On the afternoon of Saturday, October 8, 2011, José Bretón called the emergency number in Córdoba and told the operator that his two children had been lost. That evening he went to the National Police station in the city and filed a formal complaint. The account he gave that day set off an investigation that ran until a jury heard the case in June 2013, and it was false. A jury later found that by the time he made the call, he had already killed his daughter, Ruth, and his son, José, on a weekend he had arranged to spend with them in the city where he grew up.
The jury found that he had planned the killings for weeks, as an act of revenge against the children's mother after she told him she was ending their marriage. On July 22, 2013, the presiding magistrate of the jury court of the Audiencia Provincial de Córdoba sentenced him to 20 years in prison for each of two murders, with the aggravating circumstance of kinship, and fined him for simulating a crime. The High Court of Justice of Andalusia upheld the judgment in November 2013, and the Criminal Chamber of the Supreme Court dismissed his last appeal in July 2014. He denied the killings at every stage of the case. In March 2025, more than thirteen years after the children died, letters he had written to an author showed him admitting them for the first time.
José Bretón Gómez was born in Córdoba on July 21, 1972, the second of three children of a middle-class family. He went to a religious school in the city and enrolled to study law, though he did not pursue it seriously. In 1994 he joined the Spanish Army as a volunteer and was posted to the Cerro Muriano base outside Córdoba. He served in Bosnia with a Spanish contingent drawn from the Córdoba garrison, and his service record shows no incidents. He did not renew his contract when it ended in 1997. In the years that followed he worked as an ambulance driver, not always steadily.
He married a woman from Huelva, the Andalusian port city about 240 kilometers to the west, and the couple made their life there. They had two children. The marriage lasted almost a decade. In September 2011 his wife told him that she meant to end it and to stay in Huelva with the children. Divorce proceedings began that autumn, and the couple agreed on weekend arrangements under which the children would spend time with their father in Córdoba.
Psychiatric experts who examined him during the case found that he did not suffer from any mental disorder. No court that dealt with the case found any condition that reduced his responsibility.
The proven facts the jury accepted begin with that September conversation. When his wife told him she wanted to end the marriage, the court found, Bretón conceived the idea of killing the children as revenge against her, because he would not accept the separation peacefully. He chose the place and the date in advance. October 8, 2011, fell on one of his agreed weekends with the children, and when a change of dates was proposed afterward, he refused it.
Over the following weeks, between mid-September and October 7, he made a series of preparations that the jury found proven one by one. He also prepared the story he would tell. The jury found that he settled on claiming that the children had been lost, and that he worked out in advance how he would present that account to his own family and to the police.
On Friday, October 7, he collected the children from their mother in Huelva and took them to Córdoba.
The jury found that Bretón killed his daughter and his son in Córdoba that afternoon, taking advantage of his position as their father, his greater physical strength, the children's trust in him and his authority over them. Ruth and José were their mother's only children.
He then reported the children missing, first to a brother, then to the emergency number and that evening at the National Police station in Córdoba. The jury found that he made the complaint knowing that no such disappearance had taken place.
Police turned their attention to the father almost from the start. On October 18, 2011, the National Police arrested Bretón as the main suspect, and on October 21 the investigating judge ordered him held in provisional detention on charges of illegal detention and of simulating a crime. He would remain in custody for the rest of the case.
An early police expert report on evidence collected in October 2011 was later found to be wrong. On May 7, 2012, the judge formally indicted Bretón for two counts of illegal detention.
At the end of August 2012 two outside expert reports corrected the earlier finding and linked the evidence to the case. Bretón continued to maintain his innocence.
On September 5, 2012, the investigating judge charged him with two counts of murder with the qualifying circumstance of treachery (alevosía).
The murder charges sent the case to a jury. On October 20, 2012, the defense lost its appeal against that course, and Bretón would be tried by a jury court sitting within the Audiencia Provincial de Córdoba. The Supreme Court later confirmed that, under the Jury Law, the murder charges carried the case to that court as a matter of law.
The defense also challenged the handling of the evidence. In October 2012 Bretón claimed that the evidence had been tampered with, and the investigating judge asked for the chain of custody to be verified and for what the order called "dysfunctions" to be explained. In December 2012 the private prosecution, brought by the children's mother, asked for a sentence of 40 years. The public prosecutor made the same request in January 2013. In February the defense argued that the evidence had been switched and handled improperly, and in March it asked for the whole case to be annulled for violation of his rights. On May 14, 2013, the High Court of Justice of Andalusia rejected that bid.
The trial opened before a jury in Córdoba on June 17, 2013. The jury was made up of seven women and two men, sitting with a professional magistrate who presided over the court. Both the public prosecutor and the private prosecution asked the jury to find Bretón guilty of two counts of murder and to impose 40 years. The defense asked for an acquittal and for some of the central evidence to be declared invalid, arguing that Bretón had been condemned before the trial began.
Bretón testified on the second day, June 18, answering questions from the prosecutor, the private prosecution and his own lawyer for about four hours. He described himself as a calm man, slow to anger, and a good father who loved his children. He denied harming them. He insisted that the children had been lost in Córdoba, and he accused the senior police investigator of having proposed a deal to him if he confessed. Under questioning he gave two different accounts of his movements before leaving Huelva.
Over the following weeks the jury heard police officers, relatives and experts. The defense argued that the chain of custody had been broken.
The trial closed on July 8, 2013, and the jury retired to deliberate. Under the Jury Law a guilty finding on each proposition required seven of the nine votes, and jurors had to give their reasons for each one.
The jury returned on Friday, July 12, 2013, after four days of deliberation, and the reading of the verdict took about an hour. The finding was unanimous. The jury held Bretón responsible for the deaths of his two children, found that he had acted out of revenge against their mother, and found that he had simulated the children's disappearance. Of the twenty-one propositions put to it, the jury found eighteen proven. It rejected the defense argument that the origin of the evidence could not be established, and it asked that no pardon be sought for him from the Council of Ministers if he were convicted. Bretón, brought into court in handcuffs, showed no reaction as the verdict was read.
The presiding magistrate delivered the sentence ten days later, on July 22, 2013. In accordance with the verdict, the court convicted Bretón of two counts of murder (asesinato), with the aggravating circumstance of kinship in each, and sentenced him to 20 years in prison for each, a total of 40 years, with absolute disqualification for the length of the sentences and credit for the time he had spent in provisional detention. His classification in the third grade of the prison regime, the stage that allows open conditions, could not be made until he had served half of the sentence imposed.
The court barred him from coming within one kilometer of the children's mother and her parents, and from communicating with them by any means, for 21 years for each murder, counting from the time his prison treatment would allow him to be granted leave. For simulating a crime, with no aggravating or mitigating circumstances, he received a fine of nine months at ten euros a day. He was ordered to pay 500,000 euros in compensation to the children's mother, 137,335.65 euros to the Ministry of the Interior and 22,567 euros to the city of Córdoba, with interest. The court also ordered the deaths of the two children recorded in the Civil Registry in Córdoba as having occurred there on October 8, 2011, and ordered him to pay the costs of the case, including those of the private prosecution.
Both sides appealed. The defense asked the Civil and Criminal Chamber of the High Court of Justice of Andalusia to overturn the conviction. The private prosecution, brought by the children's mother, appealed as well. On November 5, 2013, the Chamber dismissed both appeals in full and confirmed the Córdoba judgment in every respect.
One of the defense arguments that the High Court addressed was that, even if Bretón had caused the deaths, nothing proved that he had meant to, so that he should at most be found guilty of reckless homicide. Neither the prosecution nor the defense had put that theory to the jury. The High Court found the suggestion that he had meant only to frighten the children's mother wholly implausible. It found that the evidence of preparation in the weeks before October 8 showed that the deaths had been thought out and prepared in advance. The jury's conclusion, the Chamber held, was the inference that flowed most naturally from the proven facts: that he had wanted and prepared his children's deaths to make their mother suffer, in the hope of escaping punishment.
Bretón then took the case to the Criminal Chamber of the Supreme Court in Madrid on fourteen grounds of cassation, alleging violations of the presumption of innocence, of the right to effective judicial protection and to a public trial with full guarantees, of the inviolability of his home and of his communications, and of the right to an independent and impartial court. The public prosecutor asked the court to reject the appeal. A five-judge panel heard argument on July 8, 2014, and announced its decision the next day. The full judgment is dated July 18, 2014, and was made public on July 28.
The Supreme Court dismissed every ground. On the chain of custody, the court held that irregularities in the protocols for collecting and transferring samples did not make the evidence void. Expert analysis, it observed, often takes place months or even years after an offense, and the argument that only a site sealed off from the first moment can yield valid evidence had no basis in law. Proof that the items examined were the same items collected was a question of fact, not a matter that turned on strict compliance with a ministerial order. The court rejected the claim that third parties had planted the evidence, and it found it expressly proven that the evidence examined came from the place where the jury found Bretón had been that afternoon.
The defense also argued that police had gone beyond the investigating judge's authorization in their first inquiries on the family land. The court noted that this complaint had not been raised before the High Court of Justice and so could not be raised for the first time in cassation, and it held in any case that the judge's orders covered what officers had done. A complaint about the examination of Bretón's communications was rejected for the same reason, and because the defense conceded at the hearing that it had no bearing on the outcome.
On the press coverage, the court agreed with the defense on one point. The senior police officer in charge of the investigation had appeared repeatedly on television, and the court recorded its concern at the frequency with which professionals bound to discretion appeared on television sets in cases of public interest. But it noted that he was not the only person connected with the case to speak to the press, and it held that the question in each case was whether the verdict rested on the evidence heard in court or on a public perception shaped in advance. Here, the court found, it was enough to read the jury's detailed reasoning to be convinced that the jurors had decided solely on what they had seen and heard at trial. That the verdict matched an earlier state of opinion was irrelevant, the court held, when it followed naturally and logically from the trial.
The Supreme Court also upheld the finding of intent to kill and the conviction for simulating a crime. It held that the evidence against Bretón carried "very intense incriminating force," and that he knew his children had not been taken by anyone because he had killed them himself hours before. The appeal was dismissed and Bretón was ordered to pay the costs. With that judgment the conviction became final.
Bretón has been in custody since October 2011. He was first held in Córdoba, in Andalusia, and was later moved to a facility in the province of Alicante, in the Valencian Community. In March 2015 the Audiencia Provincial de Córdoba fixed the maximum term he can actually serve at 25 years, the limit Spanish law sets for this combination of sentences. By March 2025 he was held in Castilla-La Mancha, classified in the second grade of the prison regime, and his release was expected in 2036.
In March 2025, letters he had exchanged with a Spanish author were set to appear in a book, together with an interview conducted in custody. In them Bretón admitted for the first time that he had killed his children. The publisher suspended the book's release that month after prosecutors in Barcelona asked the courts to halt it.
Bretón's case went to a jury because of the Jury Law of 1995, which assigns murder charges to a jury court sitting within the Audiencia Provincial, with nine citizen jurors and a professional magistrate as president. The Supreme Court held that the murder charges carried the case to that court as a matter of law, so neither his right to the ordinary judge nor the rules of jurisdiction had been breached. The jury rules on a written list of factual propositions and must give reasons for each one; the Supreme Court's judgment singled out the quality of the reasoning in this verdict.
The 40-year total is the sum of two 20-year terms for murder. The time he can actually serve is capped by the Penal Code, which limits effective imprisonment to 25 years where a person is convicted of two or more offenses and one of them carries a sentence of up to 20 years. That is the limit the Audiencia Provincial applied in 2015. Within it, the sentencing court's order that he could not be placed in the third grade before serving half the sentence, and the 21-year protection orders that begin to run only once he becomes eligible for leave, remain in force.
Bretón contested every element of the case until 2025. At trial and on appeal his defense argued that the chain of custody had been broken, that the evidence had been switched or planted, and that the senior police investigator had steered both the inquiry and public opinion. The High Court of Justice of Andalusia and the Supreme Court rejected each of those claims.
The original police expert identification of the evidence collected in October 2011 was wrong, and it was corrected by outside experts only in August 2012. The prosecution acknowledged the error in court. The jury's verdict and both appellate judgments rest on the later expert findings.
The court record leaves open the precise way in which the children died. The Supreme Court held that this did not affect the finding of intent to kill. The jury also found three of the twenty-one propositions put to it not proven; none of them concerned whether he had killed the children.
July 21, 1972: José Bretón Gómez is born in Córdoba.
1994 to 1997: Volunteer service in the Spanish Army, including a deployment to Bosnia.
September 2011: His wife tells him she intends to end their marriage and stay in Huelva with the children.
October 7, 2011: He collects the children in Huelva and takes them to Córdoba.
October 8, 2011: He kills both children in Córdoba, then reports them lost to the emergency services and to the National Police.
October 18, 2011: Arrested by the National Police.
October 21, 2011: Ordered held in provisional detention for illegal detention and simulating a crime.
November 2011: An early police expert report on the evidence is later found to be wrong.
May 7, 2012: Indicted for two counts of illegal detention.
August 27 and 28, 2012: Outside expert reports correct the earlier finding.
September 5, 2012: Charged with two counts of murder.
October 20, 2012: The defense loses its appeal against trial by jury.
May 14, 2013: The High Court of Justice of Andalusia rejects his bid to annul the case.
June 17, 2013: Trial opens in Córdoba.
July 12, 2013: The jury unanimously finds him guilty.
July 22, 2013: Sentenced to 20 years for each murder, 40 in all, and fined for simulating a crime.
November 5, 2013: The High Court of Justice of Andalusia dismisses both appeals.
July 18, 2014: The Supreme Court dismisses his cassation appeal (judgment made public July 28).
March 2015: The time he can actually serve is capped at 25 years.
March 2025: Letters to an author show him admitting the killings for the first time.