On the afternoon of Monday, March 21, 2005, nine people died in Red Lake, the tribal seat of the Red Lake Band of Chippewa Indians in the forests of far northern Minnesota. Federal investigators attributed every one of those deaths to Jeff Weise, who was 16 years old. The first two to die were his grandfather, Daryl Lussier, and Michelle Sigana. Seven more died at the reservation's high school a short time later, and at least seven other people were wounded. Weise died by suicide before the afternoon was out.
He was never arrested, never charged and never tried, so no judge or jury ever weighed the evidence against him. The FBI concluded that Weise acted alone, that what happened at the school had been planned, that apart from the first two deaths the people he targeted appeared to have been chosen at random, and that he left behind no message explaining why.
Red Lake lies about 240 miles north of the Twin Cities, just south of the Canadian border. The Red Lake Band had rejected Public Law 280, the federal statute that would have given Minnesota jurisdiction there, so the reservation was subject to federal law but not state law, and the band ran its own police force and courts. That decided who would investigate the events of March 21 and where the one later prosecution would be heard.
Weise was enrolled at the high school and is pictured in its yearbook among the sophomores. By the winter of 2005, though, he was no longer attending classes there. After a violation of school policy he had been placed in the district's Homebound program, under which a pupil is taught at home by a visiting tutor.
The first two deaths came earlier that Monday afternoon, in Red Lake. Seven more people died at the high school a short time later: Derrick Brun, Neva Rogers, and five minors from the reservation, Chase, Thurlene, Dewayne, Chanelle and Alicia. Weise died by suicide before he could be taken into custody.
Because Red Lake lies outside state jurisdiction, the inquiry fell to federal authorities, and the Minneapolis field office of the FBI led it.
The first findings came within a day. On March 22 the head of the Minneapolis office said that Weise appeared to have acted alone and had left no message about his motive. Apart from the first two people who died, those he targeted appeared to have been chosen at random.
On April 18, at the bureau's first public briefing in weeks, the same official went further. While some of Weise's actions had appeared random, the events at the school had been planned. Weise had been in electronic communication with others beforehand. The bureau did not say whether anyone had known of the plan in advance, and a federal law-enforcement official said that Weise had acted alone in the attack itself.
Within days, though, the inquiry had widened. By March 29, federal authorities had announced the arrest of a second youth from the reservation, also a juvenile. He appeared before a federal magistrate in Duluth at a closed juvenile hearing.
By mid-April the case was before a federal grand jury in Minneapolis.
The second youth's case ended without a trial. On November 29, 2005, he pleaded guilty to a single count of threatening interstate communications. The court docket said only that he had used a computer to send interstate messages that "could be taken by an objective observer as threatening." Two other charges, conspiracy to commit murder and conspiracy to commit offenses against the United States, were dropped. He was sentenced in January 2006 at a hearing closed to the public.
No court ever ruled on the deaths of March 21, 2005. Weise died before he could be arrested, and the nine deaths are his by attribution: the conclusion of the FBI's investigation, not the verdict of a trial.
His motive was never established. Investigators said he left no message, and the bureau's public findings went no further than the statement that the events at the school were planned and that he had been in electronic contact with others. How much anyone else knew beforehand was never settled in public. The one person charged in connection with the case pleaded guilty to making threatening communications, not to any part in the deaths, and both conspiracy charges against him were dropped.
March 21, 2005: Nine people die in Red Lake, Minnesota, in deaths the FBI attributes to Jeff Weise, then 16; at least seven others are wounded; Weise dies by suicide the same afternoon.
March 22, 2005: The FBI's Minneapolis office says Weise appears to have acted alone and left no message about his motive.
March 29, 2005: Federal authorities have announced the arrest of a second youth, who appears before a federal magistrate in Duluth at a closed juvenile hearing.
April 13, 2005: Teenagers subpoenaed by a federal grand jury in Minneapolis appear at the federal courthouse there.
April 18, 2005: The FBI says the events at the school were planned.
November 29, 2005: The second youth pleads guilty to threatening interstate communications; two conspiracy charges are dropped.
January 2006: He is sentenced at a closed federal hearing.