On March 10, 1980, in the Westchester County town of Purchase, New York, Dr. Herman Tarnower died, and the woman who had been his companion for fourteen years was charged with his murder. Jean Harris was fifty-six, a graduate of Smith College and the headmistress of the Madeira School, a girls' school in McLean, Virginia. She denied murder from the first day to the last. A jury in White Plains heard the case for about three months and in February 1981 found her guilty of murder in the second degree. She was sentenced to fifteen years to life, served nearly twelve years, and left custody in January 1993 only after the governor of New York granted her clemency.
The defendant was a school head with a career spent in classrooms and school offices, and the trial that followed drew reporters from across the country. Her conviction turned on choices the defense made before the jury ever retired, and her release, when it came, turned on her health.
She was born Jean Streuven on April 27, 1923, and grew up in Shaker Heights, a suburb of Cleveland, Ohio. She went to private schools and then to Smith College, where she graduated magna cum laude.
Her working life began in the classroom. She taught first grade in Grosse Pointe, Michigan. Later she moved into business and held a sales administration post in New York, which she left in 1977 to become headmistress of the Madeira School in McLean. She was still head of the school in 1980.
In 1966 she met the man she would later be convicted of killing, at a party in New York. He was twelve years older. The two were together, on and off, for fourteen years. Marriage was discussed between them and never came about. He had also become involved with a younger woman who worked in his office, a fact that would sit at the center of the trial.
The death occurred on the night of March 10, 1980, in Purchase. Jean Harris was charged with his murder. From the beginning she maintained that she had not intended his death.
The case moved through the ordinary stages of a New York felony prosecution. An indictment was filed in Westchester County, and the statements she had made to the police that night came out with it. The charges that went to trial were murder in the second degree, the count that requires proof that the accused intended to cause the death of the person who died, and two lesser counts under the state's arms law. Under New York law at the time, first-degree murder was reserved chiefly for the killing of a law-enforcement officer, so second-degree murder was the most serious charge the case could carry.
Before a jury could be chosen, the court had to decide what the jury would be allowed to hear. In the fall of 1980 the Westchester County Court in White Plains held a pretrial hearing on whether the statements she had made to the police, and certain evidence the police had obtained, could be introduced at trial.
Her lead defense lawyer asked that the press and the public be shut out of those hearings. Lawyers for two newspaper publishers opposed him. On October 8, 1980, the county court judge assigned to the case refused to close the hearings and ordered them held in open court. He gave his reasons from the bench. The defense had not shown that open hearings would cause prejudicial publicity. The statements at issue had already been made public when the indictment was filed, so reporting them again would add no harm. The jurors still to be chosen, he said, could be fair and impartial. He relied on a recent decision of the state Court of Appeals that had overturned an earlier closure order of his own in an unrelated case, and he left room for the defense to renew its request if testimony entered sensitive ground. He also denied a request to adjourn the hearings so the defense could appeal his ruling.
The evidence was admitted, and the case went to trial. The publicity question did not go away. It would return, in one form or another, at every stage of her appeals.
The trial was held in White Plains, the Westchester County court town, and ran from late 1980 into February 1981, about three months in all. Testimony was well under way by the middle of December. About a hundred journalists covered it. The prosecution argued that she had intended the death. Her lead defense lawyer argued that she had not.
The defense made a choice that shaped everything that followed. It did not raise the defense of extreme emotional disturbance, which under New York law can reduce a murder to manslaughter, and it did not ask that the jury be allowed to consider a lesser charge such as manslaughter. The jury would have two options on the main count: guilty of murder, or not guilty. No psychiatric or psychological testimony was offered; her lawyer took the view that she had not acted out of any mental illness.
She testified in her own defense for eight days. The prosecutor's cross-examination ended on February 4, 1981, her seventh day on the witness stand, after a long and contentious session. Her lawyer objected repeatedly during it and twice moved for a mistrial. The judge denied both motions and told the prosecutor to proceed. With her testimony finished, the prosecution moved to its rebuttal case. The case turned, in the end, on her account and on whether the jury believed it.
The jury of eight women and four men retired in February 1981. Over eight days of deliberations, forty-seven hours and fifty-six minutes in the jury room, they asked for all four hundred exhibits that had been admitted in evidence and for about five hours of her testimony to be read back to them. An early vote on the second day was split. A final secret ballot was unanimous.
On Tuesday, February 24, 1981, the foreman announced a verdict of guilty on each count: murder in the second degree and the two lesser counts under the arms law. Each juror was polled in turn and confirmed the verdict. The trial judge remanded her into custody, and she was held in the Westchester County jail to await sentence. Her lawyer announced the same day that he would appeal.
On March 20, 1981, the trial judge imposed sentence for murder in the second degree: fifteen years to life. She could not be considered for parole until she had served the fifteen-year minimum.
She served her sentence at a New York state prison for women north of New York City. In prison she taught parenting skills to young mothers serving sentences there.
The direct appeal came first. On December 30, 1981, a state appeals court upheld the conviction. The appeal went on through the state courts without success, and the defense then carried the case to the Supreme Court of the United States, pressing the argument it had raised since the fall of 1980: that massive publicity had denied her a fair trial. In March 1983 the Supreme Court refused to hear the case. The direct appeal was over, and the conviction was final.
Her lawyers turned next to the trial court. In the spring of 1983, after twenty-six months in custody, her lawyer filed a motion in the Westchester County court seeking a new trial on the ground that she had been mentally incompetent during part of the proceedings. The county court was expected to rule within about two months. The motion did not succeed.
By the summer of 1984 she had changed lawyers. Her new counsel sought a new trial on a different ground: that the lawyers who had represented her at trial had not adequately represented her. That request was denied, and by August 1984 the denial was on appeal to the Appellate Division of the New York State Supreme Court. That effort failed as well, and every court that reviewed the case let the verdict stand, and she remained in custody under the fifteen-years-to-life term.
With the courts closed to her, the only remaining route lay with the governor. By the spring of 1986 her lawyer was preparing to ask the governor of New York for clemency that fall. She asked for clemency in 1986, in 1988 and in 1990, and each request was refused. Through those years she suffered two heart attacks in custody.
In December 1992, as she was about to undergo heart bypass surgery, the governor granted her clemency, commuting her sentence. By then she had served nearly twelve years of the fifteen-years-to-life term.
Clemency did not free her by itself. It cleared the way for the state parole board, which still had to approve her release. In January 1993 a parole-board panel did so, and she was released on parole about three weeks after the governor's decision. She was sixty-nine.
She died on December 23, 2012, in Connecticut. She was eighty-nine.
She never accepted that she had intended his death. The jury found that she had, and its verdict of murder in the second degree, which requires intent, stands as the legal finding in the case.
The motion for a new trial filed in 1983 claimed that she had been mentally incompetent during part of the proceedings, and the motion pursued in 1984 claimed that her trial lawyers had not adequately represented her. Neither succeeded. No court overturned the conviction, and the Supreme Court of the United States declined to review it.
April 27, 1923: Jean Streuven born; raised in Shaker Heights, Ohio.
1966: Meets the man whose death she would later be convicted of causing.
1977: Leaves a sales administration post in New York to become headmistress of the Madeira School, McLean, Virginia.
March 10, 1980: The death in Purchase, Westchester County, New York; she is charged with murder.
October 8, 1980: The county court judge refuses to close the pretrial hearings on her statements and the police evidence.
Late 1980 to February 1981: Trial in White Plains, about three months; she testifies for eight days.
February 4, 1981: Cross-examination ends; two defense motions for a mistrial are denied.
February 24, 1981: After eight days of deliberations, the jury finds her guilty of murder in the second degree and two lesser counts under the arms law.
March 20, 1981: Sentenced to fifteen years to life.
December 30, 1981: A state appeals court upholds the conviction.
March 1983: The Supreme Court of the United States refuses to hear her appeal on pretrial publicity.
Spring 1983: A motion for a new trial on grounds of mental incompetence during part of the proceedings is filed in the Westchester County court.
August 1984: A second new-trial motion, on inadequate representation at trial, has been denied and is on appeal to the Appellate Division.
1986, 1988, 1990: Clemency requests to the governor refused.
December 1992: The governor grants clemency as she faces heart bypass surgery.
January 1993: A state parole-board panel approves her release; she is paroled after nearly twelve years in custody.
December 23, 2012: Dies in Connecticut, aged eighty-nine.