Joachim Peiper

Victims
Several hundred prisoners of war killed in Belgium, 1944-1945. With unarmed civilians, charged to his combat group; a US Army court at Dachau convicted him of war crimes, July 1946
Years active
December 16, 1944, to January 13, 1945 (charged period); May 16 to July 16, 1946 (trial)
Location
Malmedy and other localities in Belgium; Dachau, Schwäbisch Hall and Landsberg am Lech, Germany; Traves, France
Method
War crimes: violation of the laws and usages of war (murder of prisoners of war and noncombatant civilians)
Status
Sentenced to death July 16, 1946; left in force March 1948; commuted to life January 31, 1951; reduced to 35 years May 1954; paroled from Landsberg December 22, 1956

Joachim Peiper was a colonel of the Waffen-SS who, in the winter of 1944, led the armored spearhead of the German offensive in the Belgian Ardennes. The formation that carried his name, Combat Group Peiper, was charged after the war with killing several hundred American prisoners of war and unarmed Belgian civilians at a string of places across eastern Belgium between December 16, 1944, and January 13, 1945. The best known of those places was the Baugnez crossroads, a hamlet south of Malmedy, and the case is known by the town's name. In the spring of 1946 Peiper and 73 other former members of his command went on trial before a United States Army court at Dachau. Every man who heard a verdict was convicted. On July 16, 1946, the court sentenced Peiper and 42 others to death.

None of those sentences was carried out. The case passed through a long series of Army reviews, two special commissions and an inquiry by the United States Senate, and the sentences shrank at every stage. Peiper's own death sentence survived the first rounds of review, was commuted to life imprisonment in January 1951 and was cut to 35 years in 1954. He walked out of the war criminals' prison at Landsberg am Lech on parole on December 22, 1956.

Peiper was born on January 30, 1915, in Berlin-Wilmersdorf. He joined the Hitler Youth in 1933 and entered the SS as a candidate late that year. He was taken on as a full-time SS member in 1935, trained at the SS officer school in Braunschweig, and in 1936 joined the Leibstandarte SS Adolf Hitler, the SS regiment that later grew into the 1st SS Panzer Division. He became a member of the Nazi Party in 1938 and that year joined the personal staff of Heinrich Himmler, the head of the SS, serving as his adjutant until late in the summer of 1941. He then returned to the Leibstandarte, and from 1943 he commanded one of its panzer regiments.

The German offensive in the Ardennes opened on December 16, 1944. Peiper's command was the leading armored force of the 1st SS Panzer Division, and every man later tried in the case was a member of the Waffen-SS. The charge sheet placed the killings at a dozen localities in Belgium, beginning on December 16 and running until about January 13, 1945. It named no exact number of dead. It spoke of "several hundred" prisoners of war, whose names and exact numbers were unknown, and of unarmed Allied civilians. Figures compiled from the Army's own trial review, and later laid before the Senate, put the total at about 350 American prisoners of war who had surrendered and about 100 Belgian civilians.

American troops took Peiper into custody at Tegernsee, in Bavaria, on May 22, 1945. Investigators had already traced the killings to his combat group, whose former members were scattered through camps and hospitals across Europe and the United States. They were gathered and, between December 1945 and April 1946, more than 400 suspects were questioned at the prison in Schwäbisch Hall. When that investigation closed, the accused were brought to Dachau.

The case was entered as United States of America v. Valentin Bersin et al. and came before a general military government court of the United States Army. Seventy-four men stood accused, from senior commanders to the young enlisted men who had served under them. They were charged with violating the laws and usages of war: that they did "willfully, deliberately, and wrongfully permit, encourage, aid, abet and participate in the killings" of American prisoners of war and unarmed Allied civilians in Belgium between December 16, 1944, and January 13, 1945.

The trial opened on May 16, 1946, in the former concentration camp at Dachau, and ran for about two months. Peiper took the stand in his own defense and was cross-examined on the record. On July 16, 1946, the court convicted every one of the accused who came to judgment. It sentenced 43 to death, Peiper among them, and the rest to life imprisonment or to terms of 10, 15 or 20 years. Peiper was sent to Landsberg am Lech, where he would remain until his release.

No sentence of a Dachau court could be carried out until it had been reviewed, first in the office of the deputy theater judge advocate for war crimes, then by a war crimes board of review, and finally by the theater commander. The two reviewing offices did not see the case alike. The war crimes board of review parted company with the first review in a substantial number of cases and, on the whole, was considerably more lenient, recommending a great many more disapprovals than the theater judge advocate and the commander finally accepted. The result in the Malmedy case was still a sharp reduction. Of the 43 death sentences, the theater commander approved only 12; he reduced the sentences in 41 cases and set aside 13 outright for insufficient evidence. On March 20, 1948, 31 of the death sentences were commuted to life imprisonment. Peiper's was one of the 12 left in force.

By then nearly all of the convicted men had withdrawn the statements they gave before trial, alleging that they had been obtained under duress at Schwäbisch Hall. Those claims brought the case before two special bodies and, in the end, the United States Senate.

In 1948 the Secretary of the Army appointed a commission to study every unexecuted death sentence from the Dachau courts. It recommended that all 12 remaining Malmedy death sentences be commuted to life imprisonment, out of doubt about how the pretrial investigation had been conducted, but it did not question the verdicts, finding that the record "sufficiently manifests the guilt of the accused to warrant the findings of guilty." Its answer to any injustice was commutation, not acquittal. The Senate subcommittee later judged the commission's report incomplete on the 12 Malmedy prisoners, because it had heard no witness from the prosecution staff or from the team that conducted the pretrial investigation.

A second body, the Administration of Justice Review Board, worked alongside the commission. It had been set up to study irregularities in legal proceedings within the theater, and it went through the Malmedy charges in detail, on a fuller body of evidence than the commission had before it. It found no physical mistreatment by the American interrogation team for the purpose of securing confessions. It did find that staged trials, ruses and stratagems had been used. It made no recommendation on sentence.

The theater commander then studied the 12 remaining death sentences himself. He commuted six of them to life imprisonment and confirmed six, Peiper's among those that stood. He confirmed none that rested on evidence obtained through staged interrogations or solely on pretrial statements by other accused that had later been withdrawn. Even in the six cases he commuted, he recorded that he was certain of the prisoners' guilt but would not approve a death sentence unless the record was perfectly clear.

A subcommittee of the Senate Armed Services Committee took up the case in 1949 and presented its report on October 14 of that year. It found that "the confessions made by the prisoners, and the evidence submitted at the trial were not secured through physical mistreatment of the accused." Weighing the whole body of evidence, it found little or none to support a conclusion that the interrogation team had used physical mistreatment to secure evidence. It allowed that in individual and isolated cases a prisoner might have been struck in a moment of anger, but held that this was never a general or condoned practice and found no substantial evidence that any man's conviction had been affected by it. It found that staged trials had been used on not more than 12 of the several hundred suspects questioned, that the Army had excluded any evidence obtained by improper procedures when it made its final decisions, and that the defense had been given too little time to prepare.

Peiper's death sentence stood until January 31, 1951, when the commander of United States forces in Europe commuted the last of the Malmedy death sentences, Peiper's among them, to life imprisonment. On May 12, 1954, the commander of the United States Army in Europe reduced his life term to 35 years.

The last decision lay outside the American chain of command. The Paris-Bonn treaty of 1955 took the war criminals' cases out of American hands and gave them to a Mixed Parole and Clemency Board, made up of three West German members and one each from the United States, Britain and France. Its members were not subject to instruction from their governments, and a unanimous decision of the board could not be reviewed. On October 5, 1955, the board voted unanimously to release Peiper on parole once his parole conditions had been settled. He left Landsberg on December 22, 1956.

He worked in West Germany through the 1960s and in 1972 moved to Traves, a village in eastern France. He was killed there on July 14, 1976. No one was ever arrested or prosecuted for his death.

The court never fixed the number of the dead. The charge spoke of "several hundred" prisoners of war, their names and exact numbers unknown, and of unarmed civilians; the figures of about 350 prisoners and about 100 civilians were compiled from the Army's review of the trial and rest on the accounts of different witnesses.

The convicted men's later claims of mistreatment at Schwäbisch Hall were rejected by the Senate subcommittee, which found that the confessions and trial evidence had not been obtained by physical mistreatment, while the use of staged trials on a small number of suspects was admitted, and the Army excluded any evidence it judged tainted when it made its final decisions.

Timeline

January 30, 1915: Joachim Peiper is born in Berlin-Wilmersdorf.

1933: He joins the Hitler Youth and enters the SS as a candidate.

1936: He joins the Leibstandarte SS Adolf Hitler after SS officer training in Braunschweig.

1938: He joins the Nazi Party and Heinrich Himmler's personal staff.

December 16, 1944: The German offensive in the Ardennes begins; the charged period opens.

January 13, 1945: The charged period ends.

May 22, 1945: American troops take Peiper into custody at Tegernsee.

December 1945 to April 1946: Pretrial interrogation at Schwäbisch Hall.

May 16, 1946: Trial of 74 accused opens at Dachau.

July 16, 1946: All convicted; Peiper among 43 sentenced to death.

March 20, 1948: Thirty-one death sentences commuted; Peiper's among the 12 left standing.

September 14, 1948: Army commission reports, recommending that the 12 remaining Malmedy death sentences be commuted.

October 14, 1949: Senate subcommittee report presented to the Senate.

January 31, 1951: Peiper's death sentence commuted to life imprisonment.

May 12, 1954: His sentence reduced to 35 years.

October 5, 1955: Mixed Parole and Clemency Board votes unanimously for his parole.

December 22, 1956: Released from Landsberg on parole.

July 14, 1976: Killed in Traves, France.