On June 7, 1998, in Jasper County, Texas, three white men took the life of James Byrd Jr., a Black man from the same town. Before the end of 1999, Texas juries had convicted each of them of capital murder, the state's gravest offense, in a charge that the killing was committed in the course of a kidnapping. John William King and Lawrence Russell Brewer were sentenced to death. Shawn Allen Berry, the only one of the three who had never served a prison sentence, was sentenced to life. Texas executed Brewer in Huntsville on September 21, 2011, and King in the same city on April 24, 2019. As of April 2019, Berry remained a prisoner of the State of Texas, with no chance of parole before 2038.
The case rested on what the courts called racial animosity. When the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals upheld King's death sentence in October 2000, it listed his hostility toward Black people and his leading role in a white supremacist prison gang among the evidence a jury could weigh as motive. The Texas Department of Criminal Justice records that Brewer and King were documented members of a white supremacist organization.
Jasper is a racially mixed timber town of about 8,000 people in deep East Texas. John William King was born on November 3, 1974, and grew up in Jasper. He left school after the tenth grade and worked as a carpenter and laborer. He and Shawn Berry had known each other for close to a decade by the summer of 1998. Years earlier the two had been arrested together for a burglary, and both were sent to a boot camp program. Berry finished his probation without trouble. King violated his, and the State of Texas sent him to prison on a ten-year sentence for burglary.
It was in prison that King joined a white supremacist gang. From inside, he wrote letters to Berry setting out those views; Berry later said he never answered them. The Texas Department of Criminal Justice paroled King to Orange County on July 28, 1997, and he came back to Jasper, where he and Berry picked up their friendship.
Lawrence Russell Brewer was older, born March 13, 1967. He had completed the eleventh grade and worked as a laborer. His record ran longer than King's: an earlier Texas prison sentence for burglary, parole, a later drug possession conviction and a string of parole violations. He and King had served time together. Brewer was released on mandatory supervision in September 1997 and later came to Jasper, where he and King shared a residence with Berry.
Shawn Allen Berry was a Jasper native. Unlike King and Brewer, he had never been to prison.
The Jasper County sheriff's office took charge of the case on June 7, 1998, and the sheriff led the inquiry himself. Investigators quickly found evidence connecting the death to the three men, and local officers arrested Brewer and King within a day. Berry was arrested as well.
Berry talked first. A little over a day after the killing he gave investigators a statement that placed himself, King and Brewer together that night and implicated the other two in the death. Within days of his arrest he had signed seven statements in all, none of which was made public before his own trial. King never gave a statement to investigators, and he did not testify at his trial.
All three men were charged with capital murder, and the element that made the case capital was kidnapping. The Jasper County district attorney sought the death penalty against each of the three, and they were to be tried separately, King first.
The physical evidence the State assembled tied each of the three men to the scene in general terms. The case against King also rested on two documents in his own hand: a letter to a Texas newspaper denying involvement, which the State set out to prove false, and a note he wrote to Brewer while both were held in the county jail. The courts later treated both as evidence a jury could weigh against him.
King's trial opened in Jasper in February 1999 before a state district judge. The State's case was that King had led the three that night. King had denied any part in the death from the day he was charged, and his defense turned on the State's circumstantial evidence. There was no eyewitness to the killing and no accomplice testimony.
In February 1999 the jury found King guilty of capital murder. In the punishment phase that followed, the jury answered the special issues that Texas law put to it in a way that required a sentence of death, and on February 25, 1999, the trial judge sentenced King to death. He was received on death row the same day, at 24.
On a defense motion, Brewer's trial was moved out of Jasper to Bryan, in Brazos County, about 135 miles to the west. The Jasper County district attorney continued to prosecute it there. Brewer testified in his own defense. He acknowledged that he had been with King and Berry that night, but he denied that he had taken part in the murder, and he put the blame on Berry.
In September 1999 the jury found Brewer guilty of capital murder. In the punishment phase it found that he had acted intentionally and would be a continuing danger, and that no mitigating circumstance warranted a sentence of life. The judge sentenced him to death, and the Texas Department of Criminal Justice received him on death row on September 23, 1999. He was 32.
Berry's trial returned the case to Jasper in the fall of 1999. Before trial he had turned down an offer to plead guilty in exchange for a life sentence, and he was still facing the death penalty when the jury was sworn. The trial ran about a week. Unlike King, Berry took the stand in his own defense. He admitted that he had been at the scene that night, and he told the jury that parts of the statements he had signed after his arrest were untrue.
In November 1999 the jury found Berry guilty of capital murder. In the punishment phase it spared him. Berry was sentenced to life in prison, under a law that required him to serve at least forty calendar years before he could be considered for parole. He was 24.
Because King had been sentenced to death, his case went directly to the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals. He raised eight points of error, among them that his lawyers had been ineffective, that the evidence did not prove a kidnapping and that it did not prove he was a party to the murder.
On October 18, 2000, the court rejected every one of those claims in a unanimous opinion and affirmed the conviction and sentence. On the kidnapping element, it held that the restraint and movement of the victim was itself a kidnapping, so that it made no difference how the encounter had begun. On King's role, it held the evidence legally and factually sufficient, pointing to physical evidence placing him at the scene, to statements he had made to the press that the jury could find false and so read as consciousness of guilt, to the note to Brewer, which could be read as an admission, and to the evidence of his racial animosity as motive. The absence of an eyewitness or accomplice, it held, did not require reversal.
The remaining points fared no better. Before trial King's lawyers had asked to withdraw from the case, and the trial court had refused; the appeals court held that the refusal was within the judge's discretion, and that King had not shown his lawyers were ineffective for failing to press the request further. It upheld the removal for cause of a prospective juror who opposed the death penalty, finding no clear abuse of discretion. And it held that the affidavit King filed in support of his motion for a new trial was too conclusory to entitle him to a hearing on it.
State and federal habeas proceedings followed for more than a decade. King's first application for a state writ of habeas corpus reached the Court of Criminal Appeals in May 2001, and the court denied relief on June 20, 2001. A second application, filed in June 2012, was dismissed on September 12, 2012, without a ruling on its merits. In June 2016 a federal district court denied every claim in his amended petition. On August 8, 2017, the Fifth Circuit allowed him to appeal one claim, in part: that his trial lawyers had been ineffective in presenting the case for his innocence and in explaining the circumstantial evidence to the jury.
On February 22, 2018, the Fifth Circuit decided that claim against him. Reviewing it afresh, with King's new evidence included, the court held that his trial lawyers had acted reasonably in dealing with the physical evidence, the note to Brewer and the evidence of racial motive, and that even if they had fallen short, King had not shown that the outcome would have been different. It affirmed the denial of habeas relief. The Supreme Court of the United States denied his petition for review on October 29, 2018.
In his last weeks King's lawyers turned to McCoy v. Louisiana, a 2018 Supreme Court decision holding that a defendant may choose the objective of his own defense and that his lawyers may not concede his guilt over his objection. King said his trial lawyers had done exactly that. He raised the claim in a third state habeas application, filed in Jasper County in April 2019 with a request to stay the execution. On April 22, 2019, the Court of Criminal Appeals dismissed the application by a vote of five to four, without reaching its merits and citing its late filing, and denied the stay.
The Texas Board of Pardons and Paroles denied his request for commutation or a reprieve, and the Supreme Court of the United States denied a stay without opinion. John William King was executed in Huntsville on April 24, 2019. He was 44, and he had never stopped saying that he was not there when the death occurred.
Brewer's direct appeal reached the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals in December 1999, and the court affirmed his conviction and death sentence on April 3, 2002, in an unpublished opinion. His application for state habeas relief was denied, and the Court of Criminal Appeals upheld the denial. In federal court the district court denied all fifteen of his claims and then allowed him to appeal on one, which went to the heart of the charge on which all three men had been convicted. Texas defined kidnapping so broadly, Brewer argued, that some form of it could be found in nearly every murder, so that the kidnapping element of the capital murder statute failed to narrow the class of people eligible for death as the Constitution requires.
On September 29, 2006, the Fifth Circuit held that the argument was procedurally barred. The state habeas court had ruled that Brewer should have raised it on direct appeal and had waived it by failing to raise it properly at trial, and a federal court does not review a claim a state court has rejected on an adequate and independent state ground. Brewer had offered no cause for the default and had not argued that a miscarriage of justice would follow, so the bar held. In the same appeal he asked the Fifth Circuit to hear two more claims: that a state psychiatric examination had been compelled in violation of the Fifth Amendment, and that the evidence did not prove a kidnapping. The court declined to consider either, because he had never asked the district court to certify them for appeal. It affirmed the denial of habeas relief.
By 2011 Brewer's appeals were exhausted, and no last-day appeal was filed to stop his execution. Lawrence Russell Brewer was executed in Huntsville on September 21, 2011. He was 44. King's case was still under appeal at the time.
Berry never faced an execution date. By April 2019, when King was executed, he was serving his life sentence in Texas, and he will first become eligible for parole in 2038.
None of the three men ever gave a full account of the night that the courts accepted. King denied from his indictment onward that he was present when the victim died; the federal courts tested that claim as part of his ineffective-assistance claim and rejected it on its merits. Brewer testified that he had not taken part in the murder and blamed Berry. Berry admitted at his own trial that he had been present, but told the jury that parts of his signed statements were untrue; his statements themselves were not made public before that trial.
The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals treated the evidence of King's racial animosity as proper evidence of motive, and no court disturbed the convictions on that ground.
1967, March 13: Lawrence Russell Brewer is born.
1974, November 3: John William King is born.
1997, July 28: King is paroled from a Texas prison sentence for burglary.
1997, September: Brewer is released on mandatory supervision.
1998, June 7: The victim dies in Jasper County, Texas; King, Brewer and Berry are arrested and charged with capital murder.
1999, February: A Jasper jury convicts King of capital murder; he is sentenced to death on February 25.
1999, September: A Brazos County jury in Bryan convicts Brewer of capital murder and sentences him to death; he reaches death row on September 23.
1999, November: A Jasper jury convicts Berry of capital murder; he is sentenced to life.
2000, October 18: The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals affirms King's conviction and sentence.
2001, June 20: The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals denies King's first state habeas application.
2002, April 3: The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals affirms Brewer's conviction and sentence.
2006, September 29: The Fifth Circuit affirms the denial of federal habeas relief to Brewer.
2011, September 21: Brewer is executed in Huntsville.
2012, September 12: The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals dismisses King's second state habeas application.
2016, June: A federal district court denies King's amended habeas petition.
2017, August 8: The Fifth Circuit allows King to appeal one ineffective-assistance claim.
2018, February 22: The Fifth Circuit affirms the denial of habeas relief to King.
2018, October 29: The Supreme Court of the United States denies King's petition for review.
2019, April 22: The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals dismisses King's third state habeas application, raising McCoy v. Louisiana, and denies a stay.
2019, April 24: King is executed in Huntsville; Berry is serving life, with parole eligibility in 2038.