Jason Robb was a leader of the Aryan Brotherhood inmates at the state prison in Lucasville, Ohio, when the prison's L Section fell to rioting inmates on Easter Sunday, April 11, 1993. For eleven days three inmate factions held the cellblocks and a group of corrections officers as hostages, and when the uprising ended on April 21, ten men were dead. Two of those deaths became Robb's case. The state of Ohio never claimed that he killed anyone with his own hands. Its case was that he stood among the leaders who decided that a guard would die if their demands were not met, that he campaigned and voted for that decision, and that on the last day of the siege he took part in the decision that a fellow inmate who knew too much had to die as well.
A jury in Columbus accepted that case. In 1995 it convicted Robb of the aggravated murders of Corrections Officer Robert Vallandingham and inmate David Sommers, each with prior calculation and design, and recommended death on both counts. The trial court imposed those sentences on April 17, 1995. The Supreme Court of Ohio upheld them unanimously on March 1, 2000, in an opinion that also settled a question the uprising had raised for the first time in Ohio law: whether the recordings the FBI made of the rioters' own meetings could be used against them. Robb has carried his challenge into federal court since June 2002. At the end of 2025 that case was still pending, more than thirty years after the deaths.
Robb was born in 1967. At seventeen he was convicted of voluntary manslaughter. He pleaded guilty and received a sentence of seven to twenty-five years, and it was that sentence he was serving in the spring of 1993.
He told the jury that he joined the Aryan Brotherhood in prison for protection. By 1993 he and another inmate led a group of twenty to thirty Aryans in L Section at Lucasville.
The Aryans were one of three groups that dominated that part of the prison. The Muslims, forty or fifty strong, had a leader of their own. A third faction, the Black Gangster Disciples, had ten or twelve members in L Section and concentrated, the court found, on gang business rather than ideology. The Aryans professed racial separatism and objected to inmates of different races being made to share cells.
The spark came from outside all three. Prison officials planned mass tuberculosis testing, which the Muslims regarded as contrary to their religion, and they learned that the cells were to be locked down on April 12 to enforce it. Before April 11, the Muslim leaders met with the leaders of the Aryans and the Black Gangster Disciples to settle their differences, avoid fights among themselves and present a single front against the prison authorities. The Muslims told Robb about the planned riot before it began.
The uprising began on April 11, and within hours the rioters held L Section. They took twelve corrections officers hostage and released four of them that first day.
The Supreme Court of Ohio found that Robb joined in the capture of the officers from the start. He was among the inmates who seized the officer who would die four days later, and once that officer was taken, the court found, Robb intervened and directed that he be held as a hostage. The Aryans held him at first and later handed him over to the Muslims, who kept most of the hostages in their own stronghold.
The faction leaders met again and again to agree a negotiating line, many times in the Aryan cellblock, where an inmate who belonged to no gang worked the telephones and so heard the leaders' meetings. From April 13 the FBI recorded those meetings.
By April 14 they were angry at the lack of progress, at the shortage of food and at a public remark by a Corrections Department spokesperson, and the inmates had begun to believe that officials did not take their threats seriously.
At meetings on April 14 and in the early hours of April 15, the leaders returned to the idea of killing a guard. Four inmates who testified at Robb's trial said that he backed it. One described him as campaigning for a guard's death. Three others, including the leader of the Black Gangster Disciples, testified that Robb agreed to the killing of a hostage so that the negotiators would take the inmates seriously. At the April 15 meeting the leaders agreed to demand that the water and electricity be restored within a fixed time, ninety minutes, or a guard would die. When the vote was asked for, two witnesses who were there testified that Robb voted for it.
The demands were not met. On April 15 the officer seized on the first day was killed by inmates. The state did not claim that Robb was present. Its evidence was that he had helped bring the decision about and, afterward, that he told another captive officer that the inmates had had to kill a guard and would kill another if they needed to.
By April 17, the court found, Robb had placed himself directly in the telephone negotiations. He presented new demands and insisted that the inmates be represented by lawyers, and for several days little progress was made. In the end the state allowed a Cleveland lawyer to consult with the inmates. Robb and the other two faction leaders then negotiated, with that lawyer, with officials from the FBI, the State Highway Patrol and the prison, and those talks succeeded. On April 21, over a period of eight hours, 407 inmates surrendered and the last five hostages were released.
While the surrender was under way, the Aryans decided that the inmate who had worked the telephones in their cellblock had to die because he knew too much about what had happened there. The court found that Robb had talked with the Muslim leader about harming the victim even earlier in the siege. The Supreme Court of Ohio held that the evidence showed Robb solicited and took part in the decision to kill the inmate and was present when other Aryans carried it out.
After the death, the Aryans joined the surrender. Robb was then moved to another Ohio prison.
The Ohio State Highway Patrol investigated the uprising, and a Scioto County grand jury returned the indictment that brought Robb to trial. The Supreme Court of Ohio dates the murder indictment to July 1994; the Ohio Attorney General's capital-case records give October 5, 1994. It charged him with four counts of aggravated murder. Counts I and III alleged that he caused the deaths of the officer and the inmate with prior calculation and design. Counts II and IV charged each death as a murder committed in the course of a kidnapping. Each count carried the same three death specifications: that the murder was committed while Robb was a prisoner in a detention facility, under Ohio Revised Code 2929.04(A)(4); that it was part of a course of conduct involving the purposeful killing of two or more people, under 2929.04(A)(5); and that it was committed during a kidnapping, under 2929.04(A)(7). Count V charged him with kidnapping the officer who died, and an earlier indictment charging him with two counts of kidnapping a second officer was tried with it as Counts VI and VII.
The case was moved out of Scioto County, and Robb was tried in the Franklin County Court of Common Pleas in Columbus before a retired judge sitting by assignment. A special prosecuting attorney and two assistant special prosecutors tried the case for the state.
The trial lasted weeks. The first witnesses laid out the structure of the gangs and the takeover of L Section, and a Highway Patrol sergeant testified for several days on the investigation. Inmates who had been inside followed, among them men who had sat in the leadership meetings. The leader of the Black Gangster Disciples, a principal witness for the state, had pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit murder and cooperated with the prosecution. An Aryan recruit who took part in the inmate's death testified about it and said he had been forced to do so; the jury heard that he had a previous murder conviction in Arizona. The state also played tunnel recordings, among them a tape of the early-morning April 15 meeting at which the vote was taken, and the leader of the Black Gangster Disciples, who had been at that meeting, authenticated it. One inmate subpoenaed by the defense refused absolutely to testify and was held in contempt.
Robb's defense was that he had no part in either death. He told the jury, through his lawyers, that he took up the leadership of the Aryans only after the officer died, and that he did so to negotiate an end to the riot. He said he was neither present at nor involved in the officer's death, and a defense witness testified that he was with Robb during the surrender and that Robb could not have been present when the inmate died.
The jury rejected that defense. It convicted Robb on Count I and Count III, the aggravated murders with prior calculation and design of the officer and the inmate, and on Count II, the aggravated felony-murder of the officer, with every death specification except the kidnapping specification in Count III. On Count IV it convicted him of the lesser included offense of murder of the inmate. It also found him guilty, as charged, of kidnapping the two officers in Counts V, VI and VII.
At the penalty hearing the defense called witnesses and Robb gave an unsworn statement, in which he described his early life, his drug use and the manslaughter conviction. He said he had never agreed to the officer's death or to the killing of any guard, that he was very upset when he learned that a guard had died, and that he then set out to help negotiate an end to the uprising. He said he believed he could be of use to others if he were allowed to live. The lawyer who had taken part in the final negotiations testified about how they were conducted.
The jury's deliberations on sentence did not run smoothly. On the third day the foreman sent the judge a note complaining that one juror had reached her conclusion before the instructions were given and would not weigh the factors for and against death. A second note, signed by eleven jurors, said she had told several of them before the end of the trial that she would not sign a death verdict. The state asked the judge to excuse her and the defense objected. The judge suspended deliberations and questioned each juror separately in chambers. Each of the other eleven said they agreed with the notes; the juror concerned denied refusing to deliberate. The judge found no sufficient cause to excuse her and sent the jury back with a modified version of the supplemental instruction Ohio courts give to juries that report they cannot agree. The jury later asked whether the judge could impose either death or a life sentence even if it recommended death.
In the end the jury recommended death on Counts I and III and life imprisonment on Count II. The trial court sentenced Robb to death for the aggravated murders of the officer and the inmate, and to consecutive prison terms for the kidnappings. The sentencing entry set an execution date of October 13, 1995, a date that passed while his appeals were heard. Robb moved to vacate the death sentence, relying in part on an affidavit from the juror who had been the subject of the notes, and the trial court denied the motion.
The Tenth District Court of Appeals, sitting in Franklin County, affirmed the convictions and sentences on April 30, 1998. On one point it agreed with Robb: it held that the FBI tunnel recordings should have been suppressed under the Ohio interception statute as it stood before its 1996 amendment. But it found the error harmless.
Robb then appealed to the Supreme Court of Ohio as of right, raising twenty-nine propositions of law. The court heard the case on October 19, 1999, and decided it on March 1, 2000, by a unanimous court. It rejected every proposition.
On the recordings the court went further than the court of appeals. It held that the trial court had been right not to suppress them, though for a reason of its own. Ohio's statute carried, and still carries, an exception for interceptions carried out under federal law, and FBI agents acting under federal authority had installed and monitored the tunnel microphones. Federal law protects oral communications only when they can justifiably be considered private, and the court held that inmates who had left their cells to take part in a violent prison takeover could claim no privacy at all in their plotting. It added that, tapes aside, inmate after inmate had testified independently that Robb voted for a guard's death.
The court upheld the admission of evidence of other crimes committed during the uprising, including some with which Robb was never charged or linked, because it helped prove that the gang leaders had conspired over eleven days to seize L Section and hold and harm hostages. It held that the statements of co-conspirators were properly admitted once independent testimony had established that conspiracy, and that the partly inaudible tunnel tapes were admissible because a man present at the April 15 meeting had authenticated them and Robb's lawyers had been free to cross-examine him. It found no error in limiting cross-examination of the Arizona murder conviction to the facts the jury had already heard, and no error in excluding the out-of-court statement of the inmate who refused to testify.
Robb argued that his trial lawyers had failed him, chiefly by promising in opening statement that he would never have agreed to the officer's death because of how the officer had treated the Aryans, a claim the state met with evidence that the officer treated all inmates fairly, and by waiving final argument at the penalty phase. The court held that the opening was a reasonable attempt to deny a motive, that Robb himself had decided to waive the final argument, and that neither choice could have changed the result.
On the law of complicity the court was direct. Robb argued that a man convicted only for what others did could not be put to death. The court answered that the jury had found he intended, with prior calculation and design, that both men die, and that a gang leader who orders a killing cannot escape responsibility for it because he does not carry it out himself. It also rejected his complaint that he was being punished for going to trial, while the leader of the Black Gangster Disciples, whom he called equally culpable, had pleaded guilty and received a lesser sentence; the court said the difference was explained by that man's cooperation.
The court rejected the claims arising from the penalty deliberations. It held that the jurors' notes conveyed a good-faith belief that one of them was refusing to deliberate, which jurors may bring to the court before a verdict; that the judge had questioned every juror with as little intrusion as possible; that nothing suggested the juror concerned had been intimidated or coerced; and that the supplemental instruction was not coercive. Ohio's rule on juror testimony barred any later inquiry into the deliberations themselves without outside evidence of improper influence, and there was none.
In its own review of the sentence the court found the aggravating circumstances proved beyond a reasonable doubt. It found nothing mitigating in the nature and circumstances of the offenses. Robb's age, twenty-four or twenty-five at the time, carried no significant weight, and the court gave very little weight to his part in negotiating the surrender. It held that the aggravating circumstances outweighed the mitigating factors on each death count beyond a reasonable doubt, and that the sentences were proportionate to those it had approved in other cases of murder by inmates and of murder in the course of a kidnapping. It affirmed the judgment of the court of appeals.
Robb had already begun a second line of challenge in the trial court. He filed a petition for post-conviction relief on October 23, 1996. The trial court denied it on February 14, 2000. The Tenth District Court of Appeals affirmed that ruling on February 27, 2001, and on June 6, 2001, the Supreme Court of Ohio declined further review. No capital proceeding has been pending for him in the Ohio courts since.
On June 3, 2002, Robb filed a petition for a writ of habeas corpus in the United States District Court for the Southern District of Ohio in Columbus, naming the warden of the prison that held him as respondent. The case has moved slowly. On September 16, 2004, the court granted part of his motion for discovery. In 2008, 2017 and again in 2026 the court allowed other men convicted over the uprising, or their lawyers, into the case's protective order so that discovery could be shared. On July 16, 2012, it allowed Robb to amend his petition to add claims challenging the constitutionality of Ohio's method of execution, claims he amended several times. The state filed an amended return of writ on March 21, 2017, and Robb answered on June 19, 2017, on the question of procedural default, supplementing that reply on March 26, 2021.
The court has turned down two later attempts to widen the case. On September 12, 2017, it denied Robb's motion of January 2017 to add a claim based on Hurst v. Florida, the 2016 decision of the Supreme Court of the United States on the role of juries in death sentencing. On March 18, 2019, it denied his latest motion to amend his method-of-execution claims. Through 2019 the parties briefed how discovery documents would be filed in Robb's case and in the other federal cases arising from the uprising. On August 4, 2025, Robb filed a notice of manual filing of documents for the judge to inspect privately under the protective order; the state objected the next day, and the court granted the motion. At the end of 2025 the petition was still pending in the district court, which had not yet ruled on its merits, and Robb was also a plaintiff in the federal litigation over Ohio's execution protocol.
Robb remains under sentence of death in Ohio. On December 31, 2025, the Ohio Attorney General counted 11,216 days from his death sentence to that date, and listed his case among those pending on an initial federal habeas petition for at least ten years. No execution date has been set while that petition is undecided. Ohio has carried out no execution since July 2018.
Robb has never admitted a part in either death. At trial he said he became the Aryans' leader only after the officer died, and at the penalty phase he said he liked the officer and never agreed to his death or that of any guard. A defense witness testified that Robb was elsewhere when the inmate died. The jury rejected those accounts, and every court to review the verdict has upheld it.
The two appellate courts divided over the FBI tunnel recordings. The Tenth District held that they should have been suppressed under the Ohio statute and found the error harmless; the Supreme Court of Ohio held that they were properly admitted. The result in both courts was the same.
Much of the state's evidence came from inmates, including men who sat in the leadership meetings and an Aryan recruit who took part in the inmate's death and said he had been forced to. The leader of the Black Gangster Disciples testified after pleading guilty to conspiracy to commit murder. The defense attacked those witnesses at trial, and the Supreme Court of Ohio described the cross-examination as wide-ranging. His federal habeas case, filed in 2002, had produced no ruling on the merits by the end of 2025.
1967: Jason Robb is born.
About 1984 to 1985: At seventeen he is convicted of voluntary manslaughter on a guilty plea and sentenced to seven to twenty-five years.
April 11, 1993: Inmates seize L Section of the state prison at Lucasville, Ohio, and take twelve corrections officers hostage.
April 13, 1993: FBI technicians begin recording inmate meetings from the tunnels beneath L Section.
April 14 to 15, 1993: Gang leaders, Robb among them, agree that a guard will die unless their demands are met.
April 15, 1993: The captive officer is killed by inmates.
April 21, 1993: 407 inmates surrender and the last five hostages are freed; during the surrender an inmate is killed by Aryan inmates.
1994: A Scioto County grand jury indicts Robb on four counts of aggravated murder with death specifications.
1995: Tried in Franklin County after a change of venue, Robb is convicted of two aggravated murders with prior calculation and design, aggravated felony-murder, murder and three counts of kidnapping.
April 17, 1995: He is sentenced to death on two counts.
October 23, 1996: He files a petition for post-conviction relief.
April 30, 1998: The Tenth District Court of Appeals affirms.
October 19, 1999: The Supreme Court of Ohio hears the appeal.
February 14, 2000: The trial court denies post-conviction relief.
March 1, 2000: The Supreme Court of Ohio unanimously affirms the convictions and death sentences.
February 27, 2001: The court of appeals affirms the denial of post-conviction relief.
June 6, 2001: The Supreme Court of Ohio declines further post-conviction review.
June 3, 2002: Robb files a federal habeas corpus petition in the Southern District of Ohio.
September 16, 2004: The district court grants part of his discovery motion.
July 16, 2012: He is allowed to add method-of-execution claims.
September 12, 2017: The court denies leave to add a Hurst v. Florida claim.
March 18, 2019: The court denies his latest motion to amend.
August 2025: The court grants his motion to file documents for private inspection.
December 31, 2025: The federal petition remains pending.