Jens Soering and Elizabeth Haysom

Victims
Derek and Nancy Haysom killed in Virginia, 1985. Soering: 2 counts of first-degree murder, 1990. Haysom: pleaded guilty as accessory before the fact, 1987
Years active
March 30, 1985
Location
Boonsboro, Bedford County, Virginia; Charlottesville; Washington, D.C.; London
Method
Double murder, first degree; Haysom convicted as an accessory before the fact.
Status
Soering: two consecutive life terms (September 4, 1990). Haysom: 90 years. Both paroled November 25, 2019, and deported. Soering's innocence petition pending (November 2026).

On the evening of March 30, 1985, Derek Haysom and Nancy Haysom were killed in Boonsboro, a rural section of Bedford County in the Blue Ridge foothills west of Lynchburg, Virginia. Their daughter, Elizabeth Haysom, was 20 and in her first year at the University of Virginia in Charlottesville. Her boyfriend, Jens Soering, an 18-year-old German citizen, was in the same class. Neither was a suspect at first. A year later both were in custody in London, and by 1990 both stood convicted: Haysom on her own guilty plea to two counts of being an accessory before the fact to first-degree murder, Soering by a jury that found him guilty of two counts of first-degree murder.

The case has never settled into a single story. Soering admitted the killings to investigators in 1986 and has denied them ever since, saying he confessed to shield Haysom from the electric chair. Haysom has always said that he did it. His long resistance to extradition from Britain produced one of the best-known judgments of the European Court of Human Rights. Both were paroled in November 2019 and sent out of the United States for good, he to Germany and she to Canada. In 2026 Soering asked the Court of Appeals of Virginia to declare him innocent, and that petition is still undecided.

Charlottesville to London

Soering arrived at the University of Virginia in the fall of 1984 as an Echols scholar and a Jefferson scholar, two of the university's most selective honors. Shortly after the semester began he met Haysom at an event for Echols scholars. She was a Canadian citizen, and she too had come to Charlottesville as an honors scholar. Over that first semester a friendship turned into a romance, and by Christmas, Soering later testified, the two were in love. They wrote to each other constantly, and those letters, in which the deaths of her parents became a recurring subject, would later be central to the case.

In late March 1985 the two went to Washington, D.C., for the weekend. The prosecution's account, built from Soering's own statements and from Haysom's testimony, was that Soering drove to Bedford County alone that Saturday while Haysom stayed in the capital and made it appear that the two of them had spent the evening there together. The deaths became known on April 3, and for months the Bedford County Sheriff's Office treated the case as a double homicide with no obvious suspect.

Over time the investigators looked harder at the daughter and her boyfriend. Haysom cooperated. When they finally interviewed Soering in October 1985, he could not satisfactorily account for parts of the Washington weekend, and he declined to give the samples they asked for, saying he would provide them later. He never did. That same month he left Virginia, giving up the rest of his scholarship, and Haysom soon followed. For six months the Bedford investigators had a case that pointed toward two people who were no longer in the country.

On April 30, 1986, Soering and Haysom were arrested in London on check fraud charges, unrelated on their face to Virginia. The fraud inquiry led London detectives to contact the Bedford County Sheriff's Office, and investigators from Virginia flew to England.

The confessions

Over several days in early June 1986, after signing waivers of his rights and without a lawyer, Soering was questioned by British officers and by British and Virginia investigators together. He admitted that he had gone to Bedford County that night and killed the couple, insisting throughout that Haysom had stayed in Washington. On December 30, 1986, with a lawyer present, he admitted his involvement again in a statement to a German prosecutor. By then he was hoping to be tried in Germany.

Soering has given his own reason for those admissions ever since. He says that Haysom told him she had committed the killings, and that he took the blame because he believed he could save her from the death penalty in Virginia while he would face only a short sentence in Germany. Haysom's position, once she chose to plead guilty, has been that Soering carried out the killings and that she was an accessory to the plan.

Two extraditions

In June 1986 a Bedford County grand jury indicted both of them for capital murder, and on August 11 the United States asked Britain to extradite them under the extradition treaty of 1972. Both at first fought extradition. In the fall of 1986 Haysom changed her mind, waived extradition and returned to Virginia. In August 1987, with no plea agreement, she pleaded guilty in Bedford County Circuit Court to two counts of being an accessory before the fact to first-degree murder. The court sentenced her to two consecutive terms of 45 years, 90 years in all, and she agreed to testify against Soering.

Soering's road back was far longer. The charge he faced, capital murder, could carry the death penalty. Britain agreed to extradite him on the condition that the judge at sentencing would be told the United Kingdom wished the death penalty to be neither imposed nor carried out. West Germany wanted him as well. It sought his extradition under a treaty of 1872, on the strength of its jurisdiction over crimes committed abroad by its own nationals, and the Home Secretary chose to go ahead with the American request while leaving the German one open.

The English courts gave Soering nothing. In June 1987 the chief magistrate at Bow Street committed him to await the Home Secretary's order. The Divisional Court refused him habeas corpus, the House of Lords refused leave to appeal, and an application for judicial review failed, after which the Home Secretary authorized his surrender to the United States. In July 1988 Soering took the matter to the European Commission of Human Rights. The Commission rejected his application, and early in 1989 the case reached the European Court of Human Rights, brought there by the Commission, by the British government and by West Germany.

On July 7, 1989, in Soering v. United Kingdom, the Court ruled in his favor. It held, for the first time, that extradition itself could violate Article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights, the prohibition on inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment, even though the treatment would come from a state outside the Convention. The violation was not the death penalty as such, which the Convention then permitted, but the combination of circumstances Soering would face: his youth at the time of the offense, his mental state, the long delays between sentence and execution in Virginia, and the conditions on Virginia's death row.

The judgment was unanimous, and it went no further than that. On Soering's other complaints the Court found against him. It saw no real risk of a flagrant denial of a fair trial in Virginia under Article 6, and it held under Article 13 that judicial review in the English courts had given him an effective remedy. It treated the finding of a violation as sufficient satisfaction in itself and awarded him his legal costs.

On July 20, 1989, the British government told the House of Commons that it was in talks with the American and West German governments, and that extradition to the United States would no longer breach the Convention if the threat of a death sentence were removed. In January 1990 the Bedford County prosecutor reduced the charge to first-degree murder, Virginia formally guaranteed that no death sentence would be imposed, and Soering was extradited after about four years of resistance.

The trial, June 1990

Before trial the court refused to suppress the London statements, rejecting Soering's claim that he had waived his rights and agreed to talk only under duress, out of fear for Haysom's safety. The trial ran for about three weeks in June 1990. The prosecution's case rested on Soering's repeated admissions in England, Haysom's testimony and the physical evidence. Haysom took the stand and gave an account that closely tracked what he had told investigators in 1986.

Soering pleaded not guilty, testified, and offered the jury a reversed version of the Washington weekend. He said he had stayed in the capital while Haysom drove off, and that when she came back she told him she had killed her parents. By his account the two agreed that the only way to help her was for him to take the blame, and the London confessions were the product of that agreement. He told the jury that he loved her and believed it was the only way to save her life.

The jury did not accept his account. On June 21, 1990, it found Soering guilty of two counts of first-degree murder and recommended a life sentence on each. On September 4, 1990, the Circuit Court for Bedford County imposed the two life terms and ordered that they run consecutively.

Appeals, parole and removal

The Court of Appeals of Virginia ruled against Soering on October 9, 1991, ending his direct appeal. A habeas corpus petition reached the Supreme Court of Virginia, which sent one claim, that the prosecution had withheld evidence favorable to the defense, back to the trial court for a hearing. On April 17, 1998, in Soering v. Deeds, the Supreme Court of Virginia held that he had not shown that material exculpatory evidence was withheld or that its disclosure would probably have changed the result. Later federal and state habeas petitions also failed.

Soering became eligible for parole in 2003 and was turned down fourteen times, the last in January 2019, when the board found that releasing him then would diminish the seriousness of the crime. Parole was open to him at all only because his offenses predated Virginia's abolition of parole in 1995. In January 2010 the outgoing governor asked for his transfer to Germany to serve out his sentence there; his successor revoked the request within days, and in July 2012 the Richmond Circuit Court ruled that the governor had acted within his authority. In August 2016 Soering asked for an absolute pardon on the ground of innocence. None was granted.

On November 25, 2019, the Virginia Parole Board granted parole to both Soering and Haysom, citing their youth at the time of the offenses, their adjustment to incarceration and the roughly 33 years each had served, and finding that their release posed no risk to public safety. Neither was to be released into the United States; each was to be handed to U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement for removal, and neither could ever return. For Soering that handover had long been prepared: federal immigration authorities had lodged a detainer against him with the Virginia Department of Corrections in February 1991. The same day the governor rejected Soering's pardon request. He would leave as a paroled man convicted of two murders, not as a man found innocent. Soering was removed to Germany on December 16 to 17, 2019. Haysom was held by immigration authorities until January 22, 2020, when she was flown to Canada and handed over to Canadian authorities.

In Germany, Soering has made a living as a writer and public speaker, and he has kept trying to overturn the verdict. On February 17, 2026, he filed a petition for a writ of actual innocence in the Court of Appeals of Virginia, resting chiefly on new testing of evidence preserved from 1985, on challenges to the reliability of the London confessions and on new material, including a new witness. In August 2026 the court declined to dismiss the petition and ordered the Attorney General of Virginia to respond. On November 4, 2026, the Attorney General moved to dismiss, arguing that much of the material was not new and that the scientific results were inconclusive; the defense said it would oppose the motion and ask for an evidentiary hearing in Bedford County. The court has not yet ruled. Soering's convictions stand, and so do Haysom's.

Disputed and unproven points

The central dispute is who killed the couple. The jury's verdict, Haysom's guilty plea and testimony, and Soering's own admissions in 1986 all place him at the scene. Soering says the admissions were false and that Haysom told him she was responsible; Haysom says he did it. The defense calls the confessions unreliable and inconsistent with the evidence, while the Commonwealth relies on the trial court's 1990 finding that Soering was not acting under duress.

DNA testing of preserved samples, begun in 2009, did not match Soering; the two sides disagree on what that shows. The Parole Board's 2019 decision granted release without endorsing his claim of innocence, and whether the Court of Appeals of Virginia will hear the new evidence is the question still open.

Timeline

1984 (fall): Jens Soering and Elizabeth Haysom enroll at the University of Virginia on honors scholarships and meet.

March 30, 1985: Haysom's parents are killed in Boonsboro, Bedford County, Virginia.

April 3, 1985: The deaths become known.

October 1985: Soering is interviewed by Bedford County investigators; he and Haysom leave Virginia.

April 30, 1986: Both are arrested in London on check fraud charges.

June 1986: Soering admits the killings in interviews with British and Virginia investigators.

June 1986: A Bedford County grand jury indicts both for capital murder.

August 11, 1986: The United States requests their extradition from Britain.

December 30, 1986: Soering gives a statement to a German prosecutor.

June 1987: A Bow Street magistrate commits Soering to await the Home Secretary's extradition order.

August 1987: Haysom pleads guilty to two counts of accessory before the fact to first-degree murder; sentenced to 90 years.

July 1988: Soering applies to the European Commission of Human Rights.

July 7, 1989: The European Court of Human Rights rules unanimously that extraditing Soering to face a possible death sentence would violate Article 3.

January 1990: The capital charge is reduced to first-degree murder; Soering is extradited.

June 21, 1990: A jury convicts Soering of two counts of first-degree murder.

September 4, 1990: Soering is sentenced to two consecutive life terms.

February 1991: Federal immigration authorities lodge a detainer against Soering.

October 9, 1991: The Court of Appeals of Virginia rules against Soering on direct appeal.

April 17, 1998: The Supreme Court of Virginia denies habeas relief in Soering v. Deeds.

2003: Soering first becomes eligible for parole.

January 2010: The outgoing governor requests Soering's transfer to Germany; his successor revokes the request.

July 2012: The Richmond Circuit Court rules that the governor acted within his authority.

August 2016: Soering asks the governor for an absolute pardon.

January 2019: Soering is denied parole for the fourteenth time.

November 25, 2019: The Parole Board grants parole to both; the governor rejects Soering's pardon request.

December 16 to 17, 2019: Soering is removed to Germany.

January 22, 2020: Haysom is removed to Canada.

February 17, 2026: Soering files a petition for a writ of actual innocence in the Court of Appeals of Virginia.

August 2026: The court orders the Attorney General to respond.

November 4, 2026: The Attorney General moves to dismiss the petition.