On the night of May 24, 2000, two men robbed a fast-food restaurant in Flushing, Queens, shortly before it closed. Seven people were inside. Five of them died. Two survived. Within two days the police had both men in custody. One was Craig Godineaux, who pleaded guilty in January 2001 and was sentenced to life without parole. The other was John Taylor, a former assistant manager at the same restaurant, who had planned the robbery and who stood trial in Kew Gardens in the fall of 2002.
A Queens jury convicted Taylor of 20 counts, among them six counts of murder in the first degree, and returned three death verdicts. It was the first death sentence a Queens County jury had returned since New York restored capital punishment in 1995. The sentence never came close to being carried out. While his automatic appeal waited, the Court of Appeals, the state's highest court, struck down the instruction that New York juries had to be given about a deadlock in a capital case. When Taylor's own appeal was decided in October 2007, a divided court held that the ruling applied to him, vacated his death sentence and sent him back to Queens for resentencing. He was by then the only person left on the state's death row. In November 2007 he was resentenced to life without parole.
Taylor had worked at the Flushing restaurant, rising to assistant manager before he was moved to another location and later fired. At another of the chain's restaurants in Queens he met Craig Godineaux, then a co-worker.
In May 2000 the two men planned the robbery, and the court found that Taylor chose the restaurant.
At the time he already had a lawyer representing him in a separate, pending robbery case in Queens.
The five people who died that night were Jean Auguste, Anita Smith, Jeremy Mele, Ramon Nazario and Ali Ibadat.
Two others survived.
The break came quickly. Witnesses picked Taylor's photograph out of arrays the detectives showed them, and the police learned that he had been fired from the Flushing restaurant. On May 26, 2000, officers arrested him in Suffolk County. Godineaux was arrested in the same period.
That night he began a statement to detectives, later given again in writing and on videotape. He first put all of the deaths on Godineaux; as the questioning went on, he admitted one of the killings.
A Queens grand jury returned the first indictment on June 27, 2000. In late July both men were arraigned in Queens and pleaded not guilty to a 50-count indictment that included murder in the first and second degree and attempted murder. Under the state's capital statute, the Queens district attorney then had 120 days to decide whether to seek the death penalty against either of them.
State psychiatrists found Godineaux intellectually disabled, and New York barred the execution of anyone with that finding, so the district attorney did not seek a death sentence against him. On January 22, 2001, he pleaded guilty to the entire indictment, saying in his plea that Taylor had planned the robbery and the killings. In February 2001 he was sentenced to five consecutive terms of life without parole.
Taylor remained awaiting trial. The prosecution meant to try him as a capital defendant. The first indictment had already charged him with 24 counts of murder in the first degree, framed as intentional murders in the course of a felony and as the murder of more than one person. On April 10, 2001, about two months after Godineaux was sentenced, a second indictment charged Taylor with responsibility for all five deaths rather than one, on the theory that he had commanded the killings his accomplice carried out, and added counts of attempted murder in the first degree for the two who survived. The two indictments were consolidated by court order on March 27, 2002.
The Capital Defender Office took his case. Its lawyers made three challenges before trial that shaped what followed.
The first was to his confession. The defense argued that he had been kept from the lawyer already representing him on the pending robbery charge, and that he had been mistreated before he confessed. After a hearing, the trial justice issued a 40-page ruling on March 20, 2002. He found the detectives' sworn account, that Taylor had turned down an offer to see his lawyer, more credible than the defense's, found little support for the mistreatment claim, and allowed the confession into evidence.
The second challenge, filed the same day and before any juror was chosen, went to the sentencing statute itself. Taylor moved to have the court declare unconstitutional the instruction New York required judges to give a capital jury about what would happen if it deadlocked, and to declare that provision inseparable from the rest of the law. The instruction, the motion argued, brought arbitrariness into the sentencing proceeding and coerced jurors. The trial court denied the motion in every respect, finding that Taylor could not overcome the strong presumption that a statute is constitutional. It would become the issue on which his case was decided five years later.
The third challenge went to the grand juries. The defense argued that the pool from which the two indicting grand juries had been drawn systematically excluded Hispanic residents of Queens, and it asked the court to dismiss both indictments. The challenge was not confined to Taylor's grand juries; it reached every indictment drawn from the pool that spring. On May 22, 2002, the justice ruled that the pool was acceptable, and the ruling cleared the way for jury selection that fall.
Jury selection began in Kew Gardens in September 2002 and lasted five weeks. Opening statements were heard at the end of October.
The two sides agreed on more than either had to. Both accepted that Taylor had killed the man who had trained him; his own lawyer told the jury so. The prosecution's case was that Taylor had planned a robbery he meant to get away with whatever it cost, and that he was legally responsible for every death that followed, including the four Godineaux caused. The defense contested his responsibility for the four deaths his accomplice caused.
In November 2002 the jury convicted him on all 20 counts submitted to it. They included six counts of murder in the first degree under various theories, among them a count for the murder of more than one person in a single criminal transaction and counts for two of the murders committed in the course of a robbery, along with felony murder counts for the three other deaths and two counts of attempted murder in the first degree for the two who survived.
New York's capital statute gave the same jury a second decision. On November 25, 2002, the trial justice charged it on the sentence. As the law required, he told the jurors that they were to choose between death and life without parole, that either verdict had to be unanimous, and that if they could not agree he would impose a sentence of life with parole eligibility after 20 to 25 years on each count. He added that, given the number of counts, the sentence he would almost certainly impose in that event would be 175 years to life. The jury returned death verdicts on three counts: the multiple-victim murder count and the two robbery-murder counts. On the three felony murder counts it did not reach a unanimous verdict for either death or life without parole, and those counts carried consecutive terms of 25 years to life. It was the fourth time the Queens district attorney had sought a death sentence under the 1995 law, and the first time a Queens County jury had imposed one.
Formal sentencing took place in Kew Gardens on January 8, 2003. Under the statute the justice was bound by the jury's choice, and the January hearing made the sentence official. The justice who had tried the case sentenced Taylor to death by lethal injection.
Under the law, the death warrant was stayed at once. New York gave every death sentence an automatic direct appeal to the Court of Appeals, skipping the intermediate appellate courts. Taylor was sent to the state's death row upstate, expected to become the sixth man held there. He was the only one from Queens.
The provision Taylor had attacked before trial was a section of the Criminal Procedure Law. It required the trial judge to tell a capital jury that if it could not agree unanimously on death or life without parole, the court itself would impose a sentence with a minimum of 20 to 25 years and a maximum of life. The objection was that the instruction could push jurors toward a verdict of death rather than a deadlock.
On June 24, 2004, the Court of Appeals agreed, in People v LaValle. It held that the deadlock instruction violated the due process clause of the State Constitution, because it risked coercing jurors into a death verdict, both as it had been applied to the defendant in that case and on its face, and it declared that under the present statute the death penalty could not be imposed. The court refused to redraft the instruction itself, holding that the task belonged to the Legislature. It vacated that defendant's death sentence, affirmed his conviction and sent his case back for resentencing under the provision that would be used again for Taylor.
The ruling left four men under sentence of death in New York, and Taylor was among them.
For Taylor the effect was not immediate. His jurors had been told about the deadlock sentence in his particular terms, a maximum of 175 years to life, and the prosecution maintained that his sentence had not been tainted. Its position, which it carried into the Court of Appeals, was that LaValle had been correctly decided only as a challenge to the instruction as applied to that one defendant, and that everything the court said about the statute on its face was either plain error or dictum, binding on no later case. No new sentencing statute had been enacted, and by the time Taylor's appeal was heard, no district attorney in the state had filed a new notice of intent to seek death.
Taylor's appeal brought outside groups to the Court of Appeals on both sides. Friend-of-the-court briefs were filed on both sides. The court heard argument on September 10, 2007. The question before it was whether to revisit LaValle, a four-to-three decision, and the bench had changed since 2004: two of the judges in the LaValle majority had been replaced.
Taylor's own lawyers asked the court to decide the LaValle question first. If it vacated the death sentence on that ground, they asked, without objection from the prosecution, that it not reach the other issues in the appeal. An earlier claim about his right to counsel had already been abandoned at his request.
The court decided the case on October 23, 2007, by a vote of four to three. The lead opinion, joined by the chief judge and one other judge, held that LaValle controlled. It refused to recast the earlier decision's holding on the face of the statute as dictum, rejected the argument that the court should first ask only whether the statute was unconstitutional as applied to Taylor, holding that the precedent the prosecution relied on for that order of review, People v Stuart, governed claims that a statute was vague and had no application to a due process challenge like his, and refused either to sever the instruction or to write a replacement, finding the invalid provision bound up with the whole sentencing procedure and with the Legislature's design. LaValle was barely three years old, the opinion observed, and had not proved unworkable; and the Legislature remained free to reenact a sentencing statute without the coercive instruction.
The lead opinion explained each step. The closeness of the LaValle vote, the opinion held, gave it no less weight as precedent; a holding could be set aside only in exceptional cases, such as a rule that had proved unworkable, and since 2004 no prosecutor had filed a notice to seek death, so the decision had created no uncertainty. The court also declined to apply the looser respect for precedent usually given to constitutional rulings, since the Legislature could not amend the Constitution but could cure the statute. On the order of review, it held that the federal rule requiring a challenger to show that a law could never be validly applied did not sit well with the State Constitution's due process protections in capital cases, where the unacceptability of error called for heightened scrutiny. And it explained why the court could not simply redraft the deadlock instruction for cases like Taylor's: the judge would have to forecast a sentence before any presentence report, under rules that required one, and weigh actuarial and health questions, leaving death available only to the old, the frail and those whose crimes allowed consecutive terms. The court left open whether the charge given to Taylor's jury had in fact been coercive; on its holding there was no basis to decide that question.
A fourth judge, who had dissented in LaValle, concurred in the result only because he considered himself bound by it. Nothing in the law or the state had changed since 2004, he wrote, and the prosecution was asking the court to revive the very statute LaValle had struck down; the Legislature could undo most of the decision's effect with a simple statute, and it could repair the death penalty law or repeal it. He rejected the life-expectancy test outright, reasoning that age and health should never decide who is executed.
Three judges dissented. They would have treated the facial ruling in LaValle as dictum, since it had played no part in compelling the judgment, found that the instruction given to Taylor's jury was not coercive, and kept the statute in force for defendants who, like him, faced consecutive terms that exceeded any life span. The statute required a judge to charge on any matters appropriate in the circumstances, the dissent reasoned, and nothing barred the trial court from explaining what a deadlock would mean for the defendant before it. It pointed to the severability clause in the 1995 law as the Legislature's plain statement that a narrowed statute was better than none, held that the risk of unfairness to elderly or ill defendants could be met by the court's own proportionality review, and called the practical difficulties largely matters of scheduling. It faulted the lead opinion for leaving unanswered whether the statute was unconstitutional as applied to Taylor.
The judgment was modified by vacating the sentence of death and remitting the case to the Supreme Court, Queens County, for resentencing, and as modified it was affirmed. The 20 convictions stood.
Taylor came back to Queens Supreme Court on November 29, 2007. A different justice now presided. He resentenced Taylor to three concurrent terms of life without parole in place of the three death sentences, under the provisions the Court of Appeals had named for the purpose.
With the resentencing, New York's death row had no one left on it. Taylor was returned to state custody to serve life without the possibility of parole, the sentence Godineaux had been serving since 2001.
Taylor never denied that he planned the robbery or that he killed the man who had trained him. What he contested was the rest. At trial his lawyers argued that he had not caused his accomplice to kill the four others. The jury rejected that defense, and the convictions on all five deaths were affirmed; but the jury split on the penalty for the three felony murder counts.
The confession itself was challenged. Taylor claimed he had been denied his lawyer and mistreated before he confessed. The trial justice heard the evidence and rejected both claims, and the right-to-counsel issue was later dropped from the appeal at Taylor's own request, so no appellate court ruled on it. The other appellate issues were never reached.
The two men's accounts never matched. Godineaux pleaded guilty to the whole indictment and was sentenced for all five deaths. Taylor's first statements put every death on Godineaux. The jury's verdicts, and the Court of Appeals' affirmance of all 20 convictions, settled the legal question of Taylor's responsibility for all five.
May 2000: Taylor and Craig Godineaux plan a robbery of the restaurant where Taylor had worked.
May 24, 2000: Five people die and two survive in the robbery in Flushing, Queens.
May 26, 2000: Taylor is arrested in Suffolk County.
June 27, 2000: First indictment returned in Queens.
July 2000: Both men plead not guilty to a 50-count indictment.
January 22, 2001: Godineaux pleads guilty to the entire indictment.
February 2001: Godineaux is sentenced to five consecutive terms of life without parole.
April 10, 2001: A second indictment charges Taylor with all five deaths.
March 20, 2002: The trial justice admits Taylor's confession and denies his motion against the deadlock instruction.
March 27, 2002: The two indictments are consolidated.
May 22, 2002: The challenge to the grand jury pool is rejected.
September 2002: Jury selection begins in Kew Gardens.
November 2002: Taylor is convicted of 20 counts, including six counts of murder in the first degree.
November 25, 2002: The jury is charged on the sentence.
Late November 2002: The jury returns death verdicts on three counts.
January 8, 2003: Taylor is sentenced to death.
June 24, 2004: The Court of Appeals decides People v LaValle, leaving four men, Taylor among them, under sentence of death.
September 10, 2007: The Court of Appeals hears Taylor's appeal.
October 23, 2007: The Court of Appeals vacates the death sentence, four to three.
November 29, 2007: Taylor is resentenced to life without parole, leaving New York's death row empty.