Jeffrey Conroy was 17, a high school athlete from Medford on Long Island, when he and six other teenagers were charged in the death of Marcelo Lucero in the village of Patchogue on the night of November 8, 2008. Prosecutors said the group had gone out looking for Hispanic men to assault, and that Conroy was the one who caused the death. In April 2010 a Suffolk County jury acquitted him of murder but convicted him of manslaughter in the first degree as a hate crime, along with gang assault and assault counts tied to earlier attacks on other Hispanic men. He was sentenced the following month to 25 years in prison, the maximum.
The verdict was the first conviction in Suffolk County for a death prosecuted as a hate crime. The six other teenagers pleaded guilty to gang assault and related charges and went to prison for terms of five to seven years. Conroy was the only one of the seven to go to trial, and the only one charged with the death itself.
Conroy grew up in Medford and went to Patchogue-Medford High School, where he played three sports and was best known as a lacrosse player and a wrestler. Most of the teenagers later charged with him went to the same school.
The man who died that night was born in Gualaceo, a village on a river in the Andes of southern Ecuador. He came to the United States as a young man and made his life in Patchogue. Those close to him described someone serious and thoughtful, careful about whom he let into his life, who lifted weights, read the Bible and listened to classic rock. In the fall of 2008 he meant to sell his car and return to Ecuador for good before Christmas. He died in Patchogue that Saturday night.
Prosecutors described a night of deliberate violence: the teenagers had gone looking for Hispanic men to beat and had already gone after others earlier that day, and Conroy, they said, caused the fatal injury. The jury's manslaughter verdict later accepted that he did.
On Monday, November 10, 2008, Conroy was charged with manslaughter in the first degree as a hate crime and with assault; the six others were charged with assault. All seven pleaded not guilty, and Conroy was ordered held without bail. He remained in custody from then on. The case drew national attention, and in the fall of 2009 the United States Department of Justice opened an investigation into hate crimes against Hispanics in Suffolk County and the police response to them.
A Suffolk County grand jury indicted the seven, and the indictment was unsealed at the end of January 2009. It reached well beyond the night of November 8. The district attorney charged the teenagers with gang assault on eight Hispanic men besides the man who died, and six of the seven were charged with gang assault as a hate crime. Conroy's own exposure rose sharply: he now faced a count of murder in the second degree as a hate crime, together with manslaughter in the first degree as a hate crime, gang assault, conspiracy and assault counts for the earlier incidents. Those incidents went back at least to July 14, 2008, when he and one of the other teenagers took part in an attack on a Hispanic man, and included the beating of another Hispanic man in the days just before November 8. The cases moved to the State Supreme Court in Riverhead, the Suffolk County seat.
The other six resolved their cases without trial, and one of those who pleaded guilty testified for the prosecution. Conroy went before a jury in Riverhead in the spring of 2010.
The prosecution's case on the death rested in large part on Conroy's own words. After his arrest he had admitted to police that he was responsible. At trial, two police officers and one of the other teenagers testified that he had admitted being the one who caused the fatal injury.
The defense answered with Conroy himself, its first witness. He testified that he had not caused the death and that he had taken the blame for another of the teenagers, a youth he said he had met only that night, who he said had asked him to take responsibility. Conroy did not explain from the stand why he had agreed.
The hate-crime counts required the jury to decide why the victims had been chosen, so the trial also turned to Conroy's beliefs. Prosecutors were allowed to question him about statements he had made to jail officials after his arrest. Conroy testified that he had let a friend tattoo a swastika on his thigh as a dare. Before his sentencing, he said in an interview that he was not a white supremacist.
On Monday, April 19, 2010, the jury acquitted him of murder in the second degree as a hate crime, the most serious charge against him, and convicted him of manslaughter in the first degree as a hate crime. It also convicted him of gang assault in the first degree, conspiracy and hate-crime counts of assault and attempted assault arising from the attacks on other Hispanic men, among them the beating in the days before November 8. Under New York's hate-crime law, that verdict meant the jury found he had intentionally selected his victim, or intentionally committed the act, in whole or in substantial part because of a belief or perception about a trait the law protects. He now faced a sentence of 8 to 25 years.
On Wednesday, May 26, 2010, at the courthouse in Riverhead, the trial justice sentenced Conroy to 25 years in prison, to be followed by two and a half years of post-release supervision. The court imposed six sentences, to run concurrently: for manslaughter, for gang assault, for conspiracy, for assault as a hate crime and for two separate counts of attempted assault as a hate crime. Each was the maximum the law allowed. Before the sentence was pronounced, Conroy apologized to the victim's family.
The co-defendants were sentenced later that year. Three who had pleaded guilty to gang assault in the first degree, attempted assault in the second degree as a hate crime and conspiracy in the fourth degree, and had admitted taking part in an ongoing series of attacks on Hispanic men, received seven years each on August 25, 2010. A fourth, who had met the group only on the night of November 8 and had not taken part in the earlier attacks, pleaded guilty to the same charges and received six years, the maximum available to him. The remaining two, including the youth who testified against Conroy, pleaded guilty to gang assault and other charges; the last of the seven was sentenced in October 2010, to five years. As of October 2010 all seven were in prison, and Conroy, the only one of them tried, was serving his 25-year term in New York.
Conroy admitted to police that he had caused the death, then told the jury that the admission was false and that another teenager was responsible. Two police officers and a co-defendant testified to his admissions, and the jury convicted him on the manslaughter count. The youth he blamed pleaded guilty to gang assault and related charges and was never charged with causing the death.
The full number of attacks on Hispanic men in and around Patchogue in 2008 is not known; the indictment named eight men besides the one who died.
July 14, 2008: Conroy and another teenager take part in an attack on a Hispanic man in Patchogue, later one of the counts in the indictment.
Early November 2008: another Hispanic man is beaten in the days before November 8; Conroy is later convicted on counts arising from it.
November 8, 2008: a man from Gualaceo, Ecuador, dies in Patchogue; Conroy and six other teenagers are taken into custody.
November 10, 2008: Conroy is charged with manslaughter as a hate crime and held without bail.
January 2009: the indictment is unsealed; Conroy is charged with murder in the second degree as a hate crime, and the seven with gang assault on eight other Hispanic men.
Spring 2010: Conroy is tried in the State Supreme Court in Riverhead and testifies in his own defense.
April 19, 2010: the jury acquits him of murder and convicts him of manslaughter in the first degree as a hate crime, gang assault and other counts.
May 26, 2010: he is sentenced to 25 years in prison and two and a half years of post-release supervision.
August 25, 2010: three co-defendants are sentenced to seven years each.
October 2010: the last of the seven is sentenced, to five years; Conroy is serving his 25-year term.