On Saturday, August 23, 1628, John Felton, an infantry lieutenant with a grievance against the crown's most powerful minister, killed George Villiers, first Duke of Buckingham, at Portsmouth. The duke was the Lord High Admiral of England, the closest adviser of King Charles I and, by the summer of 1628, deeply unpopular across the kingdom. He died almost at once. Felton made no attempt to escape. He gave himself up on the spot, and three months later, when the indictment was read to him at the bar of the Court of King's Bench, he pleaded guilty and was sentenced to death. He was executed in London on November 29, 1628.
The case has two lives. The first is legal and short: a killing, a confession, a guilty plea and an execution within three months. The second is political. Felton insisted that he had acted alone and that his only prompting was a formal declaration of the House of Commons naming the duke as the chief cause of the kingdom's troubles. The government spent the autumn of 1628 looking for the conspiracy it was sure lay behind him and found none. When the king proposed to have him racked to force out names, the judges of England met and answered that the law did not allow it. Meanwhile much of the country celebrated. Hundreds of poems on the killing survive in manuscript, and historians have traced from the episode a line of argument and pamphleteering that ran toward the English Revolution.
Felton was born about 1595, probably in Suffolk, into a family of minor gentry that had come down in the world. He went into the army young. In 1625 he served as a lieutenant in the expedition against Cádiz, the first of the great military failures for which the duke would be blamed. A wound taken in service left him without the use of his left hand.
Promotion did not come. In 1627 he twice sought command of a company of his own, first on the recommendation of one senior officer and then of another, and both times he was passed over. A contemporary diarist laid the blame on a quarrel with a courtier who stood high in the duke's favor. Felton also took his case to the duke in person and was turned away. The story later told by the Earl of Clarendon, that he had resigned his commission, is judged mistaken.
The historian Thomas Cogswell traces a service record that ran through Spain, Ireland and France, and a family whose dealings with the regime had long been strained. By the summer of 1628 Felton was in London, short of money and, by every account, increasingly melancholy. The crown owed him more than eighty pounds in back pay. In July he engaged a scrivener to draw up petitions for the arrears. It was in that office that he read, and bought, a copy of the Commons' remonstrance against the duke, along with pamphlets attacking him.
London that summer was full of such material. Cogswell describes Felton entering the city's underground world of manuscript verse and tracts directed at the favorite, and witnessing the violence of June 1628, when a London crowd killed Dr. John Lambe, a man popularly linked to the duke. In Cogswell's reading, the murder that followed was not inevitable. Felton's private frustration fused with a public hatred of Buckingham that was already finding violent expression, until he came to see himself as the instrument of a national reckoning.
The duke was born on August 28, 1592, into a Leicestershire family of country gentry with no claim to great rank. He was introduced to King James I in August 1614 and rose faster than any subject of his generation. He was made a gentleman of the bedchamber and knighted in April 1615, master of the horse and a Knight of the Garter in 1616, Viscount Villiers the same year, Earl of Buckingham in January 1617 and Marquis of Buckingham in January 1619. On January 19, 1619, James appointed him Lord High Admiral. He set out to reform a navy that had decayed under his predecessor.
In 1623 he traveled in disguise to Madrid with Prince Charles in an attempt to arrange a Spanish marriage for the prince. The negotiations failed, and the two left Madrid at the end of August. That May he had been created Duke of Buckingham, the highest-ranking English nobleman without royal blood, and he came home urging war with Spain. When James died in 1625, the duke kept his place under the new king and became, if anything, more powerful.
The wars he championed went badly. The 1625 fleet sent against Cádiz achieved nothing. In May 1626 the House of Commons impeached him, presenting to the Lords a long list of charges: that he had gathered great offices into his own hands, bought the Admiralty and the wardenship of the Cinque Ports, neglected the guard of the seas until pirates infested them, extorted ten thousand pounds from the East India merchants and allowed English ships to be used against the Protestants of La Rochelle. Charles dissolved Parliament on June 14, 1626, before the case could proceed. In July 1627 the duke led an expedition to relieve the Huguenots of La Rochelle. It landed on the Isle of Ré, laid siege to the French fort there and failed, and at the end of October he withdrew with heavy losses.
When Parliament met again on March 17, 1628, its leaders agreed not to revive the impeachment. They attacked him instead by resolution. On June 11, 1628, the House of Commons voted, upon question, that "the excessive Power of the Duke of Buckingham, and the Abuse of that Power, are the chief Cause of these Evils and Dangers to the King and Kingdom," and ordered a remonstrance to be framed and presented to the king. The king forbade Buckingham to answer.
That August the duke was at Portsmouth to hurry on supplies for a new attempt to relieve La Rochelle. Officers and men who had come back from Ré blamed him for its failure, and sailors had already protested to him over unpaid wages. A meeting with the king and the deputies from La Rochelle was fixed for August 23 to settle the final plan. Gardiner quotes him in those weeks: "Some adventure may kill me as well as another man."
Felton left London that week and reached Portsmouth on August 23. That day he killed the duke.
In the confusion, suspicion first fell on a French nobleman in the duke's company. Felton came forward himself. "I am the Man that hath done the Deed," he said, as John Rushworth later printed his words; "let no Man suffer that is Innocent." The king, who was near Portsmouth when the news reached him, ordered that the killer be secured. Contemporaries describe Charles shutting himself away in grief.
Felton had written out a statement beforehand and carried it with him, because he expected to be killed on the spot. A diarist of the time, Walter Yonge, copied one version into his journal, and about fifteen other manuscript copies survive.
Felton was held in custody at Portsmouth for about two weeks and then taken under guard to London. There the questioning began in earnest. The authorities were sure that a conspiracy lay behind him and set out to find it.
Felton admitted the killing from the start and condemned himself for it. He told his examiners that the remonstrance of Parliament had turned him against the duke. He denied that anyone had set him on, the Puritans included. The remonstrance, he said, was his only "confederate and setter-on." He blamed the instigation of the Devil for his own part, but he named no living person. No accomplice was ever found.
The questioning went on through September and October. At one examination a bishop told Felton that he must expect the rack. Felton's answer, as Rushworth recorded it, was that if it came to that, "he could not tell whom he might nominate in the Extremity of Torture." Before going further, Charles asked for the judges' opinion.
On November 13, 1628, the king had the chief justice of the King's Bench put the question to all the judges: could Felton lawfully be racked to make him reveal his accomplices? Their first answer was that the king could not authorize it. On November 14 they gave their formal resolution, unanimously: Felton "ought not by the Law to be tortured by the Rack, for no such Punishment is known or allowed by our Law." The proposal, which two members of the council had backed, was dropped.
By late November the search for conspirators had come to nothing and the government let the law take its course. On Thursday, November 27, 1628, Felton was brought to the bar of the Court of King's Bench. When the indictment was read, he answered that he was guilty of killing the Duke of Buckingham. He added that he "did deserve Death for the same, though he did not do it out of Malice to him." The court pronounced sentence of death.
Felton then asked that a further punishment be added to his sentence. The court told him it could not do so, because the judgment of the law for murder was the same in every case. Charles asked the judges for the same thing, and they refused him on the same ground.
Felton was executed in London two days after the sentence, on November 29, 1628. That is the date the modern scholarly edition of the period's verse gives; the Dictionary of National Biography put the execution a day earlier, on November 28. Before the crowd he confessed and openly repented of what he had done.
The government's account of Felton did not take hold. News of the duke's death traveled fast, and across the country it set off what the historians Alastair Bellany and Andrew McRae describe as spontaneous and often reckless outbursts of joy. On his journey under guard Felton was cheered by people along the way, and soldiers petitioned the king to deal kindly with a former comrade in arms.
The poetry survives in quantity. Bellany and McRae's edition of early Stuart political verse gathers more than 350 poems on the killing, most of them copied by hand and passed from reader to reader. They fall into three broad groups. Some mock the dead duke in epitaphs and dialogues in which his ghost recounts his crimes. Others praise Felton himself. A third group is mixed or hostile, including pieces by Thomas Carew and William Davenant attacking those who celebrated the death, and eulogies for Buckingham.
Historians have read the episode as a turning point. Bellany has argued that the killing changed the course of seventeenth-century politics. The verse it produced also exposed questions that no one in 1628 could safely ask aloud: how far the king himself was responsible for the duke's rule, and how far popular, Puritan and republican impulses had already gone.
Whether Felton served in the 1627 expedition to the Isle of Ré is not settled. The Dictionary of National Biography thought it uncertain; Cogswell and the editors of the early Stuart libels place him there and describe him as badly wounded in the retreat.
His motive is the larger question. Felton himself said he acted for the public good and in response to the Commons' remonstrance, and told the court he bore the duke no malice. The government said he was driven by private resentment over his lost promotion and his unpaid wages. Modern scholarship treats the two as bound together: a personal grievance that took on a political meaning in the London of 1628.
The government never proved a conspiracy and never stopped suspecting one. Whether the questioning in London went beyond threats is also unresolved. Bellany and McRae write that he was examined repeatedly, possibly under torture; the judges' formal ruling of November 14, 1628, forbade the rack, and no record of its use on him has been produced.
The day of the execution is recorded two ways: the Early Stuart Libels edition gives November 29, 1628, two days after the sentence, while the Dictionary of National Biography gives November 28.
August 28, 1592: The future duke is born in Leicestershire.
About 1595: John Felton is born, probably in Suffolk.
August 1614: The future duke is introduced to King James I.
January 19, 1619: He is appointed Lord High Admiral.
May 18, 1623: He is created Duke of Buckingham.
1625: Felton is a lieutenant in the expedition against Cádiz.
May 1626: The House of Commons impeaches the duke; Parliament is dissolved on June 14, 1626, before the case proceeds.
July to October 1627: The duke's expedition to the Isle of Ré fails.
1627: Felton is twice refused command of a company.
March 17, 1628: Parliament meets.
June 11, 1628: The Commons resolve that the duke's excessive power and its abuse are the chief cause of the kingdom's evils, and order a remonstrance.
July 1628: Felton has petitions drawn up in London for more than eighty pounds in arrears and buys a copy of the remonstrance.
August 23, 1628: Felton kills the Duke of Buckingham at Portsmouth and gives himself up.
Early September 1628: Felton is moved from Portsmouth to London.
November 13, 1628: The king asks the judges whether Felton may lawfully be racked.
November 14, 1628: The judges resolve that he may not, because the law knows no such punishment.
November 27, 1628: Felton pleads guilty at the bar of the Court of King's Bench and is sentenced to death.
November 29, 1628: Felton is executed in London (the Dictionary of National Biography gives November 28).