Jimmy Governor was the last man proclaimed an outlaw in New South Wales, and in the record of the colony's courts he is a man convicted of a single murder. Nine people died in the space of a week in July 1900, five of them at Breelong, near Gilgandra, on the night the violence began. Governor, his younger brother Joe and their friend Jacky Underwood fled into the ranges, and the two brothers stayed free for more than three months while some 2,000 police, trackers and civilians followed them across about 3,000 kilometers of country. In October 1900 the government had them declared outlaws. Joe was killed by civilian pursuers at the end of that month. Jimmy, captured alive near Wingham, was tried in Sydney in November for the murder of one of the Breelong victims, found guilty by a jury and sentenced to death. He was executed in Sydney on January 18, 1901, within weeks of Federation.
The case sits at a seam in Australian history. It was the last outlawry in the state, and the trial turned in part on what that outlawry meant in law. It played out under the racial language of the colony, which classed Governor as a "half-caste" and treated his marriage to a white woman as an affront, and his execution was held back until the celebrations of Federation were over.
Governor was born in 1875 in the Talbragar River district of New South Wales. He was a Wiradjuri and Wonnarua man, with some Irish ancestry, and Joe was about two years his junior. The brothers were rural laborers. For a short period Jimmy had worked as a tracker with the New South Wales Mounted Police, the same force that would later hunt him.
In his early twenties he married a white teenager in a Church of England ceremony at Gulgong. The marriage drew comment in the local press, which treated a white woman's choice of an Aboriginal husband as a scandal. By 1900 the couple had a young child.
In 1900 Governor was building fences for a farming family at Breelong, near Gilgandra. He and his family lived on the property and worked for payments and rations, and they remained in debt to their employer. His wife worked for the household. The arrangement soured.
On the night of Friday, July 20, 1900, Governor went to the household at Breelong with Joe and Jacky Underwood. Five people died: Grace Mawbey; three of her children, Percy, Grace and Hilda; and Helen Josephine Kerz. A young relative of the family survived, and several other children escaped unhurt.
Of the five deaths, only one would ever come before a jury: the last-named victim's death became the single count on which Governor was tried. The deaths of the mother and her three children were never tried against him.
The next morning Governor's wife was taken into custody. Her part in the events has been disputed ever since. Contradictory statements and admissions about her role were made at the trial, where she gave evidence for the prosecution, and she was released without charge after her husband's conviction.
The three men fled. Within days Underwood had separated from the brothers, and eight days after Breelong he was arrested by civilians near Redbank and held for the police. Jimmy and Joe moved on together.
In the first six days after Breelong four more people died in three separate places: Alexander McKay at Ulan; Elizabeth O'Brien and her young son near Merriwa; and a second man. These deaths were laid at the brothers' door but were never tried against Jimmy Governor.
After those first days the case became a long pursuit.
The pursuit became the largest manhunt the colony had seen. Police, Aboriginal trackers and volunteer civilians, about 2,000 in all, worked across some 3,000 kilometers of northern and central New South Wales. The brothers repeatedly outdistanced them, and the press, which reported sightings and rumors daily, turned increasingly on the police for failing to bring the chase to an end.
The government raised the stakes. The reward for the capture of the two brothers rose from 200 pounds to 1,000 pounds. On September 29, 1900, a warrant was issued for the arrest of Jimmy and Joe Governor for murder, naming the Breelong victim on whose death the later trial would rest. The Attorney General, who had for some time resisted calls to use the outlawry law, then applied to the Supreme Court to have the brothers declared outlaws, and on October 5, 1900, they were proclaimed outlaws under the Felons Apprehension Act 1899.
The proclamation itself was a short, formal document. It recited that a judge of the Supreme Court had adjudged the brothers outlaws, it was issued in the name of the Governor of New South Wales, and it carried the signature of the same Attorney General who had held out against outlawry for so long.
The end came on the coast, more than 450 kilometers from Breelong. On the 99th day of the manhunt, in late October 1900, Jimmy Governor was captured alive by a party of civilian hunters at Bobin, near Wingham in the Manning Valley. He had been separated from his brother before he was taken. The capture was made by civilians, not by the police.
At the end of October 1900, a few days after the capture, Joe Governor was killed by civilian pursuers near Singleton. He was never tried for anything.
Governor was brought to Sydney and charged with murder on the single Breelong count. The prosecution confined the case to that one death. The other Breelong deaths, and the four deaths that followed, were not added to the indictment.
The trial opened at the criminal court at Darlinghurst, Sydney, in November 1900 before a judge and jury. Before any evidence was heard, the defense raised the outlawry. Governor's counsel argued that the proclamation of October 5 had in effect already found him guilty, so that the trial could not lawfully go on: a man who had been adjudged an outlaw had nothing left to be tried for. The Crown prosecutor answered that the Felons Apprehension Act did no more than widen the powers of arrest, and that Governor remained entitled to a trial. The court sided with the prosecution. A fresh jury was impaneled, and the trial proceeded on the single count of murder.
The jury that heard the case was all white. His wife gave evidence for the prosecution. Before she did, the judge asked whether she understood that, as a married woman, she could not be made to testify against her husband. She said she understood, and she went on to give her evidence.
Governor made a statement from the dock, and the defense built its case on provocation, which, if the jury accepted it, would have reduced the crime from murder to manslaughter.
The jury did not accept it and returned a verdict of guilty of murder. The judge's notebook records the verdict and the sentence of death, which was passed on November 23, 1900.
Jacky Underwood, the third man at Breelong, was tried separately and sentenced to death for his part in the Breelong deaths. He was executed at Dubbo on January 14, 1901.
Governor and Underwood were held much longer than was usual after sentence. Their executions were postponed until the celebrations that marked Federation had concluded.
While Governor awaited execution, warders kept a round-the-clock watch over him and recorded it in a diary now held by the State Records Authority of New South Wales.
Jimmy Governor was executed in Sydney on January 18, 1901.
The outlawry that framed the last months of the case rested on the Felons Apprehension Act 1899, the New South Wales consolidation of the colony's outlawry statutes. In the Governor case the Attorney General went to the Supreme Court, and within a month of the application the brothers' outlawry was formally gazetted. Once it was, the brothers were no longer suspects in the eyes of the colony but declared outlaws: if they failed to surrender, they could lawfully be taken dead or alive by those who hunted them.
That was the point on which Governor's defense tried to stop the trial. If the proclamation had already fixed his guilt, his counsel argued, the court had nothing left to try. The court's answer, that the Act enlarged the powers of arrest but left an outlaw's right to a trial intact, meant that Governor was tried in the ordinary way, before a jury and on a single count, rather than condemned by the proclamation itself. The Governor brothers were the last people proclaimed outlaws in New South Wales.
Nine deaths are attributed to the Governor brothers and Underwood, but Jimmy Governor was convicted of one. The deaths of the mother and her three children at Breelong, and the four deaths in the week that followed, were never tried against him, and Joe Governor, who died before he could be taken, was never tried at all.
His wife's role at Breelong was disputed at the trial and remains so. She was never charged.
Governor's account of provocation, given from the dock, was rejected by the jury.
1875: Jimmy Governor is born in the Talbragar River district of New South Wales.
1900: Governor is building fences for a farming family at Breelong, near Gilgandra.
July 20, 1900: Five people die at Breelong; Governor, his brother Joe and Jacky Underwood flee.
Late July 1900: Underwood is arrested by civilians near Redbank; four more deaths in six days are attributed to the brothers.
September 29, 1900: A warrant is issued for the arrest of both brothers for murder.
October 5, 1900: The brothers are proclaimed outlaws under the Felons Apprehension Act 1899.
Late October 1900: Jimmy Governor is captured at Bobin, near Wingham, on the 99th day of the manhunt.
End of October 1900: Joe Governor is killed by civilian pursuers north of Singleton.
November 1900: Governor is tried in Sydney; the court rejects the defense argument on outlawry; the jury finds him guilty of murder.
November 23, 1900: He is sentenced to death.
January 14, 1901: Underwood is executed at Dubbo.
January 18, 1901: Jimmy Governor is executed in Sydney.