On May 24, 2004, Brooke Wilberger was abducted in Corvallis, Oregon. For more than five years the state of Oregon could not tell her family with certainty what had become of her, even after a grand jury had charged a man with her murder and prosecutors had announced that they would ask for his execution. The man was Joel Patrick Courtney, then living in a suburb of Albuquerque, New Mexico. Six months after Corvallis, the police in Albuquerque arrested him for another abduction, and from that night on he was never free again.
The two cases ran side by side for years. New Mexico went first, and in September 2007 Courtney pleaded guilty there to criminal sexual penetration and kidnapping; he was sentenced to 18 years. Oregon had to wait. A Benton County grand jury had indicted him in July 2005 on 19 counts that included aggravated murder, and he was not brought north to answer them until April 2008, after he fought extradition before a judge in Santa Fe. The Oregon case never reached a jury. On September 21, 2009, in Marion County Circuit Court in Salem, Courtney pleaded guilty to aggravated murder and was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole. The plea took the death penalty off the table. In return, he gave the state the information it had been unable to find for itself in five years of trying, and her family at last had an answer.
She grew up near Eugene, Oregon, and her faith as a member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints was her own. She graduated from Elmira High School, west of Eugene, the year before she was taken. In high school she played soccer and ran track.
In the fall of 2003 she moved to Provo, Utah, for her first year of college, and there she found a tight circle of friends. One remembered her as tender-hearted and well loved; another said she could light up a room. She loved shoes. When the school year ended in April 2004, she came back to Oregon to spend the summer in Corvallis. She meant to return to Provo in the fall and share housing with the friends she had made there.
Courtney grew up in the suburbs west of Portland, in Washington County, Oregon. As an adult he moved often. He lived for stretches in Alaska, Florida and New Mexico, and he worked at various times as a fisherman, a mechanic and a janitor. In Oregon he had at one point supervised a cleaning crew for a Portland company. He settled in Rio Rancho, outside Albuquerque.
He had a criminal record before 2004. In 1991 he was convicted of sex abuse in Washington County, and he served time in jail for it.
In the spring of 2004 he was back in Oregon. He had a pending drunk-driving case in Lincoln County, on the coast, and a court date in Newport on May 24, 2004. He did not appear for it. He later told court staff in Newport that he had been in Corvallis that day.
On the day Courtney missed his court date, he was in Corvallis. Before the abduction, he approached two other young women. Both became alarmed, and both got away. Prosecutors later charged both encounters as attempted crimes, and in 2009 Courtney admitted them.
He then abducted the young woman from Elmira. The account the Benton County district attorney gave in 2009, after Courtney had admitted the crime, was that he raped her and then killed her. For more than five years her family did not know where she was.
For months the case had no suspect.
On November 29, 2004, Courtney abducted and sexually assaulted a young woman in Albuquerque. She escaped, called the police and later identified him. Albuquerque police arrested him on November 30, 2004, on kidnapping and assault charges, and he was held from then on at the Bernalillo County Metropolitan Detention Center.
The arrest in New Mexico opened the Oregon case. Background checks by the Albuquerque police showed that Courtney had been stopped in Newport, Oregon, for a traffic violation. Albuquerque officers contacted the police in Newport, who told them that Benton County, which includes Corvallis, might want to know about him. A detective on the New Mexico case then called investigators in Oregon, and they learned that the man in custody in Albuquerque had been in Corvallis on the day of the abduction.
Oregon investigators spent the first half of 2005 building a case against a man who was already in jail in another state. Witnesses placed him in Corvallis on May 24, 2004, and investigators linked him to the abduction by evidence.
In July 2005 a Benton County grand jury found enough evidence to charge Courtney even though she had never been found, and it returned an indictment on 19 counts, including aggravated murder, kidnapping, rape, sodomy and sexual abuse. Courtney was 39. Because the New Mexico case would be tried first, Oregon could not expect to have him in its own courts for some time.
In May 2007 a Benton County grand jury returned a second indictment, this one covering the two young women who had escaped him in Corvallis. It charged him with attempted murder, attempted kidnapping and attempted sex crimes. Courtney was arrested on the new charges in the Albuquerque jail where he had then been held for more than two years. By then the Benton County district attorney had decided that Oregon would seek a death sentence.
In September 2007, at 41, Courtney accepted a plea agreement in state district court in Albuquerque and pleaded guilty to one count of criminal sexual penetration and one count of kidnapping, both arising from November 29, 2004. The agreement called for up to 18 years in prison, followed by five to 20 years of parole, and it required him to register as a sex offender.
On December 11, 2007, the court sentenced him to the full 18 years, and Oregon began the extradition process at once.
In January 2008 Oregon's governor, Ted Kulongoski, signed an order asking New Mexico to send Courtney back to face the Oregon charges. New Mexico's governor, Bill Richardson, signed the agreement to return him later that month. Courtney contested it.
The challenge was heard in state district court in Santa Fe, where Courtney was then held in state custody. On April 4, 2008, a state district judge ordered him extradited to Oregon forthwith, and he was brought north early that month.
For the next year and a half the case moved toward trial, with prosecutors still seeking death. In June 2009 the defense asked for the trial to be held outside Benton County. The trial was expected in 2010. It never took place.
The end came within days. In the week before the plea, Courtney's lawyers contacted the prosecutors, and over the following weekend Courtney gave Oregon investigators the information they had been seeking since May 2004.
On Monday, September 21, 2009, Courtney, then 43, pleaded guilty to aggravated murder in Marion County Circuit Court in Salem. He was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole, and the plea removed any possibility of a death sentence. Under the agreement, he would first be returned to New Mexico to serve out the 18-year sentence imposed there, and only then pass into Oregon custody for the rest of his life. He had admitted the crime to investigators. After the plea, the Benton County district attorney set out in public, for the first time, the state's account of May 24, 2004, including Courtney's approaches to the two other young women that day.
After the plea, Courtney was returned to New Mexico and processed back into that state's corrections system. As of September 2009 he was in state custody in New Mexico serving the remainder of his 18-year sentence, with the Oregon sentence of life without the possibility of parole to follow.
Courtney was indicted on 19 counts in the Oregon case, including rape, sodomy and sexual abuse, but the conviction that stands is the single count of aggravated murder to which he pleaded guilty. The details of what happened after the abduction come from the prosecutor's account at the plea, which rested on Courtney's admissions to investigators; they were never tested at trial. The same holds for the May 2007 indictment covering the two women who escaped him in Corvallis: Courtney admitted approaching them, but no trial was held on those counts.
1991: Convicted of sex abuse in Washington County, Oregon; serves time in jail.
May 24, 2004: Misses a court date in Newport, Oregon; approaches two young women in Corvallis, who escape, and abducts the young woman from Elmira.
November 29, 2004: Abducts and sexually assaults a young woman in Albuquerque, New Mexico; she escapes.
November 30, 2004: Arrested in Albuquerque.
July 2005: A Benton County grand jury indicts him on 19 counts, including aggravated murder.
May 2007: Second Benton County indictment, covering the two women in Corvallis.
September 2007: Pleads guilty in Albuquerque to criminal sexual penetration and kidnapping.
December 11, 2007: Sentenced in New Mexico to 18 years.
January 2008: The governors of Oregon and New Mexico sign extradition papers.
April 4, 2008: A state district judge in Santa Fe orders him extradited to Oregon.
June 2009: Defense asks for the trial to be moved out of Benton County.
September 21, 2009: Pleads guilty to aggravated murder in Marion County Circuit Court, Salem; sentenced to life without the possibility of parole; returned to New Mexico to serve the 18-year term first.