On the morning of Friday, April 3, 2009, thirteen people died and four more were wounded at the American Civic Association in Binghamton, New York, a volunteer organization that had helped immigrants settle in the Southern Tier of New York since 1939. Most of the dead had come to the United States from other countries, and most of them had come to the association that morning to work on their English and on the path to citizenship. They came from China, Vietnam, Haiti, Pakistan, Iraq, Brazil, the Philippines and Ukraine, and from Binghamton itself.
Binghamton police attributed the deaths to Jiverly Wong, a naturalized American citizen from Vietnam who lived in neighboring Johnson City and who had himself taken English classes at the association until the month before. He died by suicide the same day. Because he died before he could be arrested, no charge was ever filed, no court heard evidence and no verdict was ever returned. Everything known about his part in the deaths rests on the police account given in the days that followed.
Wong was born in Vietnam into an ethnically Chinese family. He also used the name Jiverly Voong, and police sources in the first hours gave a further name, Linh Phat Voong. He moved to the United States in the early 1990s and became a citizen soon afterward.
He later moved to California. In the Los Angeles area he worked for about seven years for a sushi caterer, earning about nine dollars an hour. One day he simply stopped coming in. Early the following year he asked the company to send his tax forms to an address in New York.
Back in the Binghamton area he found work assembling vacuum cleaners at a plant in the city. That job ended in November 2008, and police said he had been fired. Afterward he lived on unemployment benefits of about two hundred dollars a week, and a friend said he was frustrated that he could not find work.
He lived in Johnson City, and until March 2009 he attended English classes at the American Civic Association.
His dealings with the law before April 2009 were slight. Police records showed a bad-check charge in 1992 and a speeding ticket in 2007.
Thirteen people died at the association. Their names were released over the weekend after relatives had been told. Within two days the city had heard from representatives of nine countries and two consulates.
Parveen Ali had come to the United States from Pakistan in 2001. She had recently become a citizen, was working toward a high school equivalency diploma and hoped one day to teach.
Almir Olimpio Alves had come from Brazil in September 2008. He was born in Moreno, in the state of Pernambuco in northeastern Brazil, and earned his doctorate in mathematics at the Federal University of Pernambuco in 2003, with distinction. His thesis answered a question first posed by a Binghamton mathematician and was later published in the journal Topology, and joint research that grew out of it brought him to the city. He played the guitar, wrote verse and composed melodies, though he had never trained in music, and he loved telling stories about the countryside where he grew up and the history of Pernambuco. He already wrote English well; he came to the association's classes to improve his spoken English, valued the mix of people he met there and made friends both at the association and at a Baptist church in the area. He planned to return to Brazil in July 2009.
Marc Henry Bernard had come from Haiti and lived in Endicott. Maria Bernard had also come from Haiti. Both were taking classes at the association and both were working toward citizenship.
Li Guo had come from Tianjin, in China, and had been in Binghamton since June 2008.
Lan Ho had come from Vietnam two years earlier in search of a better life. She was learning English because she wanted to find work.
Layla Khalil had left Baghdad after car bombs exploded close to her home in the city. In Binghamton she threw herself into learning English.
Roberta King grew up in Syracuse and graduated from Syracuse University. She loved music, opera, cooking, architecture and historic preservation, and she kept a collection of dolls.
Hong Xiu Mao, who went by Amy, came to the United States from China in 2004.
Dolores Yigal had come from the Philippines about a year earlier. She loved children and was learning English so that she could find work.
Maria Zobniw had come to the United States from Ukraine as a child. She attended Harpur College, the school that became Binghamton University, and spent years passing on the Ukrainian language and Ukrainian traditions to children in the area.
Jiang Ling and Haihong Zhong also died that morning. Four of the thirteen were Chinese nationals.
Police said the deaths came within a few minutes, and that Wong died by suicide. The officers who arrived first did not know that the man responsible was already dead, and for some time they believed he might still be inside and might be holding people. Dozens of people had hidden wherever they could find shelter, many of them unable to speak English, and police brought them out in groups. Thirty-seven people were brought out safely. Police did not know for certain that Wong was among the dead until late that night or early the next morning.
Four people were wounded. All four were expected to survive.
There was never going to be a trial, but there was still an investigation, and its task was to establish who the man was and why he had come to the association that morning. Binghamton police led it, and FBI agents in Los Angeles helped New York investigators look into the years Wong had spent in California.
By the next day police had settled on the outline of his last months: the loss of his job, his difficulty with English and his belief that people made fun of him. They said no motive had been determined.
On Monday, April 6, a cable news channel in Syracuse, part of Time Warner Cable, received a package that had been postmarked in Binghamton on April 3. It held a handwritten letter dated March 18, photographs of Wong and what appeared to be his driver's license. The letter blamed police for years of harassment and for the poverty he said he had fallen into, and it set out his intention to take his own life and the lives of others. The channel turned the package over to investigators, and police passed it to the FBI for review by its behavioral experts.
Police said they had no reason to believe the letter was not authentic, though it did not explain why Wong had chosen the English class.
Because Wong never faced a court, the police account is the only finding there is. No judge or jury ever tested the evidence that he alone was responsible.
His motive was never established. Police pointed to the loss of his job, his limited English and his sense that he was being mocked, while the letter mailed on April 3 blamed police harassment.
The one outside claim of responsibility, telephoned from Pakistan the day after the deaths, was rejected by the FBI.
Whether he wrote the letter was questioned at the time. Police said they had no reason to doubt it, and that a report suggesting otherwise had proved wrong.
Early 1990s: Wong moves from Vietnam to the United States and becomes a citizen soon afterward.
1992: A bad-check charge appears in his police record.
2007: A speeding ticket appears in his police record.
November 2008: His job at a vacuum plant in Binghamton ends.
Until March 2009: He attends English classes at the American Civic Association.
March 18, 2009: Date written on the letter later mailed to a Syracuse cable news channel.
April 3, 2009: Thirteen people die and four are wounded at the American Civic Association in Binghamton; police attribute the deaths to Wong, who dies by suicide the same day.
April 4 to 5, 2009: Police release the names of the dead after notifying families; FBI agents in Los Angeles join the inquiry into his past.
April 6, 2009: The Syracuse channel receives the letter, postmarked in Binghamton on April 3, and turns it over to investigators.
April 2009: Police say they have no reason to doubt the letter is his and that no motive has been determined.