On April 10, 1993, the Saturday before Easter, Janusz Walus killed Thembisile Chris Hani in Boksburg, east of Johannesburg. The victim was the general secretary of the South African Communist Party and a former chief of staff of Umkhonto we Sizwe, the armed wing of the African National Congress, and since his return from exile his speeches had drawn large crowds in the townships. Walus, a Polish immigrant who had joined the far-right Afrikaner Resistance Movement, was arrested the same day. So was Clive Derby-Lewis, a founding member of the Conservative Party who had sat on the apartheid-era President's Council. Six months later both men were convicted of murder in the Witwatersrand Local Division and sentenced to death.
The killing came in the middle of the negotiations that were meant to end white minority rule, and it nearly derailed them. Instead, the talks pressed on, and the date of South Africa's first democratic general election, April 27, 1994, was fixed in its aftermath. The death sentence was never carried out. The Constitutional Court struck down the death penalty in 1995, and in 2000 he was resentenced to life imprisonment. A Truth and Reconciliation Commission amnesty committee refused him amnesty in 1999. He became eligible to be considered for parole in 2005, and there followed a string of ministerial refusals, High Court orders, an appeal to the Supreme Court of Appeal and, in November 2022, a unanimous Constitutional Court judgment that ordered his release. He left custody on December 7, 2022, served two years on parole, and was deported to Poland in December 2024.
Walus was born in 1953 in Zakopane, in the mountains of southern Poland. He left communist-ruled Poland for South Africa in 1981, shortly before martial law was declared. About five years after his arrival he took South African citizenship, while keeping his Polish nationality.
In South Africa he moved into the politics of the white right. He joined the Afrikaner Resistance Movement, the AWB, and was active in the Conservative Party.
Chris Hani was born on June 28, 1942, in Sabalele, in the Cofimvaba district of what was then the Transkei. He joined the ANC Youth League in 1957, the underground Communist Party in 1961 and Umkhonto we Sizwe in 1962.
His adult life was spent largely in the liberation movement's underground and in exile. He joined the ANC's National Executive Committee in 1982 and became Umkhonto we Sizwe's chief of staff in 1987. After the unbanning of the ANC and the Communist Party in February 1990 he returned to South Africa, and in 1991 he became the party's general secretary, the office he held until the day he died.
The killing took place in the Dawn Park suburb of Boksburg on the Easter Saturday of 1993. Walus was arrested within hours. The same day police also arrested Clive Derby-Lewis and his wife. All three were charged in the Witwatersrand Local Division with murder and with other offenses.
The death came at the most delicate point of the transition. The negotiations between the government, the ANC and the other parties had been under way for more than a year, and the assassination of a leader with a large following among young black South Africans brought nationwide unrest and open fears of civil war. The talks survived. Government statements made since have tied the decision to set April 27, 1994 as the date of the first democratic general election to the crisis that followed the killing.
The three accused were tried together in the Witwatersrand Local Division, and all three pleaded not guilty. Derby-Lewis, a senior Conservative Party figure, had planned the killing with Walus.
On October 14, 1993, the court convicted both men of the murder and of an offense under the arms law. Derby-Lewis was also convicted of a further offense involving ammunition. His wife was acquitted of all charges. The trial court found that the killing was a planned, cold-blooded assassination, committed for a political purpose. It found no extenuating circumstances.
On October 15, 1993, the trial judge sentenced both men to death on the murder count. Walus also received five years' imprisonment on the arms-law count. Both appealed, and the appeal court dismissed their appeals.
Those death sentences would never be carried out. On June 6, 1995, in the case of S v Makwanyane, South Africa's new Constitutional Court declared capital punishment unconstitutional. The ruling invalidated the two death sentences, and the men would have to return to the court that had sentenced them for new sentences.
In April 1996 both men applied to the amnesty committee of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission. The committee had the power to grant amnesty for acts committed with a political objective in the conflicts of the past, provided the applicant made full disclosure of all relevant facts. Walus and Derby-Lewis sought amnesty for the murder and for the arms-law convictions; Derby-Lewis also applied in respect of the ammunition count. The Communist Party and the victim's family opposed the applications strenuously.
The applications were heard by a committee of five judges. Walus told the committee that he had acted on Derby-Lewis's instruction and with the authority of the Conservative Party, and that this authority had seemed obvious to him. He also conceded that he would not have gone ahead had he known that the party had not moved away from its policy of non-violence.
On April 7, 1999, almost six years after the killing, the committee refused amnesty to both men. It found that they had not shown that the killing met the act's test of a political objective, because it was common cause that they had not acted on the express authority or orders of the Conservative Party, and the evidence of the party's leader undercut any claim of implied authority. It found that Walus had not acted under duress, understood the political situation and had taken part in planning the assassination. It also found that the two men had not made full disclosure. Their accounts of the planning contradicted each other, and they had not given full answers on central matters of the preparation. The committee said there were "compelling arguments" for a wider plot behind the killing, but no conclusive evidence of one.
The two men took the refusal on review to a full bench of the High Court in Cape Town, opposed by the committee's chairperson, the victim's widow and the Communist Party. On December 15, 2000, the court dismissed the review. It held that its task was to test the committee's decision against the amnesty provisions of the Promotion of National Unity and Reconciliation Act, not to compare it with decisions in other cases.
With amnesty refused, the men had to be resentenced. Under the Criminal Law Amendment Act of 1997, prisoners whose death sentences had fallen away were returned to the court that had sentenced them, and the new sentence had to be approved by the President. On November 14, 2000, the trial court resentenced both Walus and Derby-Lewis to life imprisonment.
Derby-Lewis served more than two decades. He was released on medical parole in June 2015 and died in Pretoria on November 3, 2016.
Because of the date of his sentence, Walus fell under the parole rules that governed life prisoners sentenced before the Correctional Services Act of 1998 took full effect. Under those rules he could be considered for parole after serving a minimum period, and he became eligible in 2005. For life prisoners the decision belonged to the Minister of Justice and Correctional Services, acting on the recommendation of the parole board.
He applied for the first time in 2011. On June 22, 2011, the minister refused, with the formula that parole "is not approved at this stage," and directed that the victim's family must be given the opportunity to make either a victim impact statement or a statement of opposition. The family had not been engaged on that first application. He applied again in 2013 and in 2015. In April 2015 the minister refused once more, holding that the nature of the crime and the sentencing remarks of the trial court outweighed the factors in his favor.
Walus went to the High Court in Pretoria. On March 10, 2016, the court set aside the minister's refusal and ordered that he be placed on parole within fourteen days. The minister applied for leave to appeal; the High Court refused it, and the minister petitioned the Supreme Court of Appeal directly. Walus then asked to be released while the petition was pending. The High Court dismissed that application in April 2016, finding no exceptional circumstances that would justify lifting the automatic suspension of its order during an appeal. He stayed in custody.
On August 18, 2017, the Supreme Court of Appeal in Bloemfontein upheld the minister's appeal and set aside the High Court's judgment. It did not decide the parole question itself. It sent the matter back to the minister to reconsider and decide within ninety calendar days. In November 2017 the minister refused parole again.
In December 2016 the Department of Home Affairs decided to revoke Walus's South African citizenship and to deport him once he was released, and a warrant for his detention and removal followed. On September 6, 2018, the High Court in Pretoria found that decision invalid and unlawful and set it aside, together with the warrant. By the time his parole ended in 2024, he no longer held any South African enabling documents and was treated as a Polish national.
The same September 2018 judgment dealt with the November 2017 parole refusal. The court set it aside, finding that the parole board had left relevant information out of its recommendation to the minister and had not given Walus a chance to answer its view that he should remain in custody. It did not order his release, although he had asked for release subject to deportation to Poland. Instead it referred the application back to the minister and gave Walus, the victim's widow and the Communist Party sixty days to comment on the parole board's negative report.
On January 16, 2019, the minister refused parole again. Walus challenged that decision too. On December 12, 2019, the High Court in Pretoria set it aside and ordered the new minister, appointed after the general election earlier that year, to take a fresh decision within sixty days, and to pay Walus's costs. The court recorded that the expert and psychological assessments before the minister agreed that Walus had shown remorse and was at low risk of reoffending, but it declined to grant parole itself, holding that the administrator was best placed to decide. It also found that the previous minister had not been biased or unreasonable.
On March 16, 2020, the new minister refused parole. His published reasons weighed the planned, political nature of the killing, the conviction for murder without extenuating circumstances and the severity the trial court had intended against Walus's conduct and adjustment in custody and his completion of the programs offered in the correctional center. Walus had by then served twenty-seven years. Parole, the minister concluded, was "not approved at this stage."
Walus took that decision on review to the High Court in Pretoria, which upheld the refusal. The Supreme Court of Appeal dismissed his application for leave to appeal. He then turned to the Constitutional Court.
The Constitutional Court heard the case, Walus v Minister of Justice and Correctional Services, in February 2022.
On November 21, 2022, the court delivered a unanimous judgment, written and read by the Chief Justice. It held that it had jurisdiction under the Promotion of Administrative Justice Act and granted leave to appeal in the interests of justice. On the merits it found the minister's March 2020 decision irrational. The two reasons on which the refusal rested, the seriousness of the offense and the remarks of the sentencing court, were things Walus could never change, and the minister had not explained how he could reach a different conclusion on the same facts in future. The court read the "sentencing remarks" that parole decision-makers must consider as referring to orders setting a non-parole period, not to the trial judge's description of the crime, which had been made to justify the maximum sentence rather than to bar a later application for parole. It held that rehabilitation was the most important factor in a parole decision.
The court noted that Walus had served more than twenty-five years of his life sentence, that his disciplinary record in custody was clean and that he had met every requirement set by the correctional authorities. It held that the Bill of Rights did not protect only those who had fought for democracy.
Rather than send the matter back to the minister once more, the court decided it itself. Its order reviewed and set aside the minister's March 2020 decision, directed the minister to place Walus on parole on such terms and conditions as the minister considered appropriate, and to take all steps necessary to ensure his release within ten calendar days. The minister was ordered to pay Walus's costs, including the costs of two counsel.
Walus was placed on parole on December 7, 2022, after twenty-nine years in custody. Under the law that applied to him the parole period was two years.
The parole period ended on December 6, 2024. That day the government announced in Pretoria that, as he no longer held any South African enabling documents, the National Commissioner of Correctional Services would hand him over to the Department of Home Affairs for deportation. The Polish embassy was to meet the cost of his return. A request for an inquest into the killing was referred to the Department of Justice and Constitutional Development. The government stated that it was acting in compliance with the Constitutional Court's order and that the release had not been its decision.
He arrived in Warsaw on December 7, 2024.
As of October 2026, Walus is alive and living in Poland as a Polish citizen.
Three bodies of law shaped what happened to Walus after his conviction. The first was the abolition of the death penalty. When the Constitutional Court decided S v Makwanyane on June 6, 1995, his death sentence lost its force but was not automatically replaced. The Criminal Law Amendment Act of 1997 dealt with the prisoners left in that position: each was returned to the court that had sentenced him, the new sentence required the President's approval, and for premeditated murder the act called for life imprisonment, with no right of appeal against such a sentence. That was the route that produced his life term on November 14, 2000.
The second was the amnesty process under the Promotion of National Unity and Reconciliation Act. Amnesty was open to those who had committed offenses with a political objective and who made full disclosure, and in this case the committee tested the political objective by asking whether the two men had acted with the authority of the Conservative Party. The committee's finding that the Conservative Party had never authorized the killing, together with its finding that the two men had not disclosed everything, closed that route to him.
The third was the parole law for life prisoners. Walus's sentence was imposed before the Correctional Services Act of 1998 came into full effect, so his case was governed by the transitional provisions of that act, which govern parole for life prisoners sentenced before it took effect. Under the Correctional Services Act as it has stood since October 1, 2009, the placement of a life prisoner on parole is decided by the minister, on the recommendation of the parole board; a court may intervene only by reviewing the minister's decision, for example as irrational, under the Promotion of Administrative Justice Act of 2000. Under the legislation that applied to Walus when the Constitutional Court ordered his release, his parole period was two years, and it ran from his release to December 6, 2024.
Whether anyone else stood behind the killing has never been settled. Walus told the amnesty committee that he had believed he was acting with the Conservative Party's authority; the committee found the party had given no such authority and that the planning accounts given by Walus and Derby-Lewis contradicted each other. It found "compelling arguments" for a wider plot but no conclusive evidence of one, and no court has made any finding that others were involved. A request for an inquest was referred to the justice department in December 2024.
Walus's remorse was itself contested for more than a decade. The professional assessments before the ministers, as recorded by the High Court in December 2019, agreed that he had shown remorse and was at low risk of reoffending. Successive ministers doubted it, and remorse was among the grounds on which parole was refused. The Constitutional Court did not rest its order on a finding about remorse; it held that the refusal was irrational because it rested on factors he could never change.
1953: Janusz Walus is born in Zakopane, Poland.
1981: He emigrates to South Africa.
April 10, 1993: The SACP general secretary is killed in Boksburg; Walus is arrested the same day, as are Clive Derby-Lewis and his wife.
October 14, 1993: Walus and Derby-Lewis are convicted of murder in the Witwatersrand Local Division; the third accused is acquitted.
October 15, 1993: Both men are sentenced to death; Walus also receives five years on the arms-law count.
June 6, 1995: The Constitutional Court declares the death penalty unconstitutional in S v Makwanyane.
April 1996: Walus and Derby-Lewis apply for amnesty.
April 7, 1999: The amnesty committee refuses both applications.
November 14, 2000: The trial court resentences both men to life imprisonment.
December 15, 2000: The High Court in Cape Town dismisses their review of the amnesty refusal.
2005: Walus becomes eligible to be considered for parole.
June 22, 2011: The minister refuses his first parole application.
April 2015: A further refusal follows applications in 2013 and 2015.
June 2015: Derby-Lewis is released on medical parole.
March 10, 2016: The High Court in Pretoria orders Walus's release on parole within fourteen days.
April 2016: The High Court refuses to release him pending the minister's appeal.
November 3, 2016: Derby-Lewis dies in Pretoria.
December 2016: Home Affairs decides to revoke his South African citizenship.
August 18, 2017: The Supreme Court of Appeal sets aside the 2016 order and returns the matter to the minister.
November 2017: The minister refuses parole.
September 6, 2018: The High Court sets aside the 2017 refusal and the citizenship decision.
January 16, 2019: The minister refuses parole again.
December 12, 2019: The High Court sets aside the January 2019 refusal and orders a fresh decision.
March 16, 2020: The new minister refuses parole.
February 2022: The Constitutional Court hears his appeal.
November 21, 2022: The Constitutional Court orders that he be placed on parole within ten calendar days.
December 7, 2022: Walus is released on parole.
December 6, 2024: His parole period ends and he is deported.
December 7, 2024: He arrives in Warsaw.