John Herbert Dillinger was charged with one killing in his life and never answered it in court. On January 26, 1934, a Lake County, Indiana, indictment accused him of first-degree murder in the perpetration of a robbery, for the death eleven days earlier of Patrolman William Patrick O'Malley of the East Chicago Police Department. It was the only homicide charge ever filed against him. He was arrested in Tucson, Arizona, returned to Indiana and held at the Lake County Jail in Crown Point to await trial, and on March 3, 1934, before any jury had been chosen, he escaped. He spent the last four and a half months of his life as a federal fugitive and died in Chicago on July 22, 1934. The charge died with him.
By then the state of Indiana had already known him for ten years. He had gone into its reformatory at twenty-one on a guilty plea, entered without a lawyer, to two felonies committed in the farm town of Mooresville. He came out of the Indiana State Prison at Michigan City at almost thirty, released on parole by order of the governor after a petition from the town. Everything for which he is remembered happened in the fourteen months that followed, and the only part of it that reached an indictment for murder is the East Chicago case.
Dillinger was born in Indianapolis on June 22, 1903. He went through the city's public schools, attending Schools 38 and 55, and left at sixteen. For the next few years he held a run of ordinary jobs: a veneer mill, a machine shop on the west side, errands for the Indianapolis Board of Trade.
He enlisted in the United States Navy, trained at the Great Lakes Naval Training Station and was assigned as a fireman to the battleship Utah. He lasted about five months and deserted in December of the year he joined. The Navy gave him a dishonorable discharge.
On September 6, 1924, Dillinger and an older companion took part in an offense against a Mooresville man. The man was not seriously hurt. A Morgan County deputy sheriff found Dillinger two days later. His only earlier conviction on the state's books was for speeding, in 1920.
What followed took little more than a week. Dillinger admitted the offense, and the prosecutor told him that, having admitted it, he had no need of a lawyer. He pleaded guilty in the Morgan Circuit Court, and he entered the plea without counsel.
The court committed him on September 15, 1924. Two commitment sheets survive in the state's files under the same number, 5417: one for a term of 10 to 20 years for assault and battery with intent to rob, the other for 2 to 14 years for conspiracy to commit a felony. The ten-to-twenty-year term was the maximum. His companion, who already had a prison record, retained a lawyer, obtained a separate hearing, received 2 to 14 years and was paroled in less than two years.
The terms were imposed together. A receipt for Dillinger passed from the reformatory's superintendent to the clerk of the Morgan court on September 17, the day after he arrived at Pendleton, and the court's business with him did not end there. On September 24 the Morgan Circuit Court issued a subpoena naming him as a witness; on September 26 the county sheriff signed for him, and he was taken back to the county. A second subpoena followed on October 11. The sheriff signed for him again on October 14, and he was returned to the reformatory on October 16, 1924.
Dillinger served the first part of his sentence at the Indiana State Reformatory in Pendleton, under reformatory number 14395. The institution had been set up in 1897 for younger prisoners, those aged sixteen through thirty, and had moved to Pendleton in 1922; older men and those convicted of more serious crimes went to the state prison at Michigan City. At twenty-one, Dillinger belonged at Pendleton.
He was received on September 16, 1924. Within days the reformatory had photographed and measured him, taken a biographical statement and classified his schooling. The Navy sent his service record to the superintendent that December, and his discharge certificate, dated January 15, 1925, went into the same file. On November 7, 1924, the reformatory drew up the sheet that recorded when he would first be eligible for parole.
He worked as a seamster in the shirt factory, often finishing twice his daily quota, and he played on the reformatory baseball team. He also made friends among the other inmates.
In the last days of 1928 an attorney from Martinsville wrote to the superintendent on his behalf, and on December 27 the superintendent answered about an appearance before the Board of Pardons. The case was before the Board of Pardons in January 1929. He was denied parole in 1929. After that refusal he asked to be moved to the Indiana State Prison in Michigan City, where several of the men he knew were held, and on July 15, 1929, the governor signed Executive Order 4519 transferring him from the reformatory to the state prison.
He spent almost four more years at Michigan City. He went back to work in the prison's shirt factory, and he did not play on its baseball team.
In the spring of 1933 a petition for his release reached the governor's office. More than a hundred people from the Mooresville community signed it, and the prosecutor who had convicted him in 1924 endorsed it. On May 10, 1933, the governor signed Executive Order 7733, granting the parole. Dillinger signed his parole agreement, number GP1110, on May 22, 1933, and walked out of Michigan City after nine years in custody. The agreement carried the same number, 1110, as the parole agreement he had first signed on the day of his commitment in 1924.
For a few weeks the parole ran its ordinary course. A change of address was filed for him on May 23. At the end of June he completed his monthly parole report, a questionnaire, and on July 21, 1933, a parole visitor filed a report on him. By then the federal government had begun to take an interest: on July 28, 1933, the Bureau of Investigation of the United States Department of Justice was in touch with the reformatory about him.
The parole lasted five months. On September 22, 1933, he was arrested in Dayton, Ohio, and taken to the Allen County Jail in Lima. On October 12 he was freed from that jail. Five days later, on October 17, 1933, the governor signed Executive Order 8133, revoking his parole; the order was stamped on October 20. On the day the order was stamped, the reformatory's superintendent wrote to the warden of the state prison. From that point he was once again a prisoner of the state of Indiana, wanted to serve out the 1924 sentence.
The federal interest did not fade. Transcripts of his Indiana record went to the Department of Justice in the first days of October 1933 and again in November, when the reformatory's superintendent also wrote to the Bureau's director about him and another former inmate. Another went to the Bureau on February 6, 1934, a week after his return to Indiana.
The patrolman had served two years with the East Chicago Police Department when he died on Monday, January 15, 1934, in the city's Northside district. He was on duty when he died.
Within eleven days a Lake County grand jury had returned an indictment. On January 26, 1934, Dillinger and an associate were each indicted for first-degree murder in the perpetration of a robbery. The associate died in April 1934 without being tried. It was the charge on which Indiana would demand Dillinger from Arizona.
Dillinger and three associates had reached Tucson, Arizona, on January 21, 1934. On January 25 Tucson police arrested the four men separately in the course of the day. They were held in the Pima County jail and appeared at the Pima County Courthouse on January 26.
Two states wanted them. Ohio sought the three associates on a charge arising from Lima. Indiana sought Dillinger on the East Chicago indictment. The Lake County prosecutor and the county's chief deputy sheriff traveled to Tucson to press the Indiana claim, and the claim was granted. The three associates went by train to Ohio. Dillinger was flown back to Indiana and turned over to Lake County officers.
Dillinger arrived at the Lake County Jail in Crown Point on January 30, 1934, and was held there under heavy guard. He denied any part in the East Chicago case. The court expected to try him in the Lake Criminal Court at Crown Point at an early date unless a change of venue was granted.
He had a lawyer for the defense. In February, about three weeks before his escape, he was brought into court at Crown Point and arraigned on the murder charge, then committed again to the Lake County Jail to wait for trial. Two claims held him there: the indictment for first-degree murder in the perpetration of a robbery, and behind it the unserved balance of the 1924 sentence, to which the revoked parole had returned him.
The trial never began. On Saturday, March 3, 1934, Dillinger escaped from the Lake County Jail. He was never again in the custody of any court.
The escape turned a state prisoner into a federal one. The manner of his departure from Indiana into Illinois brought him under the National Motor Vehicle Theft Act. The law made it a federal offense to transport a stolen motor vehicle across state lines, and a violation of it gave the Division of Investigation of the United States Department of Justice the authority to pursue him. Until then the case against him had belonged to Indiana and Ohio.
The federal pursuit lasted four and a half months. On June 22, 1934, his thirty-first birthday, the federal government declared him the leading public enemy in the country, and the Justice Department offered a reward of $10,000 for his capture. A Division of Investigation wanted notice followed on June 25, 1934.
Dillinger died in Chicago on July 22, 1934. The Lake County indictment for first-degree murder had never come to trial, and he was never convicted of the murder.
The East Chicago charge was never tested. No court heard evidence on it, no jury returned a verdict and no judge entered a finding. Dillinger denied any part in it from the time of his return to Indiana, and an associate was indicted with him for the same death. Who caused the patrolman's death has never been settled by a court, and the indictment remained an accusation.
June 22, 1903: Born in Indianapolis, Indiana.
September 6, 1924: Offense against a Mooresville man, Morgan County, Indiana.
September 8, 1924: Found by a Morgan County deputy sheriff.
September 15, 1924: Committed for 10 to 20 years for assault and battery with intent to rob and 2 to 14 years for conspiracy to commit a felony, on a guilty plea.
September 16, 1924: Received at the Indiana State Reformatory, Pendleton.
September 26 and October 14, 1924: Taken back to Morgan County on subpoenas of the Morgan Circuit Court as a witness; returned to the reformatory on October 16.
January 1929: Case before the Board of Pardons.
1929: Denied parole at the Indiana State Reformatory, Pendleton.
July 15, 1929: Transferred to the Indiana State Prison, Michigan City, by Executive Order 4519.
May 10, 1933: Paroled by Executive Order 7733.
May 22, 1933: Signs parole agreement GP1110 and leaves Michigan City.
July 28, 1933: The Bureau of Investigation is in touch with the Indiana reformatory about him.
September 22, 1933: Arrested in Dayton, Ohio; held at the Allen County Jail, Lima.
October 12, 1933: Freed from the Lima jail by associates.
October 17, 1933: Parole revoked by Executive Order 8133.
January 15, 1934: An East Chicago patrolman dies in the city's Northside district.
January 25, 1934: Arrested by Tucson police in Tucson, Arizona.
January 26, 1934: Indicted in Lake County, Indiana, for first-degree murder in the perpetration of a robbery.
January 30, 1934: Arrives at the Lake County Jail, Crown Point, to await trial.
February 1934: Arraigned at Crown Point on the murder charge.
February 6, 1934: A transcript of his Indiana record goes to the Bureau of Investigation.
March 3, 1934: Escapes from the Lake County Jail before trial.
June 22, 1934: Declared the country's leading public enemy; federal reward of $10,000 offered.
June 25, 1934: Division of Investigation wanted notice issued.
July 22, 1934: Dies in Chicago, Illinois; the murder charge is never tried.