John Patler was 29 years old, a former Marine from New York City and until a few months earlier one of the senior officers of the American Nazi Party, when the party's founder, George Lincoln Rockwell, was killed in Arlington, Virginia, on August 25, 1967. An Arlington County police officer took Patler into custody about a mile away within roughly half an hour, and he was charged with murder that day. He denied it. In December 1967 a jury in the Circuit Court of Arlington County found him guilty of first-degree murder and recommended a term of 20 years, and the court imposed that sentence in February 1968. The Supreme Court of Appeals of Virginia upheld the conviction on November 30, 1970. He was paroled in August 1975, returned to custody for violating the terms of that parole, and later went back to his birth surname.
He was born John C. Patsalos in New York in 1938. He served in the United States Marine Corps, and his time there ended with a dishonorable discharge after he attended a pro-Nazi rally. He then joined the small party the victim had founded in Arlington in 1959, took the surname Patler, rose by the mid-1960s to its fourth-ranking post, and was removed from it in the spring of 1967 after a dispute with its leader.
The victim was 49. He had enlisted in the Navy in 1940 and flown as a naval pilot in the Second World War, and he was recalled to service for the Korean War, reaching the rank of commander. In 1965 he ran for governor of Virginia and received 6,366 votes.
The man convicted of the killing had worked beside the victim for years. The Commonwealth asked for death. Patler pleaded not guilty, and the case came to trial in December 1967. The prosecution built its case on physical evidence that investigators linked to him and on the testimony of witnesses. His defense was that he had been elsewhere in Arlington that afternoon and had not been among the few people who knew where the victim would be.
The trial lasted 16 days. The jury found him guilty of first-degree murder but did not choose death. Under the Virginia procedure of the time the jury fixed the punishment, and it settled on 20 years. In February 1968 the trial judge imposed the full term.
The defense appealed to the Supreme Court of Appeals of Virginia, arguing that the evidence had not proved guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. The appeal took more than two years. On November 30, 1970, in the case recorded as John Patler v. Commonwealth of Virginia, the court upheld the conviction and the 20-year sentence. His later appeals also failed.
He served about four years in a Virginia state institution and was paroled in August 1975, well short of the full term. The release did not hold. Violations of his parole conditions sent him back into custody in Virginia, where he stayed until the early 1980s.
In 1977 he announced that he would return to the surname Patsalos. In later years he started a Spanish-language newspaper, which failed, and then made his living as a commercial artist. As of November 2022 he was living in New York and working as a freelance cartoonist.
Patler never admitted the killing. His defense at trial was that he had been elsewhere in Arlington, and his lawyers argued on appeal that guilt had not been proved beyond a reasonable doubt. The Supreme Court of Appeals of Virginia rejected that argument and upheld the conviction, which remained in force through his later appeals. Contemporary reports differ by a day on the verdict: most accounts give December 15, 1967, while one wire report of the time places it on December 16.
1938: John C. Patsalos is born in New York.
Spring 1967: Patler is removed from the American Nazi Party after a dispute with its leader.
August 25, 1967: The party's founder is killed in Arlington; Patler is arrested within about half an hour and charged with murder.
December 1967: After a 16-day trial in the Circuit Court of Arlington County, a jury finds Patler guilty of first-degree murder and fixes his term at 20 years.
February 1968: The court imposes the 20-year sentence.
November 30, 1970: The Supreme Court of Appeals of Virginia upholds the conviction.
August 1975: Patler is paroled.
1977: He announces a return to the surname Patsalos.
Early 1980s: He is released after being returned to custody for parole violations.
November 2022: He is living in New York.