In September 1874 a grand jury sitting at Beaver, in southern Utah Territory, returned an indictment for murder against nine men. The crime it described was seventeen years old. On September 11, 1857, at Mountain Meadows, a valley about 35 miles southwest of Cedar City, about 120 emigrants traveling by wagon from Arkansas to California had been killed by some 50 to 60 local militiamen and their American Indian allies. One of the nine names on the indictment was John Doyle Lee, a 62-year-old farmer, ferryman and former officer of the Iron County militia who had once held federal office as an agent for Indian affairs in southern Utah.
Lee was the only one of the nine ever tried. His first trial, at Beaver in the summer of 1875, ended when the jury could not agree. At his second, in September 1876, a jury found him guilty of murder in the first degree. The Supreme Court of the Territory of Utah affirmed the judgment and sentence in February 1877, and on March 23, 1877, he was executed at Mountain Meadows. He denied to the end that he had killed anyone himself.
Lee was born on September 12, 1812, in Kaskaskia, in Randolph County, in what was then Illinois Territory. As a young man he worked a run of jobs as a clerk, a fireman and a mail contractor before taking up farming in Fayette County, Illinois.
He joined the Latter Day Saint movement in his mid-twenties and was baptized in June 1838. That year he moved to the settlements near Far West, Missouri, and was drawn into the armed conflicts of northwest Missouri as part of the movement's organized militia. When the church's members were driven out of Missouri he went first to Fayette County and then to Nauvoo, Illinois. From 1840 he served a series of proselytizing missions in Tennessee, Kentucky and Illinois, and in Nauvoo he served as a police officer and helped build a meeting hall. In the spring of 1844 he was campaigning for the presidential bid of the church's founder, Joseph Smith, when Smith's death ended the mission.
Back in Nauvoo he became secretary and bodyguard to Brigham Young, Smith's successor, and one of his most trusted associates. He went west with the main body of the church, wintering at Winter Quarters in what is now Nebraska, staying behind in 1847 on instructions to plant crops, and reaching the Salt Lake Valley with Young's company in late September 1848. He spent two years in the valley and helped found Provo.
In December 1850 he answered a call to settle southern Utah. He was among the founders of Parowan and Harmony in Iron County and became a prosperous farmer and businessman. He served as probate judge for Iron County and as a delegate to the territorial legislature, and he held federal office as agent for Indian affairs in southern Utah, with the title of farmer to the Paiute bands of the district. He was also an officer in the Iron County militia, part of the territorial militia organized throughout Utah.
In 1857 the territory was bracing for an army. President James Buchanan had decided to replace Brigham Young as governor with a non-Mormon appointee, and believing the church's members would resist, his administration sent an initial force of 2,500 troops west to escort the new governor to Great Salt Lake City. Young declared martial law and called out the territorial militia to delay the troops. The conflict that followed ended in June 1858 without a pitched battle.
That September an emigrant company from Arkansas was passing south through the territory on its way to California. The company of about 120 men, women and children was the first southbound wagon train of the year, and it reached Cedar City on September 4, 1857. On September 11, at Mountain Meadows, members of the local militia and their Indian allies killed about 120 of the emigrants. The church's later account names the killers as some 50 to 60 local militiamen and places responsibility on the local church leaders of the region, who also held civic and military posts, and on members acting under their direction. Lee was one of the leaders present.
Two months after the killings Lee wrote to Brigham Young in his capacity as superintendent of Indian affairs for the territory. The letter, dated at Harmony on November 20, 1857, would resurface in December 1876, when a copy was filed in the court record of his case.
Federal officials tried and failed to bring the case to court in the years that followed. On March 8, 1859, a federal judge opened court at Provo and swore a grand jury to inquire into the killings. The jurors, most of them church members, returned no indictment. The judge discharged them on March 21 and carried on the inquiry alone, sitting as a committing magistrate. In April 1859 a federal territorial judge issued warrants for the arrest of Lee and two other local militia leaders. The men fled. In May of that year the judge and army troops visited Mountain Meadows, and by June 1859 the federal case against 38 men had been all but abandoned.
Lee moved for a time to Santa Clara, in the far south of the territory, to raise cotton and to stay out of reach of those who wanted him tried. In March 1864 he was relieved of his office as elder of the church branch at Harmony. In October 1870 the church excommunicated him for his part in the killings. He was the only militia member to be excommunicated.
Church leaders afterward sent him to set up a crossing on the Colorado River at the mouth of the Paria, in northern Arizona, and he settled there about 1871. The place is still known as Lees Ferry.
The prosecution that finally reached Lee was made possible by a change in federal law. The Poland Act of 1874 stripped Utah's probate courts of their criminal jurisdiction, placed the prosecution of crimes in the hands of the United States attorney, abolished the territorial marshal and attorney, and set a new procedure for jury lists, with the names drawn by lot in open court. The first grand jury empaneled under the new law was summoned for the opening of the Second District Court at Beaver in September 1874.
On September 24, 1874, that grand jury returned its indictment. The caption ran in the name of the people of the United States in the Territory of Utah, the court was the District Court in and for the Second Judicial District, at its September term of 1874 in Beaver County, and the document was headed "Indictment for Murder." It named nine defendants, John D. Lee among them, and charged them in a single count with having acted feloniously, willfully, designedly, with premeditation and "of malice aforethought." The indictment placed the killings in Mountain Meadow Valley, "now Washington County," on "the sixteenth day of September one thousand eight hundred and fifty seven." It named one victim and charged the deaths of "fifty other men women and children" whose names, it said, were "wholly unknown." The foreman of the grand jury endorsed it as a true bill, and an assistant United States attorney signed it for the prosecution.
The clerk's record of that return was left unfinished. The minutes entered the indictment with blanks in it, and the full return was never written into the court's journal. The gap would matter ten months later.
A warrant for Lee's arrest was issued on October 13, 1874. On November 9, 1874, he was taken into custody at Panguitch, Utah, and he was held to answer the indictment.
Lee was brought before the district court at Beaver on July 21, 1875, to answer the indictment. The prosecution began by asking the court to repair its own record. On the motion of the United States attorney, the court recognized that the grand jury's return of September 24, 1874, had never been entered in full, and it ordered a corrected entry made nunc pro tunc, as of the original date, to stand in place of the defective journal entry and minutes. Lee's counsel excepted to the ruling.
Lee answered with a set of pleas aimed at the indictment itself. One, a plea in abatement, argued that the grand jury had not been a lawful one. It alleged that twenty-three names had been drawn on the judge's order for the September 1874 term, that twenty-two of those people had been summoned and had appeared on the opening day of the term, September 7, and it set out how the panel had then been filled. It stated, too, that he had been neither under arrest nor on bail to appear at that term when the indictment was found. The prosecution demurred to his first and second pleas and filed a replication to the third, and the defense filed a rejoinder. The court sustained the demurrer and found the third plea not well taken, and Lee's counsel entered exceptions to both rulings. Lee then pleaded not guilty.
On July 22 the defense challenged the jury panel as drawn in a manner the judge's order did not allow, and asked the court to quash it. The case went to trial before the jury as sworn.
The trial opened on July 23, 1875, before the presiding judge of the Second District. The prosecution set out to do more than convict the man in the dock: its aim was to tie the killings to the church's leaders in Salt Lake City. The prosecutor opened by telling the jury what his witnesses would show, and among the witnesses he called was one of the eight men indicted with Lee.
The defense wanted evidence of its own from the church president and from one of the church's apostles. After a physician swore that neither man could safely make the journey to Beaver, their depositions were taken in Salt Lake City, with the prosecution invited to attend, and filed with the court on August 2.
On July 29 the defense moved the court to proceed no further, arguing that no lawful term of the court was then being held. The trial went on. Both sides filed written jury instructions on August 7, the court giving some of those the defense requested and refusing others.
The twelve jurors were eight church members, one former member and three men who had never belonged to the church. They could not agree. In early August 1875 the trial ended with a hung jury, all but the three non-members voting to acquit, and the case was continued.
The prosecution regrouped through the following year. A new United States attorney took over the case, and in the summer of 1876 he reached an understanding with Brigham Young, who agreed to help locate witnesses against Lee. The case file from these months fills with subpoenas: in April 1876 the court summoned more than twenty witnesses in three separate writs, and in August it issued further subpoenas for the residents of the southern settlements whose evidence the prosecution now meant to put before a jury. A commitment order dated September 11, 1876, kept Lee in custody as the second trial approached.
The second trial opened at Beaver on September 14, 1876, before the same court. A jury was impaneled and sworn, this time made up entirely of church members, and the prosecution stated its case. It began with documents: Lee's letter of November 1857, territorial correspondence from September 1857 and January 1858, the governor's proclamation of September 15, 1857, and the deposition and affidavit taken in Salt Lake City the year before. Then came the witnesses, led by the former commander of the territorial militia and followed by men from the southern settlements, one of whom was recalled for further questioning.
When the prosecution rested, the defense called no witnesses and introduced no evidence. On September 18, with the testimony closed, Lee's counsel moved in writing to quash all further proceedings and discharge him, on the ground that the statute under which the indictment had been found was repealed. The court denied the motion and ordered the cause to proceed, and the defense excepted. Counsel on both sides argued the case to the jury, and the defense, with the court's leave, handed up its own requested instructions. The depositions were filed again on September 20 and read to the jury, and the prosecution presented its instructions the same day.
It returned its verdict at Beaver City on September 20, 1876. The written verdict, signed by the foreman, began: "We the jurors duly sworn and empanneled to try the case wherein John D. Lee is indicted for murder." It found him guilty of murder in the first degree. The clerk of the Second District Court filed it the same day, under the caption "The People Etc. vs. John D Lee, Impleadee." The court's charge to the jury was filed on October 6.
After the verdict the defense filed a bill of exceptions. It challenged the court's treatment of his pleas to the indictment and, above all, the judge's charge, which it said had failed to separate the law from the facts, had treated contested matters as proven and had misstated the defense. The court overruled it, and it overruled the motions in arrest of judgment and for a new trial.
On October 10, 1876, the court entered its judgment and sentence. Lee was ordered taken to a place of confinement within the territory and held there until Friday, January 26, 1877, when the sentence of death was to be carried out within the Second Judicial District.
Lee appealed on October 14, 1876, against the judgment and sentence and the orders refusing to arrest judgment or grant a new trial.
The appeal went to the Supreme Court of the Territory of Utah. On January 23, 1877, three days before the date fixed for the execution, that court modified the sentence so as to suspend its execution "until the further order of this Court." The court sat with its chief justice and two associate justices. Lee's counsel argued the appeal at the end of January, pressing a series of claimed errors in the indictment and the proceedings, and the cause was submitted at the January term of 1877 and taken under advisement.
On February 10, 1877, the court ruled. Its minute entry ordered, considered, adjudged and decreed that "all and singular the judgment and sentence of the District Court of the Second Judicial District of Utah Territory" be affirmed. It affirmed as well the district court's order denying Lee's motion "to set aside the said judgment and for a new trial." The cause was remanded with a direction to the district court to "set and fix a day" for carrying the sentence into effect.
The district court then fixed the new date. At its March term, in an order dated March 7, 1877, under the heading "Day of Executions Reappointed," it recited the appeal, the supreme court's suspension of the January date and its affirmance of the conviction. It set "the Twenty Third day of March, A.D. 1877" for the execution, within the Second Judicial District, and directed the United States marshal to hold Lee in confinement within the territory until then. The clerk certified a copy of the order for the marshal.
John D. Lee was executed at Mountain Meadows on March 23, 1877. The return on the order of execution was filed with the district court on April 24, 1877. He was the only person ever held to account in court for the killings of September 1857. Of the eight men indicted with him, the case against one was dismissed and none of the others was ever tried.
In 2007 the church issued a statement of regret for the killings.
Lee never admitted that he had killed anyone with his own hands. He denied it until his execution. The indictment on which he was convicted charged all nine men jointly, in a single count, with the deaths of a named man and fifty others.
He was the one militia member excommunicated for the killings, the one man tried and the one man executed, although official accounts place the killing in the hands of some 50 to 60 militiamen acting under local leaders. The prosecution's case in 1875 sought to tie the killings to the church's leadership in Salt Lake City; no court made such a finding.
September 12, 1812: John Doyle Lee is born in Kaskaskia, Illinois Territory.
June 17, 1838: Lee is baptized into the Latter Day Saint church.
September 1848: Lee reaches the Salt Lake Valley.
December 1850: Lee answers a call to settle southern Utah; he helps found Parowan and Harmony in Iron County.
September 4, 1857: An emigrant company from Arkansas bound for California reaches Cedar City.
September 11, 1857: About 120 of the emigrants are killed at Mountain Meadows by local militiamen and their allies.
November 20, 1857: Lee writes from Harmony to the territorial superintendent of Indian affairs.
March 8, 1859: A federal judge opens court at Provo; the grand jury returns no indictment and is discharged on March 21.
April 1859: A federal judge issues warrants for Lee and two other militia leaders; the men flee.
June 1859: The federal case is effectively dropped.
March 1864: Lee is relieved of his office as elder at Harmony.
October 1870: The church excommunicates Lee.
About 1871: Lee settles at the Colorado River crossing later known as Lees Ferry.
1874: Congress passes the Poland Act.
September 24, 1874: A grand jury of the Second District Court at Beaver indicts Lee and eight other men for murder.
October 13, 1874: A warrant is issued for Lee's arrest.
November 9, 1874: Lee is taken into custody at Panguitch.
March 2, 1875: The court summons eight prosecution witnesses to Beaver for April 12.
July 21, 1875: The court orders a corrected entry of the 1874 indictment; Lee is arraigned and pleads not guilty after his pleas to the indictment are overruled.
July 23, 1875: The first trial opens at Beaver.
August 1875: The first trial ends in a hung jury.
September 14, 1876: The second trial opens at Beaver.
September 18, 1876: The court denies a defense motion to quash the proceedings.
September 20, 1876: The jury finds Lee guilty of murder in the first degree.
October 10, 1876: Lee is sentenced to death, with the sentence set for January 26, 1877.
October 14, 1876: Lee appeals to the Supreme Court of the Territory of Utah.
January 3, 1877: A commitment order directs the marshal to hold Lee pending the sentence.
January 23, 1877: The territorial supreme court suspends the execution pending appeal.
February 10, 1877: The Supreme Court of the Territory of Utah affirms the judgment and sentence and the denial of a new trial.
March 7, 1877: The district court reappoints the day of execution for March 23.
March 23, 1877: Lee is executed at Mountain Meadows.
April 24, 1877: The return on the order of execution is filed.