Jodi Arias

Victims
1 murder, Travis Alexander, Mesa, Arizona, 2008. Convicted May 8, 2013, in Maricopa County Superior Court, of premeditated first-degree murder.
Years active
Offense June 4, 2008; indicted July 9, 2008; arrested July 15, 2008; arraigned September 11, 2008; trial opened January 2, 2013; verdict May 8, 2013; sentenced April 13, 2015
Location
Mesa, Arizona
Method
First-degree murder (premeditated); the State also charged first-degree felony murder in the alternative
Status
"Prison for her natural life" (April 13, 2015), after two juries could not agree on a penalty; affirmed by the Arizona Court of Appeals, March 24, 2020; review declined, 2020.

Jodi Arias was convicted in May 2013 by a jury in Maricopa County Superior Court of first-degree murder. The man she was convicted of killing was her former boyfriend, Travis Alexander, who was 30 and lived in Mesa, Arizona. He died on June 4, 2008. She pleaded not guilty and claimed self-defense at trial.

The prosecution sought the death penalty. A first jury found her guilty but could not agree on the penalty, and a second jury, selected in 2014 for the penalty phase alone, also could not agree. Under Arizona law that left the sentence to the judge. On April 13, 2015, the judge sentenced her to prison for her natural life. The Arizona Court of Appeals affirmed the conviction and sentence in March 2020, and the Arizona Supreme Court declined to review the case that November.

A grand jury in Maricopa County indicted Arias on first-degree murder on July 9, 2008, five weeks after his death in Mesa. She was arrested on July 15, 2008. At her arraignment on September 11, 2008, she pleaded not guilty. On October 31, 2008, prosecutors filed notice that they would seek the death penalty.

The State charged her with first-degree premeditated murder and, in the alternative, first-degree felony murder.

Jury selection began in December 2012, and opening statements followed on January 2, 2013. The trial ran for 67 days. Arias took the stand in her own defense from February 4, 2013. Her defense was self-defense. The judge closed the courtroom for part of her testimony; the closure later drew a challenge from news organizations and an appeals court set it aside.

Closing arguments were heard on May 2 and 3, 2013. On May 8, 2013, the jury unanimously found Arias guilty of first-degree murder. The Court of Appeals later described it as a unanimous finding of guilt of premeditated first-degree murder.

Under Arizona's capital sentencing procedure the trial moves in stages after a murder conviction. On May 15, 2013, the jury found aggravating factors that made Arias eligible for the death penalty. The jury then heard the penalty phase and deliberated from May 21. On May 23, 2013, the jurors told the judge they could not reach a unanimous decision between death and life in prison, and the judge declared a mistrial of the penalty phase. The conviction stood. A new jury was to decide the sentence.

Arizona's capital sentencing statute provides that if a penalty-phase jury cannot reach a verdict, the court dismisses it and impanels a new jury, and that if the new jury is also unable to reach a unanimous verdict, the court imposes a sentence of life or natural life.

The retrial of the penalty phase was delayed beyond the July 2013 date first set. A second jury was seated in October 2014. In January 2015 the Arizona Supreme Court refused to pause the retrial while Arias appealed a ruling on public access to her earlier closed-door testimony, and the proceedings continued.

On March 5, 2015, after five days of deliberation, the second jury could not agree on death or life in prison and the judge declared a mistrial. Eleven jurors favored death and one did not. Because two juries had now deadlocked, death was no longer an option. The judge could impose either life in prison or life with the possibility of release after 25 years.

Sentencing took place on April 13, 2015. Arias, then 34, told the court she was "truly disgusted and repulsed" with herself. The judge declined to make her eligible for release after 25 years and sentenced her to life in prison with no possibility of release. The Court of Appeals recorded the sentence in its opinion as one to "prison for her natural life." She was sent to an Arizona state women's prison.

Arias appealed her conviction and sentence to Division One of the Arizona Court of Appeals. The case was number 1 CA-CR 15-0302. Her brief argued that trial publicity and prosecutorial misconduct had deprived her of a fair trial. In January 2019 the Arizona Attorney General's Office answered that the prosecutor's conduct, which it acknowledged had at times been argumentative with witnesses, had not prejudiced the jury in light of the court's curative actions.

The court issued two decisions on March 24, 2020. In a published opinion it began: "Jodi Arias appeals her conviction and sentence for premeditated first-degree murder. She asserts that trial publicity and prosecutorial misconduct deprived her of a fair trial. For the following reasons, we affirm." On publicity it held, "we do not presume prejudice from the trial publicity." On the prosecutor it wrote, "It is plain to us that the prosecutor in this case lost sight of his ethical duties," and it described his conduct in strong terms, but it concluded that the misconduct did not affect a verdict resting on overwhelming evidence of her guilt. The final paragraph of the opinion reads: "For these reasons, we affirm." A separate memorandum decision, filed the same day under the same case number, rejected her remaining arguments.

Arias petitioned the Arizona Supreme Court for review. On November 3, 2020, the court declined to review the case and gave no reasons. The conviction and the natural life sentence stood.

Arizona allows a convicted person, after the direct appeal ends, to seek post-conviction relief in the trial court. Arias filed her notice seeking that relief in February 2021, and an attorney was appointed to represent her in the proceeding that month. The deadline for filing the petition was originally April 2021 and has been extended repeatedly. At a hearing on August 28, 2026, the Maricopa County Superior Court judge extended it again, to January 29, 2027, from a previous deadline of September 2, 2026, and granted a defense request to seal the proceeding. As of that date no petition had been filed.

Arizona divides a death-penalty trial into a guilt phase, an aggravation phase and a penalty phase. When the first penalty-phase jury deadlocks, the statute requires a new jury. When the second also deadlocks, the court imposes a sentence of life or natural life; in 2015 the choice before the judge was life with the possibility of release after 25 years or life without release. Arias's case followed that path exactly: a deadlock in May 2013, a second deadlock in March 2015, and a judge's choice in April 2015 of the harsher of the two non-capital sentences.

Arias maintained at trial that she acted in self-defense; the jury rejected that and found premeditated first-degree murder. On appeal she argued that publicity and the prosecutor's conduct had denied her a fair trial, and the Court of Appeals found the prosecutor's conduct improper but held that it did not change the outcome. No post-conviction petition has been filed, and the proceeding is sealed.

Timeline

June 4, 2008: Her former boyfriend, aged 30, dies in Mesa, Arizona.

July 9, 2008: A grand jury indicts Jodi Arias on first-degree murder.

July 15, 2008: Arias is arrested.

September 11, 2008: Arraignment; she pleads not guilty.

October 31, 2008: The State files notice of intent to seek the death penalty.

January 2, 2013: Opening statements in the trial.

February 4, 2013: Arias begins testifying in her own defense.

May 8, 2013: The jury finds her guilty of first-degree murder.

May 15, 2013: The jury finds aggravating factors.

May 23, 2013: The jury cannot agree on a sentence; the judge declares a mistrial of the penalty phase.

October 2014: A second jury is seated for the penalty phase.

March 5, 2015: The second jury deadlocks; mistrial; death is no longer an option.

April 13, 2015: Sentenced to life in prison with no possibility of release ("prison for her natural life").

March 24, 2020: The Arizona Court of Appeals affirms the conviction and sentence.

November 3, 2020: The Arizona Supreme Court declines review.

February 2021: Notice of post-conviction relief filed; counsel appointed.

August 28, 2026: The deadline to file the post-conviction petition is extended to January 29, 2027.