Joel Cacace

Victims
1 judge murdered in New York City, 1987; racketeering plea. Pleaded guilty in 2004 to racketeering on that murder and a plot to kill the judge's son. Acquitted in 2013 of a 1997 killing.
Years active
March 20, 1987 (predicate murder); August 25, 1997 (killing he was acquitted of ordering)
Location
New York City; Brooklyn
Method
Racketeering, with murder and conspiracy to murder as predicate acts
Status
240 months' imprisonment and five years' supervised release; released May 22, 2020

Joel Cacace rose through the Colombo crime family of New York to sit in its ruling administration, first as acting boss and later as consigliere, the family's third-ranking post. In August 2004 he pleaded guilty in federal court in Brooklyn to racketeering. The conviction rested on two predicate acts from 1987: a conspiracy to murder a former state and federal prosecutor, and the murder of that man's father, George Aronwald, a judge in New York City who was killed in his son's place. Cacace was sentenced to 240 months in federal custody, to be followed by five years of supervised release.

While he was serving that term, prosecutors charged him in a second killing, the 1997 death of Ralph Dols, an off-duty New York City police officer. On November 26, 2013, a federal jury in Brooklyn acquitted him. He left federal custody on May 22, 2020.

At the time of the 1987 killing he was a soldier in the family, acting, prosecutors said, on orders handed down from its boss. By 2004 he was described as the family's acting boss. In the 2013 case the court recorded that he held the post of consigliere, or counselor, which made him the third-highest-ranking member of the family and part of its ruling administration.

His standing in the family was never a side issue in court. It was the ground on which the government built its second case against him, and it was the reason the court later gave for shielding the identities of the jurors who would decide it.

The case that sent Cacace to federal custody began with an order passed down inside the family. The presentence report prepared in his racketeering case, as the federal court later summarized it, stated that in 1987 Cacace accepted orders to murder two former prosecutors. One of the two had served as both a state and a federal prosecutor and practiced law in New York.

He shared his law office with his father, the judge, and it was the judge who was killed, on March 20, 1987.

Federal prosecutors in the Eastern District of New York brought the racketeering case against Cacace and a group of co-defendants. The central charge against him was federal racketeering.

His conviction rested on two predicate acts. The first was his participation in the conspiracy to murder the former prosecutor. The second was the murder of the judge. No other killing became part of the judgment.

Cacace pleaded guilty in August 2004. The racketeering plea tied him directly to the 1987 killing, and it exposed him to up to 20 years in prison.

The sentence reached that limit. The court imposed 240 months of imprisonment, to be followed by a five-year term of supervised release. He served that term in federal custody until 2020.

The plea ended the racketeering case without a trial.

In December 2008, with Cacace already in federal custody, prosecutors in Brooklyn added him to a wide case against members of the Colombo family. A superseding indictment charged him in the death of the off-duty officer, who was killed in Brooklyn on August 25, 1997.

The charges were rebuilt more than once as cooperating witnesses came forward. A superseding indictment returned in July 2010 kept Cacace in an eight-count case beside the family's former street boss and a soldier. In July 2011 the grand jury returned the seventh superseding indictment, which concerned Cacace alone, and from that point his case moved separately from theirs. Against Cacace it carried a single count: murder in aid of racketeering, alleged to have been committed in connection with his leadership of the Colombo family.

The government at one point sought the death penalty against him. It did not pursue a death sentence at trial, and Cacace went before the jury facing the murder count while still serving the twenty-year term from 2004.

Two of the men charged with Cacace in the 1997 killing, the family's former street boss and a soldier, were tried first, in 2012, before a separate federal jury in Brooklyn. Their trial began on March 19, 2012, ran for several weeks and heard dozens of witnesses, several of them government cooperators. On May 9, 2012, the jury convicted both men of racketeering conspiracy on other predicate acts but did not convict either man of the officer's murder. Cacace's own trial on the same count came the following year.

On September 6, 2013, the district judge granted the government's motion for an anonymous and partially sequestered jury, citing among other things his 2004 conviction and his rank in the family, and allowed a detailed jury questionnaire.

On November 26, 2013, the federal jury in Brooklyn acquitted Cacace of murder in aid of racketeering in the 1997 killing. The verdict left the 2004 racketeering conviction as the only judgment against him in any killing, and he remained in federal custody on that sentence. Murder in aid of racketeering had been the sole crime charged against him in that case, so the verdict ended it.

He completed the 2004 sentence in federal custody and was released from federal custody on May 22, 2020.

The 1997 killing is not part of any conviction against Cacace. A federal jury acquitted him of murder in aid of racketeering in that death.

The presentence report in the 2004 racketeering case alleged further killings. None of them formed part of the racketeering conviction, which rested only on the conspiracy against the former prosecutor and the murder of the judge. When the government raised those allegations in 2013, the federal court declined to decide whether it could properly consider them, finding the request for an anonymous jury justified without them.

Timeline

1987: Cacace takes part in a conspiracy to murder a former state and federal prosecutor.

March 20, 1987: A judge is killed in New York City in place of his son, a former prosecutor; the killing becomes a predicate act of Cacace's racketeering conviction.

August 25, 1997: An off-duty New York City police officer is killed in Brooklyn; Cacace is later charged with ordering the killing and acquitted.

August 2004: Cacace, described as the Colombo family's acting boss, pleads guilty to racketeering in federal court in Brooklyn.

2004: He is sentenced to 240 months' imprisonment and five years of supervised release.

December 2008: A superseding indictment in the Colombo case charges him with murder in aid of racketeering in the 1997 killing.

July 2011: The seventh superseding indictment, concerning Cacace alone, separates his case from his co-defendants'.

March 19 to May 9, 2012: Two co-defendants are tried first; their jury convicts both of racketeering conspiracy but does not convict either of the 1997 killing.

September 6, 2013: The district court grants an anonymous and partially sequestered jury and allows a jury questionnaire.

November 26, 2013: A federal jury in Brooklyn acquits Cacace of murder in aid of racketeering.

May 22, 2020: Cacace is released from federal custody.