Joaquin Murrieta came north from Sonora in the California gold rush and, by the spring of 1853, was the man most often blamed for the robberies and killings that had spread through the mining counties of the Sierra foothills. He was never charged with murder in any court, never tried and never convicted. On May 17, 1853, the California Legislature passed an act that named him, with four other men called Joaquin, as the quarry of a company of mounted state rangers. On July 25, 1853, that company killed a man it identified as Murrieta at Arroyo de Cantua, in the foothills of what is now Fresno County. Whether the dead man was Murrieta was argued in the newspapers within weeks, and the question has never been closed beyond dispute.
The record and the legend part company early. The record holds a suspect's arrest in Calaveras County in April 1852, a run of killings and robberies charged to a band led by a man called Joaquin through 1852 and the first months of 1853, a state reward, a statute, a three-month ranger company, a contested identification and two state payments to the men who claimed the kill. The legend, which began with a short novel published in San Francisco in 1854, supplied the honest miner driven from his claim, the brother lynched, the young wife assaulted and the avenger's vow. Court files and the newspapers of the time show none of those wrongs.
Church records place the birth of a Joaquin Murrieta in southern Sonora in 1830; Hermosillo has also been named as his birthplace. He sometimes went by Joaquin Carrillo, and the habit later fed the belief that several different Joaquins were at work in the gold country at once.
In 1848, at about 18, Murrieta went north to the gold fields in company that included three brothers of the Feliz family, his wife's brothers. He worked a claim near the town of Sonora, in Tuolumne County, and in about April 1850 two other miners drove him off a second claim. He moved west to Niles Canyon, then part of Contra Costa County, and in 1850 worked as a vaquero near Oakley and Brentwood and as a mestenero, a catcher of wild mustangs.
Claudio Feliz, one of those brothers, turned to crime first. By late 1850 he led a band that raided ranches in the East Bay and around San Jose, and it was blamed for several deaths that year, all of them before Murrieta joined it and none of them laid to him.
In 1851 Murrieta and Reyes Feliz, another of the brothers, joined Claudio. The band robbed travelers on the roads, and its victims that year included Chinese miners, Anglo-Americans and one Black man. Claudio was killed later in 1851, and Murrieta took over what remained of his men.
The first public record to name Murrieta as a thief came from another man's confession. Teodor Basques was arrested in San Jose in November 1851 and was put to death in January 1852. His confession, printed in February 1852, named Murrieta among the men who had stolen horses and mules with him.
On April 4, 1852, bandits killed James Clark, a member of a posse, at Willow Springs, also called Waites Station. On April 19, 1852, Murrieta was arrested at Jackson, in Calaveras County, as a suspect in that death. He was not brought to trial; he got clear of Jackson and of the threat of a lynching. The same year the band was blamed for the death of Allen Ruddle.
Through the rest of 1852 the band moved between the valley and the south, trading in stolen horses, and by the autumn Murrieta was in Los Angeles County.
In early November 1852 Joshua Bean, a major general of the state militia, was killed near Mission San Gabriel. Vigilantes in Los Angeles arrested Reyes Feliz and several members of another band, and Reyes Feliz was put to death for the murder. Murrieta was implicated in the same killing, but no court ever examined that charge against him. He left Reyes Feliz to his fate and rode north to the Mother Lode.
By mid-December 1852 they were in Calaveras County again, where the band was blamed for the robbery of four businesses in Jackson and for the killing of Edward Cameron near San Andreas.
The worst of the violence charged to Murrieta came in January and February 1853, when the band was blamed for the deaths of 22 men in two months, most of them Chinese miners. In January Chinese miners were robbed near Jackson, and on January 21 the band skirmished with a posse led by the Calaveras County sheriff; no member of the posse died. Late in January John Carter was killed at Yaqui Camp, and two Americans died in a fight at the Phoenix Quartz Mill, deaths also charged to the band. On February 4 the band was said to have robbed the ferry at Winters Bar and Chinese miners near Drytown, and later that month an American and three Chinese men were killed near Jackson.
The mining towns organized against the band. Residents of Mokelumne Hill petitioned the governor and took up a collection to pay a six-man posse. In response to the petition the governor offered a reward of $1,000 for "Joaquin Carillo," the alias that a San Francisco paper had connected to Murrieta. A printed handbill offered $5,000 in the name of Chinese businessmen.
In March 1853 the band left the foothills for the remote country of the San Joaquin Valley. On April 13 Murrieta called openly at a ranch near Salinas, in mid-June the band was in Los Angeles, and late in June it took horses from the ranch of General Andres Pico.
The legislative answer began in Mariposa County, where citizens petitioned in March 1853 for a company of state rangers. Members of the Legislature at first held the bill back, doubting that anyone knew precisely which man was wanted, and an amended version passed in May. The act is dated May 17, 1853.
It did not create a police force. It authorized a single named captain to raise a company of mounted rangers "not to exceed twenty men," for three months unless the governor disbanded them sooner, to capture five men named in it, Joaquin Murrieta, Joaquin Ocomorenia, Joaquin Valenzuela, Joaquin Botellier and Joaquin Carrillo, and their associates. Each ranger was paid $150 a month. The fourth section bound the company to hand every prisoner to the authorities of the proper county for trial. None of the act's sections found any of the five men guilty of anything, and the statute itself assumed that the men it caught would face a court.
The company was mustered in at Quartzburg, in Mariposa County, on May 28, 1853, and at first searched without finding either Joaquin. On July 12, 1853, they captured Jesus Feliz, the youngest of the Feliz brothers, who offered to lead them to Murrieta.
On July 25, 1853, the rangers came on a camp of Mexican vaqueros near Cantua Creek, on the edge of the Coast Range near Panoche Pass. In the fight that followed the company killed a man that one of the rangers recognized as Murrieta, and a second man they identified as Manuel Garcia, Murrieta's lieutenant. Three of the party got away and two were taken prisoner.
One of the two prisoners died before reaching any court. The other gave his name as Jose Maria Ochoa and was later identified as Salvador Mendez. He was turned over to county authorities, and at a hearing before a Mariposa County court he swore that the dead leader was Murrieta. He was later put to death.
The rangers set out at once to prove whom they had killed. At Quartzburg witnesses swore affidavits identifying Murrieta, and in Stockton, where the company arrived on August 12, 1853, it collected several more, from a doctor who had seen Murrieta in Calaveras County, from a priest and from Sonorans who had known him for years. Mexican and Chinese witnesses gave statements, and Andres Pico, whose horses the band had taken, also identified Murrieta. The rangers carried their proof on through the mining towns through August and September.
Doubt arrived as fast as the proof. On July 28 the company's lieutenant wrote that the Joaquin killed at Cantua was Valenzuela, and he never corrected the statement in print. On August 23 a San Francisco editorial argued that Murrieta might be a myth or a composite, complaining that "every murder and robbery in the country" had been put down to Joaquin, and the same paper printed a claim that the dead man was Valenzuela. Voices in San Diego insisted that Joaquin had crossed into Baja California, and the governor's race of 1853 drew the company into its quarrels.
The company's time ran out at the end of August. The captain received the $1,000 reward originally offered for "Joaquin Carrillo," paid by warrant of the state comptroller on August 29, 1853, and the governor mustered the company out; the muster roll gives August 28 and the Legislature's disbanding is dated August 30. In San Francisco the Chinese community raised $1,000 and gave it to the captain. On May 28, 1854, the Legislature voted the rangers an additional $5,000.
Murrieta's legal position at his death was the same as on the day the act passed: a suspect in the killings of the previous year and a half, wanted under a reward and a statute, but never charged, indicted or tried for any of them.
The identity of the man killed at Arroyo de Cantua is the central dispute. The rangers' affidavits, the identification by one of their own men who knew Murrieta, the statement of the surviving prisoner and the identification by Andres Pico all named the dead leader as Murrieta, and in the mining towns there was near universal agreement that it was him. Against that stand the lieutenant's first report naming Valenzuela, the newspaper doubts of August 1853, and the political quarrels that surrounded the company. Stories that Murrieta escaped and lived out his life on a ranch in Mexico, or came back to Niles Canyon mortally wounded, have never been confirmed.
The count of his victims is not settled. The figure of 22 men in January and February 1853 covers the band, not Murrieta alone, and the legend's claim of more than nineteen men killed and $100,000 in gold taken rests on no court record. No killing was ever proved against him in any court.
The motive the legend gave him is unsupported. Court records and the newspapers of the time show no whipping of Murrieta, no assault on his wife and no lost claim of the kind described in the novel, and the brother the legend has lynched was alive in Mexico in the 1860s. Historians of the case trace his turn to crime instead to greed and to Claudio Feliz's lead.
The rewards are disputed as well. The governor's $1,000 reward, issued for "Joaquin Carillo" and paid to the captain in August 1853, is in the state's records, but the larger figures attached to the story, among them a $5,000 state reward "dead or alive" and a county reward of the same size, are additions from the legend and from a later stage play. No state or county ever offered those larger sums.
The legend has a clear origin. John Rollin Ridge, a Cherokee writer who used the name Yellow Bird, published The Life and Adventures of Joaquin Murieta, the Celebrated California Bandit in 1854, giving Murrieta a band of more than 2,000 men, a murdered bride and a crusade against the men who had wronged him. The Murrieta of later poems, dime novels and films grew from that book, not from the record.
1830: A Joaquin Murrieta is born in southern Sonora, Mexico.
1848: News of the gold strike reaches Sonora; Murrieta, about 18, goes north with relatives.
1850: Murrieta is driven off a mining claim and works as a vaquero near Oakley and Brentwood.
1851: Murrieta and Reyes Feliz join Claudio Feliz's band; Claudio is killed later in the year.
February 1852: A thief's confession, printed after his execution, names Murrieta among horse and mule thieves.
April 4, 1852: A posse member is killed at Willow Springs.
April 19, 1852: Murrieta is arrested as a suspect at Jackson, Calaveras County; he is not tried.
Early November 1852: A state militia general is killed near Mission San Gabriel; Reyes Feliz is put to death after his arrest by Los Angeles vigilantes.
Mid-December 1852: Robberies in Jackson; a man is killed near San Andreas.
January and February 1853: The band is blamed for the deaths of 22 men, most of them Chinese miners.
March 1853: Mariposa County citizens petition for a ranger company; the band moves into the San Joaquin Valley.
April 13, 1853: Murrieta visits a ranch near Salinas.
May 17, 1853: The Legislature passes the act raising a ranger company against the five Joaquins.
May 28, 1853: The company is mustered in at Quartzburg, Mariposa County.
July 12, 1853: Rangers capture Jesus Feliz.
July 25, 1853: Rangers kill a man they identify as Murrieta at Arroyo de Cantua.
July 28, 1853: The company's lieutenant names the dead man as Valenzuela.
August 12, 1853: The rangers reach Stockton and gather affidavits.
August 23, 1853: A San Francisco editorial questions whether Murrieta existed as a single man.
August 29, 1853: The governor pays the $1,000 reward; the company is mustered out.
1854: John Rollin Ridge publishes his novel of Murrieta's life.
May 28, 1854: The Legislature votes the rangers an additional $5,000.