On December 9, 1985, a civilian court in Buenos Aires sentenced the man who had ruled Argentina for five years to spend the rest of his life in confinement. The Federal Chamber found Lieutenant General Jorge Rafael Videla, the army commander who had led the coup of March 24, 1976, and headed the first military junta, guilty of 66 aggravated homicides, 306 illegal deprivations of liberty aggravated by violence and threats, 93 counts of torture, 4 counts of torture followed by death and 26 robberies. It imposed reclusión perpetua, the gravest penalty Argentine law allowed, with perpetual absolute disqualification and dismissal from the army.
That judgment did not hold. Five years later a presidential decree pardoned him, and he went free. It took two decades and a series of rulings that his pardon was unconstitutional before he stood in a dock again. In December 2010 a federal court in Córdoba sentenced him to life for the deaths of 31 political prisoners in 1976. In July 2012 a federal court in Buenos Aires gave him 50 years for the systematic taking of children from detained and disappeared parents. He died in federal custody on May 17, 2013, at 87, while on trial in yet another case.
Videla was born on August 2, 1925, in Mercedes, in the province of Buenos Aires. He entered the Colegio Militar de la Nación, the national military academy, in 1942 and graduated in December 1944 as an infantry second lieutenant. His rise was steady rather than sudden. In 1973 he was named chief of the army general staff, and in 1975 President María Estela Martínez de Perón appointed him commander in chief of the army. Within a year he had used that post to remove her.
On March 24, 1976, the armed forces overthrew the constitutional government. Videla, as army commander, joined the commanders of the other two services, Emilio Eduardo Massera and Orlando Ramón Agosti, in the first junta, and became president at its head. The Trial of the Juntas would later find that the commanders had devised and carried out a criminal plan against the people they classed as subversives. Pregnant prisoners were held until they gave birth, and their children were taken and raised under false identities, often by military or police families.
Videla held the presidency until March 29, 1981, when he handed office to General Roberto Eduardo Viola, a member of the second junta. A succession of generals followed, and constitutional rule returned in December 1983.
Videla was detained in 1984. The case, numbered 13/84, came before the Federal Chamber, the federal criminal appeals court in Buenos Aires, and the oral and public trial opened on April 22, 1985. Nine former commanders, the members of the first three juntas, sat as defendants. The prosecution presented 709 cases, and the court heard the evidence on 280 of them as emblematic of the whole. It found that the juntas had developed and carried out the criminal plan the prosecution described, and that subordinates had acted on the commanders' orders.
The judgment was delivered on December 9, 1985. The court convicted Videla as the author of 16 homicides aggravated by treachery and 50 homicides aggravated by treachery and by the participation of three or more persons, 66 in all, under article 80 of the Penal Code; of 306 illegal deprivations of liberty aggravated by threats and violence; of 93 counts of torture and 4 of torture followed by death, under article 144 ter; and of 26 robberies. All were counted as separate offenses in real concurrence.
It acquitted him on many other charges: 19 further counts of qualified homicide, 194 of qualified illegal deprivation of liberty, 171 of torture and 76 of robbery, as well as charges of abduction of a minor, reduction to servitude, usurpation, extortionate kidnapping, extortion, ideological falsification and suppression of a public document. The acquittal on the abduction of minors would matter later, because a pardon could reach only what he had been convicted of.
The court held that the gravity and extent of the harm allowed no lesser penalty than the most severe one available. It sentenced him to reclusión perpetua with perpetual absolute disqualification, the accessory penalties of the Penal Code and dismissal from the service under article 538 of the Military Justice Code, with costs.
Massera also received life imprisonment. Viola was sentenced to 17 years, Armando Lambruschini to 8 years and Agosti to 4 years and 6 months. Omar Graffigna, Leopoldo Galtieri, Jorge Isaac Anaya and Basilio Lami Dozo were acquitted for lack of evidence. The sentence became final in 1986, and Videla served it in a military prison.
He served about five years. On December 29, 1990, President Carlos Menem signed Decree 2741/90, pardoning the commanders convicted in 1985, and Videla left custody.
The pardon covered only what he had been convicted of. The 1985 court had acquitted him of abduction of minors, and the amnesty laws of the late 1980s did not reach the taking of children born to prisoners. Those offenses remained open to prosecution.
On June 9, 1998, a federal judge in San Isidro, north of Buenos Aires, ordered Videla detained on charges of substitution of civil status and the appropriation of five minors. He spent 37 days in a Buenos Aires jail before the Federal Chamber of San Martín granted him house arrest. He was 72.
He remained under house arrest for about ten years while the investigation widened. By 2008 the case had become the case of the systematic appropriation of minors, with 27 cases attributed to him of the taking, keeping and hiding of minors born in captivity or taken from their parents, together with the substitution of their identities. On October 10, 2008, a federal judge in that case revoked his house arrest, and Videla was moved to a federal prison unit at the Campo de Mayo military base outside Buenos Aires.
The pardon itself fell in another case. Beginning in 2005, federal judges struck down Menem's pardons of former officials, Videla's among them. In a case concerning an extortionate kidnapping in 1976, a federal judge declared Decree 2741/90 unconstitutional as it applied to Videla and voided the dismissal it had produced. The appeals chamber confirmed the ruling, and on April 27, 2010, the Supreme Court rejected Videla's extraordinary appeal and left the finding of unconstitutionality in place.
The first new trial took place in Córdoba, where General Luciano Benjamín Menéndez had commanded the Third Army Corps. The Federal Oral Court 1 of Córdoba joined two cases. One of them, the UP1 case, concerned the deaths of 31 political prisoners who had been held in the San Martín penitentiary, the provincial jail known as UP1, in the months after the coup.
The trial opened on July 2, 2010, with 31 defendants. Videla and Menéndez were the principal accused in the UP1 case, charged with qualified homicide, torture followed by death and aggravated torture. The prisoners had been in state custody when they died. Their deaths were officially recorded as the result of escape attempts, a version the court rejected.
Videla refused to recognize the court's authority. The day before the verdict he told it that he assumed full responsibility for the actions of the army under his command.
On December 22, 2010, the unanimous court sentenced him to life imprisonment and ordered that he serve it in an ordinary prison. Menéndez also received life. Of the other defendants, 15 received life sentences, seven received terms of 6 to 14 years and seven were acquitted for lack of evidence.
The written grounds, read on February 21, 2011, set out his convictions in full: aggravated torture of political prisoners, 30 counts; homicide qualified by treachery and by the participation of several persons, 29 counts; and torture followed by death, one count. The judges found that as commander he had set the objectives and supplied the infrastructure and means for the chain of command beneath him, that he had issued Army Directive 404/75, which put the repression in motion, and that he had designed an illegal plan dividing the country into zones. They held that it was not credible that he had been unaware of the systematic method used to eliminate prisoners who were at his disposal. After the verdict he was taken to the federal prison at Marcos Paz, west of Buenos Aires.
The case that had begun in San Isidro in 1998 reached its oral trial before the Federal Oral Court 6 in Buenos Aires. Videla sat with Reynaldo Bignone, the last president of the military government, and other former officers. The court examined 35 cases of the illegal appropriation of children; in 28 of them the children, by then adults, had recovered their identities. Six of the cases had been part of the 1985 trial, where the existence of a plan to take children born in captivity could not be proved. Videla denied that any such plan had existed.
The court found otherwise. On July 5, 2012, it held that a systematic and generalized practice of taking, keeping and hiding minors, altering or suppressing their identities, had been carried out between 1976 and 1983 as part of state terrorism. It declared Videla the criminally responsible author of the offenses of taking, keeping and hiding a minor under the age of ten, and sentenced him to 50 years in prison. Because of his earlier conviction in the Trial of the Juntas, the court unified the new sentence into reclusión perpetua.
Bignone received 15 years, the court judging that his part had been smaller because he had acted at the end of the dictatorship. Six other former military personnel, among them a doctor, received terms ranging from 5 to 40 years, and two defendants were acquitted.
One more case was open against him: the Plan Condor case, concerning the coordination among South American military governments to persecute and disappear political opponents across borders. He was still on trial in it when he died, on May 17, 2013, at the federal prison in Marcos Paz. He was 87.
He died having been convicted in three trials, in 1985, 2010 and 2012, and serving life sentences for crimes against humanity.
The 1985 court tried Videla under the ordinary Argentine Penal Code, with the Military Justice Code supplying certain accessory penalties, and each proved case counted as a separate offense. His 2010 and 2012 convictions were for crimes against humanity, which Argentine courts held could not lapse with time and could not be extinguished by amnesty or pardon. That was the ground on which the voiding of his pardon was left in place in April 2010.
Videla never accepted the judgments against him. He refused to recognize the civilian courts, called himself a political prisoner and, in the children's trial, denied that any plan to take children had existed. The courts rejected each of those positions, and his convictions stand as found.
The 1985 court acquitted him of a large number of charged offenses, including 19 counts of homicide and 194 of illegal deprivation of liberty. The numbers in his convictions are the numbers the courts found proved, not totals for the period.
No court reached a verdict on the Plan Condor charges against him. Those proceedings ended with his death, and he is not convicted of the crimes charged in that case.
Official counts of the disappeared compiled after 1983 are given variously as 9,000, more than 11,000 and 13,000; Videla's own convictions rest only on the cases the courts examined.
August 2, 1925: Born in Mercedes, Buenos Aires Province.
December 1944: Graduates from the Colegio Militar de la Nación as an infantry second lieutenant.
1973: Named chief of the army general staff.
1975: Appointed commander in chief of the army.
March 24, 1976: Leads the coup that overthrows the constitutional government; becomes president as head of the first junta.
1976: The 31 political prisoners of the UP1 case die in custody in Córdoba.
March 29, 1981: Hands the presidency to General Roberto Eduardo Viola.
December 1983: Constitutional government returns.
1984: Detained.
April 22, 1985: The Trial of the Juntas opens before the Federal Chamber in Buenos Aires.
December 9, 1985: Convicted of 66 aggravated homicides and other offenses; sentenced to reclusión perpetua.
1986: The sentence becomes final.
December 29, 1990: Pardoned by Decree 2741/90.
June 9, 1998: Detained in the children case on the order of a federal judge in San Isidro.
1998: Granted house arrest after 37 days in jail.
October 10, 2008: House arrest revoked; moved to a federal prison unit at Campo de Mayo.
April 27, 2010: The Supreme Court rejects his appeal and leaves in place the ruling that his pardon was unconstitutional.
July 2, 2010: The Córdoba trial opens.
December 22, 2010: Sentenced to life by the Federal Oral Court 1 of Córdoba.
July 5, 2012: Sentenced to 50 years by the Federal Oral Court 6 for the taking, keeping and hiding of minors; unified into reclusión perpetua.
May 17, 2013: Dies in custody at Marcos Paz, aged 87.