On December 30, 1994, two women were killed and five other people wounded at two clinics that provided abortions in Brookline, Massachusetts, a town on the western edge of Boston. The man charged with the killings, John C. Salvi III, was 22, a trainee hairdresser from Hampton, New Hampshire. He was arrested the next day in Norfolk, Virginia. In March 1996 a jury in Dedham, Massachusetts, rejected his insanity defense and convicted him of two counts of first-degree murder and of armed assault on the five people wounded. He was sentenced to two consecutive terms of life without parole.
The case did not end with the verdict. Salvi died in custody in November 1996, before his appeal was heard. Under a Massachusetts court ruling, a defendant who dies before his appeal is reviewed has his case dismissed, and in January 1997 the judge who had tried him voided the convictions. In law, the man the jury found guilty died a convicted murderer and, two months later, was no longer one.
In late 1994 he was studying at a hairdressing school in Portsmouth and working as a trainee at a salon. He had been seen demonstrating outside clinics in the Boston area, though no evidence formally tied him to any anti-abortion organization.
Shannon Lowney died at the first of the two clinics. Lee Ann Nichols died at the second, in the same town. Three people were wounded at the first clinic and two at the second. They were the only people killed that day.
Local, state and federal law enforcement mounted a manhunt across several states, but by the time his name was known he had already left Massachusetts. On December 31 a clinic in Norfolk, Virginia, came under attack. No one was hurt, and Norfolk police arrested Salvi that day. Virginia held off its own prosecution, and on January 5, 1995, he was flown back to Massachusetts. Within days he had pleaded not guilty to federal charges in Boston and, in Brookline, to state charges of two counts of murder and five of attempted murder. He was held without bail.
Massachusetts had no death penalty, and the heaviest sentence the state could impose was life imprisonment. Federal authorities weighed a separate prosecution under laws that could have allowed a death sentence. It never came to trial: after the state verdict, the United States Attorney in Boston said he would not pursue federal charges.
After a hearing in July 1995, the judge who would preside at his trial found him competent to stand trial.
Testimony began in Dedham in February 1996 and ran for six weeks. The defense did not dispute that Salvi had committed the killings. Its case was that he was legally insane at the time, and two psychiatrists called by the defense testified that he had suffered from paranoid schizophrenia for at least two years before December 1994. The prosecution's case was that he had been in control of his senses and had planned what he did.
The jury deliberated over two days and returned its verdicts on Monday, March 18, 1996: guilty of first-degree murder in the deaths of the two women, and guilty of armed assault on the five people wounded. He was sentenced that day to the mandatory term for first-degree murder in Massachusetts, life without parole, imposed twice and served consecutively.
In July 1996 he was moved to the state's maximum-security prison. On November 29, 1996, he was found dead in custody. The state medical examiner ruled out foul play, and the death was ruled a suicide.
His appeal had not yet been argued. In January 1997 his appellate lawyer asked the trial court to apply the rule that ends a case when the defendant dies before his appeal is heard. On January 21, 1997, the trial judge granted the motion and voided the convictions. No higher court ever reviewed the verdict.
The central dispute of the trial was his state of mind. The jury rejected the defense diagnosis of paranoid schizophrenia, which the state's psychiatrist had disputed; a doctor from the state hospital testified that he believed Salvi could fake mental illness. Because he died before the appeal was heard, no higher court ever ruled on the competency finding or any other issue in the case.
Whether anyone encouraged or helped him was investigated and not established. By the spring of 1995 a federal investigation had found no criminal conspiracy in his case.
The second woman's given name appears in two spellings: most trial coverage writes it as two words, and some early reports wrote Leanne.
December 30, 1994: Two women are killed and five people wounded at two clinics in Brookline, Massachusetts.
December 31, 1994: A clinic in Norfolk, Virginia, comes under attack, with no one hurt; Norfolk police arrest Salvi.
January 5, 1995: Salvi is flown back to Massachusetts, where he pleads not guilty to federal and state charges and is held without bail.
July 1995: A competency hearing is held; he is found competent to stand trial.
February 1996: Testimony begins in Dedham.
March 18, 1996: Guilty of two counts of first-degree murder and of armed assault on the five wounded; two consecutive life terms without parole.
July 1996: Moved to the state's maximum-security prison.
November 29, 1996: Found dead in custody; the death is ruled a suicide.
January 21, 1997: The trial judge voids the convictions because he died before his appeal was heard.