For sixteen years after the Civil War, the state of Missouri treated Jesse James as a fugitive from justice and never once brought him before a court. A grand jury in Daviess County indicted him, with his older brother Frank, for the murder of a Gallatin man in December 1869. In July 1881 the governor of Missouri put his name, and his brother's, at the head of a proclamation that recited that indictment, described two deaths on a train near the town of Winston, and offered rewards for the arrest and conviction of everyone who had taken part. No arrest followed. On April 3, 1882, at the age of 34, he was killed in St. Joseph by Robert Ford, a member of his own circle who had been in contact with the governor about the reward. Ford was convicted of murder and pardoned within the same day.
What the law said about Jesse James is therefore short. He was charged, proclaimed and hunted. He was never tried, and no verdict, conviction or sentence stands against him. The killings set down in his name are the ones the indictment and the proclamation describe, and the only jury ever asked to weigh the Winston deaths sat in judgment on his brother in 1883 and returned a verdict of not guilty.
Jesse Woodson James was born on September 5, 1847, in Clay County, Missouri, on a farm northeast of the town of Kearney.
Jesse was too young to enlist in 1861. Frank went first, serving under Sterling Price and later with Confederate guerrillas. Jesse later joined him in the guerrilla company led by William Anderson. He rode with that company from June 1864 until May 1865, the last year of the war, and fought with it at Centralia, Albany and Fayette in Missouri. He did not ride under William Quantrill, as is often said.
The guerrilla war in Missouri did not end cleanly in 1865. The brothers came back to a county where wartime grievances between Union and Southern families were still raw, and from early 1866 until April 1882, Jesse and Frank James were the leading figures of a loose company that local history calls the James boys' gang, a group that drew in at least thirty men at one time or another. By 1869 the brothers were involved in a series of bank robberies and murders. Neither of them was ever convicted of any crime.
John W. Sheets was one of the early settlers of Daviess County, a Virginian by birth who had held a captain's commission in the Union militia during the Civil War, and Gallatin knew him as the captain for the rest of his life.
The captain died in Gallatin on December 7, 1869, during a robbery of the Daviess County Savings Association. Suspicion fell quickly on the James brothers, and one of the horses left behind was later shown to have belonged to Jesse James.
Witnesses later said that Jesse James had sworn to avenge Anderson, the guerrilla leader, by killing Samuel P. Cox, the Union officer credited with Anderson's death, and the county's own account holds that the captain was mistaken for Cox. That motive was never tested in court. Nobody was convicted of the robbery or of the murder, and it is still not known for certain who killed the captain.
The Gallatin case marked a turn in how Missouri treated the brothers. It was the first time the state officially put a price on Jesse James and branded him an outlaw. In May 1870 a grand jury of Daviess County returned an indictment against Frank James and Jesse W. James for the captain's murder, and that indictment was still pending in the Circuit Court of Daviess County when the governor recited it in 1881.
The county's courts also reached for the brothers through a civil suit in the Daviess County Common Pleas Court. Process could never be served on them, and on July 12, 1870, the court found that the two defendants had "absconded or absented themselves from their usual place of abode in this State." Neither of them ever appeared to answer, and the plaintiff won the case.
Jesse answered the accusation in writing. In June 1870 he wrote to Governor Joseph W. McClurg denying any part in the robbery and the death. He said he had sold the horse before the crime, and several people testified that they had seen him elsewhere at the time; affidavits placed both brothers in Kearney that day. Years later another letter in his name, dated December 20, 1878, from Deer Lodge in the Montana Territory, again denied the Gallatin robbery, said the brothers had not been in Missouri at the time, and offered to surrender anywhere in the state except Gallatin if the governor would guarantee a fair trial. Nothing came of the offer, and he never stood trial in Daviess County or anywhere else.
Through the early 1870s the brothers lived as men wanted but never taken. Governor Silas Woodson asked the legislature for money to run down the bank and train robbers of the state, the James brothers among them, and failed to get it. In 1875 a measure in the Missouri legislature to grant the gang amnesty won a majority, 58 votes to 38, and failed only because it fell short of the two-thirds it needed.
In the late 1870s the brothers settled in Nashville, Tennessee, under false names; Jesse lived as Thomas Howard. On October 8, 1879, a train was stopped near Glendale, in Jackson County, and the state later named that robbery in the same breath as the brothers.
On July 15, 1881, a train on the Chicago, Rock Island and Pacific Railroad was stopped near Winston, in Daviess County, and money and express matter were taken. Two men on board died: William Westfall and a passenger, Frank McMillan.
Thirteen days later the state answered. On July 28, 1881, Governor Thomas T. Crittenden signed a proclamation at Jefferson City, under the Great Seal of Missouri. It recited the Glendale robbery of 1879 and the Winston robbery, set down the two deaths on the train, and declared that Frank James and Jesse W. James stood indicted in the Circuit Court of Daviess County for the Gallatin murder of 1869. The parties engaged in those robberies and murders, the proclamation said, had fled from justice and hidden themselves.
It then set the terms. For the arrest and conviction of each person who had taken part in the robberies or the murders, other than the two brothers, the state offered $5,000. For the arrest and delivery of Frank James or Jesse W. James to the sheriff of Daviess County, it offered $5,000 each, and for the conviction of either brother of taking part in any of the murders or robberies, a further $5,000. The new rewards replaced every earlier reward offered for the same men by any person or corporation.
Jesse James spent the last months of his life in St. Joseph, Missouri, under an alias. Charley and Robert Ford, two brothers who rode with him, were with him there.
They had other plans as well. Robert Ford had held secret talks with Governor Crittenden about capturing or killing Jesse James and had discussed the reward with him. On April 3, 1882, Robert Ford killed Jesse James in St. Joseph. Jesse James was 34. Ford reported the killing to the governor and expected to collect.
The state charged both Fords with murder, and the charge ran its course in a single day. In April 1882 the brothers were arraigned in St. Joseph on charges of murder in the first degree. They were indicted for the murder of Jesse James, found guilty and sentenced to death. That same afternoon Governor Crittenden pardoned them both.
The charges that had never reached Jesse James came to court through his brother, and the outcome of those proceedings is the nearest thing to a judicial answer on the deaths the 1881 proclamation described.
Frank James surrendered to Governor Crittenden in the governor's office at Jefferson City on October 5, 1882, about six months after his brother's death.
The Winston case against him was already on paper. In February 1882, while Jesse James was still alive and at large, a Daviess County grand jury had indicted Frank James for murder in one of the two deaths on the train.
In Daviess County the state had two sets of charges against him. The old indictment for the Gallatin murder was dropped, and the prosecution sought a conviction only on the Winston charges: the robbery and the two murders on the train. Trial opened in Gallatin on August 20, 1883, before a circuit judge from Gentry County, and ran until September 6. The prosecution's central witness was a former member of the gang who had been given immunity, and Frank James answered with an alibi. The jury was instructed on Missouri law that anyone proven to have taken part in the crime could be found guilty of the murders, even if another man's hand had caused the deaths.
On September 6, 1883, the jury returned its verdict. Frank James was "not guilty of the charges contained in the indictment." In February 1884 Missouri dismissed every other charge against him.
No proceeding of any kind against Jesse James followed his death, and no court ever decided whether he had caused the death of anyone named in the indictment or the proclamation.
Every killing attributed to Jesse James remains an accusation. The Daviess County indictment for the Gallatin death of 1869 was never tried against him, and it was dropped against his brother before the 1883 trial. The motive set down in the county's history, that the captain was mistaken for Samuel Cox, rests on what witnesses later said Jesse James had sworn, and it was never tested before a jury. Against it stand his own letter of June 1870 to Governor McClurg, the people who testified that they had seen him elsewhere, and the affidavits that placed both brothers in Kearney that day.
The Winston deaths were tried only once, against Frank James, and the jury acquitted.
September 5, 1847: Jesse Woodson James is born in Clay County, Missouri.
June 1864 to May 1865: He rides with William Anderson's Confederate guerrilla company.
December 7, 1869: A Gallatin man dies during the robbery of the Daviess County Savings Association; the brothers are later indicted in Daviess County for his murder.
May 1870: A Daviess County grand jury indicts Frank and Jesse James for the Gallatin murder.
June 1870: Jesse James writes to Governor Joseph W. McClurg denying any part in the Gallatin robbery and death.
July 12, 1870: The Daviess County Common Pleas Court finds, in a civil suit, that the brothers have absconded from their usual home.
1875: An amnesty measure for the gang fails in the Missouri legislature, 58 to 38, short of a two-thirds majority.
October 8, 1879: A train is stopped near Glendale, Jackson County.
July 15, 1881: A Rock Island train is stopped near Winston, Daviess County; two men on board die.
July 28, 1881: Governor Thomas T. Crittenden's proclamation offers rewards for the arrest and conviction of the brothers.
February 1882: A Daviess County grand jury indicts Frank James for murder in one of the Winston deaths.
April 3, 1882: Robert Ford kills Jesse James in St. Joseph, Missouri.
April 1882: The Ford brothers are arraigned on first-degree murder charges, found guilty of murder in St. Joseph, are sentenced to death and are pardoned by the governor the same afternoon.
October 5, 1882: Frank James surrenders to the governor in Jefferson City.
August 20 to September 6, 1883: Frank James is tried in Gallatin on the Winston charges and found not guilty.
February 1884: Missouri dismisses all remaining charges against Frank James.