Jaylen Fryberg

Victims
4 young people killed in Marysville, 2014; never tried. Marysville, Washington, October 24, 2014; deaths attributed to him by investigators; he died by suicide that day, never charged.
Years active
October 24, 2014 (deaths followed on October 24 and 26, October 31 and November 7, 2014)
Location
Marysville, Snohomish County, Washington
Method
Four deaths ruled or treated as homicides, attributed to him; no charge was ever filed.
Status
Deceased (died by suicide, October 24, 2014). Investigation closed July 22, 2015; records released from September 1, 2015.

On the morning of Friday, October 24, 2014, in Marysville, Washington, a city about 30 miles north of Seattle, five young people were harmed in a single act of violence. One died that day. Three more died over the following two weeks. The fifth lived. Investigators attributed every one of those deaths to Jaylen R. Fryberg, who was 15 years old at the time and who died by suicide before the morning was over.

Because he died on the day itself, Fryberg was never arrested, never charged and never tried. No jury heard evidence about him and no judge entered a finding. What exists instead is the work of a county homicide team that spent nearly nine months reconstructing the day, a ruling by the county medical examiner on each death, and a written decision, issued in July 2015, that there was no one left to charge. Every statement about his responsibility for the four deaths rests on that investigation and on nothing a court decided.

The Marysville Police Department answered the first call, and by midday the police announced that the person they believed responsible was dead. That afternoon he was identified by name. The same day the Marysville Police Department asked the Snohomish County Multi-Agency Response Team, known by its initials as SMART, to take over the investigation. The team is a standing group of homicide detectives drawn from police departments across Snohomish County, called in when a case is too large or too complex for one agency; most of its work had been the review of deaths involving police officers or people in custody. Detectives of the Washington State Patrol, agents of the Federal Bureau of Investigation and other federal agents joined it, and the Snohomish County Sheriff's Office handled its public statements.

The work began at once. By the next day, Saturday, October 25, the team had finished its on-site work in Marysville and had already interviewed more than 100 young witnesses. The sheriff's office said the county medical examiner would identify the dead and determine the cause and manner of each death, and that anyone with information should call its tip line.

The first to die, on the day itself, was Zoe. She was an artist who filled sketchbook after sketchbook, and she played every sport going, soccer most of all. She loved animals, road trips and live music. On Monday, October 27, the county medical examiner ruled her death a homicide. The same office ruled that Fryberg's death was a suicide.

The second death came on the night of Sunday, October 26, when Gia died.

Shaylee was an outgoing and confident athlete with a playful side. She died on Friday, October 31, a week to the day after she was hurt.

The last of the four, Andrew, was a friendly, caring boy and a natural athlete who loved football, wrestling and being outdoors. He died on the evening of Friday, November 7, two weeks after the violence. The fifth young person survived.

With that final death the toll attributed to Fryberg reached four.

Within three days of the violence, the county sheriff told the public that the investigation would take months. On Tuesday, October 28, dozens of investigators gathered for a briefing at which each was assigned a separate piece of the case. Two of them were Marysville detectives. The Snohomish County Prosecuting Attorney's Office, which reviews every case the team investigates, sat in on the meeting.

The first records left the team's hands within a week. On Thursday, October 30, 2014, SMART released recordings of the emergency calls and of the radio traffic between officers and dispatchers, in answer to a request under the state's public disclosure law. In November, detectives went to Cascade District Court in Snohomish County for warrants.

Detectives worked through the autumn and winter. They interviewed witnesses, gathered the accounts of the adults and young people who had been present, and assembled officers' reports from every agency that had answered the call. They separated firsthand accounts from rumor and from statements later taken back. On January 28, 2015, about three months after the violence, they interviewed the one young person who had survived. The lead investigator, a Washington State Patrol detective, drew the material together and wrote the summary of the case.

On July 22, 2015, nearly nine months after the deaths, Snohomish County announced that the SMART investigation was complete. The team stated that it was not referring any criminal charges to the county Prosecuting Attorney's Office, because the suspect in the investigation was deceased. The Marysville Police Department, which had requested the investigation, began its own review of the file. That report ran to 2,233 pages. Under the state's public records law it was not released at once; the county set August 31 as the date for the first installment, and the Everett Police Department's records staff took charge of the requests on the team's behalf.

The file was released in installments under the state's public records law. On September 1, 2015, a report of roughly 1,400 pages was made public, containing witness interview transcripts, officers' reports and the evidence the team had gathered; its summary was the work of the Washington State Patrol detective who had led the investigation. After a court hearing on September 3, about 250 further pages followed, and on September 30, 2015, a redacted transcript of the survivor's January interview was made public.

The case has been closed since July 22, 2015. No charge was ever referred, no court has ruled on the four deaths, and with the subject dead since October 24, 2014, no proceeding against him can follow.

Timeline

October 24, 2014: Violence in Marysville, Washington; one young person dies that day; Jaylen R. Fryberg, 15, dies by suicide; the Marysville Police Department asks SMART to investigate.

October 25, 2014: SMART finishes its on-site work; more than 100 witnesses have been interviewed.

October 26, 2014: The second victim dies.

October 27, 2014: The Snohomish County medical examiner rules Fryberg's death a suicide and the first death a homicide.

October 28, 2014: Dozens of investigators meet to divide the case; the county Prosecuting Attorney's Office attends.

October 30, 2014: SMART releases recordings of emergency calls and radio traffic under the public disclosure law.

October 31, 2014: The third victim dies.

November 7, 2014: The fourth victim dies.

November 2014: Detectives seek warrants in Cascade District Court.

January 28, 2015: Detectives interview the survivor.

July 22, 2015: Snohomish County announces that the SMART investigation is complete and that no charges will be referred, because the suspect is deceased; the 2,233-page report goes to Marysville police for review.

September 1, 2015: About 1,400 pages of the investigation are made public.

September 3, 2015: About 250 further pages are released after a court hearing.

September 30, 2015: A redacted transcript of the survivor's interview is made public.