Brandon Teena and two friends who were with him were killed together near Humboldt, in Richardson County in the far southeast corner of Nebraska, in the early hours of December 31, 1993. Two men from nearby Falls City, John L. Lotter and Marvin Thomas Nissen, were arrested within hours. Brandon, a young transgender man from Lincoln, had reported an assault by the two men to local law enforcement days earlier. The courts found that Lotter and Nissen set out to silence him, and that the other two were killed because they were there.
Nissen was convicted first, of one count of first degree murder and two counts of second degree murder, and on the eve of Lotter's trial he agreed to testify against his friend in return for the State's promise not to seek his execution. In May 1995 a jury found Lotter guilty of three counts of first degree murder, three related felony counts and one count of burglary, and in February 1996 a three-judge panel sentenced him to death on each murder count. Nissen received life sentences. In 2007 Nissen swore that he, not Lotter, had been the one who killed all three. Every court that has heard Lotter's challenges since then, state and federal, has held that the change does not undo the convictions, because both men planned and carried out the killings together.
Brandon had grown up in Lincoln, the state capital, and moved to Richardson County in the fall of 1993. He settled around Falls City, the county seat, where he was living as a man, and through a mutual friend he came to know Lotter and Nissen and went to parties with them.
Sometime that December, the two men learned that he was transgender. They were angry, a federal court later found, that they had been deceived. After he went to the authorities, Nissen later testified, the two men began talking about how to silence him, and within a day they had decided to kill him. On December 30 they learned he was staying with a friend near Humboldt.
Lisa Lambert lived outside Humboldt with her infant son. She had taken Brandon in, and another friend, Phillip DeVine, was staying with her that night as well. Lotter and Nissen arrived in the first hours of December 31, having agreed, as Nissen later testified, to kill anyone they found there. All three adults were killed. The child was left unharmed.
Both men were arrested within hours. Nissen gave a statement to a Nebraska State Patrol investigator in which he implicated himself and Lotter in the three deaths, and the information he gave led investigators to physical evidence that the State later used against them both. His account shifted over the following months; in September 1994, in state custody, he told a cellmate that he alone had done the killing.
The two men were tried apart in the District Court of Richardson County. Nissen went first. The jury convicted him of first degree murder in Brandon's death and of second degree murder in the other two. Under a written agreement of May 15, 1995, the State agreed not to seek a death sentence against him, and he agreed to give complete and truthful testimony against Lotter.
On the stand at Lotter's trial that May, Nissen told the jury that the two of them had planned the killings together, had gone to Humboldt agreed on killing anyone they found, and that Lotter had killed all three while he himself had taken a lesser part. His testimony was the only direct evidence that Lotter was the one who killed them, but it was not the only evidence against him: the State also showed that Lotter had supplied what both men used, had told a witness that evening that he wanted to kill someone, and had tried to arrange an alibi afterward. The jury heard from Nissen's former cellmate as well. Lotter testified in his own defense, denied any part in the planning or the killings and said he was not there. The jury convicted him on all seven counts.
Nebraska law at the time sent the question of death to a panel of three judges rather than to the jury. On February 21, 1996, Lotter's panel sentenced him to death on each of the three murder convictions and to prison terms on the other four counts. It found three statutory aggravating circumstances for each killing, among them that the murders were committed to conceal the identity of the perpetrators and that another murder was committed at the same time; for Brandon's death it also found that the killing was done to hinder law enforcement. It held that there was no appreciable difference in culpability between the two men, and it set Nissen apart because he testified and because his early statements showed an acceptance of responsibility within hours of the crime.
On November 6, 1998, the Nebraska Supreme Court affirmed the murder convictions and death sentences and vacated only the burglary sentence, on double jeopardy grounds. Lotter had attacked his trial on nearly every front: an ex parte communication by the trial court, misconduct by the prosecutor, the way the jury was chosen and the fact that it was not sequestered, the instructions it was given, the performance of his trial counsel and the imposition of the death penalty itself. Apart from the burglary point, the court found each of those claims without merit, and it held that his death sentences were proportionate to the penalty imposed in other Nebraska capital cases.
When it denied rehearing in 1999, the court issued a modified opinion that took up an ex parte meeting between the trial judge, the prosecutor and Nissen's counsel. It held that Lotter had not waived his due process claim over that meeting, but it rejected the claim. The threat to the judge's impartiality would have been enough under Nebraska law to require recusal had Lotter asked for it, the court held, but it did not amount to the kind of strong personal or financial interest in the outcome that the Due Process Clause forbids, and a full review of the record showed no actual bias. The Supreme Court of the United States declined to review the case that year.
Lotter's first postconviction case grew out of a claim that in 1997 Nissen had told a fellow inmate that he, not Lotter, was the one who killed all three. The Richardson County court granted a hearing on the claim. Deposed for it, Nissen refused to answer questions about what he had said, invoking his Fifth Amendment privilege. The court denied relief, and on July 11, 2003, the Nebraska Supreme Court affirmed. The fellow inmate's account of Nissen's words, it held, was inadmissible hearsay that the exception for statements against penal interest did not save. Nissen was entitled to stand on his privilege, because he could face a separate charge of first degree murder if Lotter were executed on testimony he had given falsely. Even if Nissen had lied at trial, that alone would not entitle Lotter to a writ of error coram nobis. The court also held that Ring v. Arizona, the 2002 decision requiring a jury to find the aggravating circumstances needed for a death sentence, did not apply retroactively to Lotter's sentences, and it rejected his remaining claims over the ex parte meeting and his trial counsel. The Supreme Court of the United States declined review in 2004.
A second appeal that year concerned Lotter's request, under the state's DNA Testing Act, to test items of evidence from the night of the killings. On September 26, 2003, the court affirmed the denial. It agreed that the testing he wanted had effectively not been available at the time of his trial, but held that it could not produce evidence that he had been wrongfully convicted or wrongfully sentenced, since such testing could show whose DNA was present but not how it came to be there. Lotter, the court added, had no constitutional right to attend the hearing on his motion. It rested on the sentencing panel's finding that there was no appreciable difference in culpability between Nissen and Lotter in the killings, a principle it would return to again and again.
In 2007 Nissen signed a sworn affidavit saying that his trial testimony about who had done the killing was false and that he, not Lotter, had killed all three. He did not take back the rest of it. He still placed Lotter at the center of the planning, the journey to Humboldt and the attempt to build alibis afterward.
Lotter's challenges in the state courts, including one built on the affidavit, and two federal habeas petitions have all failed, with the courts holding that because both men took part jointly and with reckless indifference to human life, it does not matter to their guilt whose hand caused each death.
The motion built on the affidavit was denied without a hearing, and on September 4, 2009, the Nebraska Supreme Court affirmed. Lotter's claim that the State knew or should have known Nissen was lying at trial was procedurally barred, the court held, because Lotter had not alleged that the evidence behind it was unavailable before any of his numerous earlier challenges. Perjury by a key witness is not, in and of itself, a constitutional violation, and postconviction relief cannot be used to obtain a new trial outside the three-year limit the statute sets. Taken as true, the affidavit did not show that Lotter was innocent, since whose hand caused the deaths did not decide his guilt. The court also rejected the argument that Nissen's testimony had been coerced by fear of execution: the sentence Nissen escaped was lawful when he made his agreement, a promise not to seek it was a legitimate offer of leniency, and Lotter had been free to cross-examine him about that fear. The Supreme Court of the United States declined review in 2010.
In federal court, the United States District Court for the District of Nebraska denied Lotter's first habeas petition on March 18, 2011, holding the recantation claim procedurally defaulted and finding no showing of actual innocence, because Nissen had not taken back the parts of his testimony that made Lotter jointly responsible; the Eighth Circuit refused a certificate of appealability that August, and the Supreme Court of the United States declined review in March 2012. A second petition was dismissed on February 24, 2017, the district court holding that Hurst v. Florida, the 2016 decision on judge-found facts in capital sentencing, did not apply retroactively to Lotter's case; the Eighth Circuit again refused a certificate, and the Supreme Court denied review in 2018.
Back in the state courts, Lotter argued that the findings behind his death sentences, made by a panel of judges, were unconstitutional under Hurst, and that the qualifying of his jury for a capital case had violated the Eighth and Fourteenth Amendments. On September 28, 2018, the Nebraska Supreme Court held that it had no jurisdiction over his appeals on the jury claim, because he had not filed them in time, and it affirmed the dismissal of the Hurst claim as barred by the one-year limit. Hurst, the court held, recognized no new right but merely applied Ring, and even if it had announced a new rule, it would not apply retroactively to Lotter. The Supreme Court of the United States declined review in 2019.
His next motions claimed that he is intellectually disabled and so cannot be executed under Atkins v. Virginia, and that his death sentences had been unlawfully reimposed after the Legislature passed a bill abolishing the death penalty and voters repealed that bill by referendum. The district court denied relief without a hearing in 2020. In 2022 the Nebraska Supreme Court affirmed, holding the intellectual disability claim both procedurally barred and time barred, and the other claim legally flawed, because the bill never took effect. The Supreme Court of the United States declined review in 2023.
The latest ruling came on October 23, 2026, when the Nebraska Supreme Court affirmed the denial of his motions over Nissen's prisoner records, holding that he could have raised the issue in an earlier motion. Those motions claimed that the prosecution had violated Brady v. Maryland by never disclosing Nissen's prisoner file, records Lotter said he obtained from the Nebraska Department of Correctional Services in 2023 and 2024, only after Nissen signed releases. The court did not decide whether the motions were also out of time. A defendant who files a successive motion, it held, must show on its face that the issue could not have been raised in any earlier motion, and Lotter's left unexplained how he came to have the records, when and why he sought them, and why he could not have done so in time for his previous motion. Given Nissen's longstanding cooperation with Lotter, the court held, it was not enough to say that the records had to wait for Nissen's release. It accepted that some federal courts treat defense diligence as no part of a Brady claim, but held that Nebraska's bar on successive motions may still require a defendant to act when he has reason to believe evidence was withheld.
As of that ruling, John Lotter remains under three sentences of death in Nebraska. Marvin Thomas Nissen was serving life sentences in Nebraska as of March 2023.
Which of the two men did the killing has never been settled in a way both accept. At trial Nissen said Lotter killed all three. He told a cellmate otherwise in 1994 and a fellow inmate otherwise in 1997, and in 2007 he swore that he alone had killed all three. Lotter's position from his arrest onward has been that he took no part and was not there, a position the 2007 affidavit does not support, since Nissen still placed him at the center of the plan and of the night itself.
The courts have not treated the question as decisive. The sentencing panel found no appreciable difference in culpability between the two men, and the state and federal courts have since held that whose hand caused each death does not change the degree of guilt of men who acted jointly.
Fall 1993: Brandon moves from Lincoln to Richardson County, Nebraska.
December 1993: He reports an assault by Lotter and Nissen to local law enforcement.
December 31, 1993: Three people are killed near Humboldt; Lotter and Nissen are arrested within hours.
September 1994: Nissen tells a cellmate that he, not Lotter, was the killer.
May 15, 1995: Nissen signs an agreement to testify against Lotter in return for the State not seeking his death.
May 1995: A jury convicts Lotter of three counts of first degree murder and four further counts.
February 21, 1996: A three-judge panel sentences Lotter to death on each murder count.
November 6, 1998: The Nebraska Supreme Court affirms, vacating only the burglary sentence.
1999: The court denies rehearing in a modified opinion; the Supreme Court of the United States declines review.
July 11, 2003: The Nebraska Supreme Court affirms the denial of Lotter's first postconviction case.
September 26, 2003: The court affirms the denial of DNA testing.
2007: Nissen swears that he, not Lotter, killed all three.
September 4, 2009: The Nebraska Supreme Court affirms the denial of the motion built on the affidavit.
March 18, 2011: A federal district court denies Lotter's first habeas petition; review ends in the Supreme Court of the United States in March 2012.
February 24, 2017: A second federal petition is dismissed.
September 28, 2018: The Nebraska Supreme Court rejects the Hurst and jury claims as untimely.
2022: The court rejects the intellectual disability and referendum claims; review denied in 2023.
October 23, 2026: The Nebraska Supreme Court affirms the denial of Lotter's latest motions.