Joe Brady

Victims
2 officials killed, Dublin, May 6, 1882; Brady convicted of murder at the Dublin Special Commission, April 1883.
Years active
May 6, 1882
Location
Dublin, Ireland (killings; hearings; trial; execution).
Method
Stabbed (both victims).
Status
Found guilty and sentenced to death, April 1883; no appeal on record. Executed in Dublin, Ireland, May 14, 1883.

On the evening of Saturday, May 6, 1882, the two most senior figures in the British administration of Ireland were killed together in Dublin. One was Lord Frederick Cavendish, the new Chief Secretary for Ireland, who had just arrived in the city to take up his post. The other was Thomas Henry Burke, the Under-Secretary, the most senior permanent civil servant in the country. The killings were the work of the Irish National Invincibles, a small secret society that had broken away from the Irish Republican Brotherhood. Joseph Brady, a 26-year-old Dublin stonecutter known as Joe, was one of the leading Dublin men who had helped to form it.

Brady was taken into custody in a round-up of suspected Invincibles in January 1883, charged with the others at Kilmainham in February, and brought to trial for murder before the Dublin Special Commission in April. The Crown built its case on the evidence of men who had been inside the society and agreed to testify against their former comrades, the most important of them James Carey, a former leader of the Invincibles. The jury found Brady guilty, and he was sentenced to death. He was executed in Dublin on May 14, 1883, the first of five Invincibles to die for the killings.

The Invincibles were founded in Dublin in 1881 as a splinter of the Irish Republican Brotherhood, the older Fenian organization. Historians of the society describe its aim as the overthrow of British rule in Ireland through assassination. Some of the leading Dublin Fenians formed its core. Daniel Curley was among them, and so were Brady and Carey.

Of Brady's own life before 1882, only the outline survives. He worked in Dublin as a stonecutter and lived on the north side of the city.

The spring of 1882 shifted the political ground under the society. The government had spent the Land League period arresting large numbers of "suspects," among them Charles Stewart Parnell and other Irish members of Parliament. That spring those men were released, in the arrangement remembered as the Kilmainham Treaty, and the Chief Secretary, William Forster, was replaced. The Prime Minister, W. E. Gladstone, had turned toward a policy of conciliation, and to carry it into Dublin he chose a protégé of his own, a man known to favour that course. The Under-Secretary who would serve beside him had worked in the Irish administration for years and had risen to the head of its permanent civil service.

The Under-Secretary, not the Chief Secretary, was the man the Invincibles meant to kill. Seven members of the society took part that evening, and both men died. Historians of the case have concluded that the Chief Secretary was killed because he was with the Under-Secretary, and that the men who killed him probably did not know who he was. The deaths caused outrage in Britain.

The government answered with the Prevention of Crime (Ireland) Act of 1882, and the new law gave the authorities a power they had not had before. Under its sixteenth section, a magistrate could hold a private inquiry into a crime and summon witnesses to be examined. In Dublin those examinations were conducted by a police magistrate at Dublin Castle. The men responsible stayed free for the rest of 1882, but it was under that questioning that a young Fenian eventually gave the authorities the information that opened the society to them.

The break came in January 1883. On the night of January 12, the police arrested seventeen men in Dublin, and nine more were brought in over the following days. By the end of the month many of the leading Invincibles, Brady among them, were in custody. On February 3, Brady, Carey and six others were formally charged with the murders before the magistrates at Kilmainham.

Then the prisoners began to break. Three of the men in custody agreed to become informers. The most important was Carey himself, a leading member of the Brotherhood and of the Invincibles, who turned State's evidence to save himself. On February 17, two weeks after he had been charged beside them, he gave evidence for the Crown against the men in the dock.

Brady's trial came before the Dublin Special Commission in April 1883, and the Crown's evidence came largely from the informers, Carey above all. The jury found Joseph Brady guilty of murder, and he was sentenced to death. He was the first of five Invincibles condemned on the informers' evidence. Curley, Michael Fagan, Thomas Caffrey and Timothy Kelly followed him through the Commission over the next weeks. Others received sentences of penal servitude, among them James Fitzharris, who was convicted of aiding and abetting and sentenced to penal servitude for life.

Joe Brady was executed in Dublin on May 14, 1883. Curley, Fagan, Caffrey and Kelly were executed in the same city over the following weeks, the last of them in June. Carey, the chief informer, was himself killed at sea in July 1883 on his way to the Cape Colony.

The prosecution of the Invincibles rested heavily on informers, men who had been inside the society and gave evidence to escape the charges they faced. Carey's evidence was attacked in Parliament almost as soon as it was given. Those attacks concerned what he said about people outside the society, Parnell and the Land League among them, rather than his account of the men in the dock, and the jury at Brady's trial accepted his evidence.

Two questions about the fairness of Brady's own prosecution were raised in the House of Commons and never tested in any court. While the trial was running, Irish members asked whether defense witnesses had been examined in private under section 16 of the Crimes Act; the government answered that one such witness had been examined, in March, long before the defense named its witnesses on April 7, and that the Crown had made no further approach to any of them. After the verdict, a member asked whether a juror at Brady's trial was in fact a messenger employed by the Board of Works in Dublin, and the government said only that he was a qualified juryman.

Timeline

1881: The Irish National Invincibles are founded in Dublin as a splinter of the Irish Republican Brotherhood; Brady is among the Dublin men who form the society.

May 6, 1882: The Chief Secretary for Ireland and the Under-Secretary are killed in Dublin.

1882: The Prevention of Crime (Ireland) Act is passed.

January 12, 1883: Seventeen men are arrested in Dublin; nine more follow over the next days.

February 3, 1883: Brady, Carey and six others are charged at Kilmainham, Dublin.

February 17, 1883: Carey gives evidence for the Crown against his former comrades.

April 1883: Brady is tried at the Dublin Special Commission, found guilty of murder and sentenced to death.

May 14, 1883: Brady is executed in Dublin, the first of five Invincibles.

June 1883: The last of the five is executed in Dublin.

July 1883: The chief informer is killed at sea.