On the morning of Saturday, January 8, 2011, Representative Gabrielle Giffords of Arizona was holding one of her "Congress on Your Corner" meetings in Tucson, an open event meant to let people from across her district talk with her in person. Before the meeting was over six people were dead and thirteen were wounded. Among the dead was the chief federal judge of the District of Arizona. Among the wounded was the congresswoman herself, gravely hurt, and two members of her staff. The man taken into custody that day was Jared Lee Loughner, a 22-year-old from Tucson.
There was never a trial. There were instead long proceedings about whether Loughner could be tried at all. Two federal mental health examiners diagnosed schizophrenia, a federal judge found him incompetent to stand trial, and prison doctors medicated him against his will while his lawyers fought the medication up to the Ninth Circuit. In August 2012 the same judge found him competent, and Loughner pleaded guilty to 19 federal counts. In November 2012 he was sentenced to seven consecutive life terms followed by 140 years, with no possibility of parole. Pima County's prosecutor later decided not to bring a state case, and the federal sentence became the whole of the law's answer.
Loughner grew up in Tucson. He attended Pima Community College from the summer of 2005 through the fall of 2010, and his last year there was marked by trouble. Between February and September 2010, college police had five contacts with him over disruptions in classrooms and a library on two of the college's campuses.
On September 29, 2010, the college suspended him for violating its code of conduct, and on October 4, 2010, he withdrew. A letter dated October 7 told him that to return he would need a letter from a mental health official.
The meeting that morning drew constituents, staff and neighbors from across the congresswoman's district. Six of them died.
John Roll was the chief U.S. district judge for Arizona. Every federal judge in southern Arizona stepped aside from the case after his death.
Gabe Zimmerman, Gabriel in the court papers, was a member of the congresswoman's staff.
Christina, a child, was the youngest of the dead.
Dorothy Morris, Dorwan Stoddard and Phyllis Schneck were also killed. They had come, like most of the crowd, as constituents.
Thirteen people were wounded, among them the congresswoman and two of her aides.
Loughner was taken into custody in Tucson the same morning. Prosecutors charged him by federal criminal complaint with five counts: the attempted assassination of a member of Congress, two counts of killing an employee of the United States, for the judge and the staff member, and two counts of attempting to kill employees of the United States, for the two wounded aides. The murder counts carried a possible sentence of death.
On Monday, January 10, he made his first appearance, not in Tucson but at the federal courthouse in Phoenix. The judge's death had made Tucson impossible: the entire federal bench there had recused itself. A federal magistrate judge found by clear and convincing evidence that Loughner was a danger to the community and ordered him held without bail in the custody of the Attorney General. The written order, entered under the Bail Reform Act, records that Loughner stipulated and consented to his detention on the allegations in the complaint, which it listed as two counts of first-degree murder, two counts of attempted murder and one count of attempting to assassinate a member of Congress. The magistrate judge found that no condition or combination of conditions would reasonably assure the safety of others and the community, and the order incorporated the findings of the Pretrial Services Agency. Attorneys from the Federal Defenders of San Diego took the case.
The case went to a U.S. district judge from San Diego, sitting by designation. A grand jury then returned a three-count indictment, and on January 24, 2011, in Phoenix, pleas of not guilty were entered to the counts naming the congresswoman and her two aides.
On February 4, 2011, the U.S. Attorney for Arizona and the Pima County Attorney announced how their two offices would proceed. The federal case would be tried first. Because federal law required any state prosecution to be suspended while the federal case was pending, the county's case would wait until the federal charges had been fully resolved, and the Pima County Attorney's Office would then bring state charges of its own. The two offices said in a written statement that the cases would be tried in sequence.
On March 3, 2011, a federal grand jury returned a superseding indictment of 49 counts. As the Ninth Circuit later summarized it, the charges included the attempted assassination of a member of Congress, the murder of a federal judge, the murder and attempted murder of other federal employees, causing death and injury to participants at a federally provided activity, and several related federal counts. Those counts covered the four people killed who were not federal employees and the wounded who were not on the congresswoman's staff. Federal prosecutors had not yet said whether they would seek the death penalty. Loughner was arraigned on the new indictment in Tucson and pleaded not guilty to every count.
In March 2011 the district court ordered a competency examination at the U.S. Medical Center for Federal Prisoners in Springfield, Missouri, under the federal statute governing such examinations. A Bureau of Prisons psychologist and a court-appointed psychiatrist examined him there. Both found that he had schizophrenia and that he was not competent to stand trial.
The competency hearing was held in Tucson on May 25, 2011. The judge found him incompetent: he cited the schizophrenia diagnosis and found Loughner delusional, with disorganized thinking, and lacking a clear understanding of the proceedings. The judge rejected any suggestion that he was feigning illness. Under the federal competency statute, he committed Loughner to the Springfield facility for up to four months to determine whether treatment could restore him to competency. The prosecution was suspended until that question was answered.
Two days after the ruling, Loughner was back in Springfield and refusing medication. On June 14, 2011, the facility held an administrative hearing under the Bureau of Prisons rule that applies the Supreme Court's decision in Washington v. Harper. He declined to take part. The presiding psychiatrist found him dangerous and authorized medication over his objection, and treatment began on June 21.
His lawyers went to court three days later, asking the district judge to stop it. The judge denied the motion on July 1 without an evidentiary hearing, and the defense appealed. A Ninth Circuit motions panel briefly halted the medication and then, on July 12, stayed it pending appeal. On July 18 the facility's doctors authorized emergency medication.
A second administrative hearing, on August 25, found continued medication justified, but the associate warden set that decision aside because a witness statement had been obtained after the hearing rather than before it. A third hearing, on September 15, 2011, again authorized medication on the ground that he was a danger to himself, and this time the associate warden upheld it. The district court refused to overturn the order on September 28 and 30.
At a hearing in Tucson on September 28, 2011, the treating psychologist and a second psychiatrist both testified that Loughner was likely to be restored to competency, the psychiatrist estimating a period of a few more months. The treating psychologist's diagnosis was undifferentiated schizophrenia. Prosecutors had asked for eight more months of treatment. The judge found a substantial probability of restoration, found that measurable progress toward restoration had been made, and extended the commitment by four months under the same statute, half of what the government sought. The defense filed an emergency motion to block the transfer, arguing that side effects of the treatment could impair his ability to help his lawyers and that the extension was tied to no specific treatment plan; the judge denied it on October 3. Loughner was returned to Springfield in October.
In February 2012, at a hearing in San Diego, the judge extended the commitment again, to June 7, 2012. The facility's chief psychologist had reported that Loughner still lacked an adequate understanding of the nature and consequences of the charges, which by then numbered 49, but that he had made measurable progress during his months of treatment. A report she wrote in April 2012 found him competent.
On March 5, 2012, a divided Ninth Circuit panel decided the consolidated appeals. The majority held that the standard announced in Harper "applies with equal force in the context of pretrial detainees." It found the Bureau of Prisons procedures substantially equivalent to those Harper approved, held that Loughner had no right to counsel at the administrative medication hearing because the judgment there was a medical one, and held that the facility was not required to prove that no less intrusive alternative existed, since tranquilizers, seclusion and restraints would not treat the underlying disorder. It accepted the finding that medication was in his best medical interest.
On the commitment extension, the majority treated the question as separate from the medication order. "Substantial probability," it held, meant a probability worth taking seriously, likely though not necessarily more likely than not, and the district court was not required to specify drugs and dosages in advance. Questions about side effects and a fair trial were premature and could be raised before any trial. The court affirmed both orders in the third appeal and dismissed the first two as moot. One judge concurred. The dissenting judge argued that the majority had taken the questions in the wrong order, that the commitment decision was the one actually in force, and that where the aim was restoring competency for trial, the Supreme Court's decision in Sell v. United States required the district court itself, not prison doctors, to decide whether medication was justified.
On August 7, 2012, Loughner was brought to the federal courthouse in Tucson. The court-appointed expert testified that a year of intensive treatment, medication and counseling had restored him, and traced what was called his slow descent into schizophrenia. The judge found him "competent as of today." He then pleaded guilty, count by count.
He pleaded guilty to 19 counts of murder and attempted murder, the attempted assassination of a member of Congress among them. In return the government agreed not to seek the death penalty, and 30 other counts were to be dismissed. He gave up any insanity defense. The agreement provided for a sentence of life in prison without the possibility of parole.
The 19 counts were drawn from the superseding indictment of March 3, 2011, and they reached every person killed or wounded. One count was the attempted assassination of the congresswoman. Two were the murders of federal employees, the judge and the staff member. Two were the attempted murders of the two wounded aides, both federal employees. Four counts charged him with causing the deaths of the four other people killed, as participants in a federally provided activity, and ten more with causing injury to the ten other people wounded. He also admitted that thirteen more people at the meeting had been placed at grave risk of death.
The agreement fixed the sentence count by count: life on the attempted assassination count and on each of the six counts for the dead, 20 years on each attempted murder count and 10 years on each injury count, all to run consecutively. That arithmetic produced the seven life terms followed by 140 years. Under the agreement he would never be eligible for parole and gave up any appeal of his convictions. He signed a written waiver of rights at the end of the 14-page agreement, which was made public after the hearing.
Sentencing took place in Tucson on November 8, 2012. He made no statement.
The judge imposed seven consecutive life terms, one for each of the six people killed and one for the attempted assassination, followed by 140 years, with no parole. Within days the U.S. Marshals Service returned him to the Springfield medical center, where he had been treated for about eighteen months. The judge recommended that he remain there indefinitely; the Bureau of Prisons would make the final decision.
Under the 2011 agreement the Pima County Attorney's Office gained the right to prosecute once the federal sentence was imposed. After the sentencing the county attorney announced that she would not bring state charges, which ended any possibility of a death sentence. The sentencing closed every criminal case against him.
Loughner has been in federal custody since January 8, 2011. In November 2012 he was serving his sentence at a federal medical facility in Missouri. As of November 2026 the Federal Bureau of Prisons holds him at one of its medical centers in Minnesota and lists his projected release as life. No appeal followed the plea, and no state charges were filed.
The orders at issue came from the Bureau of Prisons' own procedure, set out in its own federal regulations, under which a psychiatrist holds the hearing, a staff representative assists the prisoner, and an associate warden hears any administrative appeal. Loughner's lawyers argued that a pretrial detainee was owed more: a judicial hearing, proof by clear and convincing evidence, a lawyer at his side, periodic review and a decision by a panel rather than one psychiatrist. The majority rejected each demand, holding that none was constitutionally compelled and that the federal procedure was substantially equivalent to the one the Supreme Court had approved in Harper. The panel also noted that the commitment ordered in May 2011 had asked the Springfield facility only whether restoration was possible, a point the dissent treated as a possible conflict of interest and the majority rejected.
Whether the Bureau of Prisons should have been allowed to medicate Loughner by administrative order, rather than after a judicial decision under Sell, divided the Ninth Circuit panel two to one, and the majority's holding governed his case. The plea removed any trial finding on his mental state on January 8 itself: he gave up the insanity defense, and no jury ever heard the question.
2005 to 2010: Attends Pima Community College in Tucson.
September 29, 2010: Suspended by the college.
October 4, 2010: Withdraws from the college.
January 8, 2011: Six people killed and thirteen wounded at a public meeting held by a member of Congress in Tucson; Loughner taken into custody.
January 10, 2011: First appearance in Phoenix; ordered held without bail.
January 24, 2011: Not guilty pleas entered on the first, three-count indictment.
February 4, 2011: Federal and county prosecutors announce that the federal case will be tried first.
March 3, 2011: Federal grand jury returns a 49-count superseding indictment.
May 25, 2011: Found incompetent to stand trial; committed to the Springfield medical center.
June 14 to September 15, 2011: Three administrative hearings authorize medication over his objection.
September 28, 2011: Commitment extended four months.
October 3, 2011: Emergency defense motion against the transfer denied.
February 2012: Commitment extended to June 7, 2012, at a hearing in San Diego.
March 5, 2012: Ninth Circuit affirms the medication and commitment orders, two to one.
April 2012: The facility's chief psychologist reports him competent.
August 7, 2012: Found competent; pleads guilty to 19 federal counts.
November 8, 2012: Sentenced to seven consecutive life terms plus 140 years, without parole.
November 2012: Pima County Attorney declines to bring state charges; Loughner returned to the Springfield medical center.
November 2026: Held by the Federal Bureau of Prisons in Minnesota; projected release listed as life.