John Wilkes Booth

Victims
President Lincoln killed in Washington, 1865; never tried. Named by the War Department and in the 1865 charge against eight others as the killer; died April 26, 1865, before any trial
Years active
April 14, 1865 (the President died April 15, 1865)
Location
Bel Air and Baltimore, Maryland; Washington, D.C.; Franklin, Pennsylvania; Port Royal, Virginia
Method
Assassination of the President, attributed by the War Department and in the military commission's charge; never adjudicated against Booth
Status
Died April 26, 1865, untried. Commission verdicts June 30, 1865: four death sentences (executed in Washington July 7, 1865), three life terms, one of six years

On the night of April 14, 1865, five days after the surrender of the principal Confederate army in Virginia, the President of the United States, Abraham Lincoln, was assassinated in Washington. He died the following morning, April 15, and within hours the Chief Justice had sworn in the Vice President as the 17th President. The War Department named the man responsible almost at once. He was John Wilkes Booth, a 26-year-old actor from Maryland whose face was familiar to theatergoers in half the cities of the East, and who had spent the war years as an open sympathizer with the Confederacy.

Booth never answered for the killing in any court. Federal troops found him on a farm near Port Royal, Virginia, on April 26, 1865, twelve days after the assassination, and he died there that day. No indictment, charge or verdict was ever recorded against him. His name appears in the legal record of the case only as an absent principal: the Charge and Specification drawn up in May 1865 against eight other people described him as the conspirator who carried out the killing, and the military commission that tried those eight found most of them guilty of conspiring with him. Four were sentenced to death and executed in Washington on July 7, 1865. Three received life terms and one a term of six years. The questions that trial raised, about whether soldiers could sit in judgment on civilians while the civil courts were open, reached the Supreme Court in the years that followed.

A Maryland boyhood and a stage career

Booth was born on May 10, 1838, near Bel Air, in Harford County, Maryland, and grew up there and in Baltimore. Maryland stayed in the Union through the war, but slavery remained legal there until near its end, and Booth grew up on the Southern side of that divided state's politics. He went to school in Bel Air, Sparks and Catonsville.

His politics formed early. As a teenager he was active with the Know Nothings, the anti-immigrant party of the 1850s. He was pro-slavery and detested abolitionists. After John Brown's raid on Harpers Ferry in October 1859, Booth, then rehearsing with a theater company in Richmond, joined a local militia unit, the Richmond Grays, so that he could be present when the abolitionist was executed in Virginia. He approved of the sentence, but he came away admiring the calm with which Brown met it.

The stage was his trade from his teens. He made his debut in Baltimore in 1855, at the Charles Street Theatre, and joined the stock company of the Richmond Theater in 1858. Over the next decade he played Shakespeare and the popular melodramas of the day in cities up and down the East Coast, with Richard III among his best-known parts. By the middle of the war he was a star in his own right, and one theater season brought him about $20,000. In November 1863 he played in The Marble Heart at Ford's Theatre in Washington, a theater whose owner was a friend, with the President in the audience.

Oil, money and the turn away from the stage

In January 1864 Booth went to Franklin, in Venango County, Pennsylvania, at the height of the oil boom along the Allegheny River, and bought a lease of about three acres on a farm outside the town. With two partners from Cleveland, one of them a theater manager and friend, he formed what became known as the Dramatic Oil Company, and a local man held the property in trust for them. Drilling began in the summer of 1864. The well yielded for a time and then failed for good after an attempt to raise its output. Booth lost more than $6,000 on the venture and left the oil region in July 1864.

He was already stepping back from acting. On May 28, 1864, he drew his last regular pay and left the Boston stage. He appeared only occasionally afterward. His last appearance on any stage was at Ford's Theatre in Washington on March 18, 1865, as Duke Pescara in The Apostate.

The abduction plan

The months in which Booth's acting career faded were the months in which he turned to conspiracy. He saw the President as a tyrant who was destroying the South through war and emancipation, and he opposed the suspension of habeas corpus in Maryland in 1861, which he took as proof of that tyranny. He held that the suspension, and the imprisonment of pro-secession Maryland politicians and other Marylanders that followed it, were unconstitutional. He believed in slavery and in white supremacy. His sympathy was not only talk: during the war he secretly smuggled medicine past the Union blockade into the South. In 1864 he began recruiting men for a plan to seize the President, carry him to Richmond and use him to help turn the war in the Confederacy's favor, including as a bargaining piece for the release of Confederate soldiers held in Union camps.

The men he drew in came from his own past and from the network of Confederate sympathizers in Washington and southern Maryland. Two were boyhood friends from Baltimore, both discharged Confederate veterans. Another was a young Marylander who had served as a Confederate courier and agent, and who introduced Booth to three more: a German-born carriage painter and boatman who knew the rivers south of the capital; a young man who had studied pharmacy and had known Booth since 1863; and a former Confederate soldier who had been captured at Gettysburg and later served with a Confederate partisan unit. The courier's mother, a widow, kept a boardinghouse in Washington where the group met, and a tavern in Surrattsville, Maryland.

The plan never came close to success. On March 15, 1865, the group met and argued over it, and one of the two boyhood friends told Booth it was impractical and withdrew. An attempt on March 17 came to nothing when the President's plans that day changed. By early April, with Richmond fallen on April 2 and the main Confederate army surrendering on April 9, the purpose the plan had been meant to serve was gone.

April 1865

On April 11, 1865, the President spoke from the White House about the reconstruction of the defeated South and endorsed voting rights for some Black men. Booth was in the crowd. With the main Confederate army gone, his plan shifted from seizing the President to killing him at about this time, and he gave his associates their own targets: the Vice President and the Secretary of State.

What the federal prosecutors later set out, in the charge they drew up against Booth's associates, was a plan to kill four men on the same night: the President, the Vice President, the Secretary of State and General Ulysses S. Grant, with the aim of throwing the government into disorder. The carriage painter was assigned to the Vice President and did not act. The former Confederate soldier, guided by the pharmacy student, went after the Secretary of State in Washington the same night. The President was assassinated that night, and the charge identified Booth as the man who killed him.

Twelve days

Booth left Washington that night with the pharmacy student, and for the next twelve days the two were sheltered by Confederate sympathizers in southern Maryland and Virginia, among them a physician near Waldorf, Maryland, who later said he had not recognized Booth and had not known of the assassination.

The government's response was immediate and enormous. Authorities detained and questioned hundreds of people in the weeks that followed, and many were released for lack of evidence. The former Confederate soldier was arrested at the Washington boardinghouse on April 15, the night after the assassination. The two boyhood friends were taken on April 17. The carriage painter was arrested on April 20, and the physician on April 24.

The first price on the assassin's head came the day the President died. On April 15 the Headquarters of the Department of Washington, the military department that took in the capital, issued a notice over the signature of its commanding general offering $10,000 for the arrest of the assassins of the President and of the Secretary of State. Five days later the War Department raised the stakes tenfold. Its broadside of April 20, 1865, issued over the name of the Secretary of War, offered $100,000 for the capture of Booth, the courier and the pharmacy student, whom it called the assassins of the President. The courier was not in Washington on the night of the assassination and had already left the country; he made his way to Canada and then to Europe.

Federal troops found Booth and his companion near Port Royal, in Caroline County, Virginia, on April 26, 1865. Booth died there that day, and his companion was taken into custody.

Within a week of Booth's death, the government reached past him. On May 2, 1865, the new President issued a proclamation declaring that evidence in the hands of the Bureau of Military Justice showed that the murder of the President and the attempt on the Secretary of State had been "incited, concerted, and procured" by the Confederate President and a group of Confederate agents "harbored in Canada." It offered rewards for their arrest.

The charge against the eight

With Booth dead, the case against the conspiracy went forward against those who had been taken alive. On April 28, 1865, the Attorney General gave a short opinion that the conspirators could rightfully be tried by a military court. On May 1 the new President ordered that they be tried by a military commission. Nine Union officers, seven generals and two colonels, were appointed to it, with a major general of volunteers presiding. The commission had no judge. The Judge Advocate General, the Army's chief legal officer, prosecuted, with two assistants, and advised the members on the law.

The Charge and Specification, signed by the Judge Advocate General "by order of the President" and dated May 8, 1865, was delivered to the accused that month. It named eight defendants: the former Confederate soldier, the pharmacy student, the carriage painter, the two boyhood friends, a stagehand, the widow who kept the boardinghouse and the physician. The charge accused them of acting "for maliciously, unlawfully, and traitorously, and in aid of the existing armed rebellion against the United States," in conspiring to kill the President, the Vice President, the Secretary of State and General Grant. The conspiracy, it said, had been formed "on or before the 6th day of March, A.D. 1865," at "Washington City, within the military department of Washington." The specification named the courier and Booth as their fellow conspirators, and it carried the theory of the May 2 proclamation into the charge itself: it said the defendants had been "incited and encouraged" by Confederate leaders and by "others unknown," and stated that Booth, "in pursuance of said unlawful and traitorous conspiracy," had carried out the killing of the President on the night of April 14, 1865, and that the President had died of it.

The defendants were arraigned and the commission adopted its rules on May 9 and 10. On May 12, before testimony began, the accused pleaded that the commission had no jurisdiction over them: they were not in military service, they argued, and the civil courts in Washington were open. The prosecution answered that the commission had jurisdiction, and the members overruled the pleas. Testimony began the same day in Washington and ran until June 29, with 366 witnesses. Defense counsel renewed the challenge to jurisdiction in June, and one of them objected that the charge identified no statute at all. The prosecution's position was that the common law of war reached the case. A majority of the members was enough to convict, and two-thirds had to agree to a sentence of death.

Verdicts and sentences

The commission deliberated in secret from June 29 and delivered its findings on June 30, 1865. Every defendant was found guilty of some part of the charge, although none of the verdicts was a simple "guilty." Seven of the eight were found guilty of the charge and specification except the words alleging that they had conspired with the stagehand, of which they were found not guilty. The findings for the widow and the physician also excluded the words about harboring named members of the plot, and the findings for one of the boyhood friends excluded the words about lying in wait for General Grant. The stagehand was found not guilty of the specification and the charge, but guilty of aiding and abetting Booth's escape.

The former Confederate soldier, the pharmacy student, the carriage painter and the widow were sentenced to death. The physician and the two boyhood friends were sentenced to hard labor for life, and the stagehand to hard labor for six years, each in such penitentiary as the President should designate. Five members of the commission asked the President to grant the widow clemency. He did not.

On July 5, 1865, the President approved the findings and sentences, and they were published that day in a general court-martial order. A writ of habeas corpus issued in the widow's case by a justice of the Supreme Court of the District of Columbia was returned with the President's indorsement suspending the writ in her case. The four were executed in Washington on July 7, 1865. The widow was the first woman executed by the federal government.

The others after the verdicts

The physician, the two boyhood friends and the stagehand were sent to serve their sentences at a federal fort in the Dry Tortugas, off Florida. One of the boyhood friends died in federal custody there on September 23, 1867. In mid-1868 the physician, the other boyhood friend and the stagehand petitioned the federal district judge for the Southern District of Florida for release, arguing that the military commission had never had the power to try them. The judge denied the petition in September 1868. He held that the conspiracy had been aimed at impairing the effectiveness of military operations, that the offense was therefore a military one, and that a military commission could try it.

Their counsel then prepared petitions to go directly to the Supreme Court. The physician was pardoned by the President on February 8, 1869, before his petition was filed. The Court heard argument on the petitions of the other two on February 26, 1869. They were pardoned on March 1, 1869, in the last days of that President's term, and the Court dismissed their petitions without reaching the merits.

The courier was found anyway. In December 1866 he was arrested in Alexandria, Egypt, and he was returned to Washington in February 1867. He was not sent before a military commission. He was indicted in the civilian courts of the District of Columbia on charges that he had plotted with Booth, in violation of the ordinary laws on murder and conspiracy, and his trial ran from June 10 to August 11, 1867. The jury could not reach a verdict. He was released in late August 1867 and was never tried again.

Context: the law the commission applied

The trial of Booth's associates turned on a question that the commission answered one way in 1865 and the Supreme Court answered another way the following year. The government's case for a military trial rested on the Attorney General's view that the conspirators had committed offenses against the laws of war, which a military tribunal could try. His short opinion of April 28, 1865, was followed in July by a fuller one, signed after four of the accused had already been executed. The jurisdiction pleas of May 12 and the defense's renewed challenge in June argued the opposite: that civilians could be tried only in civil courts while those courts were open, as they were in Washington throughout.

In Ex parte Milligan, decided in 1866, the Supreme Court considered the military trial of a civilian in Indiana during the war. All the justices rejected the government's central arguments for bypassing the civil courts, and the Court held that a military commission could not try a civilian where the civil courts were open and functioning outside an actual theater of war. The decision did not reopen the 1865 verdicts by itself. It was the ground on which the physician, the boyhood friend and the stagehand sought release in 1868, and the federal judge in Florida distinguished it by treating their offense as a military one. The question never reached a ruling on the merits in the Supreme Court, because the pardons of 1869 ended the cases first.

Disputed and unproven points

Booth's guilt was never tested in any court. The case against him rests on the War Department's identification of him in April 1865, on the specification drawn against his associates, and on the evidence heard by the commission in May and June 1865. He was never charged, and the findings of June 30, 1865, were findings against the eight defendants, not against him.

The reach of the conspiracy beyond the men and the woman tried in 1865 remains unsettled. Booth traveled to Montreal before the assassination, but no evidence of a plot directed from the Confederate government has come to light.

The guilt of several of the convicted remains in dispute. The widow's conviction rested largely on the testimony of the man who leased her tavern; one of the boyhood friends admitted his part in the failed abduction attempt but said he had withdrawn from the later plans; and the physician maintained that he had not recognized Booth. The jurisdiction of a military tribunal over civilians while the civil courts were open was contested from the first day of the trial.

Timeline

May 10, 1838: Booth is born near Bel Air, Harford County, Maryland.

1855: He makes his stage debut in Baltimore.

1858: He joins the stock company of the Richmond Theater.

1859: After the October raid on Harpers Ferry, he joins the Richmond Grays, a militia unit present at the execution of John Brown in Virginia.

November 1863: He plays The Marble Heart at Ford's Theatre in Washington, with the President in the audience.

January 1864: He buys an oil lease near Franklin, Pennsylvania.

May 28, 1864: He leaves the Boston stage.

July 1864: He leaves the oil region after losing more than $6,000.

1864: He begins recruiting men for a plan to abduct the President.

March 17, 1865: An abduction attempt comes to nothing.

March 18, 1865: His last appearance on stage, at Ford's Theatre.

April 11, 1865: The President endorses voting rights for some Black men in a speech at the White House; Booth is in the crowd.

April 14, 1865: The President is assassinated in Washington; the Secretary of State is also targeted the same night.

April 15, 1865: The President dies in Washington; the Vice President is sworn in; the Department of Washington offers $10,000 for the arrest of the assassins.

April 20, 1865: The War Department offers $100,000 for the capture of Booth and two others.

April 26, 1865: Federal troops find Booth near Port Royal, Virginia, and he dies there, untried.

April 28, 1865: The Attorney General advises that the conspirators may be tried by a military court.

May 1, 1865: The President orders a military commission.

May 2, 1865: A presidential proclamation accuses the Confederate President and agents in Canada of inciting the murder and offers rewards for their arrest.

May 8, 1865: The Charge and Specification against the eight is dated and signed.

May 12, 1865: Pleas to the commission's jurisdiction are overruled; testimony begins.

June 30, 1865: The commission finds all eight defendants guilty of parts of the charge.

July 5, 1865: The President approves the findings and sentences.

July 7, 1865: Four defendants are executed in Washington.

1866: The Supreme Court decides Ex parte Milligan.

December 1866: The courier is arrested in Alexandria, Egypt.

June 10 to August 11, 1867: The courier's civilian trial ends with a divided jury; he is released later that month.

September 23, 1867: One of the boyhood friends dies in federal custody in Florida.

September 1868: The federal district judge in Florida denies the petition of three prisoners.

February 8, 1869: The physician is pardoned.

March 1, 1869: The remaining boyhood friend and the stagehand are pardoned.