On November 9, 1971 John Emil List killed five members of his family in Westfield, New Jersey: his wife, his mother, and three of his children, a daughter and two sons. He left the state the next day and did not come back for almost eighteen years. During that time he lived in Colorado and later in Virginia under the name Robert P. Clark.
He was arrested by FBI agents in Richmond, Virginia, on June 1, 1989, days after a national television program had broadcast the case. In April 1990 a jury in Elizabeth, in Union County, New Jersey, found him guilty on five counts of first-degree murder. On May 1, 1990 he received five consecutive life sentences. The Appellate Division affirmed the convictions and the sentences in 1993. List died in custody in New Jersey on March 21, 2008, at the age of 82.
List was born on September 17, 1925 in Bay City, Michigan. He was 46 in 1971 and 64 at the time of his trial. He lived in Michigan and New York before he settled in New Jersey.
The prosecution charged each of the five deaths as a separate count of first-degree murder, a distinction that later decided the form of the sentence.
The offenses took place on November 9, 1971 in Westfield, a town in Union County. List left New Jersey the next day. Within weeks he was living in Colorado under the name Robert P. Clark, the name he used for the next eighteen years.
After 1971 List lived in Colorado, where he settled in the Denver area and later in Aurora, and later in Midlothian, Virginia, near Richmond. Throughout those years the Westfield case remained open, and the man known as Robert P. Clark was not connected to it by the people around him.
On May 21, 1989 the Fox television program America's Most Wanted broadcast a segment on the Westfield case, which included an age-progressed likeness of List. A tip telephoned to the program identified the man living as Robert P. Clark with the person in the likeness. FBI agents arrested him in Richmond, Virginia, on June 1, 1989.
On July 10, 1989 a court ordered him held on bail of $5 million. He refused to admit his identity at that stage and was returned to New Jersey to stand trial. He admitted his identity during a pretrial hearing in 1990.
The Union County prosecutor's office charged List with five counts of first-degree murder, one for each of the dead. New Jersey's death penalty was not in force at the time of the offenses, so the most severe sentence available on conviction was life imprisonment.
Before the trial the defense moved to exclude evidence obtained at an early stage of the inquiry in 1971. The trial court denied the motion, relying on the doctrines of abandonment and inevitable discovery. That ruling, made in 1990, was the first of the legal questions that reached the appeal court three years later.
The trial was held in Elizabeth, the seat of Union County. Testimony began on April 1, 1990, and an assistant Union County prosecutor opened the case on April 2. The defense attorney argued that List was not guilty by reason of his mental condition at the time of the offenses. The defense also raised a claim of diminished capacity, an argument which, if accepted, would have allowed a jury to return a conviction on a lesser charge.
The jury began its deliberations on April 11, 1990. On April 12, 1990, after about nine hours, it returned a verdict of guilty on all five counts of first-degree murder, rejecting the defense that a mental defect had been responsible.
On May 1, 1990 the court imposed five consecutive life sentences, one for each count. Had the terms run concurrently, List would have become eligible for parole after 14 years and 11 months. With consecutive terms the sentences were expected to keep him in custody for the rest of his life. He was 64 years old.
List appealed to the Superior Court of New Jersey, Appellate Division. The court heard argument on April 27, 1993 and decided the case on June 21, 1993 in a per curiam opinion, State v. List, 270 N.J. Super. 169. It affirmed both the convictions and the sentences.
The appeal raised eight issues: the admissibility of evidence from the early inquiry; a claim of ineffective assistance by trial counsel; claims under the evidence rule on clergy communications and the privilege against self-incrimination, the latter raised for the first time on appeal; venue and jury selection, including the refusal of a change of venue and of additional peremptory challenges; the instructions to the jury on malice and mental defect, together with the refusal to charge manslaughter; prosecutorial conduct; and whether five consecutive life sentences were excessive.
The court agreed with the trial judge that the evidence was admissible. It held that the clergy privilege covers only confidential communications. It found no abuse of discretion in the rulings on jurors. It upheld the consecutive terms under an exception to the general limit on consecutive sentences, because the killings were predominantly independent of one another, and it found the remaining points clearly without merit. A later application for a new trial, which argued that List suffered from post-traumatic stress arising from his wartime military service, also failed.
List died in custody in New Jersey on March 21, 2008. He was 82.
The structure of the sentence turned on a feature of New Jersey law. A life term in the state carried parole eligibility after a fixed period, and concurrent life terms would have made List eligible for release in under fifteen years. The trial court instead ran the five terms consecutively, and the Appellate Division held that this was permitted because the killings were predominantly independent of one another, an exception to the general cap on consecutive terms. The capital statute was not in force when the offenses were committed, so no death sentence was available.
The verdict also shows how the mental-state defenses operate. The defense of not guilty by reason of mental condition and the claim of diminished capacity were both put to the jury, and the jury's verdict on five counts of first-degree murder rejected them.
His identity was contested only until the 1990 pretrial hearing, when List admitted who he was. The mental-condition defense was decided against him by the jury and was not upheld on appeal. A later claim based on post-traumatic stress arising from wartime service did not succeed.
September 17, 1925: John Emil List born in Bay City, Michigan.
November 9, 1971: five members of his family killed in Westfield, New Jersey.
November 10, 1971: he leaves New Jersey; he later lives in Colorado as Robert P. Clark.
May 21, 1989: America's Most Wanted broadcasts a segment on the case.
June 1, 1989: FBI agents arrest him in Richmond, Virginia.
July 10, 1989: held on $5 million bail.
April 1, 1990: testimony begins in Elizabeth, New Jersey.
April 12, 1990: jury returns guilty verdicts on five counts of first-degree murder.
May 1, 1990: five consecutive life sentences imposed.
June 21, 1993: Appellate Division affirms convictions and sentences.
March 21, 2008: dies in custody in New Jersey, aged 82.