conviction as an accessory to murder. The Neuruppin prosecutors announced the charges on February 9, 2021. In keeping with German privacy rules his full name was not released, and German reports called him Josef S.
The Neuruppin Regional Court opened the trial on October 7, 2021, sitting in Brandenburg an der Havel, where he lived, because his health allowed only short hearing days. On the second day he told the court that he was innocent, that he did not know the Sachsenhausen camp and that he had been a farm worker near Pasewalk at the time. Through the autumn and winter the case rested above all on the documents, and a historian of the Nazi concentration camp system took the court through the SS records. In March 2022 the court gave formal notice that it might also convict him of aiding attempted murder in respect of surviving prisoners who had joined the case as co-plaintiffs. At the close of the trial he told the court again that everything in the charges was false, and said he did not know why he was there.
On June 28, 2022, the court convicted him of aiding and abetting murder in combination with aiding and abetting attempted murder and sentenced him to five years' imprisonment. It found, against his repeated denials, that he had served as a guard at Sachsenhausen for about three years, and it rested that finding on the weight of the circumstantial evidence and above all on the documents with his name, birthplace and date of birth. His service as a guard, the court said, was documented almost without a gap. It found that he knew prisoners were being killed at the camp and that his guard service supported those killings. It could not establish whether he had also acted as a perpetrator in his own right. The judgment was not final, and he was not taken into custody while his defense appealed to the Federal Court of Justice.
The appeal, a Revision limited to alleged errors of law, went to the Sixth Criminal Senate of the federal court. Schuetz died on April 11, 2023, before the Senate had decided, and on May 3, 2023, it discontinued the proceedings because of his death. In deciding who should bear the costs, the Senate held that his appeal would have failed. Applying the principles the Federal Court of Justice had developed for judging the murders committed in the concentration camps of National Socialist Germany as matters of aiding and abetting, it found that his conviction for aiding murder would have stood, at least for the killing of at least 300 Soviet prisoners of war between July and September 1942 and of at least 2,600 camp inmates in the first half of February 1945. At most a minor correction to the companion conviction for aiding attempted murder would have been needed, and the conviction would otherwise have become final. The state treasury bore the costs of the proceedings but was not required to reimburse his own expenses.
He never served any part of his sentence and was never held in custody. A court had found him guilty after a full trial, but the verdict against him never became legally binding.
He denied, to the end, that he had ever served at Sachsenhausen. The trial court rejected the denial, and the Federal Court of Justice held that his appeal would have failed, but no final judgment was ever entered against him. No killing by his own hand was proven at trial; the conviction rested on his service as a guard and on the court's finding that this service aided the murders. The investigators dated the start of his service to October 23, 1941, the court to January 20, 1942. The court did not accept his claim that he spent the war as a farm laborer.
November 16, 1920: born in Lithuania (the date in his SS records).
October 23, 1941: start of his SS service at Sachsenhausen as investigators dated it, beginning with training.
January 20, 1942: start of his guard service at Sachsenhausen, as the court found.
July to September 1942: killing of at least 300 Soviet prisoners of war at the camp, one of the two findings on which the Federal Court of Justice said his conviction would have stood.
First half of February 1945: killing of at least 2,600 camp inmates.
February 18, 1945: end of his guard service at Sachsenhausen.
April 22, 1945: Soviet troops liberate Sachsenhausen.
2019: the Ludwigsburg Central Office passes the case to prosecutors in Neuruppin.
October 2019: investigators confront him with his SS service.
February 9, 2021: charged with 3,518 counts of accessory to murder.
October 7, 2021: trial opens before the Neuruppin Regional Court, sitting in Brandenburg an der Havel.
June 28, 2022: convicted of aiding and abetting murder in combination with aiding and abetting attempted murder; sentenced to five years.
April 11, 2023: dies with his appeal pending.
May 3, 2023: the Federal Court of Justice discontinues the proceedings and holds that the appeal would have failed.