John Dunn

Victims
1 police constable killed at Collector, New South Wales, 1865. Convicted of the murder of Constable Samuel Nelson and executed in Sydney, March 19, 1866
Years active
January 26, 1865 (the death); March 19, 1866 (execution)
Location
Collector; Binalong; Yass; Quambone; Sydney (all New South Wales)
Method
Murder of a police officer on duty, during the Hall gang's hold-up of the village of Collector
Status
Sentenced to death; executed in Sydney on March 19, 1866

John Dunn was the last of Ben Hall's gang to die, and the only one of the three who lived to face a court. A teenager from the Yass and Binalong district of New South Wales, he rode with Hall and John Gilbert through the summer of 1865, and on the evening of January 26 of that year, in the village of Collector, he killed the one policeman left on duty there. Both of his companions were dead by the end of May. Police took Dunn in the west of the colony about six months later, charged him with the constable's murder, and he was executed in Sydney on March 19, 1866.

Collector was the turning point of the gang's last run. Community feeling in the district soured against the three men after that evening, a reward was put on their heads, and within four months two of them had died at the hands of the police.

Dunn came from around Yass and Binalong, on the southern tablelands. He made his name there first in the saddle, as a champion jockey in the Yass district while still in his teens, and he knew which stations kept the fast racehorses.

That was the knowledge Gilbert wanted. Gilbert brought the young jockey into the newly formed Ben Hall gang with a practical aim: a rider who knew where the best horses were could keep the band mounted on animals fast enough to stay ahead of the police. Dunn was the junior of the three, years younger than either of the men he joined.

The gang moved quickly through the first weeks of 1865.

Collector lay about 35 kilometers from Goulburn, on the tablelands south of the gang's usual ground. On the evening of January 26, 1865, its mounted police were away, drawn off by reports that bushrangers were working the district. The gang had doubled back. That left one officer in the village, the constable who kept the lock-up.

Samuel Nelson had joined the New South Wales Police Force on August 5, 1857. He had served in the Lake George area before his posting to Collector, and by that summer he was the village's lock-up keeper. When word came that the bushrangers were holding one of the village inns, he went out to face them alone.

Hall and Gilbert were inside. Dunn had been left to keep watch. When the constable came up, Dunn killed him, without provocation. The gang then rode out of Collector.

The death of a lone constable on duty cost the gang the goodwill it had drawn on in parts of the district. Support turned sour, and a reward was placed on all three men.

In early May 1865 Ben Hall died near Forbes when police caught up with him. A few days later police came upon Gilbert and Dunn at Binalong. Gilbert died there. Dunn got away and rode west, out of the country where he was known.

For about six months Dunn stayed out of sight in the western districts of the colony. Police finally took him at Quambone, near Dubbo. He was charged with the murder of the Collector constable and brought to Sydney.

With Hall and Gilbert dead, Dunn alone was called to answer for Collector. He was convicted of murder and sentenced to death.

He was executed in Sydney on March 19, 1866.

The hunt for the three men ran through the year in which the New South Wales Parliament passed the Felons Apprehension Act 1865, the statute that brought outlawry into Australian law. A person proclaimed an outlaw under it could be killed on sight by any citizen. Dunn was not killed under it. He was taken alive, charged with murder and tried in the ordinary criminal courts of the colony.

Local tellings of the evening at Collector differ on how the constable came to approach the inn, but they agree that it was Dunn, keeping watch, who killed him. His exact date and place of birth and the date of his trial remain unsettled.

Timeline

Early January 1865: Ben Hall, John Gilbert and John Dunn are active in the Yass and Binalong district.

January 26, 1865: At Collector, Dunn kills the village's lock-up keeper, the only police officer on duty there that evening.

1865: The New South Wales Parliament passes the Felons Apprehension Act, introducing outlawry into Australian law.

May 1865: Hall dies near Forbes; a few days later Gilbert dies at Binalong and Dunn escapes west.

About six months after Binalong: Dunn is captured at Quambone, near Dubbo, and charged with the constable's murder.

March 19, 1866: Dunn, convicted of murder and sentenced to death, is executed in Sydney.