On April 22, 1987, a jury in Santa Monica convicted Joe Hunt of the first-degree murder and robbery of Ron Levin and found true the special circumstance that the killing took place during a robbery. Hunt was 27. The state had charged that he killed his victim in Beverly Hills in June 1984, and the special-circumstance finding made him eligible for death. The same jury chose life in prison without the possibility of parole instead, and Hunt has maintained from the day of the verdict that he is innocent.
A second prosecution followed in San Mateo County, where Hunt was charged with murder and kidnapping in a July 1984 death in Belmont. That trial ended in December 1992 with the jury deadlocked 8 to 4 in favor of acquittal. The prosecution chose not to try him again, and the case was dismissed. The Santa Monica conviction, meanwhile, has survived every challenge he has brought in the state and federal courts.
Hunt was born Joseph Henry Gamsky and grew up in Los Angeles. The Beverly Hills police investigated the June 1984 case, and the state's main witness was a former associate of Hunt's who testified under a grant of immunity. Hunt and a second man, described at trial as his bodyguard, were charged with the murder in Los Angeles County.
Hunt was free on $2 million bail when his trial began in Los Angeles County Superior Court in Santa Monica. It lasted about two months. The prosecution set the date of the killing at June 6, 1984; the defense answered that the man was still alive. The jury rejected that defense and returned its verdict in April.
The penalty phase began in May 1987, and the prosecution asked for death. On June 4, 1987, the jury rejected the death penalty and chose life without the possibility of parole, and on July 6 the trial judge imposed that sentence. The man charged with Hunt was tried separately in Santa Monica; after two juries deadlocked, he pleaded guilty under a plea bargain on December 1, 1987.
In San Mateo County, Hunt and three other men were charged with kidnapping and murder in the July 30, 1984, death of Hedayat Eslaminia of Belmont. Two of them, the dead man's son and another associate, were tried first and convicted in early 1988. Both convictions were overturned by the Ninth Circuit in 1998. The son's charges were dismissed in 1999, and the other man later pleaded guilty to reduced charges.
Hunt was brought to San Mateo County in 1988 and within months chose to represent himself. The state never sought his death in that case and filed no special-circumstance allegation with the murder charge. His trial began in Redwood City in April 1992. In December the jury announced that it was hopelessly deadlocked, 8 to 4 in favor of acquittal. The prosecution elected not to retry him, the presiding judge dismissed the case, and no court has ever made a finding against him in that death.
The fight over the Santa Monica conviction went on far longer. The California Court of Appeal rejected each of his claims on the merits, and on August 9, 2000, the California Supreme Court denied a further habeas corpus petition. By then Hunt had already carried the case into federal court on his own, without a lawyer, filing an amended petition in the Central District of California in August 1998. The district court ruled that every claim had to have been exhausted in the state courts on the day the petition was filed, and in August 2001 it dismissed the case with prejudice.
On June 5, 2003, in Hunt v. Pliler, the Ninth Circuit vacated that judgment. It held that the district court had been wrong to refuse to count claims exhausted after filing, that it had abused its discretion in dismissing the case for failure to prosecute while Hunt's objections were still pending, and that he had to be told he could drop his unexhausted claims and ask for the rest of the petition to be held while he returned to the state courts. The case went back to the district court for further proceedings.
It stayed there for more than a decade, and when it returned to the Ninth Circuit the result went the other way. On June 10, 2016, in Hunt v. Virga, a three-judge panel affirmed the district court's judgment in an unpublished memorandum. The California Supreme Court's 2000 denial, the panel held, had simply refused to decide again claims that were already decided, so the federal courts had to defer to the Court of Appeal's rulings unless they were contrary to, or an unreasonable application of, clearly established Supreme Court law. They were not. The state court had been entitled to judge Hunt's claim that his trial lawyer labored under a personal conflict of interest by the ordinary standard for ineffective assistance, because the Supreme Court had never clearly extended its stricter conflict rule beyond lawyers who represent more than one defendant. On his remaining claims that his trial lawyer had failed him, the panel found that fair-minded jurists could disagree about whether the lawyer's work fell short, and that Hunt had not shown the prejudice the law requires, given the state courts' factual finding that the victim was dead and that Hunt had killed him. It declined to consider declarations from jurors that Hunt had offered.
In January 2018, the Associated Press reported, Hunt applied to Governor Jerry Brown to commute his sentence or make him eligible for parole. As of October 2018 he had served 34 years and was held in a California state prison, serving life without the possibility of parole.
Hunt has always denied the Beverly Hills killing. At trial, and again in an interview in October 2018, he maintained that the man had staged his own disappearance to escape a pending criminal case. The Santa Monica jury rejected that defense, and the conviction has withstood every state and federal challenge he has brought.
The Belmont death remains legally unresolved as to Hunt. He testified at his 1992 trial that there had been no kidnapping, and the jury divided 8 to 4 for acquittal. With no verdict and no retrial, the case against him was dismissed, and it stands as a charge that was never proved.
June 6, 1984: The date the prosecution gives for the Beverly Hills killing.
July 30, 1984: The date of the Belmont death later charged against Hunt and three other men.
April 22, 1987: A Santa Monica jury convicts Hunt of first-degree murder and robbery and finds the robbery special circumstance true.
June 4, 1987: The jury rejects the death penalty and chooses life without parole.
July 6, 1987: The trial judge sentences Hunt to life without the possibility of parole.
December 1, 1987: The man charged with Hunt in Los Angeles County pleads guilty under a plea bargain.
Early 1988: Two other men are convicted in the Belmont death.
1988: Hunt's San Mateo County case begins; within months he represents himself.
April 1992: Hunt's San Mateo County trial opens in Redwood City.
December 1992: The jury deadlocks 8 to 4 for acquittal; the prosecution declines to retry and the case is dismissed.
February 18, 1998: The Ninth Circuit overturns the Belmont conviction of the victim's son and orders a new trial; the other associate's conviction also falls that year.
August 1998: Hunt, without a lawyer, files an amended federal habeas petition in the Central District of California.
August 9, 2000: The California Supreme Court denies his state habeas petition.
August 2001: The district court dismisses his federal petition with prejudice.
June 5, 2003: The Ninth Circuit vacates the dismissal of his federal petition in Hunt v. Pliler.
June 10, 2016: The Ninth Circuit affirms the district court's judgment against him in Hunt v. Virga.
January 2018: Hunt applies to Governor Jerry Brown for commutation.
October 2018: Hunt remains in a California state prison serving life without parole.